Watkins v. ST. MARTIN PARISH SCHOOL BD.

929 So. 2d 846, 2006 La. App. LEXIS 1038, 2006 WL 1155253
CourtLouisiana Court of Appeal
DecidedMay 3, 2006
Docket05-1535
StatusPublished
Cited by2 cases

This text of 929 So. 2d 846 (Watkins v. ST. MARTIN PARISH SCHOOL BD.) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Louisiana Court of Appeal primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Watkins v. ST. MARTIN PARISH SCHOOL BD., 929 So. 2d 846, 2006 La. App. LEXIS 1038, 2006 WL 1155253 (La. Ct. App. 2006).

Opinion

929 So.2d 846 (2006)

Wayne WATKINS
v.
ST. MARTIN PARISH SCHOOL BOARD.

No. 05-1535.

Court of Appeal of Louisiana, Third Circuit.

May 3, 2006.

*848 I. Jackson Burson, Jr., Assistant District Attorney, Eunice, LA, for Defendant/Appellant, St. Martin Parish School Board.

W. Glenn Soileau, Breaux Bridge, LA, for Plaintiff/Appellee, Wayne Watkins.

Court composed of SYLVIA R. COOKS, OSWALD A. DECUIR, and MARC T. AMY, Judges.

AMY, Judge.

The plaintiff filed suit against the defendant school board seeking credit for military service completed prior to his teaching career and the back wages associated with that credit. The defendant alleged that all but three years of the plaintiff's wage claim had prescribed. The trial court denied the exception of prescription and granted the plaintiff's wage claim. Wages and attorney's fees were awarded. The defendant appeals. For the following reasons, we maintain the exception of prescription in part. We further affirm the judgment in part, reverse in part, and remand.

Factual and Procedural Background

The plaintiff, Wayne Watkins, began his employment with the defendant, the St. Martin Parish School Board, in January 1979 as a teacher at Cecilia High School. This suit involves his contention that the defendant erroneously denied him credit and related wages for four years of military service rendered prior to the commencement of his teaching career.

The record establishes that the plaintiff served in the United States Marine Corps from November 10, 1969 to November 9, 1973. After his honorable discharge, the plaintiff obtained a Bachelor of Science Degree from the University of Southwestern Louisiana in 1976. The Vermilion Parish School Board hired the plaintiff as a teacher in Fall 1976. According to the defendant's Response to Request for Admissions, which was entered into the record, the Vermilion Parish School Board gave him "credit" for his prior military services "for purposes of the minimum salary schedule for teachers in Louisiana, and therefore beginning as a `five' (5) year teacher, rather than a `First' (1) year teacher on the schedule of minimum wages of Louisiana School Teachers." Mr. Watkins' employment in Vermilion Parish continued until January 19, 1979.

Mr. Watkins was hired by the St. Martin Parish School Board in January 1979. According to Mr. Watkins, he informed the *849 Personnel Director, Joseph Wiltz, of his military service and requested credit for his years of service. According to both the plaintiff and Mr. Wiltz, this credit was denied. Mr. Wiltz testified that the denial was based upon the defendant's military leave policy, which he explained required that military service interrupt employment as a teacher in order for credit to be awarded. Mr. Wiltz remained as Personnel Director until 1987. He testified that he consistently applied the policy.

Mr. Watkins testified that, in 2002, he was informed by fellow School Board employee Charles Trenchard that Mr. Trenchard had been given credit for his years of military service. Like Mr. Watkins, Mr. Trenchard's military service was completed prior to the commencement of his teaching career. Mr. Watkins testified that he spoke with Human Resources Director[1] David Dugas, who confirmed that Mr. Trenchard had been awarded credit for his military service. Mr. Dugas testified that Mr. Trenchard had transferred the credit for his military service from Lafayette Parish. Mr. Dugas explained that it was his understanding that the defendant school board "gave any and all honorably discharged veterans up to four years of military credit for payroll purposes." The record establishes that during the period of the plaintiff's employment a number of other teachers, in addition to Mr. Trenchard, had been given credit for prior military service.

After his conversation with Mr. Trenchard, Mr. Watkins again requested that he be provided credit for his years of military service. He also requested reimbursement of the wages for the years in which he had not been provided credit. Lottie Beebe, the School Board's Supervisor of Human Resources at that time, testified that, like Mr. Wiltz, she interpreted the defendant's military credit policy as requiring that teaching be interrupted by military service. The request for credit and associated back wages was referred to the School Board for its consideration.

On January 31, 2003, the defendant presented a check to Mr. Watkins for gross pay in the amount of $4,293.32. An attached letter addressed to Mr. Watkins and signed by Gwyn Theriot, the School Board's Chief Financial Officer, explained that it was "a payroll check for settlement of military time." The check represented back pay for the previous three years plus interest. According to Ms. Beebe, the check reflected the School Board's reaction "to the advice of Mr. Chester Cedars, who is legal counsel, because ... he wanted to more or less minimize any damages if that would be the case."

Mr. Watkins did not negotiate the check and filed the instant matter in June 2003, seeking "wages to which he is entitled from 1979 through the present date together with the appropriate notation and reflection of his retirement record that such wages are due and owing together with penalties and attorney fees for failure to pay the wages as required by Louisiana Law...." In its answer, the defendant asserted that the matter was prescribed. Consideration of the exception was deferred to the merits.

Following a hearing, the trial court denied the exception of prescription based upon a finding of contra non valentem. The trial court further found that given the defendant's application of its military service credit policy, a teacher's employment did not have to be interrupted in *850 order to receive credit for military service. Thus, the trial court found that the plaintiff was entitled to credit for his four years of military service. Based upon a stipulation as to wages and interest due, the trial court awarded damages in the amount of $95,321.75. The trial court awarded attorney's fees in the amount of $12,000.00.

The defendant appeals, arguing that the trial court erred in:

1. Failing to find that plaintiff's claim for back wages was limited by a three year prescriptive period pursuant to Louisiana Civil Code Article 3494 because the plaintiff should be credited with what he could have learned by reasonable diligence.
2. Determining that plaintiff was entitled to military service credit dating back to the date of his hiring in 1979.
3. Finding that the St. Martin Parish School Board was bound to pay plaintiff with credit for military service in contradiction to written Board policy and pertinent state law.
4. Finding that the St. Martin Parish School Board was bound by the mistaken actions of two personnel directors taken in violation of written Board policy without approval of the school board.
5. Finding that the ultra vires acts of two personnel directors in improperly granting military service credit to four or five teachers out of the hundreds of teachers hired between 1979-2003 in violation of written school board policy bound the Board to grant military service credit to plaintiff.
6. Awarding plaintiff attorney's fees under La.R.S. 23:632 because his claim for wages was not well founded and because there is no evidence in the record to substantiate the amount awarded.

Discussion

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Waller v. State, Department of Health & Hospitals
79 So. 3d 1085 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2011)
Bartucci v. Jackson
246 F. App'x 254 (Fifth Circuit, 2007)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
929 So. 2d 846, 2006 La. App. LEXIS 1038, 2006 WL 1155253, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/watkins-v-st-martin-parish-school-bd-lactapp-2006.