Van Roy v. Watermolen

104 N.W. 97, 125 Wis. 333, 1905 Wisc. LEXIS 177

• Court: Wisconsin Supreme Court
• Decided: June 23, 1905
• Status: Published

Opinion

WiNsnow, J.

Tbis was an action of trespass to real estate commenced in justice court and brought by appeal to tbe circuit court. It appeared that there was a ditch in tbe highway in front of the plaintiff’s premises and upon his side of the highway in which water ran during wet weather, and that'' a private ditch ran from plaintiff’s close into this highway ditch; that the defendant caused his cattle, several in number, to be driven to the highway ditch for the purpose of drinking, and that they trampled down the banks of the ditch, causing the water to spread out, and disturbed the outlet of plaintiff’s private ditch so as to prevent the free flow of water therein and cause it to back up onto plaintiff’s premises to some extent. This was held to be 'a technical trespass, and rightly so. This was not the use of the highway for travel, .nor was it a mere incidental turning aside of the cattle to drink as they were being rightfully driven along the highway. Had they been driven to the plaintiff’s side of the highway to graze thereon there could be no doubt that the act would be a trespass; and no difference in principle can be pointed out when they were driven there to drink instead of to graze. Sec. 1347 c, Stats. 1898, does not touch the question here presented. There is no other question in the case which merits consideration or treatment.

By the Court. — Judgment affirmed.