Wagner Wholesale Marine, Inc. v. Terrell
This text of 518 So. 2d 1141 (Wagner Wholesale Marine, Inc. v. Terrell) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Louisiana Court of Appeal primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.
Opinion
Edwin A. Lombard, Clerk of Orleans Parish Criminal Court, appeals a garnishment judgment involving money seized as contraband in conjunction with a drug arrest.
The facts are not disputed. In 1981 Wagner Wholesale Marine, Inc. obtained a judgment against Timothy Terrell for $3,210.35 plus interest, costs and attorney’s fees. In 1984 Terrell was charged with possession of cocaine and diazepam with intent to distribute. Incidental to his arrest $20,000.00 was seized and turned over to Lombard until the case was resolved.
In May, 1984 Lombard was served with interrogatories and a writ of fieri facias pursuant to garnishment proceedings filed by Wagner against Terrell. Wagner filed a rule to show cause why judgment should not be entered against Lombard as garnishee. Lombard ignored the rule and on August 2, 1985 the Civil District Court ordered:
[TJhat there be judgment herein for Wagner Wholesale Marine, Inc., plaintiff herein and against Edwin A. Lombard, Clerk of Court, Criminal District Court, Parish of Orleans, garnishee herein, ordering the garnishee to pay to plaintiff, through the Sheriff of this Court, out of monies of the defendant to satisfy the garnishment filed herein.
The judgment states that Lombard accepted service of the interrogatories, admitted possession of the $20,000, and approved the judgment. Above the signatures of each attorney on the judgment are the limiting words “Service Accepted, Judgment Approved as to Form.” Later that month Lombard answered the interrogatories as follows:
1. The Clerk of Criminal District Court for the Parish of Orleans has physical possession of Twenty Thousand and no/100 Dollars ($20,000.00).
2. The above sum was seized in connection with criminal proceedings entitled “State of Louisiana v. Timothy Terrell”, docket No. 300-623 “G” of the docket of Criminal District Court for the Parish of Orleans.
3. The Criminal District Court cannot determine- the legal owner of the above said property.
Terrell pled guilty on July 2, 1986 and pursuant to sentencing the trial judge ordered:
[T]he Property Clerk for the Orleans Parish Criminal District Court to release twenty-thousand ($20,000.00) Dollars in U.S. currency now in his possession, which represents a portion of the monies confiscated from the above-named defendant upon his arrest, to Liz Stogner, Administrative Assistant in the Judicial Administrator’s Office, for Liz Stogner to place this twenty-thousand ($20,-000.00) Dollars in the Criminal Court Fund.
In November, 1986 Wagner moved for a second garnishment judgment alleging Lombard had answered the interrogatories, consented to a judgment, but failed to turn over the funds.
[1143]*1143On February 12, 1987 the Civil District Court rendered another judgment:
IT IS ORDERED, ADJUDGED AND DECREED, that there be judgment herein for Wagner Wholesale Marine, Inc., plaintiff herein and against Edwin A. Lombard, Clerk of Court, Criminal District Court, Parish of Orleans, garnishee, in the amount of the unpaid Judgment with interest, attorney’s fees in the amount of THREE HUNDRED AND 00/100 ($300.00) DOLLARS and all costs of these proceedings.
Lombard filed a motion for a new trial which was denied on March 10, 1987.
Lombard appeals arguing that La.R.S. 32:1550,1 relative to seizure and forfeiture, and La.R.S. 15:41,2 relative to disposition of seized property, preclude jurisdiction over the funds by the Civil District Court.
We find there is insufficient proof to support either judgment. La.C.C.P. Art. 2415 provides that a third person may be ordered to deliver property when the garnishee admits property belongs to the judgment debtor or when such is found after trial on a contradictory motion. Lombard’s answers to the interrogatories specifically state that ownership of the funds was unknown. Terrell’s ownership of the money was never admitted or judicially determined.
Wagner urges that Lombard cannot escape the finality of the 1985 consent judgment. However, Lombard’s limited approval was specifically as to the form, not its content. Importantly, R.S. 32:1550 [1144]*1144A specifies that all property rights to contraband are forfeited; hence, as of Terrell’s 1984 arrest the money belonged to the State. Pursuant to R.S. 32:1550 D the money is not subject to sequestration or attachment, is in custody of the police department, and subject only to the orders of criminal district court.
Wagner also urges the criminal trial judge’s forfeiture order does not comply with La.R.S. 32:1550 and 15:41. We note Wagner did not comply with R.S. 15:41 by filing a contradictory motion in criminal district court to establish its claim.
Wagner moved for the 1987 judgment based solely on Lombard’s noncompliance with the 1985 judgment. However, C.C.P. Art. 2415 requires property to be in the possession of the garnishee. In 1987 Lombard was no longer the custodian as of the July 2, 1986 forfeiture order.
In addition, since the Criminal District Court had jurisdiction over the cash held by its Clerk, jurisdiction over it could not be conferred on the Civil District Court by consent of the parties. La. C.C.P. Art. 3.
The judgment is reversed. Plaintiff’s petition is dismissed at its costs.
REVERSED.
Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI
Cite This Page — Counsel Stack
518 So. 2d 1141, 1987 La. App. LEXIS 11067, 1987 WL 28974, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/wagner-wholesale-marine-inc-v-terrell-lactapp-1987.