Tatum v. Ridgeway Properties

348 So. 2d 1323, 1977 La. App. LEXIS 5141
CourtLouisiana Court of Appeal
DecidedAugust 9, 1977
Docket6084
StatusPublished
Cited by5 cases

This text of 348 So. 2d 1323 (Tatum v. Ridgeway Properties) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Louisiana Court of Appeal primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Tatum v. Ridgeway Properties, 348 So. 2d 1323, 1977 La. App. LEXIS 5141 (La. Ct. App. 1977).

Opinion

348 So.2d 1323 (1977)

Thelma TATUM, Plaintiff-Appellant,
v.
RIDGEWAY PROPERTIES et al., Defendants-Appellees.

No. 6084.

Court of Appeal of Louisiana, Third Circuit.

August 9, 1977.

Kenneth N. Simmons, of Davis & Simmons, Many, for plaintiff-appellant.

Lunn, Irion, Switzer, Johnson & Salley, by Harry A. Johnson, Jr., Hugh M. Stephens, Shreveport, for defendants-appellees.

Watson, Murchison, Crews & Arthur, by William P. Crews, Jr., Natchitoches, for exception-appellee.

Before HOOD, DOMENGEAUX and WATSON, JJ.

HOOD, Judge.

Plaintiffs, Dean I. Dauley and I. Boyd Ridgeway, instituted this suit against Mrs.

*1324 Thelma Tatum, seeking to annul a default judgment which Mrs. Tatum previously obtained against them. Judgment was rendered by the trial court in favor of plaintiffs, annulling and setting aside the default decree. Defendant, Mrs. Tatum, appealed. We affirm.

Plaintiffs contend that valid service of process was not made on them in the suit originally filed by Mrs. Tatum, that the trial court did not obtain jurisdiction over them, and that the default judgment rendered in that suit thus is null and void.

The issue presented is whether, in the earlier suit filed by Mrs. Tatum, service of process was made on Dauley and Ridgeway pursuant to the provisions of the Louisiana Long Arm Statute (LSA-R.S. 13:3201, et seq.).

LSA-R.S. 13:3204 and 3205, being parts of the Long Arm Statute which are applicable here, provide:

"§ 3204. Service of Process. A certified copy of the citation and of the petition in a suit under R.S. 13:3201 shall be sent by counsel for the plaintiff to the defendant by registered or certified mail, or actually delivered to the defendant by an individual designated by the court in which the suit is filed, or by one authorized by the law of the place where the service is made to serve the process of any of its courts of general jurisdiction.
"Service of process so made has the same legal force and validity as personal service on the defendant in this state." (Emphasis added).
"§ 3205. Default judgment; proof of service of process. No default judgment can be rendered against the defendant until thirty days after the filing in the record of the affidavit of the individual who either:
"(a) mailed the process to the defendant, showing that it was enclosed in an envelope properly addressed to the defendant, with sufficient postage affixed, and the date it was deposited in the United States mails, to which shall be attached the return receipt of the defendant; or
"(b) actually delivered the process to the defendant, showing the date, place, and manner of delivery." (Emphasis added).

Mrs. Tatum filed suit in January, 1976, seeking damages for personal injuries sustained by her when she slipped and fell on business premises being operated under the name of "Globe Discount City," in Shreveport. She alleges that the owner-lessor of those premises was "Ridgeway Properties," that Walgreen Company was the lessee, and that Travelers Insurance Company was the insurer of Walgreen. She instituted suit against Ridgeway Properties, Walgreen and Travelers. In her petition she described defendant, Ridgeway Properties, as follows:

"RIDGEWAY PROPERTIES, a foreign corporation domiciled in the State of Texas, with present mailing address of 812 East Marshall Street, Longview, Texas, 75601, said corporation doing business in the State of Louisiana;"

Actually, "Ridgeway Properties" is not a corporation. It is simply a trade name used by I. Boyd Ridgeway for some business enterprises in Texas. There is no corporate, partnership or legal entity of any kind known as Ridgeway Properties, and Mr. Ridgeway did not use that trade name in any of his business activities in Louisiana.

The property located in Shreveport, on which the accident occurred, was owned individually, and in indivision, by plaintiffs Dauley and Ridgeway. Dauley had no interest in any of the business enterprises operated by Ridgeway in which he used the trade name "Ridgeway Properties," and that trade name was not used in connection with the ownership or leasing of the Louisiana property.

Dauley and Ridgeway are both residents of the State of Texas. Mrs. Tatum is a resident of Sabine Parish, Louisiana. The damage suit which Mrs. Tatum instituted was filed in the Eleventh Judicial District Court, for Sabine Parish, Louisiana, and service of process of the original petition was made on defendant, "Ridgeway Properties," by sending a certified copy of the *1325 citation and of the petition by certified mail to "Ridgeway Properties, 812 East Marshall Street, Longview, Texas, 75601." A return receipt, showing delivery of the envelope containing those documents to the addressee, was signed in behalf of Ridgeway Properties by "John Jackson."

The address of Ridgeway Properties, as shown in Mrs. Tatum's petition, is the mailing address of the office of Mr. and Mrs. John Jackson. As an accommodation to Ridgeway, Mr. and Mrs. Jackson permitted him to use their mailing address for business purposes. When mail was delivered to their office, addressed to Ridgeway or to Ridgeway Properties, Mr. or Mrs. Jackson would see that it was delivered to Mr. Ridgeway. Consistent with that understanding or practice, the envelope which contained a certified copy of the citation and of the original petition in the Tatum suit was delivered to Mr. Ridgeway. The latter thereupon showed those documents to Dauley, or told him about them, since both of them jointly owned the Louisiana property, and he advised Walgreen and Travelers of the suit. He then filed the pleadings away, and he later turned them over to his attorney.

On February 12, 1976, Mrs. Tatum filed a "First Amended Petition," and on April 6, 1976, she filed a "Second Amended Petition." The same three defendants were named in both of those amended petitions, and "Ridgeway Properties" was identified in both of those pleadings as a foreign corporation domiciled in the State of Texas, exactly as was alleged in the original petition. Dauley and Ridgeway were not named as defendants in either of those pleadings. Service of process of the First and Second Amended Petitions was made on Ridgeway Properties in each instance by mailing a certified copy of the citation and of the amended petition to "Ridgeway Properties," at the above address in Longview, Texas. The envelope containing those pleadings was received by Mr. or Mrs. Jackson, the envelope was handed to Mr. Ridgeway, he in turn showed the contents to Dauley, and thereafter Ridgeway filed the documents away.

A Third Amended Petition was filed by Mrs. Tatum on May 4, 1976, in which she named a total of seven defendants. The same three defendants, i. e. Ridgeway Properties, Walgreen and Travelers, were listed in this amended petition, and in addition thereto four other defendants were named, including:

"DEAN I. DAULEY, a non-resident of the State of Louisiana, with present mailing address of 105 North Carrier Parkway, Grand Prairie, Texas, 75050;
"I. BOYD RIDGEWAY, a non-resident of the State of Louisiana, with present mailing address of 812 East Marshall Street, Longview, Texas, 75601."

Shortly after that Third Amended Petition was filed, Mrs. Tatum voluntarily dismissed her suit as to all defendants, except as to Ridgeway Properties, Dauley and Ridgeway.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Dean v. Waters
667 So. 2d 1137 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1995)
Broussard v. Polaris Industries
587 So. 2d 215 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1991)
Roark v. Ikerd
514 So. 2d 703 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1987)
Decca Leasing Corp. v. Torres
465 So. 2d 910 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1985)
Varnado v. Dille
373 So. 2d 1027 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 1979)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
348 So. 2d 1323, 1977 La. App. LEXIS 5141, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/tatum-v-ridgeway-properties-lactapp-1977.