Sturgeon, Paul

Court of Appeals of Texas

Sturgeon, Paul

DecidedMarch 19, 2015

DocketWR-40,136-11

StatusPublished

This text of Sturgeon, Paul (Sturgeon, Paul) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Court of Appeals of Texas primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook

Sturgeon, Paul, (Tex. Ct. App. 2015).

Pincite

Opinion

-- NO. _ _ _ __

.J:.IL1.1H£ t.tJLJ'n.1 /Jf l.P1MIA1AL AfptA~ {)F fOib

['i_ f1Jp_1f: ?nuL .5'7diftr:>.U l~eLATDll I AptlJt!.LJJJ7

OAJ ApphtA1/oiJ (/Jf_ IJJPIT /Jf MAMbAMLLS !.oli!JL 1110. Jl'iW1!3-A tfhuiJIJJJ /i;12. Willi of HAu.m ff;lfm

App 11t A1loJtJ fot IJ.iJZ, Jbl MltlutfAmm ~liJLtJ£). I~IJ723--JI J[tjg fh P61YJt] &u'it fltJililis fa.JJu7!~1aA5 1

RECEIVED IN Pall!!:)JLJIUL>ili COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS 'ReiA1bQ_ '&..se_ . . MAR 19 2015 IDfJ j1 J?~SJ l!JJ/ tAi2ZA . '130t.J fhAlf !bz .Ee-ewi/e., Ji~/15 11/t?z. .' IJIJJ .J)lilAA ha Auf,')'Ti lil1""'J , J&. fez_, 1"u !hdhwd> !uitAa't , f. , liJJ£;, 't ~illS, iAJ:hrJuJ follthL Thivd dar~L lew/ £1/oor. d Jhtf'l. J!J,._..zvt!Jt7mu~7 lt..FD rLs , \, DJJ j)p_ AhDul .5efllMha t.!J 1Zrl 1'10/bJ i/1.1 lkRRis 61-'!Lf} ,7fAFL<)1 1};1//_<, '7uJ?1{f)AUfid 1hw OtJti fhat UA!/~t~AJf'u//y fflOj}LiA k_ hy A~fuilliLJf JAJd Btl!'illlrJJ9i'PA111d /)VER filf£12/y, A!IIMI'.'l , IJ11e MIJ7odt!u cle.. !JvuAJ«i h b.wj /_,_jj UJ!I!Jc. or /~Jut lflVillfJJJlJJ7y T!JOLL5AIJ! r!ti)AJD A!Utlli;udtl. /Jiue_ 1 HuAliiwl Th1Jll5RAJr/ dol/A RJ , vudh 7ht!Ailw 7 iJ de;n ve_ LhLIdy Leo! f)/ !lvrn f 1 OJJ."JuAir. 'l!JiliJ//; tftu/.5 'ruilfM ,/J,fbt fAib !lruvitltd()/' !hL 1hiRLI tk/il!:e /1/cltlst. d' 1httlIJ! A!PIP 6/n~L f!IU5!RLJ1 ,PitlJJ~} hy /)pffi;_ lw7-A-tAi UuMdf ll'n I ) Af!lu£7t 'Jht~l LS AM !Jududuf /t;J 1hr..1JJdidMP.uI. 'Au 1.5 1TLJrt/'o.u. 1

1.dAIPL JJA!> Jw 1w err/ 1o /J;iUL f£/JKJ I1.1 li1L f Dd::l DIJAJd /llie:,5u_/Jl N;/uL 7h!JL1SA;ud rJpf/AJlj /)ill, ·' (}JJ .JU/Ift 'Z3, lDIJ, 7lt_l.tfoL '!Jitlf..ly !Jfuf A /:dLtffw A/tJ/Ji:.~ ~~A;r~a/ JIll f'otL5L ND, /l~D7l1, DIJJzliuq 7ht fJftLJ/5 fkrL15, AitvJ £1/JdtJoiL~ vdi1.5 dLJ/nJIEiZED t!y ~hAl liJ115 AVAdA h/c_ A: Ttii,L ~I lZiKI. I!Jm Ai11r:l~AlljtJt.Sitou/1};7 Aove.s Peli!of'!. At1u~tf.LiJJoL!.P.Jute_ . l!Jr /llc_vJt f);.J/!LJvnEd fiiJdL;dt:.e._ /Jut.iurlt.5 lhL ID{IDI!Jiltif; ·. . ·. - . .. . 1J fhL 'JJur!Je]/iJlJJf II•-' /?AUSl ft/p, Jl%1J7l3 1 vdhJ()J LJ fovc/USJ'IL tV!fit,utL tlul IJAJrutJkDtJJibiy ~vt. j l£/rikt.'J Aclu!lffy LtAJf_,t!LAJCL, fie !ltdIll bl _<:;/ut/ A ltJI!J !Jluf fiwl fJ1mllln.JJ' .L) 1hL t!PmfiAJiu7 1/kt! hy 1!7L !Dmf~AiiuAuljuJuL!y 1/LJ/, /J;u /)tf, 1,ltJ/f1 /AJ f'AU5l /l/p, Il%iJ1Z'n 1hJ~ 1 ~ foJJI' /wivt flflfiwa 7h.,/ l/IU fU t.5 /1DAltl hJ 7-Rovu !hAl l!.tLtloL h11ri tlfec7Ji!t ftoJtJJE;LI 7 vi lhc. 0JJtiJJt2 )f;uc/ ~tfAfoK J ~;luAf11JJUOLLJUL,- '; 711L &mffAtitJ7 £L/itfs _' . 01u AtJ7'tJ/ l!JdfJ!oAul.5'ru171'£JtJ, flwld A!t/P l;/,d. frpz,j /}')1fs1Attf1 !fum fJoffAl f{;A.Jt-JJ ·{Ap. Jhr.. f'A~ }/JA.\ btJE h~ttA DJuJEflE!Hhtz/tl!Jio ;hu7 Jht. f!A7 hAt! IJDI bttJu ftluaJtf! /)l iotA ftLI : 72uu:11-/ Alj Rton e."'JI ( fJJ,J l'w 7JJb, Y~JJ1'/V?Jf ·

rhtf! clidAlol IJAJLI fou!d Alof h/IVL {)({[JW/'1 /;tl !!Awl' AIJJ, IZ5fo7!!J). J.AJ 7oA.S . ~ .

1/1,_ f!t;,Jp__ 7'< hAJ lfEid lk~rl A!!.IAlM IJ! Jht/1 fhAt!t ;/u !.tJ,uliJtelio;J J;Jd/1 ·A fovllAt1 PerJJiJN.5 Anot 1)/!JJ!J2f Thalli liAJl.AJ7w7 70 dtlRivt A,ud A f'if _~uhier.uw7 'lof ~in lto,J f)/ !ht. h£)fel1'/' If {)fJ/y AAJ :lJ.J7w 7 7v dtfR.Ive_ AA11J ~flbrA flo,J b Aevev 7 iili !I iJJu7-ut.l1111 I /J1A Jfez , 7hcu f5AJo f!£1~J/i.J11f f11u thit_ Jbttlti.ISt Ulii/fttl l£KJVL5 .O/' }he_ /!tJJiillJJt.1 I tJAJt.. hAS rhL 'Kl?hJ 7o''tyiliVt. 1htff)wJUez.d !Pr.aJ!. "''" !le7ut.d IP2 ft,,L\Jdeuh(),J..

JJJ 7hL fmw1 CMe, A/J/.5/T!J~CLJ,,;, flr.£t!oz, 15 llftLIW:If)/ ho!t!lAJf Alblo A/tieJ. fad /YiwlA, '1:. {)JiilJtJedhy DollA z f.&u7 -A ·{;JI .hr,u d lhL . fJ iilA //{) u ~llor/ tJ!Jhf- ?WlJrl tf£1J1tlil71hi!> l!kn

Al!J IJU7tv/ !J/ J/uff /t} h/JILLJI bt'fuluu t.5.JffiJ£J/i/.Ja b., to,;~ I/ siJ#) ,- · . ~) 'Afo.!ly DnelJltaLb 'fllirfo.u 78.11', LA YtJ /bJA/ l'ule .Ja. 3 l.o '~ tr ~~1h1th 1io 1v ilAuLs '0Pf£JAJ:S t.A "L l/11 t.A l.l5r. AJo 1zRml2> , tlmKIy b}Dft) i1 . r ~· · L . Aptllso,J UJMMd\ '1ht!J1 /) "_jtilvitt ll1 llthl/7 h;iloLII 7tJ J/Vf)icl f.oymuJJ ftrL5e.tWJiL Jhul Atlo~ fw/Ju15l~ /mv;J,j OtJij foL [!JIJ1ft1U SA fJo,J ; .;) fltNe !'.ou7Pol OII£P lm.so~ctAI kri'ty uNrlu fA VJztlloJ foul~/ AqRt.t.mtto!l), 7hdt7m hYJ!dJ 1he Pr{)(Xllly heybAit! 7hc o/_fRJI hoAI t1 1hL lcJJJul A9l(tfYltJd! l!Jtfhv/_1/ lhtlffr-J:J,·ve_ &Ju.5Jt'.JJ7 v/7Je../)!JUA/t.L /)/ Jhe ktodf' AIIJ;I !Ails 'JrJ I'¥ 1ht Ajy!hUJhk Poul;J! ChAFLJc !Pe lDK ~7/Jf£/lfj. . ~

1tt.ll5 fu ltJ !t1.fllf f!Ddt_ .5f.L,J!.O) JituJ lli£4s lJuJ 'fo !J!JffAt · bJJ-A ·{A,t j}jJ) !Jti, Jj I lf)jf). • . , ~) .''IJ£,~.J!y DveD vtillO '' Elfttfntc.£ 'tnuht'1Lt1 Atft;ll!tJ1 DrJJtl fPiiJPr/1/J, r ?,.irlth UclI J,; Ddlol' Kt~.-d-A -CLJ K o/lirJ i/:, 1Jtm/!Url /Pz ~ymtA //. /)JJ 1Jt7 7, l010. 7hi> . il fDAltfWJVE. fVtrft,J~L JhA/ U!LILJULSJIPAJ!Ij}v hPVD iAui.J'ruur·Ai~~. ~~lA loB AtluAlLviJI!tiut.t, lull fAa J) ~vts. 1

A) lhn) Dv!lrtt ~u1 ~A lA2 hAd 6ssruto1u ()/ lht. lt>J;;,t!Ad~R£1 fJ1mIAur 0/J IJl};cftJilL [Je 7. 7Jp//) bu.rw.'.c_ Att.MJ,u 'fv {bid lad j. j r ?nymw 7ii dt.IJJAJJdvMJJtif //flu !he feluJUu £17hL ~ lt?£1 Vthit/e_, 111 b.Judy !&I !l!mm,l!alf12Juo/ ilk"' cShe. Al!trr/1 Jiu ha &mf11'1J7 1h~t I 1/r &L hAd AJti htuu le.!uNaltfJJ laA!ul _jJ_

.AtiA1bi

l. oI _ ?l!li IS>~1"'~ ~Do-1!>li{}, 11 /SIP.SJ, b Li!llE.v 7~1 :l.tiCAll/LilA letlliu lhc. 1 1 _ 1tirt~ Dtfl ~~ b.JM.:Jw/. ~J_J1 J /1JJvzA ftl~tan,_'l.3otf J:illdfmz. &, fhutLht;

l;a vt!IL , bvu 1:6/tJZ.s · ·

IJJt Kt!Aioi, h,g ExhAuJ!td hb k.mu-.~tu AI£/J };115 AlP tJ!ha._ AJUjLJJ'I fL 72uwcc!y AJ iAJJJ

7~t A,_~ !JIJ11? h1 7iPbe /;;mjldluf 1.5 M,juf.j TEl!AI, FJPI dbfl(llPA.!Alj /iu M7urc U..t. ?. Azl, J/.o7/ .5LC.. g(l) fu;m&.) KtyoAJJwl 7P AAAU AfjlKDflilllt fAJR;/ItAJ fJJJrhliflj /J/ fOcJJ lrAJtf f1tut./Li_51iAt-LJ IJJ jfi,1d /JLICALJJt JJuvll%0723/1 JtJplfAJ£1 LfJtf je_e_ L 1 lt f.st (JJlfl. 10 , 791 .S.1o1,3d l'lK ;and /;ihsDLI/ lL Dal/o '> &uu1" De·)Rir..J lltlL. Z.1S s ltd 3d tj]J I

'ra !'.oiL fJI !'JJ.iM. ha_.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI