Wells v. Wells

6 Ind. 447

• Court: Indiana Supreme Court
• Decided: June 13, 1855
• Status: Published

Opinion

Stuart, J.

Wells, the father, filed his bill in chancery against Wells, the son, an infant, in September, 1834, alleging that he had purchased,. with his own money, certain lands in Marion county, in the name of his son, and praying that the title thus nominally placed in the infant son might be vested in him. Decree accordingly.

Counsel seem to be mistaken in asserting that the bill was filed and the decree rendered the same day. The bill was filed September 23,1834, and on that day a guardian ad litem was appointed. The answer of Calvin Fletcher, guardian ad litem, was filed October 2, 1834, and the decree then passed.

It no where appears that there was any process, or any evidence. These are the errors assigned. They are clearly sufficient to reverse the case; Crain v. Parker, 1 Ind. R. 374; provided Wells, the son, has shown himself to be in a position to avail himself of them.

D. McDonald, W. A. McKenzie and W. Henderson, for the plaintiff.

We attach no importance to the admissions improvidently made for him by his guardian ad litem. But there are other considerations affecting his right to bring error upon which we were not at first so clear. The bill alleges that the land was entered in January, 1832; that the son, E. R. Wells, was at the time of filing the bill “only six years old.” If from this statement we fix his birth-day at September 23, 1828, he was of age September 22, 1849. That was the date of the removal of the disability. From that date he had five years to bring error. The transcript was filed, and errors assigned in this Court, November 12, 1853. So that he is entitled to his writ of error, however reluctant Courts may justly be to open adjudications of such long standing.

But as the decree was rendered without notice to the infant, and without evidence, it must be reversed.

We intimate no opinion as what will be the effect, if any, of the reversal on subsequently acquired titles.

Per Curiam.

The decree is reversed with costs. Cause remanded, &c.