Waters v. Durrence

Supreme Court of Georgia

Waters v. Durrence

182 S.E. 186, 181 Ga. 359, 1935 Ga. LEXIS 90

CourtSupreme Court of Georgia

DecidedOctober 19, 1935

DocketNo. 10894

StatusPublished

Cited by2 cases

This text of 182 S.E. 186 (Waters v. Durrence) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Supreme Court of Georgia primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook

Waters v. Durrence, 182 S.E. 186, 181 Ga. 359, 1935 Ga. LEXIS 90 (Ga. 1935).

Pincite

Opinion

Hutcheson, Justice.

Where a year’s support is set apart to a widow and minor children, and there is no affirmative proof that legal citation was not published, the presumption is that the law was complied with as to such citation. Winn v. Lunsford, 130 Ga. 436 (61 S. E. 9).

It will be noted from the return of the appraisers in the foregoing statement of facts that the appraisers set apart “51 acres of land,” but also that they stated in the return that they were setting apart “the entire estate,” and the defendant testified that the 151-acre tract was all the land owned by the intestate at the time of his death. If the judgment purports to set apart all of the lands of the deceased, parol evidence is admissible to show what lands were owned by the deceased. McSwain v. Ricketson, 129 Ga. 176, 179 (58 S. E. 655); Hancock v. King, 133 Ga. 734 (66 S. E. 949). “When a report of appraisers to set apart a year’s support shows that they appraised the entire estate of the [361]*361decedent and designated the whole of it as the year’s support to be allowed, failure to minutely describe [or an erroneous description] in the report the realty belonging to the estate does not render the proceeding void.” Moore v. Moore, 126 Ga. 735 (2 a) (55 S. E. 950); Stringfellow v. Stringfellow, 112 Ga. 494 (37 S. E. 767).

The land -in question could not be legally partitioned, because the widow has the right to possession and control of the same during her life. Where the allowance of a year’s support is set apart in land to a widow and her minor children, it is not subject to partition so long as there is either a widow or minor child to be supported. Whitt v. Ketchum, 84 Ga. 128 (10 S. E. 503).

The conclusion arrived at by the auditor, so far as adverse to the plaintiffs, was correct, and the judge did not err in making it the judgment of the court.

Judgment affirmed.

All the Justices concur, except Russell, G. J., absent because of illness.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Hutcheson, Justice.

Where a year’s support is set apart to a widow and minor children, and there is no affirmative proof that legal citation was not published, the presumption is that the law was complied with as to such citation. Winn v. Lunsford, 130 Ga. 436 (61 S. E. 9).

It will be noted from the return of the appraisers in the foregoing statement of facts that the appraisers set apart “51 acres of land,” but also that they stated in the return that they were setting apart “the entire estate,” and the defendant testified that the 151-acre tract was all the land owned by the intestate at the time of his death. If the judgment purports to set apart all of the lands of the deceased, parol evidence is admissible to show what lands were owned by the deceased. McSwain v. Ricketson, 129 Ga. 176, 179 (58 S. E. 655); Hancock v. King, 133 Ga. 734 (66 S. E. 949). “When a report of appraisers to set apart a year’s support shows that they appraised the entire estate of the [361]*361decedent and designated the whole of it as the year’s support to be allowed, failure to minutely describe [or an erroneous description] in the report the realty belonging to the estate does not render the proceeding void.” Moore v. Moore, 126 Ga. 735 (2 a) (55 S. E. 950); Stringfellow v. Stringfellow, 112 Ga. 494 (37 S. E. 767).

The land -in question could not be legally partitioned, because the widow has the right to possession and control of the same during her life. Where the allowance of a year’s support is set apart in land to a widow and her minor children, it is not subject to partition so long as there is either a widow or minor child to be supported. Whitt v. Ketchum, 84 Ga. 128 (10 S. E. 503).

The conclusion arrived at by the auditor, so far as adverse to the plaintiffs, was correct, and the judge did not err in making it the judgment of the court.

Judgment affirmed.

All the Justices concur, except Russell, G. J., absent because of illness.

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)

182 S.E. 186, 181 Ga. 359, 1935 Ga. LEXIS 90, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/waters-v-durrence-ga-1935.

Opinion

Related

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack