Tillman v. Bowman

27 N.W. 377, 68 Iowa 450

• Court: Supreme Court of Iowa
• Decided: March 20, 1886
• Status: Published

Opinion

Adams, On. J.

The petition showed that the certificate of deposit was executed by a banking firm which was at that time doing business in Mississippi, and was composed of one John A. Kline and one George M. Kline; that John A. Kline had died, and the defendant Bowman had been appointed administrator upon his estate in Iowa. The defendant demurred upon the ground that the district court in which the action was brought had no jurisdiction, for the reason that by statute the jurisdiction to adjudicate upon claims against an estate like the one in question .had been conferred upon the circuit court, and had been made exclusive. The defendant relies upon section 2312 of the Code, which provides that “the circuit court of each county shall have original and exclusive jurisdiction * * * of the settlement of estates of deceased persons.” The question presented is as to whether the mere adjudication of a claim against an estate is to be deemed a part of the settlement of the estate. In the opinion of the majority it is. The writer of this opinion thinks that it has been virtually settled adversely to this view in McCrary v. Deming, 38 Iowa, 531, and Crane v. Guthrie, 47 Iowa, 544; but, the majority thinking otherwise, the ruling of the court in- sustaining the demurrer must be '

Affirmed.