Walker v. Board of Supervisors

81 So. 2d 225, 224 Miss. 801, 1955 Miss. LEXIS 543
CourtMississippi Supreme Court
DecidedJune 13, 1955
DocketNo. 39819
StatusPublished
Cited by3 cases

This text of 81 So. 2d 225 (Walker v. Board of Supervisors) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Mississippi Supreme Court primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Walker v. Board of Supervisors, 81 So. 2d 225, 224 Miss. 801, 1955 Miss. LEXIS 543 (Mich. 1955).

Opinion

McGeáee, C. J.

This is a proceeding to validate $498,600.00 of 1954 Road and Bridge Bonds of Monroe County, Mississippi, issued under Senate Bill 1756 approved May 4, 1954, (Chapter-524, Local and Private Laws of 1954) entitled “An Act authorizing the board of supervisors of Monroe County, Mississippi, to issue bonds in an amount not exceeding, $500,000.00 for the purpose of constructing, reconstructing, and maintaining the roads and bridges of said county; prescribing the form and terms of such bonds; and providing the method of repayment. ’ ’

The authority of the appellants Allen Aiken Walker and others to have appeared in the chancery court to contest the validation of the bonds is not challenged.

While, the title of this Act does not so disclose, Section 9 thereof provides that “an excise tax of not exceeding one cent (1) per gallon, in addition to any such tax levied [811]*811and collected by tbe State in Monroe County, for tbe distribution of gasoline, may be collected for the benefit of said county, such collection to be made at the time and in the manner provided for the collection of the gasoline tax generally, and sums received from such tax shall be remitted by the Motor Vehicle Comptroller to the county at the same time as is remitted the amount due to the county out of the regular gasoline tax. The additional funds so derived shall be applied exclusively to paying the interest and principal on said bonds and to provide a sinking fund for retirement of same. The board of supervisors of said county, if desiring to collect., said, tax, shall enter an order on its minutes levying such tax, # # * J > ■ . ! , . '

It is important here to note that there is no-provision in the Act about this excise tax not applying to .gasoline “purchased and used for agricultural, maritime, industrial or domestic purposes,” hereinafter discussed.

On July 13, 1954, the board of supervisors adopted its resolution declaring the intention of the board to issue the said amount of “road and bridge bonds authorized by Senate Bill 1756, Local and Private Laws 1954, for the purpose of constructing, reconstructing and building roads and bridges of said county, including- the bridge or bridges over a river or stream forming part of the boundary line of Monroe County”.

This resolution set out the form of notice to the qualified electors of the county, to be published in the.local newspapers for the time required by law, giving notice that on August 7, 1954, the board would direct the issuance of such bonds, for the construction, reconstruction and building of the several road and bridge projects therein set forth, unless twenty percent of the qualified electors of the county should file their written protest against the issuance of the bonds on or before the 6th day of August, 1954, and in which event an election would be held to determine the question of whether or not such bonds should be issued. • ■

[812]*812The resolution contained the further provision that ‘ ‘ it is not the desire of the board of supervisors for any lax to be imposed on gasoline to include any tax on refund gasoline sold to farmers, and that the board intends to seek an amendment to Senate Bill 1756 to that end and purpose”. (Italics ours).

Thereafter the Board duly adjudicated on its minutes that 115 petitions containing an estimated 2,383 signatures, being the names of more than twenty percent of the qualified electors, had been filed protesting the issuance of said bonds. Therefore an election was called on the question, to be held on the 14th day of September, 1954. The notice to the qualified electors of the election recited that “said bond issue is proposed to be financed by an excise tax not exceeding one cent per gallon on gasoline sold in Monroe County, Mississippi, * * *

and in the event this excise tax not exceeding one cent a gallon on the gasoline is not sufficient to meet the annual interest and the bonds as they mature annually, a special tax sufficient to provide for the payment of the interest on said bonds and the principal of said bonds shall be levied on all taxable property in Monroe County, Mississippi”. Nothing was said in the notice of the election about an exemption from this gasoline tax of gasoline “purchased and used for agricultural, maritime, industrial or domestic purposes”. It is stipulated in the record that the “refund” gasoline tax of one cent per gallon for gasoline purchased and used for said purposes out of the seven cents per gallon levied by the State under general law amounted to :

“Fiscal year, July, 1950 through June, 1951...$15,265.03 Fiscal year, July, 1951 through June, 1952...$20,433.31 Fiscal year, July, 1952 through June, 1953...$19,711.12.”

After the election was held on September 14, 1954, and had carried by 52 votes over the required three-fifths majority of those voting in the election, the legislature at its extraordinary session of 1954 by Senate Bill 1222, approved on September 17, 1954, amended Section 9 of [813]*813Senate Bill 1756 so as to exempt and exclude from the payment of this excise tax in Monroe County all gasoline purchased and used for agricultural, maritime, industrial or domestic purposes. Therefore the subsequent resolutions and orders of the board of supervisors declaring the result of the election and providing for the issuance and sale of the bonds, and prescribing the form of the bonds, undertook to exempt from the excise tax of one cent per gallon on the gasoline sold and distributed in Monroe County such gasoline as was purchased and used for said purposes, contrary to the notice to the qualified electors which had been published prior to the election on September 14, 1954. The trial court held that this was not a material change from the question voted on in the election, although the exemption was to run throughout the life of the bonds, and although the original resolution of the board of supervisors in regard to the proposed issuance of the bonds had stated only that it was not the desire of the board that the excise tax on gasoline should be imposed on “refund” gasoline “sold to farmers”, saying nothing about whether or not it was the desire of the board to exempt such gasoline as was purchased and used for industrial, maritime or domestic purposes, and although the notice of the election said nothing about an exemption of any gasoline sold or distributed in the county.

Section 8 of Senate Bill 1756 — a purely local or special law — provided that: “Said bonds, when issued, shall be the direct obligations of said county, and the full faith, credit, and resources of Monroe County shall be irrevocably pledged for the payment thereof. It shall be the duty of the board of supervisors annually to levy upon all taxable property within said county a special tax sufficient to provide for the payment of the interest on said bonds as it accrues and the principal of said bond as it matures; provided, however, that if any other funds should be or become available and be appropriated by the board of supervisors for the aforesaid [814]*814purposes, or if the gasoline tax provided in section 9 of this act should'be levied and be appropriated by the board of supervisors for the aforesaid purposes, then and in that event the amount of special taxes to be levied under this section may be correspondingly reduced. ’ ’

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Wilson v. JONES CTY. BD. OF SUPERVISORS
342 So. 2d 1293 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 1977)
Culley v. Pearl River Industrial Commission
108 So. 2d 390 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 1959)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
81 So. 2d 225, 224 Miss. 801, 1955 Miss. LEXIS 543, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/walker-v-board-of-supervisors-miss-1955.