United States v. Eugene Laron Fishback

CourtCourt of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit
DecidedJanuary 30, 2026
Docket25-5085
StatusUnpublished

This text of United States v. Eugene Laron Fishback (United States v. Eugene Laron Fishback) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
United States v. Eugene Laron Fishback, (6th Cir. 2026).

Opinion

NOT RECOMMENDED FOR PUBLICATION File Name: 26a0065n.06

Case No. 25-5085

UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE SIXTH CIRCUIT FILED Jan 30, 2026 KELLY L. STEPHENS, Clerk ) UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, ) Plaintiff-Appellee, ) ON APPEAL FROM THE ) UNITED STATES DISTRICT v. ) COURT FOR THE EASTERN ) DISTRICT OF KENTUCKY EUGENE LARON FISHBACK, ) Defendant-Appellant. ) OPINION )

Before: COLE, MATHIS, and HERMANDORFER, Circuit Judges.

HERMANDORFER, Circuit Judge. Eugene Fishback purchased over 150,000 fentanyl-

laced pills from his supplier over the course of a few years. He then resold the pills to buyers for

profit. After searches of items and premises tied to Fishback uncovered large quantities of drugs

and a cache of weapons, a grand jury indicted Fishback on various drug-distribution counts. A

federal jury convicted him of all charges, and the district court sentenced him to 480 months’

imprisonment. On appeal, Fishback presses sufficiency-of-the-evidence challenges to his

convictions. He also contests the district court’s application of four Sentencing Guidelines

provisions. Because Fishback’s arguments all fail, we affirm.

I

Eugene Fishback sold fentanyl in eastern Kentucky for years. Christopher Smith was his

primary supplier. Starting in 2019, Fishback would exchange cash for fentanyl-laced pills from

Smith at least every other day. In the first transaction, Fishback acquired 5,000 pills. No. 25-5085, United States v. Fishback

Fishback would sometimes buy up to 10,000 pills at a time. By the time Smith moved to California

in October 2022, Fishback had purchased approximately 150,000 pills from him. And when Smith

later returned to Kentucky, he sold a couple thousand more pills to Fishback before authorities

arrested Smith in October 2023.

Between April 2019 and December 2023, law-enforcement officers caught Fishback with

large quantities of fentanyl on four different occasions. The first incident occurred on April 2,

2019, after a Lexington Police Department officer pulled Fishback over for speeding. As he

approached Fishback’s car, the officer smelled “fresh marijuana” and noticed that Fishback was

“shaking.” Day 1 Trial Tr., R.192, PageID 1981-82. A second officer arrived, and they conducted

a search. Fishback had $826 in cash and a digital scale in his pocket. The officers also found

approximately 18 grams of powder fentanyl, along with varying amounts of marijuana, cocaine,

methamphetamine, and ethylpentylone (also known as “bath salts”).

Thirteen months later, on May 3, 2020, a housekeeper at the Sure Stay Plus hotel in

Lexington, Kentucky, found a “grayish brown” “block” in a pair of jeans while cleaning a room

that Fishback had rented the night before. Id. at PageID 2022. The hotel’s surveillance footage

showed Fishback wearing the same pair of jeans. Hotel management called the police, who

recovered the jeans. Lab testing revealed that the block from the jeans contained 25 grams of

fentanyl.

Police found more fentanyl connected to Fishback on October 11, 2023. Management at

the Stoney Brooke apartment complex in Lexington evicted a tenant for failing to pay rent. The

supposed tenant went by the name of “Blake Faulk.” Day 2 Trial Tr., R.163, PageID 1077. But

Faulk didn’t actually live there. Instead, “somebody got” the apartment for Fishback. Day 3 Trial

Tr., R.164, PageID 1395-96. Fishback and his girlfriend, Tedi Hawkins, lived at the apartment

2 No. 25-5085, United States v. Fishback

with their pets for about a month and a half before the eviction order. No one else had a key to the

apartment during that time. The apartment had personal photographs of Fishback and Hawkins,

as well as mail addressed to both, and they had ordered food to the apartment via DoorDash.

Fayette County constables executed an eviction warrant and cleared the apartment so staff could

begin removing their items. Apartment staff found four guns and about 7,000 fentanyl-laced

pills—weighing 1.6 pounds—in a closet, next to numerous male, adult-sized Nike, Jordan, and

Puma shoes.

