Travelers Insurance Company v. State D.C.Y.S., No. 704571 (Feb. 4, 1994)

Connecticut Superior Court

Travelers Insurance Company v. State D.C.Y.S., No. 704571 (Feb. 4, 1994)

1994 Conn. Super. Ct. 1226

CourtConnecticut Superior Court

DecidedFebruary 4, 1994

DocketNo. 704571

StatusUnpublished

This text of 1994 Conn. Super. Ct. 1226 (Travelers Insurance Company v. State D.C.Y.S., No. 704571 (Feb. 4, 1994)) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Connecticut Superior Court primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook

Travelers Insurance Company v. State D.C.Y.S., No. 704571 (Feb. 4, 1994), 1994 Conn. Super. Ct. 1226 (Colo. Ct. App. 1994).

Pincite

Opinion

[EDITOR'S NOTE: This case is unpublished as indicated by the issuing court.] MEMORANDUM OF DECISION

RE MOTION TO DISMISS Plaintiff brings this action under C.G.S. 52-412 (b),52-146j, and 17a-28 for production of documents in compliance with a subpoena. Defendant moves to dismiss because disclosure of the documents requested is forbidden by C.G.S. 17a-28 (b).

Facts

Plaintiff issued a subpoena duces tecum dated June 24, 1993 which requires Kathy Stair (Stair) to appear and testify regarding an uninsured motorist claim and "to bring with [her] and produce . . . the following:

"The entire Department of Children and Youth Services file #WR61 pertaining to Sheyla DiSomma, adopted daughter of Renato DiSomma, D.O.B. 09-14-77, including any and all information, correspondence, records, evaluation reports, transcripts of proceedings, offices notes or copies thereof relating to services provided to Sheyla DiSomma by the Department of Children and Youth Services."

Stair is an employee of the defendant Department of Children and Youth Services.

Although the subpoena seeks the "entire . . . file #WR61 pertaining to Sheyla DiSomma" the plaintiff's brief, page 4, states that it "is seeking disclosure of any and all information which documents communications between the [defendant] and Mr. DiSomma. In particular, The Travelers is seeking copies of any documents which indicate that Mr. DiSomma was asked to pay for services rendered to Sheyla DiSomma by the [defendant]."

Law

The superior court has jurisdiction to enforce subpoenas. C.G.S. 52-412 (b). However, it has no power to CT Page 1228 order the disclosure sought here because the "records maintained by the department shall be confidential and shall not be disclosed." C.G.S. 17a-28 (b). There are exceptions in that statute but none is applicable here.

Jurisdiction of the subject matter is the power to hear and determine cases of the general class to which the proceedings in question belong (citations and quotation marks omitted). Case v. Bush, 93 Conn. 550, 552. To determine is ". . . to decide by authoritative or judicial sentence; as the court has determined the cause." Webster's International Dictionary, Second Edition. This court may not issue an order in contravention of C.G.S.17a-28 (b) and without that power it has no jurisdiction.

Motion to dismiss is granted.

N. O'Neill, J.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

[EDITOR'S NOTE: This case is unpublished as indicated by the issuing court.] MEMORANDUM OF DECISION

RE MOTION TO DISMISS Plaintiff brings this action under C.G.S. 52-412 (b),52-146j, and 17a-28 for production of documents in compliance with a subpoena. Defendant moves to dismiss because disclosure of the documents requested is forbidden by C.G.S. 17a-28 (b).

Facts

Plaintiff issued a subpoena duces tecum dated June 24, 1993 which requires Kathy Stair (Stair) to appear and testify regarding an uninsured motorist claim and "to bring with [her] and produce . . . the following:

"The entire Department of Children and Youth Services file #WR61 pertaining to Sheyla DiSomma, adopted daughter of Renato DiSomma, D.O.B. 09-14-77, including any and all information, correspondence, records, evaluation reports, transcripts of proceedings, offices notes or copies thereof relating to services provided to Sheyla DiSomma by the Department of Children and Youth Services."

Stair is an employee of the defendant Department of Children and Youth Services.

Although the subpoena seeks the "entire . . . file #WR61 pertaining to Sheyla DiSomma" the plaintiff's brief, page 4, states that it "is seeking disclosure of any and all information which documents communications between the [defendant] and Mr. DiSomma. In particular, The Travelers is seeking copies of any documents which indicate that Mr. DiSomma was asked to pay for services rendered to Sheyla DiSomma by the [defendant]."

Law

The superior court has jurisdiction to enforce subpoenas. C.G.S. 52-412 (b). However, it has no power to CT Page 1228 order the disclosure sought here because the "records maintained by the department shall be confidential and shall not be disclosed." C.G.S. 17a-28 (b). There are exceptions in that statute but none is applicable here.

Jurisdiction of the subject matter is the power to hear and determine cases of the general class to which the proceedings in question belong (citations and quotation marks omitted). Case v. Bush, 93 Conn. 550, 552. To determine is ". . . to decide by authoritative or judicial sentence; as the court has determined the cause." Webster's International Dictionary, Second Edition. This court may not issue an order in contravention of C.G.S.17a-28 (b) and without that power it has no jurisdiction.

Motion to dismiss is granted.

N. O'Neill, J.

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)

1994 Conn. Super. Ct. 1226, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/travelers-insurance-company-v-state-dcys-no-704571-feb-4-1994-connsuperct-1994.

Opinion

N. O'Neill, J.

Related

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack