Trulock v. Friendship Lodge, K. of P.

39 N.W. 654, 75 Iowa 381, 1888 Iowa Sup. LEXIS 353

• Court: Supreme Court of Iowa
• Decided: October 6, 1888
• Status: Published

Opinion

Beck, J.

— A motion to dismiss the appeal was submitted with this case. It is based upon these facts: An appeal was taken in the case by plaintiff after the judgment, and upon failure to perfect the appeal it was affirmed, on motion, at the last December term, and a judgment to that effect was entered in this court, which stands in full force and effect. It is very plain that we must regard this judgment as a final adjudication in this case. But counsel claim that plaintiff withdrew the appeal taken by him, and no appeal was pending when the judgment was affirmed in this court. But, surely, the judgment of this court cannot be assailed in this collateral way. If the judgment was erroneously entered, the plaintiff must pursue another course to correct the error. The alleged withdrawal of the appeal, as we understand the facts, was made by service of a notice upon the defendant to that effect. There was no dismissal of the appeal in this court. As we now remember the case, this court, upon the motion to affirm the judgment, considered the claim of plaintiff that his appeal had been withdrawn, and upon the facts then before us affirmed the judgment.

In our opinion defendant’s motion must be sustained, and the appeal of plaintiff must be

Dismissed.