Villa, Daniel

Court of Appeals of Texas

Villa, Daniel

Court of Appeals of Texas·Decided October 5, 2015·No. WR-29,948-10·Published

Opinion

....: '-

BLISIL"hJ C.D.UilLQ£ Cll£m~>o.L_/.tJll!t:lt4s. Abel~Siti, CISrk _e o_J_IJ.o>LL~3_o~8~----------------~ _i.lu.s..t:.w .7:~~-'J.s_~lJ. _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __ 1

_/lE ,· fJI.IJ_i.Y.fiL D.lJ..!Li.J_'LJ:llzSJJ)!l..fll'Lr:2&17i£cr:a;w~-ro_ar:.~J:Ek..Er»:R.k!JG _ra /3.E_&EUJ:E_Aj_fd.Y..dl&~E-11i:Eli>/i~I~B-r!:i.IGI:!J_eEE...&IlLSi.Tmit£ Er,o~ UJZrtJ&ur.&B.5B!icJ:lLJ:JS.. £/J:QZ:S ''-------------~

j)ii!fli.}~Cl..J:JB.K. 1 Cf-l8_-!i.DJ!L,____ I . / ~iDJ!ll3fJSE_ED:Ji2.!J:I!lllrc:RJ.JX>_OOT.EcLr&M5..LD_&~:c8~&-

~o~ll£g/..LB.'I.. 721.1:s_C/JJ.#$Z..i3B&:a~u~E-7Jiil ~~ it:B:S'_ IIL!!.ll IE 7.1tJ;_Ce.u&L.LRJ%L.L.<9.hlky_71fi!J1llt.B_~-'-D-Iili.U.C~L~/.ZJJ _lli.E..fltlo.V_ii 8LY.Li:128.brl21JluJzzll)::}'l ~e-..~1~/LEJ;JE: Z'!J:l:& C28~ i1ECIJ;f)b)__Bhll2 etR12J.G_l:J_l12 TilE hrra,;.u:._e»_({)./!.. /J.lE-~L<.&'--~ ~- _z __l{_/(/2_/ll.7.l£L..f.J~Ct2e.Y..Lb_ (}JET/lici...CeUt?:T_8gL!Ifi!E_O:MlJiiFJ1£IceJ:V.£_ Jl2Y_e_I3_5JZcJ:LQ~/:te_ /:IRlZ /l1fl._liPJI2y_G.l:_Gbl BELelzL~~~/J.b/l()S§_EJ:UfJ.;;vr;

.e.E..~f.IJL!)__CJ2/JlCLIAJ:k.eJJJ!).E_/.d1;w_, .. L,.fit2J=-&lJ~_kE]J1:J;S.,~LUl_);Jk _f!!ll?f2t;);...jJ_E_~~IJ...§IYJBJJ...Il EJ.JZ:12EJ:JI~.'LLt~?Jt£mG 71/:J:S_Cf:MI)J . utl:JL 4£ZW~cQ.l!.t..4:..fll27_~~lliE~lJJJI1Jf.,_SJ-JoU:.l,il,I_/3JZJiE!J..V_~ft_(;l;l?,g_===-= .EEll~c&=J:l.!si__,8_Eca:J~?li~m~-kll.~-Y.~~-&l1te.,.$);JJ£ 'l:JJ:o:rldm&tff= _e.MeCJ:.,J!i.EJ!7sg_f!llES}:)J;'l:__llr.Js=:ro~CR-~~l!_, ..._ '*- "'·""'"" ,__ •

--~{lll.lhl.l;._. Y12,u./1.:.'Eflg__'/t9.YE._7J:l:n:~ $~ ?:J:JJ:S../1:!~ ~:-.,....._..........,.~-- 1

.£.&~=ltll//Jl...jJ)Ai2.Gil..tyl)£!1);8?;(;gCJ:L__ @l!IJI!i»R =5X!JJ~~t~_,_,.. ' I _.EL&E ~gg_I}£J;Tn-:C}_-);f£121{ZIJ,G_ilo.Ll3- i.-8:.. fd-~-~'!!1.:.·~--=-,__

~~OU~L~~-e~~-~~3~~L·~----------------=-~--~------ '..... . .•

~--~~GiltJsE JUfl,~2.tJol>- q.;:;.,f>_9_..-!g=:O:-B~--=----=-

..-:-_{)J:13-'bR];CL_C~)(-..,-...,~·, .. . -~""~-.c-==-=- =-="==... _,_,_,,. __ • d -

·=~{ti?.,_Bfl.IS-.8 S.l)"QS£!.:- ··~·:·· _,. ..,....,=~='""·''" •. •.· ... ,.,.. "..,, .._,.,._.,..___ ,~---~==-··;~=co=-:-.~----,~-,. _fl.dD.fh=li)$...,;_C/:JUJ)Xl4JJJ-is/E:=-==""""""""·-·"'"""-·""""'•-,:=·~~=====-=-===><=-·~=-c- ....

