Valier, Nkrumah Lamunba

• Court: Court of Appeals of Texas
• Decided: December 30, 2014
• Docket: WR-77,638-08
• Status: Published

Opinion

». ' 7 71 lp §

' "\dQ.':S~Wr>r.\‘S‘\\.e`\\“\ - \A\\rsi_ \ief\.\: RECE!VED IN ` _\\c-\;-b ;y\ c\¢\% Cn' !-r- en cR:MiNALAPPEALS mm s;r. ’ae\~\ -' , ' _' . ' /-'\Del Acosta, Clerk `K_d° §§er\.i\ee>e\ U. §‘€§,L §U§`\§r U.Ss.r-\’\ § b wm ‘i\r_r` \ §§R>@A\Bo& rQ¢re`,ie\ wirer\ \ierriir>e Tueiwwme»»d\nsr wire munn ‘

§e_.°r \§\€\mmor\\\`r.rm_mde&\§`cdmr \/. `Y\\e.%ic.§e, b$ [e.xes “\eri core §rr,\\sr>'ro'.)§»e_ ree-v~/. 1932- ex

§s)_nr stu"`(\ ° Y\errw_.\=`umd eer_)rn%md creA\=LdL § _ %oér\x\§hb\i§rhcevemc\

F_\)`rdeem?e~r.\r§r\e_\“?r" \Aerd %rrefle ‘_- w ve

` §rre; met mere rarer \zr)e§~r“rr\\ re E"°Pi\ ‘Aei Xeeemem D(rrd"l-j\r_re &inies \lsr_r, B\=. _»‘Ecis_e, Er;.;deem Te OL;crln,

\`_n\\e`\_ei»re§ `§en`re\odc`cwr\ B‘r'~ Tbre. dee 9mmin Llcerrse (-_-JF T-k§, Ferrr¥w&h ngm \Jgg :\,\,, tore-4c ‘awdee\ w v\de ne i\rei women everetxhemn& §._ te air nder \'\)eiier\ \:r>v La`eec rees gerd-

vr\rudr §e. \M_§’§$.\m&c §\»\ iv §\m§. §f;osi?r t§\er\(\ wm \E? §r'rm\\c\§§§mr§$_ \;eem.\§£t+\m_p< Q;\=“X;\GA\Q_ \§Q.;,\.r;d`r$r_r>ue,r~u~_\ Ev`rcler\r;e Ex)/ribr`ri“ A‘ was Lndee:\wnen deal

\rrerr_ i\rr eee\reeimdmmm mere mm red we err mm u,»;+ aider vwr\~\s\=.zdsz)r(‘ukm\:r?r`§\, _

¥\eeée.\:re &\e>.i`ie i.\re. eiieei`rbr'\ ne ~\:\rre \‘_nu.ris_ bed b\rre §§$iu:`ei l v ask e,. mvr§m msenr\$e,\-`\'r>r~\ luke Lz>~r, e+'i r`,\\ {'\M§ mcgu-

\Nee\reeed\\a€rrmee§sre\j`rd,reee ` ` v '\\

‘l\\§"Y ‘r\\?_ \%f`br~d §X%T\’r`¥ 'iCY C_e\x\>r'T \z¥ \\e\>\e~ii Qer\§T‘%.'TExcri

§W\e\\\\i i\\e\rrree\re\,`;‘€ \?r, §§§ieeei v §§ §\e§ ve TEx-ee -

W\>\;me§`r‘: ' §re\\r§ name mae \f_'r;§§m Ex_mm‘r

“ ©r" e§§ f§e`m¥ "i§ §i%\>r>?\'¥

§W §§merm\e \ueme\\>.e\re\:em` more wherede NF me§§ereeie_d emeer ma&eer\i eed §eeieeeed dee Pev)_:r:`_jj

i\'re §i _re_?veee:i aide rra-dew i\re ’Eemr§eedr\\ §ereeeereei recre_u`re » ~d §§ _ 4 _ _ \Aw»~` w e\dm' = T'e*i\e \\§§\lw\‘§ \`_e,‘e>§\a.&`\§r\ le\\wiise\\e»\\§b\e§;§" ` ` - " - ` v

