Vogel, George Wilhelm

CourtCourt of Appeals of Texas
DecidedNovember 23, 2015
DocketWR-84,259-01
StatusPublished

This text of Vogel, George Wilhelm (Vogel, George Wilhelm) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Court of Appeals of Texas primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Vogel, George Wilhelm, (Tex. Ct. App. 2015).

Opinion

%zsvm ~

j RECE|VED lN COURT OF CR|M|NAL APPEALS

-/<:= QXL\`\(". 01 (:¢-_\\>SX `

NOV 23 2015

K°- §\)d\`~&\€>?\\$:~\ QQ N\a\\c>~¥\S 5` \.)Sf\\\`S

Abe| Aggsia, Cle[k

`\Be‘_dv "5§¢ f\\\q§s\w'~

a\ck<~».¢& ¢¢¢e_ N`o\~\¢`v~s'o~v\& \,:>§¢\\~5 \~=> \q¢ \\\\\-<.& 0»~ ~\-°-_Lc§ot.\'\a'§v

§§ WL:$&KL(§A_\LLM_QLL_@&=U»A_Ql\ L®`q\

~¥4,.¢ <§od‘°~‘\~`=d=' 433 \q'v\ed L\J e_ =»Q ;»\ ` .\A_U_ _b_-l\l\l`/\ M`\s M¢u.{\

\DL *;\_Cd\€r\)\!.,\_€(\>'z `

' ` § Q~‘Q~z\ \“\§BFQ%_{"=.\~&S \,~.'>\x<\)\€g§( 0`\'\\.\__:_____ C\§\\`c§&. \R__\_ {`_L_BQQ~(`QQS \__;\__ \l\¢\\>-K ‘(\© \JCQ~‘\_____ ,_~,-‘1\~ La&\Aq ¥~u` §m,`r\“ guy \\A.~` $\‘c,.\~u¢ c&~ qv\_»\\ L‘¢ s1 v\¢¢` o\ va~»\\)\»§\-L./‘

\° L\ML\; l\¢s s\Q\\\s-’ \\\,> QS\M¢. §Q/` ¢»~ \&L\<»s \1> \1\0~»_> \Q»Q ~\M\_;

`i\orv-q\\`.\\\o\\’\cs os> `S_ wm ~&\o`-o\e 3§§\\5 , Q\==\v\ 1 S~`~M\§~\\ \>`3-\\¢` ~4\0@'~

QSY.'~_#\_¢BLM_S _ ~_ _§_\&MKL\S.\~_\>LFA \':»o\a,\L §m\w~ 5\'\~)` C<>’-w\` \"v\ O\ S;Q\O \.J-'>Q,S`\LS \ ‘sz>»\‘\-\)\S g

,'/`\_'\§,h$$:;§_¢¢`_\§\b\z\_§~§_~§w\;§§w~ ij\&.Q\\kN_/LA_`_Q.\.\A§._

Q'\.w <`<:\L_\\>.osxk ié= malng

`\H:QSQ_\_SL~\\O v\\* 33 ‘\ g ¥:M 35 o

L\;|‘\A:\) SXov\ aY`)( ~\ 1 3$)

C_,o._w\e (\ 1:>

'T_v\ ¥`L` ' _ Cfl w"KL m\\~a\vw \)c»e\!z_\ g `_\__v\ 5~>\!\4 e.r"\M\"/\°\&" (p\a$°~*°¢\ v § Qw,g\` §§ Agpu. §

c-b,(_?LL\-"-{\ Q_.\L{`k-» qq` (`ou`l`\".\’__\:(~ O`\\Mi`&\,

Q_\&c~`€` §§ ecw&€' \, Q§\m 5\~0?\/\'$‘ Yr\'v\c ,

§§ ix -S¥\v\ i-\-X

` ` Q_\/_\\_§_Q'_: MS\:`, .\L».. `)A§@MLL \'(aM-§V\o-Ml\>?»>ov\ ¥-_r~`os`-_\'

"`:\_':,_5\-\»`113'¥ '\\~=v\c<`&v\g %\/\<>r~<>v~ MQC_¢L\\’;\_ \\`\c,-.\¢.c~<-dc>\p` give ?\¢\¢L:»v\ \'

\\ov\¢qrq\o\L \{1#\ \>3§31 ;

CS"~:\°\ 5\>*'\€.. §M§rl°_v\\)"\ qu`r" 'S` A.[\\p¢`cks \v\ 5>\'\°;\("‘ Q'W\Q.\C>.\ Qq[`?h.g\\-\\

O¢~ AP\'\Q\¢` %\ku¢

?\o`\v§\-\Q&S er\'ca\`v\o_\ m§\c§~;_g»£¢p .:(‘1\¢~\¥ 991 N\o`v\é o`vwo§ o`AA`) v E`>L~\-r<>`or\¢\\r\ow_u\ W\q§r'&¢`% v

\ a 331 \§<>~\c> ve.\v\__::s>é><:__§o"\_§ _Qg;\s,v*§'

. (`W\ c.__¢§b v_\g__u.> &\w-“BL\S\\\!\L\M_\)LKQQ §§10§10(` 000 31 \~»\ 5x-\:\cL GAQQ\)L* 3\~4\\1<\°

O`v\<§\ `&\u M\§\£`L<§ @o§,g_ °~V\C§ ;§\QS §>~'\\S O"\°\\v\<>§\ Q®\h\\c \\Q\/\ ~Qc.c~ '~.>3€~\; G'Q

\`\:\`o`v\ §o\\w\u$ c.\v\<~§ -2_~£5\~.'~<»\@¢¢\\1\°~'\»\\ w\\lr s 'b\w~_$\-»~Qv\¥ \<> 5\\& \|QL>>S;QFOL‘

,<_c§\»s~c“> sOr` <\=~\S_S Cov\\,q\~/\u'\ §x>r\§‘\\v\ 5\5~'\1 \s.:)'z~\*' \'4 o_v\<§ \)QQ'J~\& §\/\Q@

~¥~J\L Cou`rl¥ ‘\>V\{ Q§\\o\.c.;`\/\K°e

;"i\

‘\- v zé\w\£_£_,g` oQ' gav\\e§-

m___&_\° (`

wae§ \Q\\\AM §O%Q\ .` \»C: ~.\a¢ wmaqu

Q€>~'\‘Q\‘\u& c»_¥' ML`YQ\Q~\S\<»\\ \')v\\\' arc- \ BC.T \v\ vQO\K

Qm`.`.v\\q "\"¢qu c\v\c§ Qow\ \sz_ Co<\\&c§v€c& \ {ch»_\e<& oév; D>‘B“la._F'M 350 . `

L\v \`~v\<\’\\$\~gv\ :v‘l\ "1"| 33-(

?\v.§.€> o~\c\u\`\*( 53

\<` G\\ waf`€&\ L\(\v>`,Q` `§,LQ u~\\‘v\ Q;\&F\L dc 6 cum+'\

d C.\\<~\;'\D§\I\Lf' \¢?<~\v\L C:\\u`\é\ Q'Q'Cc\er\`%

\')(0\'\@€`0"_3\‘1- \`\/\ fm _>)\' Q§!\\Lg gu§~\Ce_ \\Q CQO\""T')

l \A:Ov\c>c‘o.\>\<_ <~7>\\0\1"¢\/\ MQ.\CQ`\\~\ § \1LS~\~\C4 \

‘~\ov\e<`a\'\la. ‘\)\cw<, w %r`u.uv\ 1 503\~\€€ )

\5¢0\\¢0¢&\&_ kux L’~')\‘-\»L)

G-~v\e\ `\\I\L EQan-F`er`>¢A Qo‘~u"\‘. ~'Q \A

Quoqc\\u` ©f` Cu`c~mvc`v %\:_.chssc.r‘s `X§v\~=EY Q_Ow\ \>L \CCcL\-€.c§ OA' .. n ;:>u® srsz Qc.u_&\\\ €Q (¥

301 ':<;nn\ Y\%*" -\,_S\-L¢=Qq§ v

Hou$\-o»\\"l">( '|'I 001 \,;‘<\

\‘5~@\\\"\5 QDW\X‘A_'TQLQ_&

'\29._

va :E.;>\L §§ Q`M:w;$

§§WQ\\§\}§ 13\,.5§@\<§ i§:==§ <§uo£s\mrc\s §\\L , _ . l

§'\Q\\m\ \ 3»¢.3%¢ “o\ QQm\.\-\ c¢~\L l v ‘_ §\¢\\Q\,\ q\m\\\w¢§v § QQ.M`§L\ . 5 f "\\ng@e§\v»\ \~.\§~`m\°<§ v§ ¢\¢.\Rr \¢ cwaqu 4\~¢\<§\: \\\-»\\Q\ \\\e\~.x\ ., » 4 @¢AU~ m\\w~\wk< 131 QM\:L\ ` _ , _ 5 \\\m \\\>uL\\\»\Q,M\NL mg j ' f _ '. Q~\Q Y\M\M§ m\¢\§»;m\ w¢;\ §§ M“>`M ~_» l w,w@~&\ W`.\ W;\\m ‘»\ ~'&s" `\3\\ Q_ IV\;W 4,&\_ Q@>\M(\§Q§ . , _ l/-\ - \K 'b. SXA\QW`¢§ §§ QQSL_ ' 7 \<1 ~ze ./; axq\.km§ A. §\ws¢\\c\;¢k ~ w ' F. ':m,¢_-x <\`>RM\L&§:¢;~ ¢;\\.LQ- m- 3a Q, K\A\»\N»\§ §§ Qq.&:> ' _ '5\ - 39- \A- '{Bw<}§c\»\u\- 1 ` 33 "' fd- _;. o`<§§c /. AQ_>§\AQ\;\`\~ '(95“°."1(¢ b '<'>1 - B\G~\kwv& u§ ¢L\\Qv\§r& l 4 "\’\ -"\¢\ 5 , csva %\oév`»\w`\)ér ' 5"° ‘\' `-Y>`\G,Q\<"S LQ\Q d\c\~\ev\€§wq\ c\e£\v\\\\`ov\$~ 3.'\\ _5 *' -\Q.`\¢Q,.;l.,\\._&.a.;_ -%`2~33 16 mm 5;1&`\3_\,\.®‘(.’>} a@\\;s\v w w-

~TDC_S c.§c\¢~>§-Lé\ _S,v\w\o`\z\-cus-\--Q\\A'¢\ uccch %\o

' ll"§\\=)w’§¢\g \v\¢\\cx`\'u\€'L{`Q»o~/$nv\\')<€‘\ 3

1'3\

`<;;\\; § QQ\\L§§_%».» S.,_¢;\\‘% §__'§>_:_¢_;_;.EMA\§ \\s\rw\ .

: \I'ICL_P<'T:LQD DF -L/_\' 130':$3£‘ §4\\,` Ac:c‘>/bur;, z=:§ ` 35 \ \r:c@u\mv© <»F MI:\F:°J€P

2 `F'/§:».mz@ ~ro baum U\S€‘A¢\)d ?Mesem' vs §wbéq€ '?>Ll

`S-T|\I.L)o\?-€ ‘\`o TILE P~wd DOL\LE'F' QA<§€ wl '\ REA%ONAE>L'CT\ME' 35

q »;P\"-\'-L.T® ‘P\ES\?me Qa_ wMMoM\QNTE w\_'%§n-\r Y~AP-T-E€"d.. . ` _35“

5 . \?\1\:».\>9~€ to ‘D?~\

"Y\" "\)\E§vowb€m\’% \s:¢i_\'\-v€w> \>\EL.AT<>'R§ ©`\L~\\x;v§@ ®E~v::v\ovo 3e1

'Yi\: umwa-moa QF: ’S>'\>*\- Q\G~*\T~S 440

§\. Q.sv\§¥\\~§\\v~\é§ \\oi\\/\\ Q§ME `®&o<.ess vume '¢\\

’B' p\'-"LB\¥`Y m bz'P~T €~`QP K>¢sv Qarouxcr\'o© QEL\ &`F.- 95

Q., Q€L\\TQP.S \?;1&,~¥§ vs <;:Pv:c.(Z-I XM§A\?-=¥ :r.M_ `YQ~I*‘

b Qp\:)sw-»\-v\\x-\QMM_ V`\C\\\T §Q Q\,~.wms€i. v:Qwv‘\'L-:r> 43

E. C_owm:r_m\oww. R\e¢\\~w?-,'FFEQ\\)E Qmm\)s€¢ \xxo@v-re\> 51 z

35 ®ELM~FQRS %m$\'*:;\~vv\o§wA-L §\C-»'\"<\` \'O N@€SS*OQ‘°“RTS V‘U€BSS

§ ,‘\a`&¢>¢-r@\c 13 gamch B€~v\\;m€\> :LLL.€QJ\L¢_~§ ` (ol

\2>4><_k

,1»';'~§ »»'»a .`

C . :~\§x¢`>§ ‘v§ §-~§_\;Q¢ \\\Q§

`P`o`c\\)<\$\

QEAL §§ ~'\i,§§§sf§°¥ § E\;§` §§

Q\r\f> d d ‘5"'\` v A { »

M<`o\r\`\\l>_i’> Qq\ F?>Q'“LGY 'L\O\S<& (De~\)'vs .\. L<\Q-\w" (Q,O\ \:3¢\ L\'_:')°\ 7 ‘SY\ SA' 4 wabe v ©\\\@ 60 11 F%¢»Sl 338 5'~\ S\MQ§OM m\@\%\ 450 Fz@& z,<>z,,z<>s ` 52 '“\’Q_\\\,\QQQ§; 0\€03¢;@3@ 151 ‘Y ~ 3qu

'*\>.w'\.> u L;> .;1&'105 51

C,ge..of~<:r»`\O\>S\/\ LQ'~O "

` 4.;1@\€@`)_:~. v>.~\ Q\L\, Q¢;M»\MCL )o'm-\o~ls-(w\@§ ql\sz<.m

_!L<.><\<> “'I:,\ D=g\_> L-L)€'\F> `I;~\ m S\Q`\P. 300(0 “T<,x Nc\>g Lax\s loq _ '°)?> MLCX@L\¢\ `;1<>\5 ""\:\q NQ L¢)<'\:> 5150_5 ( . 5'~\~\ 513 w§ X>\s\- LU'\_<. `\BU\\Q§\ \) S\U`\M'z sims _\)

mci

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack