Testamentary Trust Estate of Klauder

22 Pa. D. & C.4th 100, 1994 Pa. Dist. & Cnty. Dec. LEXIS 96
CourtPennsylvania Court of Common Pleas, Montgomery County
DecidedDecember 2, 1994
Docketno. 26014
StatusPublished

This text of 22 Pa. D. & C.4th 100 (Testamentary Trust Estate of Klauder) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Pennsylvania Court of Common Pleas, Montgomery County primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Testamentary Trust Estate of Klauder, 22 Pa. D. & C.4th 100, 1994 Pa. Dist. & Cnty. Dec. LEXIS 96 (Pa. Super. Ct. 1994).

Opinion

TAXIS, S.J.,

The fifth and final account of Mellon Bank, N.A., corporate trustee, for the testamentary trust estate created under the will of C.W. Klauder, deceased, sur trust for the benefit of his wife, Jane E. Klauder et al., was examined and audited by this court on July 5, 1994, and re-examined on December 2, 1994.

By Item no. 7 of his will, the testator directed his surviving trustees to terminate this trust 20 years after the decease of the last living child of his. Mary M. K. Jones, the testator’s last living child, died on November 2, 1973. The trust terminated on November 2, 1993.

The fifth and final account has been filed to recognize the trust’s termination and to seek court approval to distribute nine-tenths of the trust principal on a per capita basis to the heirs and descendants of C.W. Klauder and one-twentieth of the trust principal to each of the Protestant Episcopal Dioceses of Pennsylvania and Arkansas to be used to erect small churches in poor parishes in each Diocese. Objections and supplemental objections to the accountant’s proposed per capita distribution of nine-tenths of the trust principal have been filed.

The present accountant received the funds now before this court for audit per adjudication of this court confirmed nisi on November 30, 1983 and per the court approved amended schedule of distribution filed thereto.

The fifth and final account is stated from September 3, 1986 to January 14, 1994. The accountant reports [102]*102gross receipts of $227,143.17, of which $239,660.21 remains on hand. The net balance of assets on hand consists of treasury bills (which became due in February of 1994) and cash as set forth on pages 8 and 27 of the fifth and final account. The principal assets are subject to the payment of ($8,078.34) in fiduciary fees due to Mellon Bank, N.A., as well as the payment of ($21,298.05) to Mellon Bank, N.A., the latter of which is to be charged against William A. K. Jones’ share and the payment of which will reimburse Mellon Bank, N.A., per a family agreement executed on June 20, 1986. See page 8 of the fifth and final account.

The accountant reports that the principal assets may be subject to the payment of legal expenses incurred by Mellon Bank, N.A., as corporate trustee, to defend itself in the federal suit captioned, Simpson v. Mellon Bank, N.A., no. 93-2054, which suit was filed in the United States District Court for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania.

Justin Benedict filed separate objections with this court on July 1, 1994, objecting to the payment of Mellon Bank, N.A.’s legal fees and expenses incurred in the above-captioned federal suit. The court expresses no view sur this issue at this time.

As of June 14, 1994, the principal balance on hand (which includes the payment of $8,078.34 to the accountant) was revalued at $236,605.61, as was the income balance on hand at $3,206.50.

The trust before this court for audit is not subject to the payment of Pennsylvania transfer inheritance tax as the trust was created prior to the institution of this tax.

All parties having or claiming any interest in this testamentary trust, of whom the accountant has notice [103]*103or knowledge, are stated to have received written notice of this audit, in conformity with the rules of court.

All said parties in interest are living, of age, and sui juris except for certain descendants of C.W. Klauder who are either deceased or minors and whose names are listed in paragraph five of the petition for adjudication. The.court waives the appointment of a guardian ad litem to represent the interests of all descendants who are minors. The court is satisfied that their interests are adequately represented by adult, sui juris parties in interest, making the appointment of a guardian ad litem unnecessary in accordance with the provisions of 20 Pa.C.S. §§3504, 7183(2).

