United States v. Brooks

389 F. Supp. 3d 619
CourtDistrict Court, E.D. Missouri
DecidedMay 29, 2019
DocketCase No. 4:17-CR-00048-BCW
StatusPublished

This text of 389 F. Supp. 3d 619 (United States v. Brooks) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering District Court, E.D. Missouri primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
United States v. Brooks, 389 F. Supp. 3d 619 (E.D. Mo. 2019).

Opinion

BRIAN C. WIMES, UNITED STATES DISTRICT JUDGE

Before the Court is Magistrate Judge Robert E. Larsen's Report and Recommendations (Doc. #74) concerning Defendant's Motion to Suppress Physical Evidence and Statements. (Doc. #45). Defendant filed objections. (Doc. #77). After an independent review of the record and the applicable law, the Court adopts the Magistrate's Report and Recommendations. Accordingly, it is hereby

ORDERED that the Magistrate's Report and Recommendations (Doc. #74) are adopted and shall be attached to and made part of this Order. It is further

ORDERED Defendant's Motion to Suppress (Doc. #45) is DENIED.

IT IS SO ORDERED.

REPORT AND RECOMMENDATION

ROBERT E. LARSEN, United States Magistrate Judge *622On August 8, 2017, the Grand Jury returned a three-count superseding indictment charging defendant Clarence Brooks with being a felon in possession of a firearm, possessing with intent to distribute five grams or more of methamphetamine, and knowingly carrying and using a firearm during and in relation to a drug trafficking crime. (Doc. 29). Defendant filed a motion to suppress physical evidence and his statements based on the Fourth and Fifth Amendments. (Doc. 45). The motion is fully briefed and ready to rule. (Docs. 45, 47, 52, 55).

Evidence

The evidence includes the Kansas City, Missouri Police Department ("KCPD") dash cam videos of the traffic stop (Doc. 45-1; Gvt. Exh. 1 (5829@2017023201151); Gvt. Exh. 2 (5788@20170203201200)), KCPD investigative reports (Doc. 45-2)1 , and the Joint Set of Stipulated Facts for Suppression Hearing (Doc. 54). The parties offered no witnesses, given the stipulated facts. Upon review, the Court adopts the Joint Set of Stipulated Facts as set forth below, and makes additional fact findings based on the evidence presented by the parties:

1. On February 3, 2017, at approximately 8:15 p.m., in Kansas City, Missouri, KCPD Officers Payne and Solomon were on routine patrol in the area of 18th Street and Prospect Avenue, Kansas City, in the Western District of Missouri. (Docs. 45-2, 54).
2. While on patrol, the license plate reader in the officers' patrol vehicle indicated that they had just passed by a possible stolen vehicle. (Docs. 54, 45-2).
3. The officers performed a U-turn, located the possible stolen vehicle, and confirmed with KCPD dispatch that the vehicle was, in fact, reported stolen; the information regarding the stolen vehicle matched that of the green Honda Civic, license plate number of DK1D4J, the officers were following. (Docs. 54, 45-2).
4. The officers followed the vehicle for several minutes, turned on their patrol vehicle's emergency lights, and pulled over the vehicle near the entrance to the I-70 westbound ramp from Prospect Avenue. (Docs. 54, 45-2).
5. The officers conducted a "felony car check" with their guns drawn and attempted to remove the vehicle's occupants by verbal commands, at times through the use of a public address system ("PA").
6. Review of the audio and video recordings taken form the KCPD vehicle that initiated the stop reveals the following series of events:
8:17:01 p.m. Traffic stop begins.
8:17:10 p.m. (Officer 2) "Alright it's your show."2
8:17:16 p.m. (Officer 1) "Driver let me see your hands. Let me see your hands." (Both individuals in the green Honda appear to put their hands up).
*6238:17:20 p.m. (Officer 1) "Turn the vehicle off. Driver turn the vehicle off."
8:17:37 p.m. (Officer 1) "Driver throw the keys out the windows. Driver throw the keys out the window. Throw the keys out of the window." (Driver does not comply).
8:18:02 p.m. (Officer 3 in a KCPD backup vehicle) "Don't have keys bud."
(Officer 4, possibly a Sergeant in KCPD backup vehicle) "(inaudible) the PA work?"
(Officer 2) "No sir. Maybe it does (inaudible) check."
8:18:07 p.m. (Officer 2) (with PA) "Driver throw the keys out the window slowly."
(Officer 2) (speaking to Officer 1) "Update her" (possibly referring to radio dispatch; Officer 2 then appears to say to the other KCPD officers on the scene) "Let him do it."
8:18:35 p.m. (Officer 2) (speaking to Officer 1) "Alright, they're being cooperative Solomon. Proceed with the commands. Get the driver out first."
8:18:36 p.m. (Officer 1) "Driver, with your left hand, slowly open the door. Driver, slowly open your door." (Driver fails to comply).
8:18:59 p.m. (Officer 2) "Hey Solomon I'm handing you the PA. Take this it is working."
8:19:00 p.m. (Officer 1) (PA) "Driver, slowly open the door."
(Repeated). (Driver fails to comply).
(Passenger starts to get out of the car).
8:19:22 p.m. (Officer 3) "Driver slowly open the door."
8:19:22 p.m. (Officer 1) "Driver open the door."
8:19:25 p.m. (Officer 2) "Let's ditch the PA Solomon. Forget the PA."
8:19:30 p.m. (Officer 3) "Passenger stay in the car. Your hands up. Hands up."
8:19:36 p.m. (Officer 1) "Driver get out."
8:19:36 p.m. (Officer 2) "Keep talking to him Solomon. Keep talking to him."
8:19:38 p.m. (Officer 1) "Get out with your hands up. Driver, driver only, get out with your hands up."
8:19:49 p.m. (Officer 2) "This is a great learning experience, I am not mad at all."
8:19:52 p.m. (Officer 1) "Driver get out of the car with your hands up." (Driver does not comply).
8:19:52 p.m. (Officer 2) "Solomon now you cover me."
8:19:57 p.m. (Officer 2) "Passenger keep your hands in plain view. Step out of the car slowly. Step out. Nice and slow. Close your door. Face away from us. Walk backwards to the sound of my voice. Move, Move, Move, Move. Stop."
8:20:13 p.m. (Officer 2) "Take one step to your right. Move. Drop down to your left knee. Stop. Drop down to your left knee. Prone all the way out onto your stomach."
(Unknown officer on scene) "Hands up driver. Hands up driver." (In response to movement by the driver).
8:20:30 p.m. (Driver closes his door and drives off in the vehicle onto I-70.)
8:20:31 p.m. (Officer 2) "Put your hands behind your head." (Still directing the passenger's motions).
*624"That's fine. We're on him now." (Stated to Officer 1 in response to driver taking off in the vehicle).
8:20:38 p.m.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Terry v. Ohio
392 U.S. 1 (Supreme Court, 1968)
United States v. Robinson
414 U.S. 218 (Supreme Court, 1973)
New York v. Quarles
467 U.S. 649 (Supreme Court, 1984)
Berkemer v. McCarty
468 U.S. 420 (Supreme Court, 1984)
Maryland v. Wilson
519 U.S. 408 (Supreme Court, 1997)
Maryland v. Pringle
540 U.S. 366 (Supreme Court, 2003)
Devenpeck v. Alford
543 U.S. 146 (Supreme Court, 2004)
Brendlin v. California
551 U.S. 249 (Supreme Court, 2007)
Arizona v. Johnson
555 U.S. 323 (Supreme Court, 2009)
United States v. Henderson
613 F.3d 1177 (Eighth Circuit, 2010)
United States v. Webster
625 F.3d 439 (Eighth Circuit, 2010)
United States v. Leonard David Griffin
922 F.2d 1343 (Eighth Circuit, 1990)
Terry D. McIntyre v. Paul Caspari
35 F.3d 338 (Eighth Circuit, 1994)
United States v. Tonnie Franklin Williams
181 F.3d 945 (Eighth Circuit, 1999)
United States v. Lucky C. Brown
217 F.3d 605 (Eighth Circuit, 2000)
United States v. Billy Ray Rowland
341 F.3d 774 (Eighth Circuit, 2003)
United States v. Rey Gama Mendoza
421 F.3d 663 (Eighth Circuit, 2005)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
389 F. Supp. 3d 619, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/united-states-v-brooks-moed-2019.