Wesley v. City of Detroit

Michigan Supreme Court

Wesley v. City of Detroit

76 N.W. 104, 117 Mich. 658, 1898 Mich. LEXIS 933

CourtMichigan Supreme Court

DecidedJuly 18, 1898

StatusPublished

Cited by10 cases

This text of 76 N.W. 104 (Wesley v. City of Detroit) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Michigan Supreme Court primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook

Wesley v. City of Detroit, 76 N.W. 104, 117 Mich. 658, 1898 Mich. LEXIS 933 (Mich. 1898).

Pincite

Opinions

Grant, C. J.

I think the court was correct in directing a verdict. The sidewalk was in a condition in which the city had a right to leave it. If there had been a plank or stone walk of the same incline as the ground, it would have been equally, if not more, dangerous. It was not unsafe or dangerous in its original condition. It was made unsafe solely by the accumulation of ice and snow. [659]*659Sidewalks and streets must have inclines, and, whatever may be the decisions of the courts of other States, it is settled in this State that municipalities are not liable for accidents caused by the natural accumulations of ice and snow. Gavett v. City of Jackson, 109 Mich. 408 (32 L. R. A. 861); Hutchinson v. City of Ypsilanti, 103 Mich. 12. See, also, authorities cited in these two cases. All inclined sidewalks become dangerous for pedestrians when covered with ice. All the law requires is that the municipality shall keep them otherwise in a reasonably safe condition.

The judgment is affirmed.

Hooker and Long, JJ., concurred with Grant, C. J.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Grant, C. J.

I think the court was correct in directing a verdict. The sidewalk was in a condition in which the city had a right to leave it. If there had been a plank or stone walk of the same incline as the ground, it would have been equally, if not more, dangerous. It was not unsafe or dangerous in its original condition. It was made unsafe solely by the accumulation of ice and snow. [659]*659Sidewalks and streets must have inclines, and, whatever may be the decisions of the courts of other States, it is settled in this State that municipalities are not liable for accidents caused by the natural accumulations of ice and snow. Gavett v. City of Jackson, 109 Mich. 408 (32 L. R. A. 861); Hutchinson v. City of Ypsilanti, 103 Mich. 12. See, also, authorities cited in these two cases. All inclined sidewalks become dangerous for pedestrians when covered with ice. All the law requires is that the municipality shall keep them otherwise in a reasonably safe condition.

The judgment is affirmed.

Hooker and Long, JJ., concurred with Grant, C. J.

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)

76 N.W. 104, 117 Mich. 658, 1898 Mich. LEXIS 933, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/wesley-v-city-of-detroit-mich-1898.

Opinions

Related

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack