-__- .- I'? ifl"'] _,-:::2 L _ . . ~,,·i~r · ,~:. ·: ~~J T~..:.-~.. 4 6 ., ·.r .- if/'~~'
,_li!Jl.LC.iluvfJ ur: CJtiu i' ttJAJl. ·:-J.:\QQ·euf~;-_r .::;. : ·. L:~': ~
/J. r r- K- o.cllu.,_l]xdue.. ~-5L_li.JU. 1 .. .~~(0~~\W~lQ) ~~ _ ' •(COO'~Pt!Ot= r.~IDillNAt ~EAtS
----~[IJe. r:;J~rJ4 _~-Ci1tV1l t1C: . _llppi:A-I6 _: · ___ o . ___ • ::\:~uta_9_2015 _ ·_____ :_:~---- _______ Ai W hA .4r1 "1j,:) . ·. . 0 _ .~~~~cm'la. Cl®vk AQ,S rJd h rl wr.1 . ·. . . r~:~~~~~:.~~~o;!~"~:a~~· ·· at the time of imaging. _ ·-__ ll lw i'T U[ 11A tln >CJiltvLt.lS . :. ).,_, -. . - _ -_ - - . . . - .. , . . . ····:,-· ·············· .. , . ,:,·· . _
. ..... I.J j ~I HI:) JAd lCL n1 ITJ,-.~~··· a~(2.... ~11~f.,, 1.. 52u
Tl-~if ~t()f:.T i r ,. tJHlL< F,< II! . IJ-d ,~6 (1 ~i.LJi.AJAJ.:t.,O .tiu.~. QJ,CJ I. .u4 ru w I;Ju.to ·. dlt! Cd11 J too A tl-h: £t.5~uudtwr.Qj .i 10 FU~ TUwa_.,JLJIAI~QCJiC,I{IJH J~ , . -.- .. :· ·:-J ...... ,.· -
. . . - ... ~ ·,···· . . ·-:;-;·.~,-;-.· .. ;:;,·-.:,- ·":."!':~··-~;-<"-.:.·. .. -::"'.~~~-~-;·· ,-c . . . •:: . .·· ! .. ··.. . •• "!
. .· - -~ (otfH *Givf ,H3}:t,:[,,2{, • . . .. . . . . . .. •• . .. > " ., -.. ---·-· - ...... ··• \' ..""_'!:···· . . • • . . .
·. .... ..,
CL.~ r C1, Juif__LtUpfOU'.LA.o________ ________-~~ _l_\3JtL ___ ! _ ---A_
-t:i41: ~i)tir1LiL.~LLJ_,:_ tE.~-AJ:_IL)&k1.il6 \ ·.... . ~ q~_..3K_,__Mwr.[.i__/i)~•"'· OIINIJ4 .:...--___,_todd tilMJ\AiiJ,tU sr, 5ulre. :~Lld ( :!~ of} ~j_i1L,Lll1J~.Ii.9Uc.S_,__·-·--+:!i----., !)t
Jl ·f r- ~ttt.}_L~-S[U.k1L---.....__ _ _ ____.:~:f___. ._ C>'
"'" ~~-·c .• -~-·--··-····-~-····~--·-~;;~·~·-·~~~~-·~-·~·-·-· ...~.-·-~-----·-~-·"·"·"'
---- ,/\c·r,··[- f-J·C.. ,·I""' 161" 'l . · . . ·.~.-- . - - . . . . . . . . . .-.. .-- ·---. ·.?_.?,).n.:.<'fJ/\. .J ,-.,. ~! i . - ...·.-.:_ : :":":,. . . : ";: : ;: ;,. .,. ."'' ;;;\(;~~ . '"'·'"'''c"'·"·'-'·1-'\'.'~•-·"·'"''' - ~ -· .... · ---.--........ ~--. . . . ··~~-- ......... _.~.. ~i • ~1~ E5ru·J,: . l' Juir .... ···.; . . :.. ~~:;., ·. . . . . ·. "
. .----~ ~1 _ _~l~/L . 9_z+~l . i -- - - · - - ·. · · · •- -~- : . · - •--'-"- • -• :~:.':~.~-. :'c' /-~~::·_.," ' ·s•c· ·• ...· .. ······- · ---
~~UJJT6\.(!'I I[ ft:ll&s Jlc2d . ·' .... _.: ... - ~-~ ~-~·, ..,,;.:__ .;;.·' . . . . .
. , •.• ; ' ,/" .• ·;>" · •• _,.;. ~; < . ;~.; ·.·.;>,;-. ,,, . : ,;. ~;:
Wu~Jt1 . (1.;z_. l\f0(li~·&fo .-. - - ................,......... . . , ,.,. . . : . . ,. ~."'~'"•~·· .... d ••
. i *' r::i /Z: ll~ .. t{)i~ ru.icJ' . l)r. [l~i4~:. t.tr:;_l(Jal~_-44:::.:::. :.·::·::,;.~.:.:::: ............. .... . .. . . .. •" .. ·-· . . . . . . ----·---· .. .
; ,:·:.......... .-~~ ~;::_~t;i-"' . . . ...... ~-·~-~: ~-- -""·' .,.,
. Ai C....IJ. 11 .JA-t411. 1lQ · .. · :cCC~ ;.~ ·:c ·~· • Ae.s f(Xl HJ(J ILlr.. . (> . w TP•••····c•• ; '""'··: ··~~· .• ,.., . '·
2l< 3 wckJ L.lc.llc.ill L 1!J i~:r~& i.tif C.:k1t Jwl·.:Sr' c~;+;~··c;;;.~:: ;;~ . ~u. iL)ivicsiuk-tl"rM . fL ... ···-··.··-············:~··;. ,·-.~;.·.·····-,......... . f::KAIL.lU. ~du.JIQ.Lj ~UMiU kJid4.·t33 · ~ivul"='l!du'f . lk>-33 · · ..15 ··. · T r ~
iL}Jll'l M. TEii.lu 16 ~d 1. . ·. . · ., ~l
_ ______.;~~~. -------.-...........,............. , . . :·. 'J ·,2! ' . .,Re,t. Q1Zl411.4 ·...... .-,_-""•"• ·' ----·--~----''-=--
- ·_-_- .Ail._,~- • ~~~-=~-"-~~- .---- -~------· -"·= = - ··-- --"~~-= -""·= ~~~~ -~- --~----~~=-=~.,r~;=f.JM:"ic.==·l>~
- 'l ·-·r·a ti; 1!f[i_Ll~E~_ }Q!~-I·:~---~~~~-~~~~~:~-•-;:;·_--=:;~~~:-:.:;=::~~--ii: . -~~-~ .: .·. : . --:.·-~::·_;_ :- - ·;~. .t ·~; • . '·:· ~ • .,.. r ;---~;:
3. ---. -lUd '
______ - 0-~. f1 r-/J., 'f IJ d- K j T j(l)5 ··- .: __________ .
--··-··- -_ ------ I .. . .
----------- ---- - . . .
. > . -- - ---- -- ---- • -- -
·- ·- -- . .. -- - - • -·-- ,__ ..... -,...
- - ------ - . ...•.................•. .- .. ·:·::···· ._____ __.,-_-__
-- ,~;
=~· .. :. •.:~.;.·;,.;;... ~?'"':.:~<'Y.<:>~:~"t·:-·
-~,.
--------:---~--------- ·. . . ., ... •,--·,"-'·::':<"'_~;, -~ •. _, ·-
---------,-----------
4. 6TA Tf..-kAa ·uT- Ll~ -_ TI:L: ~-Ase, ---·--" . - ·- f .
6J Issue.. ·tout-Go tJI~d ;: ;.
