Home/Texas Supreme Court/Villa, Daniel

Villa, Daniel

Texas Supreme Court·Decided October 16, 2015·No. WR-29,948-10·Published

Opinion

B@ ,QC|QA 0

DHTE§L§¢?.'§Z;.ZDU ~

q~§ ~¢2§- - ~.-»§-"'x’§w::n;»w;q‘»~¢.... . ;, "§~ ` ", wi ' ’::v»§…"»"§_'§,';§=.-`.._:j .' g ‘

...Q&§¢§,§c@§m -§§§ » . ¢MBM~§»§G.QM&I§ §Qf. §N§M§m§§ . .w~ .~ .. RECHVEUTN §MQD §§I. Q§F Q§Mé駧 .WM§§..§§§£QUI MM¢NAL~APPEALS M.Q)..Ul¥z@g §§ ~J » §§;,-¢..,~ -_§ . 4_- §§§§§§§§ §§§ 162315.§

§§MJ§M§QB 7/1…§,§ §§ §§ §§ §§§§§§.§§§ § §§ . _, _ A_g_elAqg_sta C!_erk §2;§/2£.2,.1;12¢222;)§ Q§§B§M§I§L 172 § ... /§@/Q §§§§..§D§§§§ §§.Z§§§?.B»mm§<;@u

§£§§9@2./Q<§§§§M@c§)@§s§m,§~&§§§§§ ., ZW§FOK§‘£DJ§§§SZ§TMQLI§LU?LSMUM§§§

. ,J___ __ 2 72)75/7)=<:#/1) L2 S§@QZWM§»§ HQ/>§§/z 224§¢/536/13

w . ` _ ’“»§”-~ .' “_ ', »£MUNMMNJ~ZJWW§W “ * ». § § , ~ . 1 . ,- w)F/JQ@z/Ie)§§ 2§2§51§§..

""§§. .e.\s§ "§'.~," ... -":»¢'»~:¢ . ' . " '.§' '..§;“.I ‘ §.'" " _-ha_§~rg ‘ L ., …_§§

' m ' o -~ 4 " ~` ¢_Hu~ ._.- § . . , ~~ ' . ....…_,: , . '- ,

l _ 7 1110732.301`>¥}22/2€29~73 v;/7)1)77(:_y

22222.22/52-:207.9772§5@§332)71:2272) 779 .

2 2727 22272)7);)322520733232 12223221', ,97)72037272377 rin 2727- 333<;32373§322)22(2§ sr m 3227/722 772-n 377 » 2 CMU§SZ;OA) C@w,)?'>/)27`3X#2$2CH2&7) /1)1,/3)02:`2° 25(5<383//8,),22 /92222/-1/&255200727)02:2’@2§2§02/727?/222 777£5,,,/9/5§[7?/97 jr 717/75 /’757275 g¢~)g§@)\)/)L /<_77@7,9/ 737ng 1975 777/: /'790779 <;77973@ /777>27: 77 2£2222£2$; 732522§22'¢: 2225 /“-"02}79)7. §‘ , ~ 2 2222;2/2522272:2152%2/:77007722/72/ 772>:2r3/_1)777 02`1)2 C;)%$§ 22 .23.§222§§232§§§ . ,_ 2§032)2320 2 522.332222735/23222337 2777232022§§2;77723332@32223223727333373257¥2372wa 22212222832 02132<§7227”'2]7/07 1907/215 17727'_3 @F c7',/)715 5 2333 /2)712.2 2750332,7232322?3)237§ v 222§23 272/3237 122/93 2 71)3)32, 2772§20523 37225333)233) 033;7.2327773 63 rLr/w/Jc> ~ <;32>2§3§0722522222 2§2§§22:372232)2?32©02#277/32723 730th 2510 1931°19/9®95 R/: F19790 5/2§722\)§22;§3022§5:33311723 §171232§§2§3/2)7»§2322323£222 2722.322..22 /73273.2277 723c¢>3$ .32§72332 1~`/$£13» ._ :~ 1 1 `22$22§§022227)’32722;02 27232 C337er 252 20212722226222.3272177235139)>317 P/v'/?S/i- . 2 .222227§ 2239237322;2223222)3Y 33332373733§23332 227\)22):312323§223 2222§.22233»2/29) 222/322 322 1/1227932 , 7223.372 0371)1).2:272033 32022232 /m:37' 777/3 232 2032 23232 2 72§@2222323339 332 72§222033§22‘2. o 2232 ®3320933 32273 233'>`22©3)12,122021“122 §§222~) 377,/3220272 @)¢3.)3353)1) 2922/211 257 . 333221322;17232221§@3)2%322323§227§25.2<;32)11201?21>352$>’722 57723523<222131§'7222/3223§63§227§333:3»279 372 3333/92 mm§'z.z§;§vw¢?§§r§s 33279393277777§ 333 322 23552;332 222322§2§3 22332287233227\)6 7773 E>€)@a$z;/f

»». ..~. dm.e:;m-,,

\/_2

1°,/

, §§§ eo»z§§§§¢W/¢§£@QZP§MW mw Q¢,;z /;;,F/e§§§w, MM§§MM§)JM§ C§§:. .,_,..,§§E C,¢.?u§/:§§J;.§z/zs _;,.,, j ,MLM§§ZZ{£MJ§C;OM§/' Duz@§w§ §c/,¢z[/MQ ;, ~» . §§!z§§&?§[§/zz§wz a)§§§f§u§§..§§§§§§‘@ §/§PD!¢;,NM § ,_ _. MMM §§MM§§Z;/z§f§)<§f§s/ ,, ,M§§§§§)Q§§Q§ § sz§§§o.§i:§§§/€y_. § zz§lz:):zzzto§ml§§z?zz§ §w;§ _, § ~ ;. . ':`..`£§§Q.Q§Q§QIM§MJ§£M§§ ,C§,§.7.2391§)§§ -),§J§Fr;£€;:f Q§J,/?§¢.§§§f£ ,‘.Z,£Q§§ whaley oF 310st ' . , ,§§§F;§§s§ § !>’¢:Mz,:. §§§z§¢§§ §I§§; 3§_). §§)§ 3§1, 3§2 §§ 71 §M¢:. §§»§Mm§)§§§§§@)§a§w.§§§zf§ §z§§z/zz§.,e@)§§w ';_;\.,£zz§)¢§MM§QFMNSJ§BMW; .. ._ .. .. §&LQM§S.§M§ » § v …,§)42 §?£§!§§7..../£/?5;7.@§/2»0/0 xaaa€

~.»

w §§ “.“ ~* ‘-~» ~ w ’ ‘ ‘\-1_~. _v """' gm _____As .L.n§ .A.

P,i

§ _ _..In)/)OH.`??F:S._ QEQL@K&[Z@M

.__§L,§00002:22212:2229§‘?_/.3.3§2_23_/_0222722£292222:¢~22202;292222____§ §23£2225_/9@§§2§20129§720€290::§2@9720 220 522$7229222 02020; 20222;_~ 2290 V_/_Z.§)_Q§ 021£;22902§ QMM§ 2929029_27% @F 292920?22_@95 72902_:_ __§._§§ 29§@§(:02§’_022) §§7;0§/0 7 &2§2725/;;, 7/_22? /52_2@;5 §§_7725_22¢792;¢9_2;,;0; §merw§_§@;_l%w§000§®002 07

§§_§ 77 § § ., i. § . . .i w.52'”€_20222 020 1307/37 ,§_§202§5,

§, . § . , , , . § 222§5`722<;72'222/2'_“ §0022227720§,§__

,, § ., .. 30202 2§),1222209___#/_33~022&_§___§__§ ' &0§0§02222” ,'/§3_322/9 0 §§

§§ 27729.2?/20222§0020);2;22_+§§ ` 1 '

, § , 7 » 9225 202792922§2£_¢_`/§5/._1__§_-§§§-§§

§§§§§ §_ §§ _§..§.2§222122522909; 229<22;~ 9§'2;;2 `

E.. . . § x § ,,§ v~,»-. , §_. -

.. 22.§§. , ,.., § . §_ ,_ , :_ §¢ .¢.A- ~z M w *- L `,,, , _._ _.L_s_ § ,§__'z:.":_-_z- ~ - w ~ w \-~, h __ `. ____ v __§$_,,_ W--=z m v ~~-v-'-`-_»- --' _` M _ _§ ._.___. _ - --» § .._ § §§ __»-- _:__§-§_§_ __ __ __ ,.._..,._.. § _§__.. ~L § ~*_.; ~` 77 z ~>* __§ u<;§`._ §§ § _, ,. § §§ ~__~ 2 _- -w__ §

P-$

GHuSE 2226,-260;8»9))2299»29

39823139_660970 . 13 c150292€2§22223 660_2921 8227202:2)6 9062720 6622227<2/? 6002922)292 972’392$

