Thompson, James

• Court: Texas Supreme Court
• Decided: November 18, 2015
• Docket: PD-1244-15
• Status: Published

Opinion

A/h: 'VO IJL-MM* I ^ 15 • « *m+ RECEIVED IN COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS NOV 18 2015 ORIGINAL jry r//£ cower of ^^^

J/l/7£5 7>W/y/?5JA' courtof raS APPEALS OF CRIMINAL

Abel Acosta, Clerk

a/V/?f/£Al /7?d/V r#£ /3rx &Z&XZCT

Or/LC /zra&svcadJOS /?eAu&s/&d rAAl£ 0/z Cd/VJT&A/rs

-Z'sie/tx <*/7/Zttdhrt&es -^ - ///

St

-i^r *OaZ/v, &kz y-ccZtsn* ar<2^/>teZ/9er 2$7&r are-/Dre^e,^a£sz**s Z&2&- &£oC&a/JZiZZty . Stfo/^ S/&L CS les&idte Zo /6c*iZi /4fe /?&s>sl1ter JZ&ejls/s#e. <£&/z*sif jo&ytzcz /%l~ arortct^&es- zt\de. Z%c ^zz^^^/^ess^t^a/j/^sa a/a&s Z^s rejcv&^tyz /\e&&iner Jets7a dertce*//$&. r6#s4f& t^Tt/roTzZ*s&5 O-dUtJteS' ?/Ocel Aer ^Zsvertq i/if/vie-nc^- Hie Jt*Tors ? ^ <^ <^ /ceAScmyZr •dLw.., Afyune/frs A/fD/?/ir//z>tf£7zr££ 3 ~>&cer/)6t (yrjune/iter /cee/t6eo>*», JZ~/z orc/er j£'yO/n&ses&e- esr&€>Cesn0er /j 2£/3* Vopcode Z/Z& te/ls/s/^caPTci/szr^^&h?

/^ar?j^r/&i/c£^0„ A/tyu/>?£fi/TS /fa//) Aur/fj/2_Z7z:££ 7 &MCsOUir£/»z as*//styes. a, /O

* i Z°cusUdn/ ?£> /tx./?./fa>-/? 38.0}(&) /At siawc a/jJaMnBSS^^&e&es/caZs&rfe aJ^pft&uZedJdew Z%ere&/c&i /& r&ud/new a^enct e/e/er/voia cj/&2Aer /Tve? am.

/y^e^a^///&/^c^t/i Oa/VSS //^07noSey/V

/re'*/ Zx%t/&e/y£s A^etftmZ-' /V^J^C S/a//ey V26 S. 7a/?c

S'VS'/V, /fo/)tf &raa*e?s Scute //9 C^/yous olf/s£y /x. /Sfr/

/rZaJZ^zc^se/ySr S/x£ '

A/ite-cxs ZO&uni* AA. Z^6z<^ fy/sieyoast/S/1.

Src/?Aer> /J. /ZyS'/je. MM ZUte/tcJA*** f£j -*£ &> Z^rotoJ. CArafAj /$*«* ?e&/ 4//?e*z/yr -*5/i£. "/Vtrk J$Aus/Zkt /Orl /Vu-ecej Z^Z£*>Zj /2A. /L&s^

zWjus z$as£ /* 7tffy/

(I JT/?c/ex^/^/^a^^/z/^s GzU/z/D y3/xr£t 398 z>oj 3d.J2.2o, 22g rsxAsc&w.A*. 2z>;3 n< /3&-T/ZA/V rj£Ar£t 02$ jS£J,Zd382,3X1 7v< Cr6»/fc> zfs? a /3U/tJCE \zJ>rAr£, 37/ S» 2d 2S2 rucAopU// /r\ / Jj CA/WEIL vfacxs /MS. a. U2z> , v 7 g

(jMcr/2 vS/Ar£ W2S02J $gt 92, /ex6>/*,yfo /9?z> j^ Ao*cJumv-jgmZCtfA/vt3£/& 8JS-£ti2j23%2*oAx6A„Ay/W^ . iS /CTAftVjr/trB fssszjjiJjUimtt /i*6,«,fy>/99?, k . , . . J0 /nZLte \rjrA//E 9/8SZJ2JSJJ; S-Z2 r^c Zss„ zfa /99Z , . ? /tort/tod rJrtrz BZ/siJjZjgz/.Bz^r^/^/^^/^/^rj/^^ ' > rtoMjzrswe s^^3d%9/y7/r^4^r&MXMJi^^r

/*&*** ^j^ar szj3«!m w a*,**,, /fa. 2*3 /* fAoua v£r/?rs /7s-sv3J*/933 , ' /*

SAmdmW. vSmrs */z>,sz/3JZ7 SUU'g*r /ex. Z>/^A^ /99r _ ' 7 ti£A/£* V^mm^ ^S-atis 2%3/J/^/£U9^j7a/^^^/?09^) , . . 9 7&XAS Srz?7^7Z££ F£X/ls comz^oir/vjrA/ALMcpc/zjoazBeCric.c.P.) S//?r/.<22 (20/9) , . 9 A*r/,/y(ji)z (2*/v^ V."S s?/?rj8'.072C2j;j),. . ,3'$ /?/2r32,30i2 U) 20/3,. . . 3.2,1 7~£X4S /2Ul£S 0£A/r°£/2AZ2z /Wdz££a/2£ C/:/?,A/>') /2//LE f,c/^ . // /?///£ 3f.0fC*) , . . // /2^z/r W.2J. . . . 3 /ZUL£ te> 3tt) , . . , 8 /2Ml£ 9* / /

in /?/2/^/

ST///7/£ z^ztfrztf C/trzvjr/Z/ti /ffl&us Z)£ T£X45

ua/wes //?

V.

7%e~S/*/e22ee.

ys, ,y srocvj (josr/t^ rr?c*™a5c>^ s^et/O^Zr£rt 6V*t2*6to2/e.^fZfZe.&Z&s?c/

JO. 5AiZes?ert//&aasi/*nj Z/r*//&*/ ayuroenr-ts i^a^OU^ecaase,Oe. Caus*yjbea& f>6A*™^Q/s & C07)$uzer a/76SSues /St*/ ^e/e^&*z/&/ZJe*?ce. stec&s^ari? if Z&L

^C&ZesWesi/ &/"zfde. S*zs&

Z$e

a/t/iJeavp, c^tM*. cA/&/> 6Jerk/ /Ql^a/^ ^-//

/. r/z C/e/k's/&*<,/

U//2. S/a/es?&/7/A/A&.Zks

///£ SAzZe. €/}Aa/>oeA'Z7?/, /Atny&Scm*; 3vA<2r/n&i/6//A% A£>^re^ce/us -^A^ cUs^^z/eAze^ 7^" a^e/^0%/aaari!U/a&^Se>cazAassauA^ OzAecesicy&&&£ a. dAt/& a#Aadfc&je- &/ZzZe3&A^yor<>&zb&'an

-Ad< /A£y&£r& Ave* Cozz/iZs &zes& &zA

AeAmya&zrv/er. /XeLJiMj/£uAA/V/.7Af<&?2c&e7?n jueAA/or? aA//*z*v ouzatAsa/i2 Z%: zAiAAca^/A tLSSe&easiecoZ^A/vertAaAZ&e <»> e&cAyz%zZ£ur/ty/H, <&»eA A&U/ fre/& f&rf ZWdw/Qnlty. AA* /^/^reArctuAA&iur^Aa a6cc*/re

Z/2e SAcAlnrai/catyo Aioo&AA3?/; 7A&&2&773 vorter Ci^^AAi&ns 6MuAA>er£~Sex&&A&nzs?7£f ez^atavA

zAuA//W2. /c&>0rZeAs Ae^sA; lA/A,/?* Z^'/3 . AAe SfcAe.^r.&'eeAtfO/&&*'& c

*AAr„,/s>,,rccA^A. A^Zr. /A*?TK2S*?7J>s)r*Ar Ac«sA&AZS; /Az cALaArja

/Az. deize, sOS&A &mi//d&nsy /iAau/Ar-zA^A&- 3d, j2zf/3 Ate, Ar&/COlz/tfAeartZAftt s>fc/eAn Az Z&rvAze tAu/tsM a Jre/AteAAeon** Az zJ>Ac/A /fa. ZrzsA

Coze//'rz&trtAArq«sr)<2>vAsjA*r*> A>e>Z%^AAes ar>Ajc^Z^7S. /?,/?. ti/3,*,. S-3Z>, r7L r^eA^<^**dcAA3 cMy/*6*S*z&/3A>*/^zS^Aj^ AjpecAs. 5/a^^jr^A^

Or) 0*/yA-A//»e /?e///z^/£ A?Kcr&Zw*p//&*^ <*S 'Si/I* 2. jrfe As?b/%cs Aec#/h/<&' /2ere*A%' ^/^A>fy/4as /c/c. 2*f JJ- ATssu£ /°/2£3£zVsr£/3

CZ/C /Ae, z^ToZAer Szier/^ZzAzAe. a/^ncA^zAer z£Ae^ cA&> aZz/z-A, Zt/cAztess Zizizz aA-Sz> es /Azs r&SuAzzzi A^AAAextz&zA Ce&^rimA z&3 zlccms&t f/3cc/zies L&Slfczvcny Az/besi*&. /j&e-Xu.rors ? zfzSAJ^zAA^zf ££lzm/UA s4A<$azy£zvr/W£/4/z?/k/erzzE3

Ate. Z^ezZz&sA?* Cztzc/^'/>zzzsA/Azls * ZcZAsAl AA^^rAtA* zZ<$Azcrciz)ce. AdAzAe. erraz~ ci/LA/2&A&?//&. Afc.A>3 W.Aa)fA?*/zzA> irS/£z£> ?S5,zjz,3zz5 c^Se., AcresaSA/y zuz&s s2*A<^^Ah?z^f?£r^* & ZtZziw J.J, sVzuAe ziz? aztAcry^^zZexcuaAticA^ej 2/At 77Z.C.A, Ar/. 3%.0?2> /Az Aezrc** AeAAyZi/L/d ^Az^r^u/?e Z%e "ZZ^^ Aeld^a^ A*?c& Sense. SZ&A: ztziA'/Oe/e/Jte arxzisveziZJjZlzzis Aoresea&A. A&jAzryte>rz£s2cA& /Ac /A^ZAazzrZ1se/£s /cA^A zizAzAzAcVOd; c^Az~>4zAcA*Z*z*Ss&Zj ZAcuAd. d zfzAAs sVeZztfe/j AAzJAzaz>/2e SAreeA, 6jA&>i ^Aey2*2zzuAJ.J. trtzArtAAe £Zr*A<&c&A£. ca zidAz azLzA/A^ ziA^e., A&s a^zztrs&AorcAr to *A>Zz/ J.J> ztncAAArTZ^zzTer^zyy AdzzfcAzA zUe Aa>z*se~ ar>esz&p7 Z^^zA^p sAe sv&&#A ziL tftzAcsy See. Z&A*. iz^Z'3yo AAer~&m tc& cjJ)*m Me *u&s 6sZ*/&9ertA..A ceA*y Zj^zzZa vS/*A. 9/2 SzuZ2A %% $2 (/ex ZsJrt/ito. /490)> /&A>c*>a en Zfazcia. Abe ZWzZ'A&AyeScAs *1ttScZK

Z%i Z^/Z'*/AL AZne ztfe /Lzt** z^^z^Je^ Ozk/ z^azcA/^Az^ZA$L Z^rA zA^AcA^^: fv^tar A A?e Sc

3*//2-%:L Acda ce-sA/yt/ra AAzs rcoorc /\Z/iuA gAiA&c/zAcA JosAua. e**zs ^zz^A^se^Az(y Aeres^ J.J/''£ a/c^A/vo/Aer^ices/c^^/ten (/c?A?yi?/&/%s 9/-#2 )- yfs?AAy<&*z ZtsA^^/y(/££Vo/S' fa */Sj '$! Ajur AesAZ/»eMy zs AA<*A/Z/tsAca/ysiej zfAe. /*2«/%er} As A^e^/zAsAperserZ; A*secA cViyzu/ /th^zezAe.; AA*/ JasAtc*. ZoAeZ's * 2) S/Aus A/cAz2esS A^AuActzc Z^AAxe/f/&zWaSsAcAA "~2? rzx>/£Zv AZrzsAc&p/je 3/re^z.SAe 6/ZeAZst'A Z^AoAztZaS Zk?&*4 OZZ', zAtS AzAAarJe c€i??2ZAAZi AzSZ> z/zzAitcAzAats ee/AAertcz, '(/c/3A>AS~A>j /Z/a^xA Sex. aAo AA*n>'*/yAz?2) Aja^t Ay cAc sA*A: fAzZw/S/y /z>r) 3) /AeSAA, iu /Vs° Jesxsest; aZSe &>neZecze~ &za(AaZzt z

H) SAA ZAAziet&j Sesje^/ZreJ*, sAtAAzsAe* **J^:(fiz€lA/3/^/79) Ay A&JesyJesi, "$'> A/iA Anseu/an /Ac 6/tizesA<2jiAZ&7iyyt>us Zk/Ao cAz*zec/: A. » Ae zwertActtneA-As'j/ A AAe-r^Zzler,

3") A)uzcha Cross exasnAztsAZw Zzze, AhAn-se- z&cseAzA«l Zzie&st} AAoAzAere Ze/as a. z^^c&A&A eAAozA At aoAJsz& cnA&y zu/Aaess'Aez*u*s£ AzcsAc/**,)* SA&eAA**Az*sz*<2s Cz30n>/6/z>j/8V ty.'Soyt%« /Z/iu«J -/Zrtz/caji/ic &/rc

$: ZlCzJj Zt/dS/lA/ten*. ZL ZZ&icerZed'&A£rZAn cAe/Oa'A^A^zAe Z^ZUU Ajpo&Av&nAZ& /zuJZ ij/o Ate. 0icA*y Zc/cAs)&££ zJasAAAe zz? zz£* z&se ; /f:J£&zAy<&t ZtzA* tAetZtzs, Ae/^/sA --AAc ezLAA/ZrzZ'AA/y£j - zAz*z^iSrits /r2e?ZZ?er azTtZ'/Aen Ae. Z*Z

6)SAzAls Zl/AziesS; /feres&SAzeeA, &&/£y>ezA/^ACzAL/'/ArAAe*v?/>e SAreeA A*AZzVcr>? OlcAsczAe. ziz>AZzT&p Z*/ez& aaz2e. 2E access r*?*tyAe. Azr? rrd&zioUs *.+ . 9) Alt /fAtS ZaAjcxxAAzAe. /SatrAAeAA/Ae. Aezir^a Ze> zAe/erz>uZ>e zlzA ALyD/^oer &uAcru ZtsJtsieSS &/is C/2/2A>/Sz)j AJTS, 2r2zuA AAs StM*; z%zn z^as zz^A ZUzAAcstczl AejAZrc zA^Aznz/A £ 6^es/AA^AAAzcsAaz.neA3AreeA^zis zA/&A'z^^yZsA £zzAAez?c£ AA«AAzjrcsAc^e ^A/eeA^^^res^A^A^, z^cM zAe zzLA/aAA^y^A/vsAi ZJAes> AL <&mpAurtt>nAcA>scrA>eJAA£ JZXu^A&A^ c/z ,.+,-> ./.. . > ^s , „ , / ~z-./ , ~.

ArA3U72i2a)(A. /Ac JA*A«A *s yz^A^zyy «~/JjL 7z^ zi*«A/2.t ora^oA, /%c Aus yztrreAAS, czk^AzA*^ ^ <^^ alztsc^#£szre2Zn JoacAzzv ty zA*/»Ae/l WSSZcZ^A^%2*a (AveZ//*sfoZ99/) '™eJ^/*y&r^A*s

AZsA/^sy "en tSuz/z Zs A^ZctAA) ct "z><>A^/z ^AkcA^raA^^g^yyr,*^ r^^zA^zA^ yDfigzsesA es/J&sA^ ar^orc^zz/y £<&>?ty£cA, Jl A^bon? VA/^A. AZ?SZZ3d ¥/% ??/ CTEx. zfy>. Te**diu». -2^/wWS/J yfr? ztc^zzs^cr z^A* y»6c yAuA&f)erSzv2 z^zv^j ^ A*/**"*!* ^^2^^ce At>e*/2oA. AZrzsA^zic JAreeA'asAie^AAz/y>ersc^ zv uAaw /%*, zAAAzr^A. a, ^AaA/herz/^^Aas a.yoerJ^/7 z^Ar??^A &. zja*sA/6 CZZ°2) zs zZ Zc/cAr?eS£ czazusx*/A/e /AyAssxAzrzA. /Ae. £/*£%'Azv<2*>AzneziA^AAte. ZAvALA^AAz Z^AAuA^^r^*dzs "zs? ZAy&s/??rpt tzA^A/Ae ei>vZ3 f2/?A,d/?Z?A,/Z^> 9-/0. /Ac e/zc^Cue^AAus c*t?jA/AuAA'cA^A^^aAA AeztrJay. A/L yezA'/>Ztts/'AAer?Ae. cemszAteA'z£AdeAerrrzz^e cA^A/Ae A&&^ ^A Aezz6&S/reeAzy^A^^ce.Z%e. jur*y*: A^/sAa^y/A^er/p^Aa f'y^ye*sA^'Sz^ze>J zmAAise?*z./>/?ey. ^ ^ zAAr^yA'' Aaczzzha A> de> AAaA/lzld'zAey?cSe.g^zA'zj £ZyZicA&z*A'z^eA&zyrsPvA^c^eA^ AaS Z&MZ>ey>e^A Aa zAe- ZjAtAA''Aeries'*. SArzeAAyAzi*zA ? ^ ~^ 7ASA /yasrjy?Afy/ez>w