~-i 5TJ.1T,: "A'Lu 11 ot: _ En r. r ..._ ~ '". .. .. ·.. . " . . .. . __ ._ _, ... ··"'·"~_...;:. ···'··'· "'"" . ~,•"'-~""'~'\\. .-:w:.·~~"~-;F:~- ;...·, . ..~~. .·":~-"-·~-,.;~.;;_,;;:_.J<:·--~ . '' . ... •. ' .. • . .. ·' . :- ? ~ ····''"""'''''''''"''''' '"'
. '- . .. 1 ·- \ . . I: ~1J1 fl: " A£ u[ Cjl . :cl b{ I Q(J 1 cII Ll.kJ; ·:.~:.:~.· .-~:::::·::~.:,':;::~:-~::;tL; ·.:~;::·:·~_;' ~~·- 0
l j ··.: •:f d • ·_.
~ ' 6u M II AALl I Ll r: ILk. t\H ~~1.111.41 J! lJ .·. :;;:}. _J ·- ' . . a11 lA ,'1 J IJ /~K r >·-~~~-o._u l0--_-_ ·r ~: ·. 1 .,,,, _ . . ...... '":··~:--·;::-.:~_·,~··~~~.:·::' . :~;; _···:-·":·''·-··
J ld._qK•~~ HuG -dU¢1_--.. _- .. ......•. '• • • ·''"~~ ~.
........, - ..•, -·•"" ~'"'' "v'•t'"''~ _,..., ..-. a "' ~ ·'·· '·"'".:. >·:·---:---?::· . . . "'"·'"<:'·";""':' '"~;\.t~. -- • ..... ''""::~·'. ~ ··' ............... ,w . ... .
. qwf"lll~f(J-IIAI11 , ~... .. ... , ,.," ,::~l,> G, h_.. •. ·· . - ..... -...... ~-- . . . .. . ~ '~... . ·•.. ' '; . .. .. • ; . -~' .. .: -~~-.\·::· : :"':"'\~:;
·' q, ,0 wfj f_f;e 11. •··• ..'···· ...·• ··.·- ~--:-.--:··.·>-:<>~£>'-.{· ,.,::.•(>-: ;i. ;.~·',·.~~~:. ,. ' .• :.·,<~.!~---- . ,,; .... ..... ;..;}-<·:::_-., • •··· ..... , . .
, -II i c_tiA Ti h~- C/1"[ f: t1 k 5tn \Jtc.,e • ·I ' ' · · · ,_·,•.- · · • ··,,,,,.·;., ... ~ ,.;,.r•. •• · ..> :, ......... _ ,,; ... ··., •.. ("".;~~!.•::-;.~.,.;•--:.:;:::;;;:;>•-~· .::;.;, ... __ ..,,~<>::x-,(:.:~·"'"M''''"""=·''"Y''"''.' .. ... \ 1~, A(l(l b cJI x. > -- .. .. . . . ... .. .. ·- .-..... ·:·~,.._ .. .-::---.:.~:-'- '?' ';\.-v ·";}'~:::': •, '!<.. ·:;.-._:_~ .............. " •. ., ..,~~. .·. \ 1 ,.
_. _-. -lA .t Tl!f._.o.n4 tJitiJ(..l 01: :A(J()~(~.: -.M~ui lll
-~.........._ ..______________________ __ / '!
tA~L " i=- · ,-~ ~----:~-~-=:<=~-~~~~'~=r:=c===~~~-===c~=~•-==iJ!:\jf.~-== ilA~;;,~ ~~;=~iaJ.~~5~.,:i-~.Ui _:±~~~~r:Gi~ 400. -i,t;;~~~--Qi3r:· ~---~~--~--- ~, '11. tJ 11 l~\. {)tu'\t_. __ . . .... ···""'· ,,1•.. .._,
~_._~1~ <'--li1l'-J-~ ~ 2fL ~1"i__jg._':l_(!(l·_~JI-~}J~~~~hf2K&_._~~--
4, E.\ t ~ \ i I\~ '6-&S B.uJ ~d t51 cr~x:. lS~~J ._ . . . ~-·, . .{.
