United States v. Price

65 F.3d 903, 1995 U.S. App. LEXIS 27616, 1995 WL 545374
CourtCourt of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit
DecidedSeptember 29, 1995
Docket94-6141, 94-6152
StatusPublished
Cited by14 cases

This text of 65 F.3d 903 (United States v. Price) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
United States v. Price, 65 F.3d 903, 1995 U.S. App. LEXIS 27616, 1995 WL 545374 (11th Cir. 1995).

Opinion

*905 PER CURIAM:

John and David Price were convicted for conspiracy, in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 371 (1988), to commit murder and for the use of interstate commerce facilities in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 1958 (1988), with the intent to commit murder-for-hire. John Price was also convicted of solicitation to commit a crime of violence in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 373 (1988), while David Price was separately convicted for using interstate commerce facilities in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 1958 (1988), with the intent to commit murder-for-hire. 1 John Price was sentenced to 360 months imprisonment and fined. David Price was sentenced to 300 months in prison and was ordered to pay fines as well. The Prices appeal, challenging their convictions and their sentences. We affirm their convictions but vacate their sentences and remand for resentencing.

I. FACTS AND PROCEDURAL HISTORY

John Price was president of Price Rubber Corporation, a business headquartered in Montgomery, Alabama. His son David managed a Texas rubber plant owned by the company. Several business-related incidents gave rise to the convictions now at issue.

Before establishing operations in Montgomery, John Price owned a rubber warehouse and distribution center in Auburn, Georgia. That facility burned in 1974, causing Price a three million dollar uninsured loss. The Prices have always believed that Auburn resident David Hawthorne was responsible for the arson. Nothing came of their suspicions for a time, however, because shortly after the fire, the Prices left Auburn and moved to Montgomery to found Price Rubber.

The Prices acquired more perceived enemies when, in 1986, Sy Shafer and Ellis Lucas sold their printing concern, Pioneer Press, to Kenny Price, John Price’s nephew. Kenny was affiliated with the Prices’ enterprise, and he ran the printing business “parallel” to the principal rubber operation. (Gov’t Ex. 6 at 17-18.) Shafer and Lucas retained Leon Capouano, a Montgomery lawyer, to handle the sale of Pioneer Press.

The acquisition proved troublesome for the Prices. The parties to the deal became involved in litigation, and ultimately Shafer and Lucas obtained a money judgment against Pioneer Press and Kenny Price. Litigation continued through 1992; Sy Shafer had filed two suits directly against John Price by the fall of 1991. Family relations turned so sour that John Price fired nephew Kenny, on the belief that he was stealing from the company. After his severance from the Price empire, Kenny became a prospective witness for Sy Shafer against his uncle.

Further problems arose for Price Rubber in 1991, when Internal Revenue Agent Dwight Huff initiated an examination of the company’s tax records. Though routine, the review spanned the next two years, in part because of the failure of Price Rubber to timely provide information necessary for the audit’s completion.

Not fond of lawyers, John Price and his son David decided to bypass legal recourse and deal with their woes through a sinister plot to pay back their perceived enemies by hiring hitmen to wreak various degrees of havoc upon them. Bobby Price (unrelated to, but acquainted with John and David Price) was the Prices’ initial contact with the underworld. 2 In November, 1991, David Price visited Bobby’s auto body shop in Montgomery. At this meeting, David handed Bobby $2000 and instructed him to find “the right people” to blow up Leon Capoua-no’s law office and to kill David Hawthorne in Auburn, Georgia. (R. 18 at 329.) Later, David mailed Bobby two packages which contained maps, photographs, and other information about Capouano and Hawthorne. The second parcel also contained a note indicating that David Price had two more names to add to the “hit list,” apparently Kenny Price and Sy Shafer.

*906 Meanwhile, Bobby Price was arrested July 8, 1992, for trafficking in marijuana. In exchange for a lighter sentence, Bobby struck a deal with the government, eventually providing information about the Prices’ murder-for-hire plot. 3 After his agreement with the government, the federal agents orchestrated a meeting on August 14, 1992, between Bobby Price and David Price, during which David told Bobby that Kenny Price and David Hawthorne were still prime targets. David also took Bobby out to Elmore County, Alabama, to “case” Kenny’s trailer. David paid Bobby $1500, and Bobby explained that he had two friends (FBI special agents) who would be willing to do these jobs for the Prices.

One week later, Bobby had a similar meeting with John Price. There, John expressed his desire to have Kenny “busted up pretty good,” (Gov’t Ex. 2 at 59), though he expressed hesitation about killing his nephew outright. As for David Hawthorne, John stated that “the guy needs to be rubbed out. No question about that.” (Id. at 62.) 4

By September 16, Bobby had introduced David Price to the undercover FBI agents, and meetings between the participants continued through the fall of 1992. During these meetings, the murders of Kenny Price, David Hawthorne, and Sy Shafer, as well as the bombing of Leon Capouano’s law office, were planned and paid for by John and David Price. 5 Finally, John Price sent a letter to the agents in January, 1993, requesting the “well damaged carcass” of IRS agent Dwight Huff, in retaliation for the inconvenience caused by the audit of Price Rubber. (Gov’t Ex. 63.)

The last meeting between the federal agents and John Price occurred on January 27, 1993, in Montgomery. There the agents told Price that the first murder, that of Sy Shafer, had been completed, and they showed him pictures of what they said was the body. John Price paid the agents $20,-000 and expressed enthusiasm about the imminent success of the remaining jobs. Later that day, he and son David were arrested.

A grand jury in the Middle District of Alabama indicted the Prices jointly, and the case went to trial in June, 1993. The Prices were acquitted on two counts of witness tampering, but the jury was unable to reach a verdict on the other counts. As a result, a mistrial was declared as to those counts. Retrial began in July, 1993, and the jury returned guilty verdicts against both defendants on the remaining charges. The Prices filed a motion for a new trial, which alleged, among other things, that juror misconduct deprived them of a fair trial. The court questioned the jurors in camera to investigate the alleged improprieties, and some instances of misconduct were found. The judge ruled that none of the incidents prejudiced the defendants’ rights and denied the motion for a new trial.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Shevgert v. United States
M.D. Florida, 2025
Beatty v. Lamont
D. Connecticut, 2024
United States v. Ketut Pujayasa
703 F. App'x 817 (Eleventh Circuit, 2017)
United States v. Ambrose Puente
267 F. App'x 863 (Eleventh Circuit, 2008)
United States v. Sawyer
180 F.3d 1319 (Eleventh Circuit, 1999)
United States v. Price
130 F.3d 443 (Eleventh Circuit, 1997)
United States v. Ruth Alston Breeding
109 F.3d 308 (Sixth Circuit, 1997)
United States v. David S. Taylor
88 F.3d 938 (Eleventh Circuit, 1996)
United States v. Robert E. Hines
88 F.3d 661 (Eighth Circuit, 1996)
Piccirilli v. United States
First Circuit, 1995

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
65 F.3d 903, 1995 U.S. App. LEXIS 27616, 1995 WL 545374, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/united-states-v-price-ca11-1995.