The Office of Attorney General, on behalf of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, as parens patriae for charities, issued a charitable gift clearance certificate dated September 28, 1994.

C.W. Klauder executed his last will and testament on November 12, 1895. He amended his will by codicil thereto dated January 26, 1903. At the time of execution, he was the husband of Jane E. Klauder, and the father of five children — George C. Klauder, Mary M. Klauder (later Jones), Emma Klauder (later Barnes), Jeannette Klauder (later Spencer), and Estelle Klauder (later Trites).

The dispositive will provisions made C.W. Klauder’s wife and his children the immediate objects of his bounty upon his untimely death on March 3, 1905.

By his will, Klauder’s estate assets (with the exception of his outright personalty bequests to his wife, Jane E. Klauder, under Item no. 2) passed to his designated trustees or to the survivors thereof, to hold, in trust. The testator directed that trust income, not trust principal, was payable during the trust’s existence.

[104]*104A $2,000 annual annuity was payable from the trust income, in quarterly installments of $500, to the testator’s wife, Jane E. Klauder, until the earlier of her death or remarriage. (Item no. 3.) The balance of the trust income was divided into three parts, one-third of which was payable to the testator’s wife until the earlier of her death or remarriage, and the remaining two-thirds of which was to be divided “share and share alike,” or on a per capita basis, among the testator’s children. (Item no. 4.) The testator provided that should any child of his die before his wife and leave a child or children surviving, said surviving child or children was entitled to receive his or her parent’s share of the trust income between them “share and share alike.” (Item no. 5.) Items nos. 4 and 5 read together provide for a per capita distribution of trust income among beneficiaries of the same degree of kinship and for a per stirpital distribution among beneficiaries of unequal degrees of kinship.

Upon the death of Jane E. Klauder on November 5, 1927, the trustees were to pay all of the trust income to the testator’s children “share and share alike” with the share payable to a deceased child of the testator to be paid to his or her surviving child or children between them “share and share alike.” (Item no. 6.) Again, the testator directed distribution of trust income among beneficiaries of the same degree of kinship on a per capita basis and for distribution among beneficiaries of unequal degrees of kinship on a per stirpital basis.

William A. K. Jones (by his agent, First American Bank, N.A.), Sarah A. Bolgiano, Jeanne S. Richardson, and Thomas K. Spencer (the surviving grandchildren of the testator), and Justin Benedict and William I. Simpson Jr. (two of the testator’s great-grandchildren) [105]*105are the current income beneficiaries. See pages 22-26 of the fifth and final account for the fractional distributions of income among them by right of representation — that is — per stirpes.

The trustees were to hold the trust principal for the respective lives of the testator’s children and, in accordance with the Rule Against Perpetuities, for another 20 years after the death the survivor of the testator’s children. As stated, Mary M. K. Jones, the decedent’s last surviving child, died on November 2, 1973, and the trust terminated 20 years thereafter, on November 2, 1993.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Burleigh Estate
175 A.2d 838 (Supreme Court of Pennsylvania, 1961)
Hamilton Estate
312 A.2d 373 (Supreme Court of Pennsylvania, 1973)
Wanamaker Estate
159 A.2d 201 (Supreme Court of Pennsylvania, 1960)
Mayhew's Estate
160 A. 724 (Supreme Court of Pennsylvania, 1931)
Baskin's Appeal
45 Am. Dec. 641 (Supreme Court of Pennsylvania, 1846)
Hoch's Estate
26 A. 610 (Supreme Court of Pennsylvania, 1893)
Glenn v. Stewart
108 A. 599 (Supreme Court of Pennsylvania, 1919)
Grimm Estate
275 A.2d 349 (Supreme Court of Pennsylvania, 1971)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
22 Pa. D. & C.4th 100, 1994 Pa. Dist. & Cnty. Dec. LEXIS 96, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/testamentary-trust-estate-of-klauder-pactcomplmontgo-1994.