i`\ee were me "Ke_\e¢i -\i%eiex\?.“`-Yj_¢_ig»_-_eef

§_t:\\%¥\ir_rdc\e‘<\el \I `LD\£&_`\\I\

` `Y\\e\ue_ §wm&& U.wew. \`>\F \-_\\e_ ‘Fmrrx~_¥zeei§: §e\mdmee§c §Ye_\>r.rie%°. \\`?o §es§ee °i\r\eii med{re_ rev Q'e‘?bvee mexich re\\§re\\ ‘s\m_dd cd§'\»d.c:\§. ~"r.\r\e §¥`\_\r`r. § sz `meuel}c,'r€£ r>F Cli;'rzee e. 0 F i\re \.\e'>.§_cd Sicieg,‘_ b cree- §Le'ei\ cream dee 7 l

meier\ re`ei\\';re `r.\-.i' \M§rd_krrried§ei§ee) i_\\e 'Q_\tr\ree§ §miaek`u:>\\ m\'r= \;\r\e\eerri*`i . \)`r°i _"k`§`\{ § l `

`Y\xe§irie§\=`(eurs r)\\erird `rr\*d\re`r.ed$reirv`reetl \\§\‘rrumed\ _\~\.rx<\iee\\\.r:r\i`cr\`rer \\esr; ch-iszr -\-_\\e§ra¥€ec\es§, r t\m~m%v& r>\\ ev §§an WM\B§§ r A_`i.c\ i.\un\ see i,\r\er& \ax\ime\" ~ _ r `\.r\i€ei"\e ‘

need `€\x\r>u>\:\(;‘§\.\;mw §\\e§em_k vok."\,t>\\ b\:' t\\eYWade galewd §\~c&~m_

§§ _\`ex&emi§\ma§x§\\\exe_u\c>§¥ar Q.c§§e\§>. \-.\\s_§ov\$m\.mx<‘!. \§»x§\.eeeu£cx`\\:\.$ %&Jk>.\a§. §w§>.m`\;\\‘<,\w_`§€x¢\a§e%§:£¢.\ak W<' §§ \-\\e_§nm®.c..\x\nmi\ \m.\r.\nau’.r. ¥_\\e umw m §\m,%e\~\xen`mm\ \x\e\§§=ex\émk ce \~.\\a, Q_m~\§\.cl\a\~\ex\‘s.,k§=>>.dzm`a§ w\é\ ' §e`e§.a&€_\>d&.\\ruéx ` uaw n§e\/ £;z>\smce e£xc;e\\e§ am \\_m§\@s,\\mi \ §\\L em\z%e'amm& \ \u§$_e\>eé eha the UM\W\ wwm weed €~»\MW=M

Qx\¢\>.\>a\&.\§\ ca é»ea._&l.\:k\,:>ee§m\ \ mms\§§ §\veern .'

' `\\\e%ha@_ev vice am \.m“céw§ a\\s.% was \»;\~\l~wwc`\u\ mm `\x\' X.\\a_ `\.Y\A`>;e&mx\k_ \e‘ae\\eu:¥ ita §m`&§.»¥a\s-e- Lc\er&`€;? indian \=nm ~t\r\e, Q_Dv\§\m` Wdz\ L\nec\,,’t.\\e§= `a_em§:.\\i.& \" vs §c> due?voae%§'._u\=¥c ?\b§r& &§SX£?Y: S..Wuv>\ `§?;:\LUE~ \;knui:£i;:iLmnicLu;-Lv\i& dime mmm&`\m\ vaca \~_\r\a&\ne.%§\a\eed u Sh'm- ®N>E&S'$ 15 "=5’\35 wrth ‘P~ § . \§e\ %`.\x . § . `\z>\\u€,\>c\m¢k§ii\e\ w me ve where eha guns \§u aim §Mee\\e am mvve¢&`§", %\\@~m¢<\_`\;\kev<>\ég‘? \\. ` s o %.. §\€\0.\:. \Qmm. a c.u\A \).A.léa"mi \j€.cc<‘;_\:\'azea&n:_,\b? t\\e. §1`~/; u\ t\\z>;\' \~.»0 M“~>)é, `\<*.» \\\¢»\' wfw¢ - . “~‘\W> wi Sf\\\w&\\v Mn\\a - §§ ` \L\\-°\\¢\\ . § .~ w>m% ’ § S\%w \X[>Y\we AHA i\-gxw wm.\§\‘tv\d am am mae mu£uma\\em\(;§…me wm wee-am ex e\\'e emma T '\A. \Xe.%s.v . `U.>\:\\VGL.L\\\:§ mm s/;w ). '

. "\\\L§§DAQ_§'~:- '\eii\s \)`u>\r.\=eA \¢\\e%\ \§. w“g§\w‘mm\ 15de \.m_é.nx \»_\\L§\_»e?`\'um§.§. L\m.a§e_' rev §\e¥vur\£nr&\\ “mem§.mn& §\.m\\\:j`\\}_'> mm Lx\ §\\e Lm\jae&m_\i: m`\.*<_\\ea& m §e'§e\¢`we iree¢\’rt\=ier., “v<\ \'~n>e»\ §\\_n. Mm§\eam,.x\& Ti.¥?c\m.:\\’\v§§r& \-_\.nc:‘x §\ae %. ` ~ mae £\ne mm wm

1 _ wm~\`>_.\\e& §\\ead\ef§ema\oasmc.£§¢esx \m~ on m m\;u>o$ `\).S`ma_\c._ CX.\.\\ .'\\rw_ua§c{ev\& o‘»?`( `£\\L ">Sc¢._¥€_ ?n>'>ecp&u€~ (`._rm(;` Sk`\.\l degran t\\e

`\\“L\`N Mwnm `

c\_x\.c§u£>eéxoa\,.> <\\::> ¥»ovce"li.¥= ?u:w c~$_‘cu `CL\:LR.."UF¥ l abc ‘ B~%L‘E`\tc\ ">\'\L£;:: §\ML “§$Licm& :::§en§§ § =`\"\%:‘:`;\\.D'£xbj§\ woulch t{§;:e,, \`f\=g‘?\pc?£;$ \ &.\\:d \;\\a.\~f\m\- - well `\x\ &_\r\`e'.‘s knee ~\ \"\x*.\i“u&l€i' gage/amici cg£v;o,, V\%.K.o _&\'¥.\wk V\x.`\&`o§_'_»e.c\ c\l&\nt neea\ a gin w \\m)e.%e); ial-th -' g mae penal §§e\xeen\&v.gg@rl wm&.&e)i`. LSA; r; O£>v-rec;&'? Fl .l/k¢,% 1 Si,r.(,?~.?\.ve\.qe

came `\.\\

-~

W‘~\S".“m`»§= l\l \\ §m\m '<\a.§§£°>'*é\\s_®mw_rk. o\`- \~_\m_ u-`m\L bv- ¥.\\&mw*€> X.\\s\_\\r.sv"\ £\¢\r._& ‘\.\¢\§_ \I:u.»a ">s\s»..\€\ bob WU\§L ., %u_\"\xzc\&\?‘°~l\¢‘~\ _ \_\:M_~§. ;1.\\_ _ _ _

\§U\AKM“ME\»MEX\\A "~"c“ P`\`\ L\\ \<.\\S§. ‘?~\>\~m M= c~ ‘\¢I»Wa:s m‘e`\é;msi_x w’\§<.\s\ `\»<\§.<>W\&f`\»°‘\ ‘\\S`\>\)\AS‘-A~\>'j\\"“"- \:-_\L_~_§‘°\\°~"C~ “‘_`~“&°3 3§\» \g gil 5\°\_\1\ _ _ g ~_ f", w ~\\`Y\“L“ UNS“M M ° . ;>~\»\L\_.M§_M f ' Q\>kq`u\ h\\v.k§§\_`\,mdx wm;@g\w , 'Q_.c~s'\,x;¥€>m>.w\g;l§b§.' 53. ~Q\X:FGJ\:\Y\D‘C§IS. '“` v XX€A\;\~_$Q;§ \\_\g¢\xc_\\o§;_ `\S\u_\\c..d %§':i\ \.c>`\,k\\ E‘v.\m. R§$`,m.n`§. X\\o_\\ '*cv"x_m§ w\m)&%:\_o_`\wlm nude c>\: H’-\bm ocs (3.§¥1! mcca\% \\>'».,i\m§.\~€§\x%ma -¥3> S§,\l&\\§;s -\~;\\n_wmm:§."\\\n$ `\‘\v. Y\Q.WQA\; `\1\\?'¢~\‘ o'\r,¥\§>'»;\_ wm\.\lés\mm'\%d:w§&'b ~\`»¥HQLXY\\:,‘€_»§§ ';~.. L§u~c\ .é. m vq.§\m$ wmm._£\m_ gm gus U“Mr~\. 3m \\um iv Mm;\\\wsm \A.S."W\n &\°\°xs\ ,,c.m\ mg ,,¥.M. §§;_p_ ss¢z»

dr . . `,l »»,,.\l - ». - ': :" ':' `». `

mm >£_\m<'_ wm mm w\\\>`\s:_§=u§ `\\`w'\ ‘\A\\`l_r§\"x c§ m chimva Q.\A`u\»x\ml\ -T\'ll$ S}wu:Ln§ ever wm t\u_ PrF_WLm\ £\u:;¥__ tenuic;i{bn L:\'. laule cu\A d\; wm unc‘ue.§¥wr\¢~_)d.:\e_§équ)ls§\ u\u`\\lmv\le§'lm\bum. -

. 1 m amax \N._ <>\;_“mg». wm\ w own gm smng Q_n\\»u;¥\n\ \\Lo\.c\\»e_vl \03:§.\~` &wu:\xu~ t\n.m w \>mu§§ Unn.&sh b¥’ £\np_ \:ow~&€' wi\'\ l M.mw&¥;§ v. LL;M*@.M u.a.;w\\~;zm mse).. Tlm umm.zt WM*C `€\m) ;` ' m - \€éw¢c>E.(.-.'F¢L\Sn, wm manhale lou th ~

§B“\*"W\b‘§=\\`w»' ' ‘~`§ `¥`\S> ’Am_§mmm ~ \a: saw Lc.

\\» k wm`u~§m\ nw >C\im§\ \AL § ‘:r.\g»_ Q»L_Amu\

v » "5§: - ? ‘G\Q.SXOAL\ _ - - °5~& \-\-(\`§\ X%x>\§.el"' " `M"“ ' x ~ . 5§':‘j"?~‘\ wm \)\ QM;;:D&S . X¢L‘Lg `;@~\'SLP \AQRM\<.X§§\».S \i §®(&b \n\r_c,vve.c§€A

'A\ `K\\.o_ timaarom_aa arLt\ua\-m)c.\\n&. ot °s’cai&_ Y<\c._t:\\\;§h \l'\mmt,ts`u\r;§_\:\ra§_‘€-c»t\an_:\; wm Xxs ta\~.<‘ran\ ot ‘ca_m\§Qd wm Lki \_t`)f\ c\.rsr<.a wax msa w mws§_~'~t.mm»ta MM“:\ emma twisz ~L\t§_u- …rsr ¥_\\L waxmaa.

' o'€ k\\§.akmetmiassm£\ui.\w:a\\m 3m `~ _ '\>tn.¢i.ox X_\r\s_ waxe€.&_aa \Lc.»_a~`_s)_ u\`- \-_\w_ a.t~-omnir\`\ll _ _ _ y `\sa `\,o\mv_\¢\nti-` ~\<.\\`L a>_\.un':n '\a‘€- X.\M_M ` '»' ' ` °¥"

\<.\\sz. wanda 'Q‘€ K.t\i_s\_ ar ari».§ma w ;as

\€Q_»a\¢:\sax:m\l uadt?;\) Ld.mmst_€)tbl\il&a “ Y>" and (`..`\ max S.\_r,a;a.csv\:a \St&\;\\\am\s md E-.\>uh.r\f_o_t.`l\)r\x.\s_\;§_"l\“ *<.\\.c& "\`~o§."uo.. '€.uLC\SmCL mata \).a.we)t w b\¢§ras.\\ ’c\'\_v_ Ra$.uu:tr.ia womu:j:\.b\\ \ waazs\~&eci \N(_K&_»\\»_ \`U'.o<'c\ \_m &\\s_ i£.air` mo“):k<:¥ L\X¥am;§\b:t§¢ra. ~L:. mia\sw_ri £\ML _ '_ _ \an\s.we_ wouir.\\in§a\\Lm milk ka\ss)_ \:\~a§. u\ amiss iga arva et_._ ,P_SN\_Q_ ma \Nu_ WL‘AU » o. » », \_ _, 'S\a l`\mt Y>taa \lwst§rts\\llsita»tsi\ \°t%`?\ \ss\\m\`artsmususr\ ama tamm

mq_g§g_&. R\SO m \'\B..L`A\_"a:

`Y\’\s, Raa\_u~_m\k Maarts\)ui \sk.:\a arQ_abnductnr_L Q\= i\\¢w`\rknco..-, \ar£: Pssr '\-.\\n. vln\ct¥usr\ or k\\s)_\.\nl?r£d anita Qn<\sk`\iruiru)r\ ms arrin bw,e,

'Fo\.\x\d i~_\\n_ otaa\r.utn°_r &a_\_\ir(\i\\w:_km\d a Mwo£ls\a c\_tstdd:

`\\m. akaiz_‘?vaas:_rtirtsr a V\o\.rlastta \"\`L's:nr\_l:\».ti viewed t\m. ll » _ _ ur~¥w\:\\'\ ldr'f‘{_\_and_.mo ni;

§.am\.\ir'\ts\\\n»§.ts\ctirust\ B\= Avl. °_;K l'ls. E.vttl.mu_

- orr mr \ltmi“\'\;m assault ®. ab r~.b»_ vt Yt;_ic_ was mt 405 \;Laromaa€,ci. ll\mui a)\u~i; drives ama ibid t:\~ wbd mean and mbd

at ma am `Xst wag`tsrr\(r¢&am$'.. B. metz llle aUle\=r-mtt=d §:;? . L\

\\_c,\§§m\s.éc\l=‘&r ¥_\§L\(\L~‘cmc&m`\!\? §;\. §1";`1;¢» B`.\A\\A&m&~\:`m€c? § . `X_\smr\ur\ X~.\'\L `\_Am\¥\,\x;\r>¢ &m,c\bm:v o'F thsz_ \:ov€n£`c_£_ wm mt\w& ¥\»3=. » \`S\ \A\\lc\\ \M>AA\N>.'Y Q._TMM§MD§ LY\ t\\l& (LC»SL‘ . l§.wfwr& \€»\l."; m"§ `A . \§V\xumz,\x\ \FA§£:`. L%?§vo\.‘&\§§\\\`§c,_& §§/&,0"). “\"m%v§$`mm\_\. Q\`,A<\m gmc unum `u\ `B\AR:_L>QS w again \,~L;; \X\">\\ Y~d‘r \<£?i§:`\.\\£."\x\ m">&\\mj\\'i`b\e.'lg b\` wm \`C~.\\SLV'.;L‘: ‘. N`ov dlg\ {:\M_~H~\A ` w ¢\§m;.\\ \¢ `RW$§UAL<\ m §§ was \=m- ~M<_ §_,` Mam mm va LrQ_I:\ Es\l `\c\smx.v_ Q.'Q¢\l\>§& ." \\“. §rbvl&u\ \>_x:&,&&"a§. H%:h>rm§§(`z€/m;} MS§L» \Am~ wax am \"\e;n§\\°\\’&p\\\ my\x;x€.s&c.\§,>&m\ am '.Xw~i£z `Sc;n; ¥i'mQMM wax am em\W fm msa.m. \\sumas fm ~\\¢\L RLH.UAQMS_ inme &ze$m,\x m#am\ "ru¢ wm `Bw\£ mm w\A wiley 'u\ °nMNM> w z \\-\a M_ul\ QQMM N`c>‘\;\'\°_>"§'&$`l.:i _ viii YX\-X.\B%. 213 .E\)`\.c\.u\m\£`o&'£u \’>L\).S»r\ v ` KG\\ \§m ‘w`u§_u\m_ b\:écc§mm§ kim c>'€"€ Lwr or @t\\m~ WSM\ `L\\ N`Lu\xéc`m'\\ v¥ @m>x‘§: m`\.'sr>\\% §§ £\\g_Qm\'s§€a.mh>n& bv `\m».& c>\= i:\rm §§w&€_c>\= "K»;m§\ ‘<:\~ c>\`- &\\a; §m\‘s¥\,%\.&`um m \,~ws § _Q\\L \\1\`\3¢€13 w c>? Am_{.m.\

M\\>»_ mwr\mm v wgw.\§. m\mwkm\ off ux\§§\r`\.v\`mo; wm “ v X“ °““:“°$9~ ’\"~’\“M"€¥ *¢`~1~' wmvmwg m mm

\\MR.\M\A§S'\*L\\L §\\\c.\§\§§_`\»\\ n X»\\D£§? \\E "\¢*C.\d.§§_.`\@€&\ h\` \\ASCL Ym%.gm\;\.b_ 65 \ £\\.c.§c \»,\~& whm \»`>=Q. e\b\q£>.xu§. `&!\)~\`LQ\£~’S:LM\ R>"\`~

r:.? \<,\C\S'z §m\\`»&`\b\\& c>'i= h\\`.\&_ ¥w&_i_uls_\ ¥.\\u\ m\A_ `\.r\ %»A\me».i:\ \~.\I\LM g\m.§_\ A~`).&veqcm§\ ~ m m`»c\nmo. w <>\£m`m§c\ '» °dd=:»&L\l ~\c»uf>.\\mm\°\%.\ ‘E>\\A Q.c\ margin &Y§\. Qr\m.§\>§.\°\m\ .““\ML\UW @\= v§l.“§§:lg @L;' A.\>QS. mdc mma$n§&. c\ e\b&v\m__ § `\.m_\) L&c§;\_&_ c§-"»%x_w cr'\_).\. ’\\m_’\_m_\)::§; L\l\.%i_c>\su\§o\x>&v`\.x\§. C)&"m.\m§ m wus.¢:§. \`Y_\,c\§`cr»<\°>\*_\l¥> \m'_§m;@h ac\\§_"' , §§ c\x\A ¥J\\a_ w‘»dm\m_.. X& mimms k\\e;k ~¥,\\9. 'w lem was mm£;:\'owulmml\ 7 wu\c\ \\m.\)&. \>mr\ ` 6\>’.\-efxm \ml:\¢u\§&\&cméwo.gclhe; md _ AA§&’:;ML Fe§ci \:\n¢$~ `Lrt mai

’ L\“\\'-um& ` v\§©lxmc¥ L ` .\_\.x\.ém.~ Q\~&.'BX»ZL'$ \;\\9_ Lf\c.€u;'\~:§v€SDJ-chn£t\m_ §§°_~AL.\;\L \uxz\ m§:>co.`u\m_r\i § QMLC\M\QL %§\L\AA mm \;L \~UMA.' {§“LLAC\W_ `\.\A_m§£`\ §§wa '\)¢S wash wmmk"~.m\ w t\m ~Q.\s Ldmm,"¥uw'e‘;b'am\ awk\j§\wc\¢ £\\o. mm \~ms$: muchu:\ar\" .Smu\sn> Hemz\m~son vi §:wde_\&& `S\w.- 3d 7513 ,75~3 &`\J..`L. A\>¥ .-- egova Q_\\r{.§k{_ &Do

. ` \§ mixed hugh \i><\s_»i\hdm\\ m md v

Qbmh\_\».m\\

, `K\\L R§s%\iim§ wm:\vuhi him ‘<\\iA ndle §§ \\lu\.\zsz£.§ wm \ALCDY\“\£_\E\\ £\'\.\_§:L W_\.Lm\§. \\n&_hv_.u“qc\ \5;

_X.W§Clhiiiis c,&`um

X \€\\r\imr§\\wmv\\m\>"clig: '\\Ux'\£o \SU\L¢`I\`“\ him A'Qrem§, \.\\iii\ mw ¢,i».&\\i\@i\\iir\~. ma \\C\Sr:> -‘€v\.‘>_\°ix wm `cimw%ai, ow&b blm Qu\A '

Q~U)S\§\MB.&R? hiqu "

`1 \§\<\v\im\\ m\ii§h\v<>i`iu~ ;maz~h \S@\ mm mh \\§:Q.\m>r»\§s_t\m*c\\cé; signs card _Q_.)dvvts:\to higl:_\u§ \`*\r’c`\m\ max valid _~ \~>h§m *\u~¢> \i& %sh\ mm w h“s;;rueni on _§

- \_\m@\mmi W\h §§ M(\h.».vh \hv\ v 0 hi mm ubih“lih `\‘\:m> ~\\QS\ m\ th h in:g§_mm_____ QDJ:\_

`€\‘\Q-`S Wc> \S

. \\°\°5 th \? \'\ “\“i"b’ M\\c