Syndicate 420 at Lloyd's London v. Early American Insurance

796 F.2d 821
CourtCourt of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit
DecidedAugust 13, 1986
DocketNo. 85-3353
StatusPublished
Cited by2 cases

This text of 796 F.2d 821 (Syndicate 420 at Lloyd's London v. Early American Insurance) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Syndicate 420 at Lloyd's London v. Early American Insurance, 796 F.2d 821 (5th Cir. 1986).

Opinion

JOHN R. BROWN, Circuit Judge:

In this appeal, we are asked to review the Herculean efforts of a district judge to slay this Hydra of litigation.1 Using the sword of a forum non conveniens dismissal, the court below held that this complex series of suits under the Louisiana Direct Action Statute was more appropriately resolved in Great Britain. Using a conditional dismissal, rather than a torch, he attempted to cauterize the wound in order to ensure that the parties dismissed could successfully intervene in an ongoing British lawsuit concerning the same transactions. We have thoroughly reviewed the record and have concluded that, while the labors of the district judge were not in vain, they were not completely successful in ensuring the availability of the alternative forum. Thus, while we affirm the decision of the District Court, we do so only after having modified the conditions imposed on the dismissal.

The Playbill

The cast of characters in this drama is quite large as it indirectly involves at least forty-five separate insurers. There are, however, five principals with whom the reader will become well acquainted as the tale unfolds. The first is Early American Insurance Company (Early American), an Alabama corporation, which issued marine insurance to vessels, principally owned or operated by Louisiana citizens, that plied the inland and coastly waters of Louisiana. Early American is currently undergoing liquidation in.bankruptcy proceedings. World American Underwriters (World), the second of the five, is a Delaware corporation that does business in Louisiana. It acted as agent for Early American in placing its insurance and in obtaining reinsurance of Early American’s portfolio. The third of the players is A.W. Knott Becker & Scott (KBS). KBS, a British entity, is an insurance broker dealing with underwriters at Lloyd’s, London. KBS, like Early American, is undergoing liquidation proceedings.

There are two remaining players in this drama. The fourth is Syndicate 420 at Lloyd’s London; the fifth is a group known [824]*824as the Errors and Omissions Insurers of KBS. Syndicate 420 is an underwriting syndicate, an unincorporated association of insurers at Lloyd's that assumes insurance risks. The Errors and Omissions Insurers, however, are less susceptible to cogent description. There are, in.fact, two groups of insurers who subscribe to KBS’ errors and omissions2 cover. The first group (the 82-83 Underwriters) subscribed to the professional indemnity policy issued to KBS for the period from April 1, 1982-April 30, 1983. The second group (the 83-84 Underwriters) subscribed to an identical policy for the period of May 1, 1983-April 30, 1984.3

With that cast of characters in mind, we now turn to set the stage.

Prologue

The circumstances of this tale are intimately intertwined with the tradition, practices, and sometimes curious language of Lloyd’s of London. As all know, Lloyd’s is not, in reality, an insurance company in either the English or the American sense. It bears little resemblance to a typical corporate insurer. On the underwriting floor at Lloyd’s in London are seated a number of underwriters for various syndicates. The syndicates are groups of insurer-investors, represented by the underwriter, that are organized for the purpose of assuming insurance risks. Brokers, such as KBS, approach the underwriter at his desk — in Lloyd’s parlance “the box” — and solicit the underwriter’s agreement to accept a risk. The broker presents to the underwriter a broker’s slip which, under the rules of Lloyd’s, must contain all material facts relating to the risk. If the underwriter agrees to accept all, or part, of a risk, he signifies his agreement by signing the slip. The signature, or “scratch,” of the underwriter on the slip is the last act necessary for the formation of the insurance contract at Lloyd’s.

The brokering of risks and the formation of contracts at Lloyd’s proceeds rapidly. It affords the underwriter little opportunity to investigate the contours of the risk being brokered. Thus, to minimize their risk, the underwriters usually do not agree to insure entire policies. Rather, there will be a number of syndicates that agree to subscribe to a given cover, each assuming only a specified portion of the total risk.

Lloyd’s has taken steps to minimize the peril involved in such rapid decision-making. Thus, it imposes upon brokers at Lloyd’s a duty of utmost good faith and full disclosure. All facts pertinent and material to the risk must be disclosed when the risk is tendered to the underwriter. The critical nature of this duty, for purposes of this litigation, is that the nondisclosure of material facts in a broker’s slip is sufficient — in the eyes of Lloyd’s — to render the policies issued on the risk void ab initio.

The stage is set, the players have assumed their positions, the curtain rises ...

... And the Tale Unfolds

As we stated, Early American issued marine insurance to vessels that plied the waters of Louisiana. That portfolio was partially reinsured by Edinburgh Insurance Company, but in 1982 Edinburgh underwent voluntary liquidation and withdrew from the marine insurance business. Upon being informed of Edinburgh’s withdrawal, Early American similarly determined to abandon its marine portfolio. It informed its agent, World, of its decision and requested that World obtain 100% reinsurance of the entire portfolio.

World was contacted in June of 1982 by a representative of KBS who proposed to obtain the desired reinsurance for World and Early American. KBS offered to use its resources as an authorized broker at Lloyd’s to obtain reinsurance at Lloyd’s. [825]*825World agreed, and shortly thereafter KBS contacted Syndicate 420’s underwriter and secured his subscription to a KBS slip, which, subject to specified terms and conditions, authorized KBS to issue a cover note to Early American which cover note would have the effect of allowing World American to reinsure certain risks through Syndicate 420. Instead of issuing the cover note directly, however, KBS issued it to the account of Channel Underwriters. Channel, in turn, issued the cover note to World at World’s offices in Metairie, Louisiana.

Syndicate 420 now alleges that the KBS slip misrepresented the nature of the Early American risk. Specifically, the Syndicate contends that KBS:

(1) Failed to disclose that Early American’s portfolio suffered from an adverse loss ratio in the years for which the Syndicate issued its guaranty;
(2) Failed to disclose that Early American sought reinsurance of its entire portfolio and planned to retain none of the risk itself; and,
(3) Misled Syndicate 420 by stating that its cover note would be issued only for a specific layer of reinsurance on business attaching after July of 1982 when, in fact, the cover note was used by Early American to reinsure its existing portfolio on a primary loss basis.

Syndicate 420 contends that these misrepresentations constitute a breach of KBS’s duty of utmost good faith and disclosure. It has, therefore, taken steps to vitiate the obligations its underwriter assumed when he signed the KBS slip.

The first step taken by Syndicate 420 was to file suit against a number of parties in the Eastern District of Louisiana.4

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
796 F.2d 821, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/syndicate-420-at-lloyds-london-v-early-american-insurance-ca5-1986.