Urbina v. Thoms

Opinion

5(&200(1'(' )25 )8//7(;7 38%/,&$7,21  8UELQDY7KRPV 1R 3XUVXDQW WR 6L[WK &LUFXLW 5XOH 

(/(&7521,& &,7$7,21  )(' $SS 3 WK &LU

,,, )LOH 1DPH DS

)RUWKHIRUHJRLQJUHDVRQVZHDIILUPWKHMXGJPHQWRIWKH GLVWULFW FRXUW GLVPLVVLQJ SHWLWLRQHUjV SHWLWLRQ IRU D ZULW RI 81,7('67$7(6&28572)$33($/6 KDEHDVFRUSXV )257+(6,;7+&,5&8,7 BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB

%(1s$0,1 85%,1$ ; 3HWLWLRQHU$SSHOODQW    1R Y  !  0$5<(//(1 7+206:DUGHQ  5HVSRQGHQW$SSHOOHH  1 $SSHDOIURPWKH8QLWHG6WDWHV'LVWULFW&RXUW IRUWKH(DVWHUQ'LVWULFWRI.HQWXFN\DW/H[LQJWRQ 1Rn+HQU\5:LOKRLWsU'LVWULFWsXGJH 6XEPLWWHG$XJXVW 'HFLGHGDQG)LOHG2FWREHU %HIRUH.(,7+.(11('<DQG%$7&+(/'(5&LUFXLW sXGJHV BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB &2816(/ 21%5,()7KRPDV/HH*HQWU\$66,67$1781,7(' 67$7(6 $77251(< /H[LQJWRQ .HQWXFN\  %HQMDPLQ 8UELQD/H[LQJWRQ.HQWXFN\SURVH

  8UELQDY7KRPV 1R 1R 8UELQDY7KRPV 

BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB KLV SHULRG RI UHJXODU SDUROH WR EH WROOHG ZKHQ KH OHIW WKH FRXQWU\7KXVZHDIILUPWKHKROGLQJRIWKHGLVWULFWFRXUWWKDW 23,1,21 mDV SHWLWLRQHU KDV QRW VHW IRUWK DQ\ IDFWXDO DOOHJDWLRQV BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB VXSSRUWLQJ KLV LPSOLFDWLRQ WKDW WROOLQJ ZDV LQWHQGHG WKLV FODLPLVLQVXIILFLHQWO\SOHGWRJRIRUZDUG7KLVFRXUWFDQQRW .(11('< &LUFXLW sXGJH  3HWLWLRQHU %HQMDPLQ 8UELQD RQWKHDEVHQFHRIDVVHUWHGIDFWVGHWHUPLQHWKDWWKHVHQWHQFLQJ ILOHGDSURVHSHWLWLRQIRUDZULWRIKDEHDVFRUSXVSXUVXDQWWR FRXUWLQWHQGHGWRWROOSHWLWLRQHUjVSHULRGRIUHJXODUSDUROHl  86& †  FODLPLQJ WKDW WKH 8QLWHG 6WDWHV 3DUROH s$ &RPPLVVLRQ 863& YLRODWHG KLV )LIWK $PHQGPHQW GXH SURFHVV ULJKWV E\ H[FHHGLQJ LWV MXULVGLFWLRQ WR FKDQJH KLV 3HWLWLRQHUDOVRFODLPVWKDWWKH863&LVZLWKRXWMXULVGLFWLRQ UHJXODU SDUROH VWDWXV WR VSHFLDO SDUROH VWDWXV ZKLOH KH D WRLQLWLDWHDFKDQJHLQSDUROHVWDWXVZKLOHDGHSRUWHGDOLHQLV GHSRUWHG DOLHQ ZDV RXW RI WKH FRXQWU\  7KH GLVWULFW FRXUW RXW RI WKH FRXQWU\  7KH GLVWULFW FRXUW FLWHG *XHUUHUR GLVPLVVHG SHWLWLRQHUjV ZULW VXD VSRQWH ZLWKRXW SUHMXGLFH *XHUUHURY&ODUN)6XSS('9DIRUWKH 3HWLWLRQHUQRZDSSHDOVWKDWGLVPLVVDO)RUWKHUHDVRQVVWDWHG SURSRVLWLRQWKDWWKH863&GRHVLQIDFWKDYHMXULVGLFWLRQWR EHORZZHDIILUPWKHMXGJPHQWRIWKHGLVWULFWFRXUWGLVPLVVLQJ DGGUHVVDGHSRUWHGDOLHQjVVSHFLDOSDUROHVWDWXV,Q*XHUUHUR SHWLWLRQHUjVFODLPV *XHUUHUR WKH GLVWULFW FRXUW FRQFOXGHG WKDW WKH 863& KDG MXULVGLFWLRQWRUHYRNHDGHSRUWHGDOLHQjVVSHFLDOSDUROHWHUP , ,GDW7KHUHWKHFRXUWH[SODLQHGWKDW 2Q 'HFHPEHU   SHWLWLRQHU ZDV VHQWHQFHG WR D 7RKROGRWKHUZLVHZRXOGEHWRJLYHSDUROHHVWKHNH\WR SHULRGRIVHYHQ\HDUVLQSULVRQDQGILYH\HDUVSUREDWLRQWRUXQ WKHUHPRYDORIWKHLUSDUROHUHVWULFWLRQVDOOWKH\ZRXOG FRQVHFXWLYHO\ IRU NQRZLQJO\ ZLOOIXOO\ DQG XQODZIXOO\ KDYHWRGRWRGHIHDWSDUROHLVWROHDYHWKH8QLWHG6WDWHV FRQVSLULQJ WR GLVWULEXWH KHURLQ SRVVHVVLQJ KHURLQ DQG 7KLVLVQRQVHQVH7KHWHUPmMXULVGLFWLRQlLQWKHVWDWXWH GLVWULEXWLQJ KHURLQ LQ YLRODWLRQ RI  86& ††  DQG JRYHUQLQJ MXULVGLFWLRQ RI WKH 8QLWHG 6WDWHV 3DUROH D   $V D FRQGLWLRQ RI KLV SUREDWLRQ SHWLWLRQHU DQ &RPPLVVLRQLVXVHGLQWKHVHQVHWKDWDSDUROHHjVFRQGXFW DOLHQZDVRUGHUHGWROHDYHWKHFRXQWU\DQGQRWWRUHWXUQ LVVXEMHFWWR&RPPLVVLRQVXSHUYLVLRQXQWLOWKHH[SLUDWLRQ RIWKHVHQWHQFH$QGWKLVLVWUXHZKHUHYHUWKHSDUROHH 2Q 1RYHPEHU   SHWLWLRQHU ZDV VHQWHQFHG RQ DQ PD\WUDYHO DGGLWLRQDO FRXQW WR VHUYH WKUHH DQG D KDOI \HDUV WR UXQ FRQFXUUHQWO\ZLWKKLV'HFHPEHUVHQWHQFH3HWLWLRQHU ,G&HUWDLQO\WKHGLVWULFWFRXUWZDVFRUUHFWLQFRQFOXGLQJWKDW ZDVDOVRVHQWHQFHGWRDWHQ\HDUWHUPRIVSHFLDOSDUROHWRUXQ LIWKH863&KDVMXULVGLFWLRQWRUHYRNHVSHFLDOSDUROHVWDWXV FRQVHFXWLYHO\WRKLVLPSULVRQPHQW3HWLWLRQHUZDVRUGHUHG LWPXVWDOVRKDYHMXULVGLFWLRQWRLQLWLDWHVSHFLDOSDUROHVWDWXV WKDW LI KH ZDV GHSRUWHG KH ZDV QRW WR UHHQWHU WKH 8QLWHG ZKLOHDQDOLHQLVGHSRUWHG:HWKHUHIRUHDIILUPWKHGLVWULFW 6WDWHV EXW WKDW LI KH GLG UHHQWHU KH ZDV WR QRWLI\ KLV FRXUWjV KROGLQJ WKDW WKH 863& KDG MXULVGLFWLRQ WR DFWLYDWH SUREDWLRQRIILFHUZLWKLQWKUHHGD\V SHWLWLRQHUjVVSHFLDOSDUROHVWDWXVDIWHUWKHFRPSOHWLRQRIKLV SULVRQWLPHDQGJHQHUDOSDUROHSHULRGZKLOHSHWLWLRQHUZDVRQ 3HWLWLRQHU ZDV UHOHDVHG RQ $SULO   WR WKH GHSRUWDWLRQVWDWXV ,PPLJUDWLRQDQG1DWXUDOL]DWLRQ6HUYLFH,16DOOHJHGO\RQ UHJXODUSDUROH2Q0D\WKH,16GHSRUWHGSHWLWLRQHU WR 0H[LFR ZKLOH KH ZDV VWLOO RQ UHJXODU SDUROH VWDWXV $FFRUGLQJWRD863&ZDUUDQWSHWLWLRQHUjVVSHFLDOSDUROHWHUP  8UELQDY7KRPV 1R 1R 8UELQDY7KRPV 

FRXUWDVVXPHGIRUSXUSRVHVRIDUJXPHQWWKDWSHWLWLRQHUZDV EHJDQRQ'HFHPEHUDIWHUKHZDVGHSRUWHGDQGZKLOH UHOHDVHGRQUHJXODUSDUROHVWDWXV'HVSLWHDSSDUHQWFRQIOLFWV KHZDVLQ0H[LFR LQSHWLWLRQHUjVSURVHSOHDGLQJVLWVHHPVFOHDUWKDWSHWLWLRQHU ZDV LQ IDFW UHOHDVHG RQ UHJXODU SDUROH  3HWLWLRQHU ZDV 2Q1RYHPEHUSHWLWLRQHUZDVDUUHVWHGEXWUHOHDVHG VHQWHQFHGWRDSHULRGRIVHYHQ\HDUVLPSULVRQPHQWLQ IRUGUXJUHODWHGRIIHQVHVLQ&KLFDJRDIWHUKHKDGLOOHJDOO\UH EXWZDVUHOHDVHGLQDVRXWOLQHGDERYHVSHFLDOSDUROH HQWHUHG WKH 8QLWHG 6WDWHV 2Q 0DUFK   WKH 863& IROORZVWKHWHUPRILPSULVRQPHQWZKLOHUHJXODUSDUROHHQWDLOV LVVXHGDQDUUHVWZDUUDQWIRUSHWLWLRQHU2QsXQHSHWLWLRQHU UHOHDVH EHIRUH WKH HQG RI WKH WHUP (YDQV  )G DW  ZDVDUUHVWHG2Q$SULOWKH863&KHOGSHWLWLRQHUjV 7KXVSHWLWLRQHUZDVUHOHDVHGRQUHJXODUSDUROH SDUROHUHYRFDWLRQKHDULQJDQGGHWHUPLQHGWKDWSHWLWLRQHUKDG YLRODWHGWKHWHUPVRIKLVVSHFLDOSDUROH2Q0D\WKH 3HWLWLRQHU FODLPV WKDW ZKHQ KH ZDV GHSRUWHG ZKLOH RQ 863& LVVXHG D QRWLFH RI DFWLRQ LQ ZKLFK LW  UHYRNHG UHJXODUSDUROHVWDWXVKLVSHULRGRIUHJXODUSDUROHZDVWROOHG SHWLWLRQHUjVVSHFLDOSDUROHGHFODUHGWKDWQRWLPHVSHQWRQ XQWLOKHUHHQWHUHGWKH8QLWHG6WDWHV7KXVKHFODLPVWKDWKH VSHFLDO SDUROH FRXOG EH FUHGLWHG WRZDUG FRPSOHWLRQ RI ZDVRQUHJXODUSDUROHVWDWXVZKHQKHLOOHJDOO\UHHQWHUHGWKH SHWLWLRQHUjVVHQWHQFHFRQYHUWHGSHWLWLRQHUjVVSHFLDOSDUROH FRXQWU\VRPHWLPHSULRUWRKLV1RYHPEHUDUUHVW7KH WHUP WR UHJXODU SDUROH ZLWK HOLJLELOLW\ IRU SDUROH WR EH 6L[WK &LUFXLW KDV DGGUHVVHG WKH LVVXH RI WROOLQJ IRU DQ GHWHUPLQHGSXUVXDQWWR86&†DGHWHUPLQHG H[FOXGHGDOLHQjVVXSHUYLVHGUHOHDVHVWDWXV:HDJUHHZLWKWKH WKDWSHWLWLRQHUjVPDQGDWRU\UHOHDVHZDVWRIXOOWHUPOHVV GLVWULFWFRXUWWKDWFDVHODZDGGUHVVLQJWKHWROOLQJRIVXSHUYLVHG GD\VXQGHU86&†DQGVXEMHFWWR&)5† UHOHDVHSHULRGVFDQEHDSSOLHGHTXDOO\WRSHULRGVRISDUROH,Q DQGGLUHFWHGSHWLWLRQHUWRFRQWLQXHWRDSUHVXPSWLYHSDUROH 8QLWHG6WDWHVY,VRQJ)GWK&LUWKHFRXUW DIWHUWKHVHUYLFHRIPRQWKVRQWKHmQHZlVHQWHQFHXQWLO KHOGWKDWDGLVWULFWFRXUWKDVDXWKRULW\WRSURYLGHWKDWDSHULRG 1RYHPEHU   DW ZKLFK WLPH KH ZRXOG EH UHOHDVHG RIVXSHUYLVHGUHOHDVHEHWROOHGZKLOHDGHSRUWHGDOLHQLVRXWRI VXEMHFW WR DQ ,16 GHWDLQHU RU LI WKH GHWDLQHU ZDV QRW WKHFRXQWU\,VRQJUHOLHGKHDYLO\RQWKHSDUWLFXODUODQJXDJH H[HUFLVHGWKHQKHZRXOGEHUHOHDVHGWRDQDSSURYHGSODQ RIWKHVHQWHQFLQJFRXUWj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†KDEHDVSHWLWLRQLQWKHGLVWULFW FRXUW7KHGLVWULFWFRXUWKHOGWKDWLWFRXOGQRWFRQFOXGHWKDW WKH 863& LQWHQGHG SHWLWLRQHUjV UHJXODU SDUROH VWDWXV WR EH  7KH VHQWHQFH LQ ,VRQJ LQFOXGHG WKH IROORZLQJ ODQJXDJH mLQ WKH WROOHGZKLOHKHZDVRXWRIWKHFRXQWU\WKDWWKH863&KDG HYHQW GHIHQGDQW LV SHUPLWWHG DW DQ\ WLPH LQ WKH IXWXUH WR UHHQWHU WKH MXULVGLFWLRQ RYHU SHWLWLRQHUjV VSHFLDO SDUROH VWDWXV ZKLOH 8QLWHG 6WDWHV GHIHQGDQW VKDOO UHSRUW WR WKH QHDUHVW 8QLWHG 6WDWHV SHWLWLRQHU ZDV RXW RI WKH FRXQWU\ DQG WKDW SHWLWLRQHU KDG 3UREDWLRQ 2IILFH ZLWKLQ  KRXUV RI UHHQWU\ LQWR WKLV FRXQWU\ DW ZKLFK WLPH >WKH@ SHULRG RI VXSHUYLVHG UHOHDVH VKDOO EH UHVXPHGl ,G DW  7KH FRXUW FRQFOXGHG WKDW m>W@KH SHULRG RI VXSHUYLVHG UHOHDVH FRXOG RQO\ µUHVXPH>@j XSRQ 0U ,VRQJjV UHWXUQ LI VXVSHQGHG GXULQJ KLV DEVHQFHl ,G DW   8UELQDY7KRPV 1R 1R 8UELQDY7KRPV 

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+DLQHVY.HUQHU 86    ,Q UXOLQJ RQ D PRWLRQ WR GLVPLVV WKH 6SHFLDOSDUROHZDVFUHDWHGLQDVDQDGGLWLRQDOSHQDOW\ DOOHJDWLRQV LQ D SUR VH SHWLWLRQ PXVW EH WDNHQ DV WUXH DQG IRUDOOGUXJRIIHQVHVDQGZDVPDQGDWRU\LQDOOVXFKFDVHVXQWLO FRQVWUXHGLQIDYRURIWKHSHWLWLRQHU0DORQHY&RO\HU WKH 6HQWHQFLQJ 5HIRUP $FW UHSODFHG LW ZLWK mVXSHUYLVHG )G  WK &LU   7KLV FRXUW UHYLHZV GH QRYR WKH UHOHDVHl  6SHFLDO SDUROH LV JRYHUQHG E\  86& †  OHJDO FRQFOXVLRQV RI WKH GLVWULFW FRXUW LQ D KDEHDV FRUSXV ZKLFK&RQJUHVVUHSHDOHGLQEXWZKLFKVWLOODSSOLHVWR GHFLVLRQ8QLWHG6WDWHVY3HWHUPDQ)GWK GUXJFULPHVFRPPLWWHGEHIRUH1RYHPEHU'ROILY &LU 3RQWHVVR  )G   WK &LU  FLWDWLRQV RPLWWHG6SHFLDOSDUROHGLIIHUVIURPUHJXODUSDUROHLQWKUHH $FFRUGLQJ WR WKH 863& SHWLWLRQHUj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†  SHWLWLRQ IRU KDEHDV UHOLHI LQ WKH GLVWULFW FRXUW ZH GHFOLQH WR UXOH RQ WKH LVVXH $V WKH WLPHVSHQWLQQRQFXVWRGLDOVXSHUYLVLRQRUmVWUHHWWLPHl GLVWULFW FRXUW FRUUHFWO\ H[SODLQHG WKH 863& KDV VSHFLILF UHJXODWLRQV IRU DSSHDOLQJ SDUROH GHFLVLRQV WR WKH 1DWLRQDO $SSHDOV %RDUG  &)5 (YDQVY8QLWHG6WDWHV3DUROH&RPPjQ)GWK †  DQG MXGLFLDO UHYLHZ RI D SDUROH FRPPLVVLRQ GHFLVLRQ PD\ RFFXU &LU%HFDXVHWKH863&FRQFOXGHGWKDWSHWLWLRQHUKDG RQO\ DIWHU H[KDXVWLRQ RI DYDLODEOH DGPLQLVWUDWLYH UHPHGLHV 6PLWK Y YLRODWHG KLV VSHFLDO SDUROH LW RUGHUHG SHWLWLRQHU WR DQ 7KRPSVRQ  )G   WK &LU  3HWLWLRQHU DGPLWV WKDW KH DGGLWLRQDOWHUPRILPSULVRQPHQWHTXDOWRWHQ\HDUVWKHHQWLUH GLG QRW SUHVHQW KLV FXUUHQW FODLPV EHIRUH DQ DGPLQLVWUDWLYH WULEXQDO OHQJWKRIKLVVSHFLDOSDUROHWHUPHYHQWKRXJKKHKDGDOUHDG\ FRPSOHWHG DOPRVW HLJKW \HDUV RI WKDW VSHFLDO SDUROH WHUP &LWLQJ 6PLWK Y 7KRPSVRQ WKH 6L[WK &LUFXLW KDV VWDWHG WKDW mWKH %XUHDX

RI 3ULVRQV VKRXOG EH JLYHQ WKH RSSRUWXQLW\ WR FRQVLGHU WKH DSSOLFDWLRQ RI

LWV SROLF\ WR >SHWLWLRQHUjV@ FODLP EHIRUH WKH PDWWHU LV OLWLJDWHG LQ WKH IHGHUDO 3HWLWLRQHU WKXV ZRXOG SUHIHU WR KDYH EHHQ VHQWHQFHG IRU D FRXUWVl 7D\ORU Y 8QLWHG 6WDWHV  )G  WK &LU  7DEOH YLRODWLRQRIUHJXODUSDUROH XQSXEOLVKHG RSLQLRQ $OWKRXJK LW DSSHDUV WKDW SHWLWLRQHU IDLOHG WR

H[KDXVW KLV DGPLQLVWUDWLYH UHPHGLHV DV LV UHTXLUHG WKDW FODLP ZDV QRW $VDSUHOLPLQDU\PDWWHUWKHGLVWULFWFRXUWFRQFOXGHGWKDW UDLVHG E\ WKH JRYHUQPHQW RQ DSSHDO DQG LV WKHUHIRUH ZDLYHG 6HH %ULQGOH\ SHWLWLRQHU KDG QRW FRQFOXVLYHO\ HVWDEOLVKHG WKH IDFW WKDW KH ZDVRULJLQDOO\UHOHDVHGIURPSULVRQRQUHJXODUSDUROHVWDWXV Y 0F&XOOHQ  )G   WK &LU  KROGLQJ WKDW WKH SODLQWLIIV

E\ QRW EULHILQJ WKH TXHVWLRQ KDG ZDLYHG WKHLU DSSHDO RI WKH GLVWULFW FRXUW V

GHFLVLRQ QRW WR VHYHU WKHLU OHJDO IURP WKHLU HTXLWDEOH FLYLO ULJKW FODLPV s$%HFDXVHSHWLWLRQHULVSURVHKRZHYHUWKHGLVWULFW