Villa, Daniel

Texas Supreme Court

Villa, Daniel

DecidedOctober 16, 2015

DocketWR-29,948-10

StatusPublished

This text of Villa, Daniel (Villa, Daniel) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Texas Supreme Court primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook

Villa, Daniel, (Tex. 2015).

Pincite

Opinion

B@ ,QC|QA 0

DHTE§L§¢?.'§Z;.ZDU ~

q~§ ~¢2§- - ~.-»§-"'x’§w::n;»w;q‘»~¢.... . ;, "§~ ` ", wi ' ’::v»§…"»"§_'§,';§=.-`.._:j .' g ‘

...Q&§¢§,§c@§m -§§§ » . ¢MBM~§»§G.QM&I§ §Qf. §N§M§m§§ . .w~ .~ .. RECHVEUTN §MQD §§I. Q§F Q§Méé§§ .WM§§..§§§£QUI MM¢NAL~APPEALS M.Q)..Ul¥z@g §§ ~J » §§;,-¢..,~ -_§ . 4_- §§§§§§§§ §§§ 162315.§

§§MJ§M§QB 7/1…§,§ §§ §§ §§ §§§§§§.§§§ § §§ . _, _ A_g_elAqg_sta C!_erk §2;§/2£.2,.1;12¢222;)§ Q§§B§M§I§L 172 § ... /§@/Q §§§§..§D§§§§ §§.Z§§§?.B»mm§<;@u

§£§§9@2./Q<§§§§M@c§)@§s§m,§~&§§§§§ ., ZW§FOK§‘£DJ§§§SZ§TMQLI§LU?LSMUM§§§

. ,J___ __ 2 72)75/7)=<:#/1) L2 S§@QZWM§»§ HQ/>§§/z 224§¢/536/13

w . ` _ ’“»§”-~ .' “_ ', »£MUNMMNJ~ZJWW§W “ * ». § § , ~ . 1 . ,- w)F/JQ@z/Ie)§§ 2§2§51§§..

""§§. .e.\s§ "§'.~," ... -":»¢'»~:¢ . ' . " '.§' '..§;“.I ‘ §.'" " _-ha_§~rg ‘ L ., …_§§

' m ' o -~ 4 " ~` ¢_Hu~ ._.- § . . , ~~ ' . ....…_,: , . '- ,

l _ 7 1110732.301`>¥}22/2€29~73 v;/7)1)77(:_y

22222.22/52-:207.9772§5@§332)71:2272) 779 .

2 2727 22272)7);)322520733232 12223221', ,97)72037272377 rin 2727- 333<;32373§322)22(2§ sr m 3227/722 772-n 377 » 2 CMU§SZ;OA) C@w,)?'>/)27`3X#2$2CH2&7) /1)1,/3)02:`2° 25(5<383//8,),22 /92222/-1/&255200727)02:2’@2§2§02/727?/222 777£5,,,/9/5§[7?/97 jr 717/75 /’757275 g¢~)g§@)\)/)L /<_77@7,9/ 737ng 1975 777/: /'790779 <;77973@ /777>27: 77 2£2222£2$; 732522§22'¢: 2225 /“-"02}79)7. §‘ , ~ 2 2222;2/2522272:2152%2/:77007722/72/ 772>:2r3/_1)777 02`1)2 C;)%$§ 22 .23.§222§§232§§§ . ,_ 2§032)2320 2 522.332222735/23222337 2777232022§§2;77723332@32223223727333373257¥2372wa 22212222832 02132<§7227”'2]7/07 1907/215 17727'_3 @F c7',/)715 5 2333 /2)712.2 2750332,7232322?3)237§ v 222§23 272/3237 122/93 2 71)3)32, 2772§20523 37225333)233) 033;7.2327773 63 rLr/w/Jc> ~ <;32>2§3§0722522222 2§2§§22:372232)2?32©02#277/32723 730th 2510 1931°19/9®95 R/: F19790 5/2§722\)§22;§3022§5:33311723 §171232§§2§3/2)7»§2322323£222 2722.322..22 /73273.2277 723c¢>3$ .32§72332 1~`/$£13» ._ :~ 1 1 `22$22§§022227)’32722;02 27232 C337er 252 20212722226222.3272177235139)>317 P/v'/?S/i- . 2 .222227§ 2239237322;2223222)3Y 33332373733§23332 227\)22):312323§223 2222§.22233»2/29) 222/322 322 1/1227932 , 7223.372 0371)1).2:272033 32022232 /m:37' 777/3 232 2032 23232 2 72§@2222323339 332 72§222033§22‘2. o 2232 ®3320933 32273 233'>`22©3)12,122021“122 §§222~) 377,/3220272 @)¢3.)3353)1) 2922/211 257 . 333221322;17232221§@3)2%322323§227§25.2<;32)11201?21>352$>’722 57723523<222131§'7222/3223§63§227§333:3»279 372 3333/92 mm§'z.z§;§vw¢?§§r§s 33279393277777§ 333 322 23552;332 222322§2§3 22332287233227\)6 7773 E>€)@a$z;/f

»». ..~. dm.e:;m-,,

\/_2

1°,/

, §§§ eo»z§§§§¢W/¢§£@QZP§MW mw Q¢,;z /;;,F/e§§§w, MM§§MM§)JM§ C§§:. .,_,..,§§E C,¢.?u§/:§§J;.§z/zs _;,.,, j ,MLM§§ZZ{£MJ§C;OM§/' Duz@§w§ §c/,¢z[/MQ ;, ~» . §§!z§§&?§[§/zz§wz a)§§§f§u§§..§§§§§§‘@ §/§PD!¢;,NM § ,_ _. MMM §§MM§§Z;/z§f§)<§f§s/ ,, ,M§§§§§)Q§§Q§ § sz§§§o.§i:§§§/€y_. § zz§lz:):zzzto§ml§§z?zz§ §w;§ _, § ~ ;. . ':`..`£§§Q.Q§Q§QIM§MJ§£M§§ ,C§,§.7.2391§)§§ -),§J§Fr;£€;:f Q§J,/?§¢.§§§f£ ,‘.Z,£Q§§ whaley oF 310st ' . , ,§§§F;§§s§ § !>’¢:Mz,:. §§§z§¢§§ §I§§; 3§_). §§)§ 3§1, 3§2 §§ 71 §M¢:. §§»§Mm§)§§§§§@)§a§w.§§§zf§ §z§§z/zz§.,e@)§§w ';_;\.,£zz§)¢§MM§QFMNSJ§BMW; .. ._ .. .. §&LQM§S.§M§ » § v …,§)42 §?£§!§§7..../£/?5;7.@§/2»0/0 xaaa€

~.»

w §§ “.“ ~* ‘-~» ~ w ’ ‘ ‘\-1_~. _v """' gm _____As .L.n§ .A.

P,i

§ _ _..In)/)OH.`??F:S._ QEQL@K&[Z@M

.__§L,§00002:22212:2229§‘?_/.3.3§2_23_/_0222722£292222:¢~22202;292222____§ §23£2225_/9@§§2§20129§720€290::§2@9720 220 522$7229222 02020; 20222;_~ 2290 V_/_Z.§)_Q§ 021£;22902§ QMM§ 2929029_27% @F 292920?22_@95 72902_:_ __§._§§ 29§@§(:02§’_022) §§7;0§/0 7 &2§2725/;;, 7/_22? /52_2@;5 §§_7725_22¢792;¢9_2;,;0; §merw§_§@;_l%w§000§®002 07

§§_§ 77 § § ., i. § . . .i w.52'”€_20222 020 1307/37 ,§_§202§5,

§, . § . , , , . § 222§5`722<;72'222/2'_“ §0022227720§,§__

,, § ., .. 30202 2§),1222209___#/_33~022&_§___§__§ ' &0§0§02222” ,'/§3_322/9 0 §§

§§ 27729.2?/20222§0020);2;22_+§§ ` 1 '

, § , 7 » 9225 202792922§2£_¢_`/§5/._1__§_-§§§-§§

§§§§§ §_ §§ _§..§.2§222122522909; 229<22;~ 9§'2;;2 `

E.. . . § x § ,,§ v~,»-. , §_. -

.. 22.§§. , ,.., § . §_ ,_ , :_ §¢ .¢.A- ~z M w *- L `,,, , _._ _.L_s_ § ,§__'z:.":_-_z- ~ - w ~ w \-~, h __ `. ____ v __§$_,,_ W--=z m v ~~-v-'-`-_»- --' _` M _ _§ ._.___. _ - --» § .._ § §§ __»-- _:__§-§_§_ __ __ __ ,.._..,._.. § _§__.. ~L § ~*_.; ~` 77 z ~>* __§ u<;§`._ §§ § _, ,. § §§ ~__~ 2 _- -w__ §