,1826,0860073 633 2935.7.720,, 73025 .‘7 8_~‘22_/

- ~\;:;11:1 :.3:“_;;;¢¢;:3;!.:§

_,~Ar_-_,

913,’ 2929/922 603 3936 63576_18 053 1622 2123 0032282: v, 139023; 2 831€0_6222309_3_0_7.9026660783663$3§_2:02932006803809_333_ 2/222922@03639293[9/2£2.3€9?£338939<_7;3[19£799£93£22937 7:0§1__3. 2062_92§367 9 29220_ 600328_3/168 720 7;2225 92729220297):223 29292’2769223

9123 Q63575 569 9 341270320 121/2874 9992@720@ 4 4 44 4 , 4

30@?£ QLW€X, 33 4_ 1 4 MfE/D._/j¢_/Cg'

306235322229953 00022)22;622375 293622357_82293622§,..c - “293 08 371/83 3 22913V 992d 667223222307 29292927_6_22227 83622____3$5 233922 Q@_§<;QEMMDQ§JHE 9882.;_€`29_7;0212 BOQK_ZD]Z?£_T£ML,_ _ ,.

,_629;0227 76 44_4662?292§67 29_2980. 36022293/._629_ 72)1293 9123923291703__3 089’81760 ______ 29361220_732:030 3123'22370_7229229/92392833 7203 793 98022§3_ 579220_32\20_0322039 6922_63,42922396372;13 079

2100 88;23€ 227 2 "O 7793.29773370>20 623 7793 6000-7 6

99 (`DFV 629 77919 /?707’2'32~_)._3)2222_._ 3552333@29/0 2772`:`§_2 -, ,32137813333329783 802¢2 05;2,1/49_0423006;_ 7_:_6_2_95 479495;8532, 332229_33‘963362_96_30§5238236300....229290227723 §

1;§__3333,§, §. 839293672'020/ 51282222:7720 __ § _, … 230202292202 9856)23 §§ § ,_ _§ 3 ~2_§§._§_1__§1 ` \ 3 30$79066023/2§§3…

§§1_§,212=23287<2622,910,32333 3 33 1§--§..__3 31 1.362232220_2,173222;§ 900/333

_C,;Qu.

2852:<5:1’22;507 014)3222 _. '55¢2_22,@02055<9011;52222 5 \. 5 . 2255 5 - 555 225

525€19.@/17205,1;2212221_'/_200__$£_555 2555555 555 ....... ` 552 09.19.00;222)¢;31» 5 , 5 55 . 552 _5_555555.

' './5525100358055@5§5752;2§1502$2‘75¢2.2032 5 5 255255 _5 5

..,_5..5,..,__,.'{.5_25(.~ ._`5 ..2.2_5, ...,. , 2_ -.,51.5

5~52.-. ~. .__5'-_.,_,.2 n~~.. 51 .., /5.._1_… 5

2210,50202211@1)709522€12§02§;):92@0002 025/225502§121§.1122192502

. 023§*Qum-E/QBQ.;€MMCMIJZEQQ321<5525@2501012@212@:2280§5:2

2221222121)0.62222£522211€102101)5810¢:)<57;022.22£2_725<712421;.@5002:5105 00202)_-§<;1 292 2000 c)%wz&' j5@0251)1)2`/72E 094 21072011221102§50222251;@217'

2215©110;;759 2022 @£ULOB\)HMV 22859211)6 555 :

2421>.;052)5255(;_4 322 55 444 5 5 _ 0227005105222 '20;25 500/205120250’455025$5§52120050200410220025 210 912/257 2002 010 02212

0202 1212511, 022111§25 21§<;>XX-XXXXXXX;2200911:0005;5 25<;>110§97§ 0202 000 owe

852/512222592281515@2 7721:2£1”8405<;@51;20:/5255@85€£ 7657721:5725€22245€@5225:¢5>;5?5:026022£€>/ 52.5£0250501£2200@§., 6221”2\)’222§ 5 22421§0250212:2522§5512224§@22101550€§42@1§:259 525022 29 50102§1)7::2921' /22§921>0§ 1212_2722£ 2200£§”240019200 1100713003

5£;1210§:52251012$0522110 2721$55 2100 262115)5§5;15;15@5752255 052721252022:00)555

» 925 772)3 _(`191/27' 55

.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Villa, Daniel, (Tex. 2015).

Villa, Daniel (Villa, Daniel) — published by Counsel Stack Legal Research, free access to 12M+ legal documents.