Tobacco Growers Co-Operative Ass'n v. Spikes

121 S.E. 636, 187 N.C. 367, 1924 N.C. LEXIS 285

• Court: Supreme Court of North Carolina
• Decided: March 5, 1924
• Status: Published

Opinion

Hoke, J.

On the hearing there were facts in evidence 'on part of plaintiff tending to show that plaintiff is an association duly organized under chapter 87, Laws of 1921; that defendant had become a member and signed the standard form of contract by which he was obligated to sell and deliver to plaintiff all tobacco grown by him or acquired as landlord during the years 1922, 23, 24, 25, 26, and that in breach of bis agreement be bad sold bis tobacco crop for 1923 to others. Defendant denied bis membership and disavowed any and all obligation to deliver.

The Court has held that the act under which plaintiff is organized is constitutional, that the standard form of contract signed by its members is valid and enforceable by specific performance, and that ordinarily an injunction lies when it appears to be reasonably necessary to protect and conserve plaintiff’s rights under the contract. Coőp. Assn. v. Jones, 185 N. C., 265; Tobacco Assn. v. Battle, ante, 260, and Tobacco Assn. v. Patterson, ante, 252.

In the present case it appears that the questions at issue depend largely on defendant’s membership, and three witnesses for plaintiff having sworn he waá a member, and for defendant the fact he denied only by his own affidavit, there being no claim or evidence ultra, the case comes directly under Tobacco Assn. v. Battle, supra, and the restraining order should be continued to the hearing.

Reversed.