United States v. Jones

62 F.2d 347, 1932 U.S. App. LEXIS 3166

• Court: Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit
• Decided: December 2, 1932
• Docket: No. 3339
• Status: Published

Opinion

PER CURIAM.

This is an appeal from, a judgment in favor of plaintiff on a policy of war risk insurance. The policy was continued in force by payment of premiums until August 31, 1919. The only question we need consider is whether the evidence was sufficient to establish total and permanent disability on the part of the insured at that time. We do not think that it was.

There is evidence tending to show that plaintiff was suffering at the time of the lapse of the policy with chronic bronchial asthma, and that he had a fractured coccyx bone; but the fractured coccyx bone did not constitute disability of cither a total or permanent nature, and, while the asthma was chronic, the disability resulting from it was not total. About a month before the policy lapsed, plaintiff went to work as a,n automobile mechanic in a garage at Lumberton, N. C., where he worked for a year ana a half at wages of from $30 to $35 per week. When the firm for which ho was working discontinued business, he went to York, S. C!) and opened up a repair shop of his own; which he operated for about a year. Following this, he worked about a year for the Willys Knight Company at wages of $20 per week. He then worked for about ten months for Scotland county at a wage of $35 per week, repairing trucks for the county highway commission. There can be no question that between 1919 and 1924 he was working with substantial regularity at good wages; and, in view of this, it cannot he said that in 1919 he was totally and permanently disabled. U. S. v. Diehl (C. C. A. 4th) 62 F.(2d) 343 (this day decided); U. S. v. Harrison (C. C. A. 4th) 49 F.(2d) 227; Nicolay v. U. S. (C. C. A.) 51 F.(2d) 170; U. S. v. McGill (C. C. A.) 56 F.(2d) 522. The judgment below will ho reversed.

Reversed.