5. GJ \tjc..ULi d . .. Jl.J] S.t . . d1: .gcJ .Ar . '. . ltlloi!J; ... . . .·. _.,,_: ..., ..., ,. ,;:,:..... . ... ~- ~-=. < "<- • ~ ' ' "' "' • ,~,.~ , , .... -· --~---- • • :-: •••
~~ lu IP..E-. C.tlr
Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI
-__- .- I'? ifl"'] _,-:::2 L _ . . ~,,·i~r · ,~:. ·: ~~J T~..:.-~.. 4 6 ., ·.r .- if/'~~'
,_li!Jl.LC.iluvfJ ur: CJtiu i' ttJAJl. ·:-J.:\QQ·euf~;-_r .::;. : ·. L:~': ~
/J. r r- K- o.cllu.,_l]xdue.. ~-5L_li.JU. 1 .. .~~(0~~\W~lQ) ~~ _ ' •(COO'~Pt!Ot= r.~IDillNAt ~EAtS
----~[IJe. r:;J~rJ4 _~-Ci1tV1l t1C: . _llppi:A-I6 _: · ___ o . ___ • ::\:~uta_9_2015 _ ·_____ :_:~---- _______ Ai W hA .4r1 "1j,:) . ·. . 0 _ .~~~~cm'la. Cl®vk AQ,S rJd h rl wr.1 . ·. . . r~:~~~~~:.~~~o;!~"~:a~~· ·· at the time of imaging. _ ·-__ ll lw i'T U[ 11A tln >CJiltvLt.lS . :. ).,_, -. . - _ -_ - - . . . - .. , . . . ····:,-· ·············· .. , . ,:,·· . _
. ..... I.J j ~I HI:) JAd lCL n1 ITJ,-.~~··· a~(2.... ~11~f.,, 1.. 52u
Tl-~if ~t()f:.T i r ,. tJHlL< F,< II! . IJ-d ,~6 (1 ~i.LJi.AJAJ.:t.,O .tiu.~. QJ,CJ I. .u4 ru w I;Ju.to ·. dlt! Cd11 J too A tl-h: £t.5~uudtwr.Qj .i 10 FU~ TUwa_.,JLJIAI~QCJiC,I{IJH J~ , . -.- .. :· ·:-J ...... ,.· -
. . . - ... ~ ·,···· . . ·-:;-;·.~,-;-.· .. ;:;,·-.:,- ·":."!':~··-~;-<"-.:.·. .. -::"'.~~~-~-;·· ,-c . . . •:: . .·· ! .. ··.. . •• "!
. .· - -~ (otfH *Givf ,H3}:t,:[,,2{, • . . .. . . . . . .. •• . .. > " ., -.. ---·-· - ...... ··• \' ..""_'!:···· . . • • . . .
·. .... ..,
CL.~ r C1, Juif__LtUpfOU'.LA.o________ ________-~~ _l_\3JtL ___ ! _ ---A_
-t:i41: ~i)tir1LiL.~LLJ_,:_ tE.~-AJ:_IL)&k1.il6 \ ·.... . ~ q~_..3K_,__Mwr.[.i__/i)~•"'· OIINIJ4 .:...--___,_todd tilMJ\AiiJ,tU sr, 5ulre. :~Lld ( :!~ of} ~j_i1L,Lll1J~.Ii.9Uc.S_,__·-·--+:!i----., !)t
Jl ·f r- ~ttt.}_L~-S[U.k1L---.....__ _ _ ____.:~:f___. ._ C>'
"'" ~~-·c .• -~-·--··-····-~-····~--·-~;;~·~·-·~~~~-·~-·~·-·-· ...~.-·-~-----·-~-·"·"·"'
---- ,/\c·r,··[- f-J·C.. ,·I""' 161" 'l . · . . ·.~.-- . - - . . . . . . . . . .-.. .-- ·---. ·.?_.?,).n.:.<'fJ/\. .J ,-.,. ~! i . - ...·.-.:_ : :":":,. . . : ";: : ;: ;,. .,. ."'' ;;;\(;~~ . '"'·'"'''c"'·"·'-'·1-'\'.'~•-·"·'"''' - ~ -· .... · ---.--........ ~--. . . . ··~~-- ......... _.~.. ~i • ~1~ E5ru·J,: . l' Juir .... ···.; . . :.. ~~:;., ·. . . . . ·. "
. .----~ ~1 _ _~l~/L . 9_z+~l . i -- - - · - - ·. · · · •- -~- : . · - •--'-"- • -• :~:.':~.~-. :'c' /-~~::·_.," ' ·s•c· ·• ...· .. ······- · ---
~~UJJT6\.(!'I I[ ft:ll&s Jlc2d . ·' .... _.: ... - ~-~ ~-~·, ..,,;.:__ .;;.·' . . . . .
. , •.• ; ' ,/" .• ·;>" · •• _,.;. ~; < . ;~.; ·.·.;>,;-. ,,, . : ,;. ~;:
Wu~Jt1 . (1.;z_. l\f0(li~·&fo .-. - - ................,......... . . , ,.,. . . : . . ,. ~."'~'"•~·· .... d ••
. i *' r::i /Z: ll~ .. t{)i~ ru.icJ' . l)r. [l~i4~:. t.tr:;_l(Jal~_-44:::.:::. :.·::·::,;.~.:.:::: ............. .... . .. . . .. •" .. ·-· . . . . . . ----·---· .. .
; ,:·:.......... .-~~ ~;::_~t;i-"' . . . ...... ~-·~-~: ~-- -""·' .,.,
. Ai C....IJ. 11 .JA-t411. 1lQ · .. · :cCC~ ;.~ ·:c ·~· • Ae.s f(Xl HJ(J ILlr.. . (> . w TP•••····c•• ; '""'··: ··~~· .• ,.., . '·
2l< 3 wckJ L.lc.llc.ill L 1!J i~:r~& i.tif C.:k1t Jwl·.:Sr' c~;+;~··c;;;.~:: ;;~ . ~u. iL)ivicsiuk-tl"rM . fL ... ···-··.··-············:~··;. ,·-.~;.·.·····-,......... . f::KAIL.lU. ~du.JIQ.Lj ~UMiU kJid4.·t33 · ~ivul"='l!du'f . lk>-33 · · ..15 ··. · T r ~
iL}Jll'l M. TEii.lu 16 ~d 1. . ·. . · ., ~l
_ ______.;~~~. -------.-...........,............. , . . :·. 'J ·,2! ' . .,Re,t. Q1Zl411.4 ·...... .-,_-""•"• ·' ----·--~----''-=--
- ·_-_- .Ail._,~- • ~~~-=~-"-~~- .---- -~------· -"·= = - ··-- --"~~-= -""·= ~~~~ -~- --~----~~=-=~.,r~;=f.JM:"ic.==·l>~
- 'l ·-·r·a ti; 1!f[i_Ll~E~_ }Q!~-I·:~---~~~~-~~~~~:~-•-;:;·_--=:;~~~:-:.:;=::~~--ii: . -~~-~ .: .·. : . --:.·-~::·_;_ :- - ·;~. .t ·~; • . '·:· ~ • .,.. r ;---~;:
3. ---. -lUd '
______ - 0-~. f1 r-/J., 'f IJ d- K j T j(l)5 ··- .: __________ .
--··-··- -_ ------ I .. . .
----------- ---- - . . .
. > . -- - ---- -- ---- • -- -
·- ·- -- . .. -- - - • -·-- ,__ ..... -,...
- - ------ - . ...•.................•. .- .. ·:·::···· ._____ __.,-_-__
-- ,~;
=~· .. :. •.:~.;.·;,.;;... ~?'"':.:~<'Y.<:>~:~"t·:-·
-~,.
--------:---~--------- ·. . . ., ... •,--·,"-'·::':<"'_~;, -~ •. _, ·-
---------,-----------
4. 6TA Tf..-kAa ·uT- Ll~ -_ TI:L: ~-Ase, ---·--" . - ·- f .