P-$

GHuSE 2226,-260;8»9))2299»29

39823139_660970 . 13 c150292€2§22223 660_2921 8227202:2)6 9062720 6622227<2/? 6002922)292 972’392$

,1826,0860073 633 2935.7.720,, 73025 .‘7 8_~‘22_/

- ~\;:;11:1 :.3:“_;;;¢¢;:3;!.:§

_,~Ar_-_,

913,’ 2929/922 603 3936 63576_18 053 1622 2123 0032282: v, 139023; 2 831€0_6222309_3_0_7.9026660783663$3§_2:02932006803809_333_ 2/222922@03639293[9/2£2.3€9?£338939<_7;3[19£799£93£22937 7:0§1__3. 2062_92§367 9 29220_ 600328_3/168 720 7;2225 92729220297):223 29292’2769223

9123 Q63575 569 9 341270320 121/2874 9992@720@ 4 4 44 4 , 4

30@?£ QLW€X, 33 4_ 1 4 MfE/D._/j¢_/Cg'

306235322229953 00022)22;622375 293622357_82293622§,..c - “293 08 371/83 3 22913V 992d 667223222307 29292927_6_22227 83622____3$5 233922 Q@_§<;QEMMDQ§JHE 9882.;_€`29_7;0212 BOQK_ZD]Z?£_T£ML,_ _ ,.

,_629;0227 76 44_4662?292§67 29_2980. 36022293/._629_ 72)1293 9123923291703__3 089’81760 ______ 29361220_732:030 3123'22370_7229229/92392833 7203 793 98022§3_ 579220_32\20_0322039 6922_63,42922396372;13 079

2100 88;23€ 227 2 "O 7793.29773370>20 623 7793 6000-7 6

99 (`DFV 629 77919 /?707’2'32~_)._3)2222_._ 3552333@29/0 2772`:`§_2 -, ,32137813333329783 802¢2 05;2,1/49_0423006;_ 7_:_6_2_95 479495;8532, 332229_33‘963362_96_30§5238236300....229290227723 §

1;§__3333,§, §. 839293672'020/ 51282222:7720 __ § _, … 230202292202 9856)23 §§ § ,_ _§ 3 ~2_§§._§_1__§1 ` \ 3 30$79066023/2§§3…

§§1_§,212=23287<2622,910,32333 3 33 1§--§..__3 31 1.362232220_2,173222;§ 900/333

_C,;Qu.

2852:<5:1’22;507 014)3222 _. '55¢2_22,@02055<9011;52222 5 \. 5 . 2255 5 - 555 225

525€19.@/17205,1;2212221_'/_200__$£_555 2555555 555 ....... ` 552 09.19.00;222)¢;31» 5 , 5 55 . 552 _5_555555.

' './5525100358055@5§5752;2§1502$2‘75¢2.2032 5 5 255255 _5 5

..,_5..5,..,__,.'{.5_25(.~ ._`5 ..2.2_5, ...,. , 2_ -.,51.5

5~52.-. ~. .__5'-_.,_,.2 n~~.. 51 .., /5.._1_… 5

2210,50202211@1)709522€12§02§;):92@0002 025/225502§121§.1122192502

. 023§*Qum-E/QBQ.;€MMCMIJZEQQ321<5525@2501012@212@:2280§5:2

2221222121)0.62222£522211€102101)5810¢:)<57;022.22£2_725<712421;.@5002:5105 00202)_-§<;1 292 2000 c)%wz&' j5@0251)1)2`/72E 094 21072011221102§50222251;@217'

2215©110;;759 2022 @£ULOB\)HMV 22859211)6 555 :

2421>.;052)5255(;_4 322 55 444 5 5 _ 0227005105222 '20;25 500/205120250’455025$5§52120050200410220025 210 912/257 2002 010 02212

0202 1212511, 022111§25 21§<;>XX-XXXXXXX;2200911:0005;5 25<;>110§97§ 0202 000 owe

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI