Vezey v. Green

35 P.3d 14, 2001 Alas. LEXIS 158, 2001 WL 1448759
CourtAlaska Supreme Court
DecidedNovember 16, 2001
DocketS-9440
StatusPublished
Cited by32 cases

This text of 35 P.3d 14 (Vezey v. Green) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Alaska Supreme Court primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Vezey v. Green, 35 P.3d 14, 2001 Alas. LEXIS 158, 2001 WL 1448759 (Ala. 2001).

Opinions

OPINION

FABE, Chief Justice.

I,. INTRODUCTION

Angela Green took possession of part of her family's land in 1982. The land was probably an oral gift to Green from her grandparents. For the following decade, Green lived on the land during the summer. She gradually built a house, cleared surrounding land, [18]*18cultivated a garden and fruit trees, and raised poultry. In 1994 her grandparents sold their interest in the land to Allen Vezey. Green brought suit claiming that she had gained title by adverse possession to the house and surrounding land. The superior court upheld her claim. Vezey now challenges the finding of adverse possession as well as the superior court's determination of what land Green actually possessed. Because Green has demonstrated adverse possession of part but not all of the area awarded, we affirm as to the north, east, and south portions, but remand as to the west portion.

II. FACTS AND PROCEEDINGS

In 1982 Angela Green's grandmother, Billie Harrild, offered Green a piece of the family's land near Shaw Creek. Billie was declining in health, and wanted her granddaughter to have a home near the Harrilds' own. Green selected a parcel of land on a bluff, across Shaw Creek from her grandparents' house. The alleged gift was not recorded, and Billie and Elden Harrild, the grandparents, and John Harrild, a cousin, remained the owners of record. However, according to Green's testimony, in the ten years following her entry onto the property, all three "absolutely" recognized the land as hers. John Harrild, the only record owner alive at the time of trial, waived participation in this case and indicated his agreement that Green's claims be recognized. Neighbors testified that Billie consistently referred to the land as Green's property, and a stranger to Green who asked Billie about buying the property around 1987 testified that she told him she could not sell the bluff because it belonged to her granddaughter. Elden and Billie Harrild died in the winter of 1995-1996.

Between 1982 and 1992 Green gradually constructed a house and cultivated grounds on the bluff, She worked on the property over the summers, and worked as a nurse and glassmaker in California for the rest of the year. In 1982 she planned the site of her house and cleared trees on the lot. In the summers of 1983 and 1984 she lived in a camper on the property, cleared more trees and stumps, and oversaw hand exeavation for the foundation of the house. In the following summers, she gradually expanded the cultivated section of the property, planting lilac bushes and fruit trees and installing a coop for chickens and turkeys. A neighbor, Art McTaggart, helped to erect the house itself and to install a water system, propane heater, electrical wiring, and a generator. He worked with Green on the house every summer from 1982 through 1991. Beginning in 1987 Green lived in the nearly complete house during the summers. She arranged for telephone service beginning around 1985, and dealt with fire authorities to determine how far away from the house to clear trees. In 1986 Green worked in Fairbanks the whole year and visited the property by snow machine during the winter; in 1989 she lived on the property for eight or nine months. Green lived on the bluff and with her grandmother for a month and a half in the summer of 1992, but did not come to Alaska in 1998.

Green left trees standing on much of the property, but cleared undergrowth and planted native plants over an area of several acres. She also cut trees from a wide area on the southern hillside in order to clear the view from the cabin. She posted "No Trespassing" signs and built benches in some areas away from the house. She put up a chain across the road entering the property, but did not fence the entire area. Although the improvements were not entirely visible from the road, a neighbor testified that local residents as far away as Delta Junction, twenty miles down Richardson Highway, knew of the bluff as Angela Green's property. A lien filed against the property reflected this belief: Despite the fact that land records showed the Harrilds as owners, the lien declared that Green held the property either in her own right or as a constructive trust for Billie.

In 1990 the house was considerably damaged by vandalism. Green repaired the damage when she returned to Alaska in the spring. Witnesses who visited the property in the summer of 1998, the year that Green did not visit Alaska, said that the house looked empty, vandalized, and not kept up.

Green arranged with her grandparents that, for the remainder of their lives, they [19]*19could extract and sell small quantities of rock from the property in order to support themselves and John Harrild. This extraction was not to involve heavy equipment; according to Green, both she and Billie Harrild strongly opposed use of such equipment on the property.

Sometime between 1988 and 1991 the Har-rilds executed a contract with an extraction company, Earthmovers, allowing them to excavate rock from the family property, including the bluff. The contract apparently included an option for Earthmovers to buy the property. According to Green, Billie's mental capacities were declining at the time of this contract, and she no longer handled her own finances or affairs.

Earthmovers excavated a trench on the bluff on a day when Green was not at home. When Green returned and found the workers and equipment on the property, however, she told them that they were not allowed to excavate there. Green granted the workers permission to finish the task at hand, insisted that they arrange to repair a telephone line that they had damaged, and ordered them to leave the property.

In 1988 Allen Vezey became interested in Shaw Creek area properties. Vezey planned to consolidate property in the area in order to quarry for rock. He purchased property adjoining the Harrilds' and carried out dynamiting and excavation. Green testified that Billie strongly opposed this use of the property, and that her grandmother was "absolutely livid" with Vezey.

Vezey approached the Harrilds about purchasing their land in 1998. He and his engineer, Ken Colette, had a number of meetings with the Harrilds. Both testified that the tone was cordial and Billie exhibited no hostility toward Vezey, although Colette testified that Billie Harrild was "in and out of cognizance" during this period, and that he himself would have been reluctant to enter into a contract with her at times. According to Vezey, the Harrilds mentioned Green only to say that they planned to give her an acre of land. Colette recalled mention of "Angela's acre" in early meetings with the Harrilds, but did not testify that the Harrilds said the land was only a planned gift for the future. The Harrilds' statements caused Vezey and Colette to double-check the property records for the bluff area-a response which suggests that the Harrilds gave Vezey reason to fear that Green already owned the land.

In 1994, while Vezey was still in negotiations with the Harrilds, he received a phone call from Angela Green. According to Vezey, Green was "borderline hysterical" and objected to his purchasing the property. She expressed some involvement or interest in the land, he testified, but did not say that she owned it. According to Green, she told Vez-ey during the phone call that the land belonged to her, that it was not for sale, and that he was to stay off of her property. The trial court accepted Green's version of the call, and expressed scepticism about Vezey's testimony on this and other issues.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Janice L. Park v. Bradley Brown and Karen Brown
549 P.3d 934 (Alaska Supreme Court, 2024)
David Willems v. James Batcheller
Court of Appeals of Virginia, 2023
Shay Hurd v. Larry E. Henley
478 P.3d 208 (Alaska Supreme Court, 2020)
State of Alaska v. Falealo Manuele Pulusila
467 P.3d 211 (Alaska Supreme Court, 2020)
Doan v. Banner Health, Inc.
442 P.3d 706 (Alaska Supreme Court, 2019)
In re Estate of Hatten
440 P.3d 256 (Alaska Supreme Court, 2019)
Barbara Tagaban v. Edward Tagaban
Alaska Supreme Court, 2018
Dixon v. Dixon
407 P.3d 453 (Alaska Supreme Court, 2017)
Yuk v. Robertson
397 P.3d 261 (Alaska Supreme Court, 2017)
State v. Schmidt
323 P.3d 647 (Alaska Supreme Court, 2014)
Dan v. Dan
288 P.3d 480 (Alaska Supreme Court, 2012)
Bittle v. Cam-Colorado, LLC
2012 COA 93 (Colorado Court of Appeals, 2012)
Farmer v. Farmer
230 P.3d 689 (Alaska Supreme Court, 2010)
Hansen v. Davis
220 P.3d 911 (Alaska Supreme Court, 2009)
Vezey v. Green
171 P.3d 1125 (Alaska Supreme Court, 2007)
Price v. Eastham
128 P.3d 725 (Alaska Supreme Court, 2006)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
35 P.3d 14, 2001 Alas. LEXIS 158, 2001 WL 1448759, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/vezey-v-green-alaska-2001.