Stoutmire v. State

358 So. 2d 508
CourtCourt of Criminal Appeals of Alabama
DecidedMay 2, 1978
StatusPublished
Cited by6 cases

This text of 358 So. 2d 508 (Stoutmire v. State) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Court of Criminal Appeals of Alabama primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Stoutmire v. State, 358 So. 2d 508 (Ala. Ct. App. 1978).

Opinion

358 So.2d 508 (1978)

John STOUTMIRE, alias John J. Stoutmire
v.
STATE.

3 Div. 870.

Court of Criminal Appeals of Alabama.

May 2, 1978.

*509 Tyrone C. Means, of Gray, Seay & Langford, Montgomery, for appellant.

William J. Baxley, Atty. Gen. and Milton E. Belcher, Asst. Atty. Gen., for the State.

BOWEN, Judge.

This is an appeal from an indictment and conviction of assaulting a peace officer with a deadly weapon. Sentence was fixed at two years' imprisonment by the trial judge. The appellant's retained trial counsel was appointed to represent him on this appeal.

The only question presented is whether the state made out a prima facie case. The appellant alleges that the state failed to prove (1) an assault (2) with a deadly weapon.

The state's evidence reveals that on the night of the 11th of September, 1977, officers of the Georgiana Police Department received information as to the whereabouts of the appellant who was being sought on charges of burglary and grand larceny in Butler and Montgomery County.

Inside the residence of Margaret Reese the officers attempted to arrest the appellant. When approached the appellant ran into the bedroom where he turned and pulled a pocket knife on the pursuing officers. Because the conviction must stand or fall on these events, they must be examined in detail.

Officer James Blackmon of the Georgiana Police Department testified that after the appellant was advised of the fact that he was under arrest, he "broke loose and ran". The appellant knocked two officers back and "slung them loose".

"Then, all three of us followed him back to the back room, and he went over to a window and had knocked the screen out, and had the window open. We told him not to go out the window, not to go any further, something in that order, and he started turning around, and as he turned around, he pulled that knife out of his pocket and opened the blade on it. At that time, all three of us drawed our guns on him at that time."
* * * * * *
"A. Well, he was waving it in front of him (indicating) like that, warning us not to come any closer.
"Q. Did he threaten you with the knife?
"A. Well, he was just waving it around telling us and warning us to stay back.
"Q. And, telling you not to come any closer?
"A. That's correct."
"A. Well, when he was waving the knife, we pleaded with him to drop the knife, and several seconds, seems like maybe longer, but we pleaded with him several seconds. He wouldn't do it, and he started easing out the window, backing out."

After the appellant was out the window,

"he run a short distance from us, and when he went outside, I could hear Joe telling how to throw the knife down. He didn't do it, and when I got out there, he had done started easing along a little sidewalk, along in front of the house, and he ran a short distance, then he turned back on us."

And again on cross examination:

". . . all of us followed him into the bedroom."
* * * * * *
*510 "Yes, sir, that's when he turned around and pulled the knife."
* * * * * *
"Oh, we was pretty doggone close to him, maybe five or six or seven or eight feet, something like that."
* * * * * *
"Well, when he run in there, he turned around and he pulled the knife on us, he waived the knife around and warned us not to come any closer."
* * * * * *
"Q. Did he charge you with the knife?
"A. No, sir, not exactly, not inside the house.
"Q. He just tried to hold you back with it?
"A. That's correct."

Once outside the house, the appellant

". . . went a little further to the corner of the building. He went on back towards like he was going towards the back yard, then he turned around, and then he took a few steps forward."
* * * * * *
"A. He didn't say anything on the outside.
"Q. Did he again charge the officers?
"A. Like I said, he turned around and took several steps back towards us, at that time, I was about ten or fifteen feet away from him."

When the appellant turned around in the backyard and turned toward the officers he had the knife in his hand.

Butler County Deputy Sheriff Levoy Blackburn testified to substantially the same facts.

"So, when he started to search him, he broke and run, and he run into me and Grayson, pushed us aside and went to the back bedroom. When we got there, he pulled a knife, as he kind of turned, that's when he pulled it. He said something, but I couldn't understand what he was saying, but he pushed the screen out of the window and went out through the window."
* * * * * *
"Well, when he got outside—whenever I got around to where James was, he had turned—he run out there a piece and he turned and started back (with the knife in his hand)."

When the appellant started back Officer Blackmon shot him.

Deputy Blackburn, testified on cross examination that:

"When he got into the back bedroom, he pulled that knife on me."
* * * * * *
"On all of us."
* * * * * *
"Q. Did any of the officers have theirs (pistols) drawn?
"A. Not until after he pulled the knife."
* * * * * *
"Q. What was he trying to do in the bedroom?
"A. Well, when he pulled the knife out, he turned like he was going to come towards us, and that's when I pulled mine.
"Q. Did he come towards you?
"A. No, sir.
"Q. Was he trying to get out the window?
"A. After he turned, we drawed our guns, he backed up to the window and knocked the screen off. Then, he backed out the window."

Butler County Deputy Sheriff Lamar Grayson stated:

"We tried to, you know, to restrain him, and he started hitting at us, trying to get away from us. He ran back into the back bedroom, down the hallway, to a back bedroom. We followed him into a bedroom, and at this time, he pulled out a knife on us. He was right next to a window. Whenever he got into the room, we got in right behind him, and he pulled out a knife on us."
* * * * * *
"Well, he pulled it out of his pocket, he waved it at us, said don't come any closer, *511 something like that. He had it like this (indicating).
"Q. What did you do then?
"A. We tried several times to get him to drop the knife. So, we pulled our guns out at this time and at the time he come out with the knife, we tried several times to get him to drop the knife. When he refused and would not do that, he knocked a screen out of the window and he finally slid out that window, . . . .

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Twyman v. State
565 So. 2d 1215 (Court of Criminal Appeals of Alabama, 1990)
Lee v. State
540 So. 2d 802 (Court of Criminal Appeals of Alabama, 1988)
Baker v. State
404 So. 2d 100 (Court of Criminal Appeals of Alabama, 1980)
Cordial v. State
389 So. 2d 170 (Court of Criminal Appeals of Alabama, 1980)
Kendricks v. State
378 So. 2d 1203 (Court of Criminal Appeals of Alabama, 1979)
McArdle v. State
372 So. 2d 897 (Court of Criminal Appeals of Alabama, 1979)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
358 So. 2d 508, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/stoutmire-v-state-alacrimapp-1978.