United States Trust Co. v. Tuchowska

227 N.W. 539, 249 Mich. 16, 1929 Mich. LEXIS 650

• Court: Michigan Supreme Court
• Decided: December 3, 1929
• Docket: Docket No. 39, Calendar No. 34,552.
• Status: Published

Opinion

Fead, J.

This is an action to recover $2,000 loaned to defendant by decedent in her lifetime and for other recovery not of consequence here. Defendant pleaded payment. The trial was before the court without a jury, and plaintiff had judgment for $1,000.

■ Before any testimony was taken, defendant’s former counsel made an opening statement in which he conceded that the loan had been made, and the amount. This concession rendered harmless any error in receiving in evidence a memorandum of the loan, made by decedent, and also obliged the court to deny defendant’s motion for judgment at the close of plaintiff’s case. Defendant’s own testimony as to payment was properly rejected as within the equal knowledge of the deceased. The testimony of defendant’s wife and daughter of payment was received and formed the basis of the credit allowed by the court. The court credited the specific payments to which they testified. He properly rejected their general assertions of payment in full, as not credible under their statements of the circumstances. Defendant cannot complain of the reception of certain inadmissible testimony because no proper objection was made to its introduction. The court properly refused to make findings of fact and law as request therefor was not made until after entry of judgment. Defendant had the burden of proving payment and the verdict was not against the great weight of evidence except, possibly, as intimated by the court in ruling upon the motion for a new trial, in the respect that the allowance of credits to defendant was excessive. No good grounds were shown for a new trial.

Judgment is affirmed, with, costs.

North, C. J., and Butzel, Wiest, Clark, McDonald, Potter, and Sharpe, JJ., concurred.