Just a few months later, on December 6, 2023, law-enforcement officers executed a search

warrant at the Raintree apartment complex in Lexington. Hawkins’s sister leased the unit, but

Hawkins lived and paid rent there, and Fishback sometimes stayed overnight. Fishback would

also store drugs there. Officers discovered “just under 250 fentanyl pills and carfentanil pills” at

the apartment. Id. at PageID 1548. The fentanyl pills weighed 14.56 grams and the carfentanil

pills weighed 8.82 grams. Carfentanil, which is even more potent than fentanyl, is typically used

as a “veterinary medicine to sedate and potentially euthanize zoo animals, hippopotamus[es],

elephant[s], things of that nature.” Id. at PageID 1564.

That same day, officers arrested Fishback outside a clothing store in Lexington. The

officers searched Fishback’s car and found even more fentanyl-laced pills, totaling 43.05 grams,

as well as carfentanil-laced pills, totaling 22.76 grams.

A federal grand jury charged Fishback with one count of conspiracy to distribute and

possess with the intent to distribute a substance containing 400 grams or more of fentanyl and 10

grams or more of carfentanil. It also charged Fishback with four counts of possessing with the

intent to distribute fentanyl—based on the fentanyl found in Fishback’s car (count two), the Sure

Stay Plus hotel (count three), the Stoney Brooke apartment (count four), and the Raintree

3 No. 25-5085, United States v. Fishback

apartment (count five). Hawkins was charged as Fishback’s co-defendant for all counts except the

ones related to the car and hotel, and she later pled guilty to the conspiracy count and to possessing

with the intent to distribute the Stoney Brooke fentanyl.

While in jail awaiting trial, Fishback talked to Hawkins on a three-way call. Fishback told

Hawkins to withdraw her guilty plea and offered her money. He suggested that, without the plea,

the Government would have a harder time proving the conspiracy. Following Fishback’s direction,

Hawkins moved to withdraw her guilty plea, but the district court denied the motion.

Fishback proceeded to trial. Smith and Hawkins, among others, testified against Fishback

and detailed his drug-distribution activities and connection to both the Stoney Brooke and Raintree

apartments. A jury found Fishback guilty on all five counts. At the sentencing hearing, the district

court applied Sentencing Guidelines enhancements for maintaining a drug premises, possessing a

firearm during a drug offense, and obstruction of justice. The district court ultimately sentenced

Fishback to 480 months’ imprisonment. This appeal followed.

II

Fishback nominally contests all five convictions for lack of sufficient evidence. But he

forfeited any arguments aimed at his convictions based on the fentanyl found during the 2019

traffic stop and the search of the Raintree apartment by failing to develop them in his opening

brief. See United States v. Fox, 134 F.4th 348, 372 (6th Cir. 2025) (per curiam). Fishback instead

focuses his sufficiency-of-the-evidence challenge on (1) the conspiracy conviction, (2) the

conviction based on fentanyl found at the Sure Stay Plus hotel, and (3) the conviction based on

fentanyl found at the Stoney Brooke apartment. Each of his arguments fails.

4 No. 25-5085, United States v. Fishback

A

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Jackson v. Virginia
443 U.S. 307 (Supreme Court, 1979)
United States v. Fekete
535 F.3d 471 (Sixth Circuit, 2008)
United States v. Wheaton
517 F.3d 350 (Sixth Circuit, 2008)
United States v. Allen
619 F.3d 518 (Sixth Circuit, 2010)
United States v. Carlos Johnson
737 F.3d 444 (Sixth Circuit, 2013)
United States v. Salah Dado
759 F.3d 550 (Sixth Circuit, 2014)
United States v. Norman West
962 F.3d 183 (Sixth Circuit, 2020)
United States v. Harry French
976 F.3d 744 (Sixth Circuit, 2020)
United States v. Jaquar Latimer
16 F.4th 222 (Sixth Circuit, 2021)
United States v. Leonel Miller Hinojosa, Jr.
67 F.4th 334 (Sixth Circuit, 2023)
United States v. Michael Terry, Jr.
83 F.4th 1039 (Sixth Circuit, 2023)
United States v. Condarius Deshun Tripplet
112 F.4th 428 (Sixth Circuit, 2024)
United States v. Duane Gary Underwood, II
129 F.4th 912 (Sixth Circuit, 2025)
United States v. Lamonte Brown
131 F.4th 337 (Sixth Circuit, 2025)
United States v. Juan Grogan
133 F.4th 553 (Sixth Circuit, 2025)
United States v. Jesse Fairley
137 F.4th 503 (Sixth Circuit, 2025)
United States v. Freddie Knipp, Jr.
138 F.4th 429 (Sixth Circuit, 2025)
United States v. Marquise Figures
138 F.4th 438 (Sixth Circuit, 2025)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
United States v. Eugene Laron Fishback, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/united-states-v-eugene-laron-fishback-ca6-2026.