,.,e~.eJ,_(j()'X,_j_D.So"'~"'=-c-""=-o ..'C'====-· · ;,."'-~·- = = =... .... __ .._, ----.::::::::::J

~u~eo~~rexb3_~~~8~~~~~~~~-=~====~

. . ======·=-~=~~«======~- •. ~- ======~~=====·=== I .. .B.R;l~l'£LI-08iY7-:cS""l1!2MJ:=:J:::J:~JJ..S-=:l:Q=$I8Tii19..-EI~.l:2.4lJJ/9-=-t!J~~. ~ElJ:cl:BJ:JO-=-Cf;>.AJC).J.Jcfii.0AJ2-c;2£LdJ.w_e;y-=--~&JJ:J;EJ;ic£.,=--= ·" "'_ .

"{)g_J:f~-CL.:f?Jl.):.-),... .. . .. . .. . h •••••• -- · - ·" .l28-rE C~-~.tf5~:t.DJ~.. --,~ I "...... .ElJcL&SW~l!).l.~5/3..~~EPJl28111!aCB;_~T~-013sJECJ:ZILj,J$~Q"""" . SIHTES /2-1:J.){):DJG. &F Fos:;.LEtJJ.O~CPJJ'""ClddS.L0~-<:7E:/.,!Jk/.:..c:l.I!J-= c.S&4).'(Jj)J~Ce1~"JdMJJ.i£,_8[?JWj~_e_S;J:}t~fLJ~O=-IJJ.u.P:lB~.==-r:-8Ys.f£.~"-·-,-:-c:.·~ ,f1Li:JJ;}s;_£&£XlE-7J):Ji$_..f!J.8;lt::kl:LEM1b.&tJ=8.£I))£LLl:.D--!2tEJlJL-_ ~EJJ]:Zz>N-<:2Ll1ifi__CJ:)p~Z.r:~ .. --=- ___/3.1J1CW..s:.&_J:s__tJ=&XI!Jf.LC!)Il.'L~E7JtJ2iJ~&riiC~IcLlLJ3..JJg J2.7:F.JIJ:J.flBJ,_/2fr(BJZlJ:hll2~X.b.=~~~IN"'"&£@.~_£-- ...Sl3LK Ltdldldl.~E)t)QfilfJt4LilJIL!!Z't-12ii""~';/!LE!J§:.E~Sm.ug ..B=-Ce/1'l ~£Tlt~IJ2E!.'l:Z:£Ul)._Lb-=[);t~-=ilif~);'grcJ:. fl.U:&!l!QB~~'-=-== .. I '"'·=='['_JlJL)Ji<.=ttau~lfe~=~{},f.lg<>-~4$XilJJ~.,-W"'Z:kU:~~mB:U~,,= .

- . .. . ··=. =-· == =·= =-= . =j].&$,l!llc.r£..U2L~8Jde.az...1ZD1/2"'"===- . ~ .• /ll). #. _.,""-~--'. ,.,_,._ • _ --- .. "'''-'----- ~ _ ~,_,_~ -'--~ ~-~C.C ~- ~~~~'1l..~""'"""'La8..Ql).J$:'-'=----- --,--=-· """""""-"""'"''"--=·.~='- :::::.oc.....,.;,..,.=J r:::-·-:.:"'" ·-.,.~~"'---"-x~r .. - -·- -· __.,.,. -,.~T,J-trftm ,..U1J.l;_l;_,_c::j2,._-:_Q_~r~~=....,. ...,____ -···~=-------"'··-"" .... . .. _ .......... . 2:b.kS--:l!.£I

,.~e~~~-:-~m,~>rf~T.F;>.-u~UAl.Q~G c£ -~ .aalQ·.~~z;~fi.~~~.kau.J! Q~·rS-~v~J....... i.;~.,.......,..,~~

~7J:J.J~};;l~i~~)lJlJ~:o.(;;t:JJJiil:r:~,~(~~!<.ftl!@l4.;-~ . . I(:·:~ ~j· JJ).[J/Jl..C;jt).llJi5/ii21JAP~..U.W.tl:;kl&l~'fb~Jt:<, ~t.J:b4.~ .• . ..812attQ; a~\~8~. . .. . . . .. I Qll#:£liP(~EU&'?, I ·. . . . . . ..J)i:.,'i-~7;:2i.g. ,_ ,•• ~~~¢A4.:~.~g.r:/£~~.FJ£.~··.·. Jit?JX2l:JJ.~ff4;~/4J:/4J..!~~~~-8~{4JJ~fJ.l.f/JJ,vj@n:~~· .~~C:Z:IiJ~)3Jt~l~~~l;/bJ~(liJJi{ ~~ZJi[!. BP!:t§2JM.i$.. ~~ w,nr~~r: KJcu1~~ ~-ll•t?.-2 ~~[=~rri/2. at~~~~~~~~-~ SF?-~~.<7.~?.P~PY0f4!Aif.z:;pyq~~-· . .. . ,,;,:i;i~~~~~~~~OI:;#i~~;.* ..~:•·~~~ ··"#"~•:l;,tr·: l'l."'ii(IYo'l.a 1':ru1· . irl. ·_~~;,.;· *li'iM·.,;,·.,wnl~ iti

·~-~.r;;;tJJJ~l:IJ$.:;-~Q2&J;·~ ,e6$;~l;/;Ji . J/)/J§J~/2.~~~-~~~4-: U,,~iit/~'[;ij~e r-n; ~.. ~ 'T' ..Jc ~u1:-:rc;;~ 4' t:;:o..,... rr.;-r- r~ - ;,;;~.r;.~,.}~£d]Jt~~'!Pi!N;!~K?-'~"·~~il!t.4Jr.r·~· ~- . : : : r •.1.. 3. ,. ~.,c;~.~.~~'lJtll:i.~ .~f.ti.li.~. fttr;;Cl¥i~ §./i,k~~.~~ ~~C:Jlil~- ~-lO~,.~JaiJ4"llJ;(J/~JJJ)~~~l);llf(~~-a:lf;~~ ~--~ . . . . I .

.. f!([?Ji.. Jl~iclS . .~. y;c;;:Jj~i')r..·~~:i·pi.r.n::·rn.Q):·Il§.'tln'u.J:1 :,r~.··I n~t!i.·_-·i )!;i.litiio~o!¥ )~it.: .···9_:r.· ,. ·_ .·, ..iiit.iw':k(;~:.~Q~~t~~~-@vJ:~~. ti$a.f:«.Jf(~_~llt§~·t4JtJ.J..~.l :JJ~ae ~~rll~~.,y(ti~---~(?14~~,{;;/.(.f~~!~J:.{~~~/1~/if.~~;~l· -~~-. ~~~-~~~(~--'i;.~-~z;nil~~¥?;~-~ ·~~~i~1(J~~-~.(f)lli_f41iJ.lJ~l!;TJ;,.CIJ~~'~L :~.·~,. ,C(J.(.t!IQJ~~.~-~~~~~B.Q.J$JJ:t;:rTI~i1: W;w _,z&Qt4.~:~fJIJI/Jj~lJJ~-n-~~QJ.d~~Cti~i.·~..,{~ .fll£.J..t~~7EJil;];lJ/fi.,~lJJJt?'q!)fil,/iikl,~ ~l~4s;~ .a. ~-~-~~~r;i/Jil&/••~.fJJif! ~~ .Ta·.fll-h. ~~t4~.7i~t&¥t.t:t,g:~li5~-fi!JJ~--~~~~ . ZAll.d&~~Gi: (,;ob).U;~~~. tliJik~..ta.li§'QJlf&QIJ.IA~. t1:~~ I

~8Uii ~J.C;JJ.~J;f,./J.t~R~.l;~::$./.,J~~i!>~ ·.~;~ltllJ,, ~~~~liE-.~~4. .~~~~ .i£. .IJJ;F;. /J.t;,,':J.,,j;i~~'(:.~~. -~ ~ ~-~J~ MJ.iCA~£ J1/JatllS ·Q;IJ/?t.JS, . lat.W..:I:L,_~£./JJ~:a~J... ~1J:JtJI~ttllf~r;aqur~~~~- ..11..~1:>.okl2w~tJ)ti4~~.~JP.·f4.z;t:;.IP!iJ#l:tJ;;~4~ ..•.... -11~ (;6J~'I;jtWJ4.&Ao.. 'J:J4.~G$.4~·4--) ~U.f)/.tk .. . ..6~~· .o~IJJf/i. . _7;,7; ~~.!4i:s; a.l:t?-~ We~.--~-iiltJ.~t;4J;Afl:tlhr&kiJI:k..fi<..., £l.t(@~~Z:,..~_fiJ,~L,..a,~~ . S/l.V2.$.~r7)?Jini;@~4i.~. JJJ~tJ41J..lU:()..,G81JJJi4,W~.·f.fl/iJ~~IiJ.;/.£~c.~W.X.lU~l:Q..f,~pjiR~

P.2- '..c:;,.!,,lJ:iii.,:~~&~,..w ·i' w"'"i'~;.,<,irl-'>r·.,.~i·;oo-., '*riilld,;,._, ...., ,., ..,

~.~~~~.~~.~~J~.~ ll/JI?£~~4~~~

~.Ge)/).£ C!J.~:a.ct(?. .•-,, '" tr?:J f . . . . . . . .; •• g~·~- -.~~;,;,i",~"'-~·.~~.:·.·~'!"'#-!'-,''l""" f

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI