United States v. Price

• Court: District Court, District of Columbia
• Decided: March 31, 2016
• Docket: Criminal No. 2007-0152
• Status: Published

Opinion

&+5212/2*<  -DQXDU\  3HQUHJLVWHURQ$QWKRQ\6XJJV¶FHOOSKRQHVVWDUWHG  -DQXDU\ &RQWUROOHGSXUFKDVHIURP-DPHV3DUNHU7KHFRRSHUDWRUSDLG DQGUHFHLYHGLQH[FKDQJHDQHLJKWRXQFHERWWOHWKDWODWHUWHVWHG SRVLWLYHIRU3&3'XULQJWKHLUPHHWLQJZKLFKZDVWDSHG3DUNHUWROG WKHFRRSHUDWRUWKDWKHQHHGHGWRPDNHDFDOO3HQUHJLVWHUHYLGHQFH HVWDEOLVKHGWKDWWKHFDOOZDVWR6XJJV  -DQXDU\ %HJLQQLQJRIZLUHWDSRQ6XJJV¶FHOOSKRQH³6XJJV:LUHWDS´  -DQXDU\ &DOOVUHFRUGHGE\6XJJV:LUHWDS  'DWH $FWLYDWLRQ 2WKHU ([FHUSWVIURPWUDQVFULSW 7HVWLPRQ\IURP$JHQW 1XPEHU 3DUW\ %HYLQJWRQ   +HOHU\ 3ULFH³,QHHGWRKROODDW\RXWDONWR\RX´ ,GHQWLILHGRWKHUSDUW\DV SP 3ULFH 3ULFHDP7UDW   8QNQRZQ -DPHV 'LVFXVVLRQDERXW³JHWWLQJWRJHWKHU´ 'HIHQVHFRXQVHODVNHG 3DUNHU %DVHGRQWULDOWHVWLPRQ\WUDQVFULSWIURP ZKHWKHUWKH\FRXOGKDYH DFWLYDWLRQQRWLQUHFRUG EHHQJHWWLQJWRJHWKHUWR ³SODFHEHWVRUJDPEOH´ %HYLQJWRQWHVWLILHGWKDW ³EDVHGRQRXULQYHVWLJDWLRQ DOORIWKHFDOOV,EHOLHYHLW ZRXOGEHDERXWVRPHWKLQJ GLIIHUHQW´DP7U DW   -XOLDQ -RKQVRQ³

  'DWH $FWLYDWLRQ 2WKHU ([FHUSWVIURPWUDQVFULSW 7HVWLPRQ\IURP$JHQW 1XPEHU 3DUW\ %HYLQJWRQ   -XOLDQ -RKQVRQ³:KDW¶VJRLQJRQZLWK\RX"´ %HYLQJWRQWHVWLILHGWKDW SP -RKQVRQ 6XJJV1RWKLQJMXVWPRYLQJDURXQGIRUD -RKQVRQZDV³ORRNLQJWREH PLQXWH:KDW¶VKDSSHQLQJ"´ VXSSOLHGZLWK3&3´ -RKQVRQ³$LQ¶WQRWKLQJ:DLWLQJRQ\RX SP7UDW WRVOLGHEDFNWKURXJK,ZLVK\RXFRXOG¶YH OLNH\RXMXVWGLG´  6XJJV³2KPDQ\RXWHUULEOH+RZPXFK \RXXVHDOORIXVJRLQJWKHZKROHQLQH \DUGV"´  -RKQVRQ³,DP%REEXWV

\RXWDONLQ¶ ERXW\RXPRYLQJDURXQG6

,WKRXJKW \RXZRXOGKDYHP\OLWWOHOXJJDJHZLWK\RX RUVRPHWKLQJ´  6XJJV³2KQDKHOOQDK*LYHPHDERXW PLQXWHV´   (UQHVW *ORYHUWDONLQJDERXW³%URWKHU´³0DQ %HYLQJWRQWHVWLILHGWKDW SP *ORYHU GRQ¶WZDQWWRZRUNDMREPDQGRQ¶WZDQW ³%URWKHU´ZDVDUHIHUHQFHWR WRGRQRWKLQJ$SS+HMXVWZDQWWRZDON 3ULFHDQGWKDWZKDW6XJJV DURXQGORRNVOLFNWDONVOLFNDQGJDPEOH ZDVVD\LQJDERXWKLPZDV \RXNQRZ7KDWPDQDLQ¶WWU\LQJWRGR WKDW³3ULFHQHHGVWRKDYHD QRWKLQJFRQFUHWHDQGVHULRXV´ MREVRKHDSSHDUVWREH  JHWWLQJPRQH\OHJLWLPDWHO\´ 6XJJV³+HJRWWDJHWVRPHWKLQJWRFRYHU DP7UDW KLPXSWKRXJKPDQ´   -XOLDQ 6XJJV³2QP\ZD\WREULQJ\RXWKLVKDLU %HYLQJWRQZDVDVNHGWR SP -RKQVRQ GU\HU:KDW\RXZDQWWKHKDLUGU\HUWKDW GHVFULEH-RKQVRQ¶VKDLU \RXDVNHGPHERXWHDUOLHU´ VW\OHDQGKHWHVWLILHGWKDW  -RKQVRQ¶V³KDLUZDVFXW -RKQVRQ³:KDW\RXVD\"´ YHU\VKRUWRUYHU\FORVH´  SP7UDW 6XJJV³,VD\\RXZDQWPHWREULQJ\RX WKHKDLUGU\HUWKDW\RXDVNHGPHERXW HDUOLHU"´  -RKQVRQ³

  'DWH $FWLYDWLRQ 2WKHU ([FHUSWVIURPWUDQVFULSW 7HVWLPRQ\IURP$JHQW 1XPEHU 3DUW\ %HYLQJWRQ   (UQHVW *ORYHU³5HPHPEHUODVWQLJKWZHJRW 6HH$FWLYDWLRQEHORZ DP *ORYHU WRJHWKHU´   6XJJV³

,GRQ¶WNQRZZK\$LQ¶W QRERG\HOVH´  *ORYHU³\RXNQRZWKLVWKHILUVW, KHDUGRIWKLV  6XJJV³(YHU\WKLQJZDVSURSHU\RX NQRZ´   (UQHVW 3DUNHU³,JRWWRZDLWIRUWKHSHRSOHWKRXJK 6HH$FWLYDWLRQEHORZ DP *ORYHU \RXNQRZEXW,¶PUHDG\WRVHH\RX -DPHV WKRXJK

  'DWH $FWLYDWLRQ 2WKHU ([FHUSWVIURPWUDQVFULSW 7HVWLPRQ\IURP$JHQW 1XPEHU 3DUW\ %HYLQJWRQ   +HOHU\ 3ULFH,QHHGWRKROODUDW\RXZKHQ\RXJHW 1RQH DP 3ULFH DFKDQFH´  6XJJV³,¶PJRQQDFRPHWKURXJKWKHUH (YHU\WKLQJFRRO"´  3ULFH³

WKDWWU\ 1RQH SP 3ULFH XSDOUHDG\RQWKH8,GLG\RX)RRO"´  3ULFH³1DZ,¶PDKROGLQJEDE\ $QGDQRWKHUWUH\ZLOOFRPHLQ\RXNQRZ IXFNWKDWVKLW´  6XJJV³2K\HDK\HDKZHJRQQDEH DOULJKW,¶PZDLWLQJRQ\RXWKRXJK)RRO ,¶PDOULJKWZHOO,¶P,¶PMXVWZDLWLQJRQ \RXPDQ,¶PDKLW\RXXSVKRUWO\PDQ ,MXVWFDPHWKURXJK´

  'DWH $FWLYDWLRQ 2WKHU ([FHUSWVIURPWUDQVFULSW 7HVWLPRQ\IURP$JHQW 1XPEHU 3DUW\ %HYLQJWRQ   (UQHVW *ORYHU³,WROGWKHPPDQ,²,¶PMXVW %HYLQJWRQWHVWLILHGWKDW SP *ORYHU JRLQJWRJRDKHDGPDQDQGXKDQGXKXK ³ZKDWZDVJRLQJRQ´LQWKH ,WROGWKHPWRPDNHVXUH,¶PSURSHU´ VHULHVRIFDOOVEHWZHHQ  6XJJVDQG(UQHVW*ORYHURQ  -DQXDU\ 6XJJV³/LNHWHOO\RXWKLVKHKLWWKH $FWLYDWLRQV FRXVLQDQG\RXNQRZDQGWKHFRXVLQ ZDVWKDW³0U6XJJVVROG DLQ¶WFRPSODLQ´ 0U(UQHVW*ORYHUDTXDQWLW\  RI3&3ZKLFK0U(UQHVW *ORYHUWKHQUHVROGWR DQRWKHUFXVWRPHUZHOO DFWXDOO\WZRFXVWRPHUV 2QHRIWKHFXVWRPHUVKDG FRPSODLQWVDERXWWKHTXDOLW\ RIWKH3&3DQGWKHRWKHURQH GLGQRW´+HDOVRWHVWLILHG WKDW6XJJV¶UHVSRQVHWR *ORYHUZDVWKDW³IURP HYHU\WKLQJKHKDGKHDUG IURPKLVRWKHUFXVWRPHUV HYHU\WKLQJZDVILQHDQG SURSHU´   -DQXDU\ 9LGHRWDSHGPHHWLQJEHWZHHQ/RQQHOO*ORYHUDQG&RUQHOO*ORYHUDW ZKLFK/RQQHOOJDYH&RUQHOODERWWOHFRQWDLQLQJOLTXLG  -DQXDU\ &DOOVUHFRUGHGE\6XJJV:LUHWDS  'DWH $FWLYDWLRQ 2WKHU ([FHUSWVIURPWUDQVFULSW 7HVWLPRQ\IURP$JHQW 1XPEHU 3DUW\ %HYLQJWRQ   (UQHVW 6XJJV³:KDW¶VWKHGHDOZLWK\RX´ 1RQH SP *ORYHU  *ORYHU$LQ¶WWRRPXFKPDQ,¶PKROODDW OLWWOH\RXQJQ

WRGD\PDQ+HVDLGKLV EURWKHUVD\KHJRLQJWRNHHSKLVWKRXJK´  6XJJV³/LNH,WROG\RX,DLQ¶W,DLQ¶WJRWQR SUREOHP\RXNQRZVROLNH´  ³,WROG\RXHYHU\WKLQJSURSHURQP\HQG´

  'DWH $FWLYDWLRQ 2WKHU ([FHUSWVIURPWUDQVFULSW 7HVWLPRQ\IURP$JHQW 1XPEHU 3DUW\ %HYLQJWRQ   +HOHU\ 3ULFH³,ZDQW\RXNQRZZKDW,DVNHG 1RQH SP 3ULFH \RXXKPWKHRWKHUGD\´  6XJJV³DV@ VRRQDVWKHJDPH´  3ULFH³1DZQDZPD\EHWRPRUURZIRUVXUH 7RPRUURZWKRXJKFRPHFRPHDQGVHHPH WRPRUURZ´  3ULFH³+LWPHWRPRUURZFDXVHWKHPSHRSOHV EHHQSUHVVLQJPHIRUUHDO´   (UQHVW *ORYHU³RNMXVWKLWPHLQWKHPRUQLQJRU 1RQH  *ORYHU VRPHWKLQJ\RXNQRZ´ SP  6XJJV³,¶PZRUNLQJWRPRUURZ:KHQ,JHW RII,¶OOKLW\RXZHJRIURPWKHUH´   *OHQGDOH  1RQH SP /HH

  'DWH $FWLYDWLRQ 2WKHU ([FHUSWVIURPWUDQVFULSW 7HVWLPRQ\IURP$JHQW 1XPEHU 3DUW\ %HYLQJWRQ   +HOHU\ 3ULFH³3ULFH@ZDQWVWR ,¶PMXVWGRLQJVRPHPRYLQJDURXQG

  'DWH $FWLYDWLRQ 2WKHU ([FHUSWVIURPWUDQVFULSW 7HVWLPRQ\IURP$JHQW 1XPEHU 3DUW\ %HYLQJWRQ   +HOHU\ 3ULFH³/HWPHKROODDW\RXPDQZKHQ\RX 1RQH SP 3ULFH JHWDFKDQFH´  6XJJV³,¶OOFDOO\RXZKHQ,¶PRQP\ ZD\LQWRZQ´   +HOHU\ 3ULFH³-XVWZDLWLQJRQ\RX´ 1RQH SP 3ULFH  6XJJV2ND\JLYHPHDERXWPLQXWHV,¶OO KLW\RXULJKWEDFNWKHQ´   +HOHU\ 3ULFH³2KHYHU\WKLQJ¶VVWLOODOOJRRG,¶P 1RQH SP 3ULFH MXVWZDLWLQJIRUXKPP\OLWWOHODG\ IULHQGDFRPHDQGJHWKHUGDXJKWHUPDQ $QGWKHQ,,¶OOEH,¶OOEHULJKWWKHUHZLWK \RX´  6XJJV³2ND\MXVWKLWPHWKHQ,¶PZDLWLQJ RQ\RX´   +HOHU\ 6XJJV\RXRQWKHFOXEULJKW"´ 1RQH SP 3ULFH  3ULFH³1DZ,DLQ¶WHYHQ,DLQ¶WHYHQ,DLQ¶W HYHQLQWKHFOXE,FDQ,FDQPHHW\RXGRZQ WKHUHWKRXJK,¶OOPHHW\RXGRZQWKHUH WKRXJK´  6XJJV³$OULJKW,¶PULJKWKHUH´   3ULFH 6XJJV³,¶PDOUHDG\DWWKHOLJKW:KHUH\RX /DZHQIRUFHPHQWZDV SP DW)RRO"´ OLVWHQLQJWRWKHVHULHVRI  FDOOVEHWZHHQ6XJJVDQG 3ULFH³2KRND\,¶PDW,¶PDWXPE\WKHD 3ULFHRQDQG WHOO´ WULHGWRVHWXS VXUYHLOODQFH6HH SP7UDW

  'DWH $FWLYDWLRQ 2WKHU ([FHUSWVIURPWUDQVFULSW 7HVWLPRQ\IURP$JHQW 1XPEHU 3DUW\ %HYLQJWRQ   +HOHU\ 6XJJV³1RZWKDWRWKHUFDUMXVWSXOOHGEDFN $JHQW%HYLQJWRQ SP 3ULFH XSPDQ

  'DWH $FWLYDWLRQ 2WKHU ([FHUSWVIURPWUDQVFULSW 7HVWLPRQ\IURP$JHQW 1XPEHU 3DUW\ %HYLQJWRQ   *OHQGDOH /HH³,¶PZDLWLQJIRUWKLVOLWWOHGXGHWR 1RQH  /HH KLWPHEDFN´ SP  6XJJV³$OULJKW,MXVWVHH\RXWRPRUURZ ZKHQ,JHWRII´  /HH³%XW,JRWWKDWRWKHUOLWWOHMXVWMXVW I

LW,¶PMXVWJRQQDWHOOKLPWRMXVWZDLW WLOWRPRUURZWKHQ´  6XJJV³:K\ZKDW¶VZURQJ":KDWKHQHHG ´ /HH³&DXVH,JRWOLWWOHGXGHPDPWU\LQJKH WU\LQJWRGR\RXNQRZZKDW,¶PVD\LQJ" %XWKHFRXQWLQJKHFRXQWLQJKLVVFUDWFK´  6XJJV³2K´  /HH³+HVDLGKHZDVJRLQJWRFDOOPHEDFN LQPLQXWHV´  6XJJV³2KDOULJKWZHOOMXVW,PHDQMXVWWHOO KLPWRZDLWWLOWRPRUURZ,DLQ¶WHYHQ FRPLQJEDFNRXWWRQLJKW´   -DPHV 3DUNHU³,WROG\RX,QHHGWRKROOHU´ 1RQH SP 3DUNHU  6XJJV³,NQRZLW,DLQ¶WJRQQDEHDEOHWR JHWWR\RXXQWLOODWHURQWRQLJKWWKRXJK´  6XJJV³+H\ZK\WKHSKRQHNHHSFOLFNLQJ OLNHWKDW"´  3DUNHU³6KHFOLFNLQJ"´  6XJJV³

  'DWH $FWLYDWLRQ 2WKHU ([FHUSWVIURPWUDQVFULSW 7HVWLPRQ\IURP$JHQW 1XPEHU 3DUW\ %HYLQJWRQ   /RQQHOO 7UDQVFULSWRIFDOOPLVVLQJIURPUHFRUG $JHQW%HYLQJWRQ SP *ORYHU WHVWLILHGWKDW³>I@URPWKLV FDOOZHNQHZWKH\ZHUH JRLQJWRPHHW´ SP7UDW   +HOHU\ 6XJJV³,MXVWDLQ¶WOLNHWKDWORRNWKHRWKHU 1RQH SP 3ULFH GD\WKRXJK\RXNQRZ´  ,VD\ZHMXVWJRWWRUDSPDNHVXUH HYHU\WKLQJFRRO,MXVWDLQ¶WOLNHWKDWORRNWKH RWKHUGD\GRZQWKHUH\RXNQRZ´  3ULFH³,WKLQN,WKLQN,WKLQNLWVDOULJKW WKRXJK,,,GLGQ¶W\RXNQRZ,GLGQ¶WJHW QREDGYLEHV´  6XJJV³2KRND\$OULJKW´  3ULFH³,WKLQNHYHU\WKLQJJRRG´  6XJJV³,¶PJRQQDPDNHDUXQ´  6XJJV³

,DLQ¶WJRWQRFKRLFHWRFRPH RXW,DLQ¶WJRWQRFKRLFH+HJRLQJWRFDOO PHEDFNLQPLQXWHV´  6XJJV³,¶PVD\LQJJLYHPHDERXWDQKRXU )RRODQG,¶OOKLW\RXULJKWEDFNOHWPHVHH ZKDW¶VKDSSHQLQJ´   +HOHU\ 7UDQVFULSWRIFDOOPLVVLQJIURPUHFRUG 1RQHSeeSP SP 3ULFH 7UDW   -DQXDU\  6XUYHLOODQFHRIPHHWLQJEHWZHHQ6XJJVDQG/RQQHOO*ORYHU SP7UDW   

  -DQXDU\ &DOOVUHFRUGHGE\6XJJV:LUHWDS  'DWH $FWLYDWLRQ 2WKHU ([FHUSWVIURPWUDQVFULSW 7HVWLPRQ\IURP$JHQW 1XPEHU 3DUW\ %HYLQJWRQ   +HOHU\ 6XJJV³,¶PZDLWLQJEDE\,DLQ¶WIRUJRW $JHQW%HYLQJWRQWHVWLILHG SP 3ULFH DERXW\RX´ WKDWZKHQ6XJJV¶VDLG  ³,¶POD\LQJ´LW³UHIHUVWR 3ULFH³&DXVHWKH\NHHSFDOOLQJPH ZDLWLQJ´SP7U ´ DW  6XJJV³

  -DQ0DUFK &DOOVUHFRUGHGE\6XJJVZLUHWDS   'DWH $FWLYDWLRQ 2WKHU ([FHUSWVIURPWUDQVFULSW 7HVWLPRQ\IURP$JHQW 1XPEHU 3DUW\ %HYLQJWRQ   -XOLDQ -RKQVRQ³:KDWFKDORRNLQOLNHRYHUWKHUH" $JHQW%HYLQJWRQ SP -RKQVRQ  WHVWLILHGWKDWWKH 6XJJV³8KZKDWFKDPHDQRQXKV

RQ UHIHUHQFHVWRWK6WUHHW WKHVWRUHWLS"´ DQGQG6WUHHWZHUH  VLJQLILFDQWEHFDXVH³3&3 -RKQVRQ³

XKZKDW¶VWKDWVL[WHHQWKXK DQGRXQFHV´DQGWKDW RYHUWKHUHE\XKZKDW¶VWKDWVRXWKHDVWWKDW ZKDWWKLVH[FKDQJH LWXVHWREHDW"´ PHDQWZDVWKDW³0U  6XJJVLVLQGLFDWLQJKH -RKQVRQ³

,PHDQ\RXDLQ¶WSXWPHRQ QXWWLQEXWQGVWUHHWWKDW¶VJRQH´  ³,PLJKWQHHGWRFRPHVHH\RXWKRXJK´  6XJJV³2N+RZORQJ\RXJRQQDEH EHIRUH\RXFRPHRYHUKHUH"´

  'DWH $FWLYDWLRQ 2WKHU ([FHUSWVIURPWUDQVFULSW 7HVWLPRQ\IURP$JHQW 1XPEHU 3DUW\ %HYLQJWRQ   +HOHU\ 3ULFH³0DQPRWK>@HUI

SUHVVLQJPH 1RQH SP 3ULFH EDE\´  6XJJV³

  'DWH $FWLYDWLRQ 2WKHU ([FHUSWVIURPWUDQVFULSW 7HVWLPRQ\IURP$JHQW 1XPEHU 3DUW\ %HYLQJWRQ   *OHQGDOH 6XJJV³:KDW¶VKDSSHQLQJ" 1RQH SP /HH  /HH³:KDW\RXLQWKHKRXVH"´  6XJJV³1DK,¶PPRYLQJDURXQG´  /HH³,QHHGWRJHWRQH´  6XJJV³:KHUH\RXDW"´  /HH³,¶PVLWWLQJXSDW7DNRPD6WDWLRQULJKW QRZ´  6XJJV³$OULJKWFDXVH,ZKDW¶VXSLV HYHU\WKLQJWKHUHRUZKDW"´   *OHQGDOH 6XJJV³,¶PDERXWWRULGHXSWKHUH\RXLQ 1RQH SP /HH WKHVWDWLRQQRZ"´  ³,VD\,¶PJRQQDULGHXSWKHUH

  'DWH $FWLYDWLRQ 2WKHU ([FHUSWVIURPWUDQVFULSW 7HVWLPRQ\IURP$JHQW 1XPEHU 3DUW\ %HYLQJWRQ   -XOLDQ 6XJJV³

\RXNQRZ"´ DERXW/HHDQGDQRWKHU  DVVRFLDWH-RKQDQGWKDW ³,FDQ¶WKHDU\RXZKDWKDSSHQ"´ ³0U6XJJVLVFRQFHUQHG  WKDW*OHQGDOH/HHLV -RKQVRQ³'LG\RXKROGWKHPWKUHHGRZQ"´ WHOOLQJ-RKQHYHU\WKLQJ  WKDWWKH\¶UHGRLQJDQGLI 6XJJV³1DK,¶PVD\LQJ,¶PJRLQJWRJLYH -RKQLVDUUHVWHGIRU LWWR\RXDOODWRQH,JRW\RX´ VRPHWKLQJKHZLOOWHVWLI\  DJDLQVWWKHP´ ³+HGRQ¶WZDQWQRWKLQJLQOLIHWKHQHYHU\ SP7UDW WKLQJKHGRKHJRWWRGLVFXVVZLWK%LJ -RKQWKDW¶VDQRWKHULVVXH,JRWZLWKKLP, GRQ¶WZDQW-RKQLQP\EXVLQHVVGRQ¶W NQRZ-RKQIHHLQJ\RXHYHU\WKLQJ\RXZLQG PHXS  ³

WRJHWRQWKDWVWDQGRQXVLI LIWKH\VQDWFKKLPXSDERXWVRPHWKLQJ´  ³8KKXK\HDKDQGWKHQJRQQDUXQWRWKH QH[WFUHZDQGWHOOWKHPZKDW¶VJRLQJRQ ZLWKXV´   *OHQGDOH 9RLFHPDLOPHVVDJH³&X]JLYHPHDFDOO, 1RQH SP /HH QHHGWZRRIWKRVHWLFNHWV´   *OHQGDOH 6XJJV³,¶PZLWKP\SDUWQHUQRZ,¶P 1RQH SP /HH JRQQDFDOO\RXEDFNLQDQKRXU´  /HH³,JRWDIHZSHRSOHZDLWLQJ´

  'DWH $FWLYDWLRQ 2WKHU ([FHUSWVIURPWUDQVFULSW 7HVWLPRQ\IURP$JHQW 1XPEHU 3DUW\ %HYLQJWRQ   *OHQGDOH 6XJJV³P@WRKROGRQ WKDW¶VDOO,¶PMXVWZDLWLQJRQKLPWR\RX NQRZWDNHFDUHZKDWKHJRWWRGR´   *OHQGDOH /HH³:KDW¶VJRLQJRQ"´ 1RQH SP /HH  6XJJV³

  'DWH $FWLYDWLRQ 2WKHU ([FHUSWVIURPWUDQVFULSW 7HVWLPRQ\IURP$JHQW 1XPEHU 3DUW\ %HYLQJWRQ   (UQHVW *ORYHU³&X]DLQ¶WFDOO\RXEDFN\HW´ 1RQH SP *ORYHU  6XJJV³1DZPDQV

,¶PVWLOOOD\LQJ ´  ³0RWKHUI

JRWPHIUXVWUDWHGDVD PRWKHUI

´  *ORYHU³+LVV

VKRXOGEHLQPRWLRQ LQDPLQXWH\RXNQRZ"´  ³

  'DWH $FWLYDWLRQ 2WKHU ([FHUSWVIURPWUDQVFULSW 7HVWLPRQ\IURP$JHQW 1XPEHU 3DUW\ %HYLQJWRQ   +HOHU\ 6XJJV³PDQZHVKRXOGXPKDYHWKDWD %HYLQJWRQWHVWLILHGWKDW SP 3ULFH DSDUWPHQWFOHDQHGRXWRQHGD\WKLVZHHN 6XJJV¶UHIHUHQFHWRDQ \RXNQRZ´ ³DSDUWPHQW´ZDVKLP  ³OHWWLQJ0U3ULFHNQRZ 3ULFH³+XK"´ WKDWKHVKRXOGKDYH3&3  IRUVDOHWKHIROORZLQJ 6XJJV³ZHVKRXOGKDYHWKDWDSDUWPHQW ZHHN´SP7U FOHDQHGRXWRQHGD\WKLVZHHNWKHQ\RXFDQ DW PRYHLQWKHUH\RXNQRZ"´   3ULFH³2K\HDK´  6XJJV³+@HJDYHPHDSLDQRWKRXJK´ SDUWLFXODUFRQWH[W,  ZRXOGVD\WKUHHWKRXVDQG 6XJJV³,WROG\RX*UHJZDQWWREHLQWKH EHFDXVHKHWDONVDERXWD JDPHVREDG´ G>H@XFHDQGWKHQDSLDQR´  DQG³>D@SLDQRLVDFRGH *ORYHU³&>RXVLQWKRXJKDLQ¶WJRWEDFNDW 1RQH SP *ORYHU \RX":KDW¶VXSZLWKROGFX]WKRXJKPDQ"´  6XJJV³0RWKHUI

MXVWJRWXV OD\LQJ´   +HOHU\ 3ULFHEDFNJURXQGFRQYHUVDWLRQSLFNHGXS 1RQH SP 3ULFH RQYRLFHPDLO³,NQRZKHDLQ¶WJRWQRWKLQJ +H¶GDEHHQFDOOHG7KHZD\ZHZDV PRYLQJWKDWVKLW´

  'DWH $FWLYDWLRQ 2WKHU ([FHUSWVIURPWUDQVFULSW 7HVWLPRQ\IURP$JHQW 1XPEHU 3DUW\ %HYLQJWRQ   -RH-RH -RH-RH³,WDONVWR(UQLHDERXWDERXW 1RQH DP WHQVRPHWKLQJULJKW´  ³,VDLGORRNPDQ,¶PWU\LQJWRKROODDW\RX UHDOEULHI´  6XJJV³+@HFDOOHGPHWRJHWPHWRJRDOO WKHZD\XSWR(GJHZRRGPDQ,¶PWRWLQJ HYHU\WKLQJDQGWKHPPRWKHUI

DLQ¶W JRWWKHLUPRQH\UHDG\RUQRWKLQJ´  ³+HFDOOHGPHWKLVPRUQLQJWRFRPHE\DQG VHHKLPZHWDONHG6R,VDLGZHOO-R-R\RX NQRZDK5LJKWQRZ,DLQ¶WJRWP\KRXVH UHDG\\HWEXWZKHQ,JHWP\KRXVHUHDG\ ,JLYHKLPDFDOO,JHWVXSWKHUH,¶P VLWWLQJDURXQGDERXWPLQXWHVLQWKHFDU ZDLWLQJIRUKLPWRFRPHRXWRIWKHEXLOGLQJ DQGKHFRPHVRXWRIWKHEXLOGLQJPDQKH DLQ¶WJRWQRQRPRWKHUIXFNLQJ1V´   +HOHU\ 9RLFHPDLO³$SSOHJLYHPHDFDOOPDQ, 1RQH SP 3ULFH QHHGWRKHDUIURP\RXPDQ,W¶VXUJHQW PDQ

  'DWH $FWLYDWLRQ 2WKHU ([FHUSWVIURPWUDQVFULSW 7HVWLPRQ\IURP$JHQW 1XPEHU 3DUW\ %HYLQJWRQ   +HOHU\ 6XJJV³&DQ,VSHDNWR%URWKHU"´ 1RQH SP 3ULFH  3ULFH³'DPQ)RRO´  ³0DQ,WHOO\RXPDQ\RXQHHGWRFRPHKROOD DWPHPDQ´  6XJJV³,¶PRQP\ZD\)RRO´  3ULFH³%XWMXVWFRPHRQPDQFDXVH,QHHG \RXDWRJRWDNHFDUHRIVRPHWKLQJUHDO TXLFN´  6XJJV³$OULJKW,¶PDFRPHWDONWR\RX´   +HOHU\ 6XJJV³%HULJKWWKHUHLQPLQXWHV´ 1RQH SP 3ULFH   +HOHU\ 3ULFH³,VKRXOGEHKLWWLQJ\RXDLQDGD\ 1RQH DP 3ULFH RUVR´   +HOHU\ 9RLFHPDLOPHVVDJH³)RRODQVZHU\RXU 1RQH SP 3ULFH SKRQHPDQI

\RXGRQ¶WOLNHPRRODRU ZKDW"´   0DUFK 7UXFNEXJLQVWDOOHG  0DUFK  6HDUFKRI6XJJV¶KRPHLWHPVVHL]HGLQFOXGHGVHYHQERWWOHVRI3&3 EXFNHWVWKDWVPHOOHGRI3&3DQGKDG3&3UHVLGXHDLUIUHVKHQHUD PHDVXULQJFXSIXQQHOILQJHUSULQWRQEXFNHWLQFDVKDOOIURP EDVHPHQWDQGVHYHQRXQFHERWWOHVRI3&3LQDWWLF  0DUFK  7UXFN%XJ$FWLYDWLRQ/RQQHOO*ORYHUDQG&KULVWLDQ'RQDOGVRQ 'LGQRWLQFULPLQDWH+HOHU\3ULFHRU(UQHVW*ORYHU  0DUFK$SU &DOOVUHFRUGHGE\6XJJVZLUHWDS  'DWH $FWLYDWLRQ 2WKHU ([FHUSWVIURPWUDQVFULSW 7HVWLPRQ\IURP$JHQW 1XPEHU 3DUW\ %HYLQJWRQ   *OHQGDOH /HH³+H\&X]EULQJPHDGHXFH´ 1RQH SP /HH  6XJJV³$OULJKWRND\,VHH\RXZKHQ,JHW WKHUH´

  'DWH $FWLYDWLRQ 2WKHU ([FHUSWVIURPWUDQVFULSW 7HVWLPRQ\IURP$JHQW 1XPEHU 3DUW\ %HYLQJWRQ   +HOHU\ 6XJJV³:KDW¶VKDSSHQLQJZLWK\RXEDE\"´ 1RQH SP 3ULFH  3ULFH³,ZDQW\RXMXVWWRFRPHKROOHUDWPH ZKHQ\RXJHWDFKDQFH´  6XJJV2ND\,¶OOFDOO\RXDVVRRQDV,JHWWR WKH\DUGWRP\FDU*LYHPHDERXW PLQXWHV´   +HOHU\ 6XJJV³,¶POHDYLQJRXWWKHGRRUQRZ´ 1RQH SP 3ULFH   +HOHU\ 3ULFH³

  $SULO 7UXFN%XJ/RQQHOO*ORYHUDQG6XJJV,QFULPLQDWHG+HOHU\ 3ULFH  $SULO  &DOOVUHFRUGHGE\6XJJVZLUHWDS  'DWH $FWLYDWLRQ 2WKHU ([FHUSWVIURPWUDQVFULSW 7HVWLPRQ\IURP 1XPEHU 3DUW\ $JHQW%HYLQJWRQ   -DPHV 3DUNHU³,¶PDWU\WRKROODDW\RX´ 1RQH 3DUNHU  6XJJV³$OULJKW:KHQ\RXFRPLQJEDFN"´  3DUNHU³,¶PDJRDKHDGDQG,FRPLQJEDFN WRPRUURZ´  6XJJV³2K\HDK\HD,¶PMXVWVD\LQJ,,DLQ¶W NQRZZKDWZDVJRLQJRQPDQ:HJRWRJHWRQ SDJHWRJHWKHU\RXNQRZ"´  3DUNHU³:@KDW\RXZDQWPH WRGR"'R\RXZDQWPHWRKROOHUDW\RXUURRPPDWH ODWHURQRURUKRZGR\RXZDQWWRGRLW´  3DUNHU³7@HOOKLP,¶OOULGHRXWWKHUHDERXWQLQH´   $SULO 6XJJVZLUHWDSHQGV$JHQW%HYLQJWRQWHVWLILHGWKDWWKHZLUHWDSZDVWDNHQ GRZQEHFDXVHWKHIRFXVRIWKHLQYHVWLJDWLRQZDVVKLIWLQJWRKLVVXSSOLHU /RQQHOO*ORYHUDQGLGHQWLI\LQJKLVRWKHUFXVWRPHUVDQGKLVVRXUFHRI VXSSO\SeeSP7UDW  $SULO 7UXFN%XJ/RQQHOO*ORYHUDQG6XJJV,QFULPLQDWHG(UQHVW*ORYHU 

  0D\ 7UXFN%XJ/RQQHOO*ORYHUDQG6XJJV,QFULPLQDWHG+HOHU\3ULFH   0D\ 7UXFN%XJ/RQQHOO*ORYHUDQG&RUQHOO*ORYHU,QFULPLQDWHG (UQHVW*ORYHU   0D\ 6HDUFKRI-DPHV3DUNHU¶VDSDUWPHQW)URPWKHNLWFKHQWKHLWHPVVHL]HG LQFOXGHGWZRERWWOHVFRQWDLQLQJ3&3UHVLGXHDSODWHZLWK3&3UHVLGXHD ER[KROGLQJTXDUWHURXQFHJODVVERWWOHVDIXQQHODVFDOHDQGDFLJDUHWWH OLNHLWHPXVHGIRUVPRNLQJ3&3SP7UDWIURP 3DUNHU¶VEHGURRPWKHLWHPVVHL]HGLQFOXGHGVHYHUDOJODVVERWWOHVWKDW VPHOOHGOLNH3&3DQGVHYHUDOVPDOOHUYLDOVSP7UDW  -XQH 7UXFNEXJWHUPLQDWHG   6HDUFKRI(UQHVW*ORYHU¶VKRXVH,WHPVVHL]HGLQFOXGHGGLJLWDOVFDOH ELOOZLWKKHURLQRQLWOLWWOHEDJJLHVRQHZLWKKHURLQLQLWWZRVKRHER[HV ILOOHGZLWKVPDOOJODVVERWWOHVDQGWRSVWZRWXUNH\EDVWHUVWZRH\H GURSSHUVMXLFHERWWOHZLWKJUDPV3&3&RUQHOO*ORYHU¶VILQJHUSULQWV ZHUHRQWKHVKRHER[YDQLOODH[WUDFWERWWOHVZLWKJUDPV3&3WZR IXQQHOVWXUNH\EDVWHUVKRWJXQULIOHER[HVRIDPPXQLWLRQ   $UUHVWRI6XJJV,WHPVVHL]HGLQFOXGHGLQFDVKDQGWZRFHOOSKRQHV RQHZDVWKHRQHWKDWKDGEHHQZLUHWDSSHG&HOOSKRQH³FRQWDFWV´ PDWFKHG+HOHU\3ULFH¶VQXPEHUZLWKWKHQDPH³%URWKHU´