United States v. Holz

103 F. Supp. 191, 1950 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 4286
CourtDistrict Court, E.D. Illinois
DecidedOctober 14, 1950
DocketNo. 17333
StatusPublished

This text of 103 F. Supp. 191 (United States v. Holz) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering District Court, E.D. Illinois primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
United States v. Holz, 103 F. Supp. 191, 1950 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 4286 (illinoised 1950).

Opinion

PLATT, District Judge.

In this case defendants Harry Holz and Linda Martin were indicted in the First Count for violation of Section 2421, Title 18, United States Code, and in the Second Count charged with a violation of Section 371, of said Title 18. Count One alleges defendants transported in interstate commerce one Linda Martin from Kankakee, Illinois to Logansport, Indiana with the intent and purpose that the said woman give herself up to prostitution and debauchery and engage in other immoral practices. Count Two charges the two defendants with conspiracy to violate said Section 2421, Title 18 by transporting the said Linda Martin from Kankakee, Illinois to Logans-port, Indiana for the said purposes of prostitution. Defendants entered pleas of not guilty. Defendants waived trial by jury and consented to trial by court. At the beginning of the trial, the United States Attorney made a motion to nolle' prosequi Count One as to the defendant Linda Martin. This motion was allowed.

Let us review the facts as they appear in the evidence. On behalf of the United States, Mr. and Mrs. Fred Martin testified Linda Martin was a professional prostitute and employed by them at Club 17 on Bsute 17 east of Kankakee, Illinois for about two or three months during the summer of 1948. They operated the house of prostitution. Defendant Holz visited Linda Martin nearly every day while she was employed at Club 17. When she left Club 17 she went to work for Holz who operated a tavern.

Mildred Arnold testified that on the evening of November 18, 1949 Linda Martin appeared at her home in Logansport, Indiana and requested employment as a prostitute. Mildred Arnold operated a house of prostitution in Logansport, Indiana. Mildred Arnold informed her she would have to obtain a health certificate before going to work. On November 19th defendant Martin arrived at Mildred Arnold’s shortly before noon with a large traveling bag and a small train case; that on November 19, 1949.at about 2:30 to 3 p. m. Harry Holz called and came out to the house; that the three of them talked and then for fear that there might be a raid on the house Linda Martin went back to Kankakee with Holz that night. About March 7, 1950 Linda Martin called her on the telephone from Kankakee and came to her house and worked about five days; that she left the night of March 14th about midnight with Holz. Holz told Mildred Arnold at that time in March that he was driving through from Muncie to his home. Linda wanted a day off and went back with Holz to Kanka-kee. Between March 14 and March 20 Linda Martin called the Arnold woman by telephone and told her if anybody asked how she had got to her place she came on the train from Chicago.

Charles F. Parrett, Sheriff of Cass County, Indiana, testified that he and the Prosecuting Attorney of that county, Thomas F. Hirschauer, were driving on East Wabash Avenue in the vicinity of Mildred Arnold’s home when they saw a Buick automobile stop in front of the Arnold house and let a girl out. The car had no license plates and for that reason it was stopped within two blocks. Holz was driving the car and told Sheriff Parrett someone had attempted to steal his license plates or reflectors, and that was why they were not on the car; that he did not know the girl he left at Mildred Arnold’s house; “that they had just been out having a little fun”. Holz was arrested to appear in Justice of the Peace Court at 2 p. m. that afternoon. Hirschauer and Parrett then went back to the Arnold home to interview Linda Martin. Parrett testified she said she knew Holz, that he operated a tavern in Kanka-kee and she worked for him. The Prosecuting Attorney, Hirschauer, questioned Linda Martin. He testified, “I remember she asked if this was routine, that she just had gotten in town. I said, ‘No it is not routine’. I asked where she had come from. She said from Kankakee, Illinois. Prior— and then I asked her if she knew Harry Holz and she said yes I do, and then as best I can remember she said she just come with him from Kankakee, Illinois.”

Thomas Barksdale, Special Agent of the F.B.I., testified that on March 14, 1950 Berglund, Special Agent of the F.B.I. and Barksdale met Holz at his tavern near [193]*193Kankakee, Illinois. They told him they wanted to question Linda Martin about a person she knew. Holz asked who this person was, and they said they would rather not discuss that. Holz told the F.B.I. Agents that he was going to meet Linda Martin in Chicago, and that she would be in town the next day. Arrangements were made to meet Linda Martin and Holz on the evening of March 15th at a tavern in Kankakee; that Berglund and he met Linda Martin and Holz at a tavern. They all then went to the Kankakee police station. Barksdale further testified that Linda Martin told him that on November 18th she took a bus to Chicago and train to Logansport where she met Harry Holz. Later she said Harry Holz took her to Chicago; that she had had an argument with Holz. She said she went to work for Mildred Arnold as a prostitute. In response to a question if Holz took her there she said, “I do as I please. Harry doesn’t take me anywhere. I have been around longer than that.” Holz told Barksdale he had been in Logans-port November 18, 1949 with Linda Martin; that he knew she would be in Logans-port, but did not say that he took her over there. Linda Martin further told Barksdale she went to Mildred Arnold’s house the next day after examination at a doctor’s office. She told Barksdale she had been a prostitute for approximately seven years and was twenty-five years of age. She further told Barksdale that Holz had kept her.

Thomas L. Cooper, physician and surgeon and city health officer of Logansport testified he examined Linda Martin on November 19th. She gave her name as Kitty Martin, address 514 East Wabash Avenue, Logansport, Indiana. The hospital record and report on the blood test introduced in evidence shows that this occurred on November 19th.

Mr. Edgar Donar, clerk at the Lafayette Hotel in Kankakee, Illinois, testified he had known Holz for a number of years; that Holz and Linda Martin registered at the hotel as man and wife many times starting about October 6, 1949; that Holz and Martin registered at the hotel on November 19th at 5 a. m. The records of the hotel showed that the room they occupied on March 7, 1950 had a telephone call to Lo-gansport that evening. He further testified that John Rockert was the bellboy from 11 p. m. November 18th to 7 a. m. November 19th.

In defense Linda Martin took the witness stand as did Harry Holz. Linda Martin said on November 18th she tended bar for Holz until 1:30 a. m. of November 19th at his tavern at Routes 1 and 17. They were on unfriendly terms because he had not been around; that she left and went to several bars and at one of these she met Holz. About 5 a. m. she and Holz registered at the Lafayette Hotel for a place for her to leave her clothes. They left at 5 :30 a. m. or shortly thereafter in Holz’ Buick automobile; that they drove to the Union Station in Chicago; she then checked her bags at the Union Station and did some drinking alone. She told Holz she was going to visit friends in Logansport, Indiana; that she called Mildred Arnold two or three days before by telephone and Mildred Arnold said she could use her. Later she testified she called Mildred Arnold from the depot at Kankakee the day before. When she arrived in Logansport she met Holz at the ■depot; that she told Holz she had some shopping to do. She left the depot in a taxicab. She went to the doctor’s office for examination and then to the Walgreen Drug Store. She had made arrangements with Holz to meet her there.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Wilson v. United States
162 U.S. 613 (Supreme Court, 1896)
United States v. Holte
236 U.S. 140 (Supreme Court, 1915)
Gebardi v. United States
287 U.S. 112 (Supreme Court, 1932)
Wright v. United States
175 F.2d 384 (Eighth Circuit, 1949)
MacKreth v. United States
103 F.2d 495 (Fifth Circuit, 1939)
Martin v. United States
100 F.2d 490 (Tenth Circuit, 1938)
Loftus v. United States
46 F.2d 841 (Seventh Circuit, 1931)
Marino v. United States
91 F.2d 691 (Ninth Circuit, 1937)
Madsen v. United States
165 F.2d 507 (Tenth Circuit, 1947)
Myres v. United States
174 F.2d 329 (Eighth Circuit, 1949)
Israel v. United States
3 F.2d 743 (Sixth Circuit, 1925)
Downs v. United States
3 F.2d 855 (Third Circuit, 1925)
Shama v. United States
94 F.2d 1 (Eighth Circuit, 1938)
United States v. Reginelli
133 F.2d 595 (Third Circuit, 1943)
Telman v. United States
67 F.2d 716 (Tenth Circuit, 1933)
Wilkerson v. United States
41 F.2d 654 (Seventh Circuit, 1930)
United States v. Trierweiler
52 F. Supp. 4 (E.D. Illinois, 1943)
United States v. Sorrentino
78 F. Supp. 425 (M.D. Pennsylvania, 1948)
Reavis v. United States
106 F.2d 982 (Tenth Circuit, 1939)
United States v. Fleenor
162 F.2d 935 (Seventh Circuit, 1947)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
103 F. Supp. 191, 1950 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 4286, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/united-states-v-holz-illinoised-1950.