6J Issue.. ·tout-Go tJI~d ;: ;.
~-i 5TJ.1T,: "A'Lu 11 ot: _ En r. r ..._ ~ '". .. .. ·.. . " . . .. . __ ._ _, ... ··"'·"~_...;:. ···'··'· "'"" . ~,•"'-~""'~'\\. .-:w:.·~~"~-;F:~- ;...·, . ..~~. .·":~-"-·~-,.;~.;;_,;;:_.J<:·--~ . '' . ... •. ' .. • . .. ·' . :- ? ~ ····''"""'''''''''"''''' '"'
. '- . .. 1 ·- \ . . I: ~1J1 fl: " A£ u[ Cjl . :cl b{ I Q(J 1 cII Ll.kJ; ·:.~:.:~.· .-~:::::·::~.:,':;::~:-~::;tL; ·.:~;::·:·~_;' ~~·- 0
l j ··.: •:f d • ·_.
~ ' 6u M II AALl I Ll r: ILk. t\H ~~1.111.41 J! lJ .·. :;;:}. _J ·- ' . . a11 lA ,'1 J IJ /~K r >·-~~~-o._u l0--_-_ ·r ~: ·. 1 .,,,, _ . . ...... '":··~:--·;::-.:~_·,~··~~~.:·::' . :~;; _···:-·":·''·-··
J ld._qK•~~ HuG -dU¢1_--.. _- .. ......•. '• • • ·''"~~ ~.
........, - ..•, -·•"" ~'"'' "v'•t'"''~ _,..., ..-. a "' ~ ·'·· '·"'".:. >·:·---:---?::· . . . "'"·'"<:'·";""':' '"~;\.t~. -- • ..... ''""::~·'. ~ ··' ............... ,w . ... .
. qwf"lll~f(J-IIAI11 , ~... .. ... , ,.," ,::~l,> G, h_.. •. ·· . - ..... -...... ~-- . . . .. . ~ '~... . ·•.. ' '; . .. .. • ; . -~' .. .: -~~-.\·::· : :"':"'\~:;
·' q, ,0 wfj f_f;e 11. •··• ..'···· ...·• ··.·- ~--:-.--:··.·>-:<>~£>'-.{· ,.,::.•(>-: ;i. ;.~·',·.~~~:. ,. ' .• :.·,<~.!~---- . ,,; .... ..... ;..;}-<·:::_-., • •··· ..... , . .
, -II i c_tiA Ti h~- C/1"[ f: t1 k 5tn \Jtc.,e • ·I ' ' · · · ,_·,•.- · · • ··,,,,,.·;., ... ~ ,.;,.r•. •• · ..> :, ......... _ ,,; ... ··., •.. ("".;~~!.•::-;.~.,.;•--:.:;:::;;;:;>•-~· .::;.;, ... __ ..,,~<>::x-,(:.:~·"'"M''''"""=·''"Y''"''.' .. ... \ 1~, A(l(l b cJI x. > -- .. .. . . . ... .. .. ·- .-..... ·:·~,.._ .. .-::---.:.~:-'- '?' ';\.-v ·";}'~:::': •, '!<.. ·:;.-._:_~ .............. " •. ., ..,~~. .·. \ 1 ,.
_. _-. -lA .t Tl!f._.o.n4 tJitiJ(..l 01: :A(J()~(~.: -.M~ui lll
-~.........._ ..______________________ __ / '!
tA~L " i=- · ,-~ ~----:~-~-=:<=~-~~~~'~=r:=c===~~~-===c~=~•-==iJ!:\jf.~-== ilA~;;,~ ~~;=~iaJ.~~5~.,:i-~.Ui _:±~~~~r:Gi~ 400. -i,t;;~~~--Qi3r:· ~---~~--~--- ~, '11. tJ 11 l~\. {)tu'\t_. __ . . .... ···""'· ,,1•.. .._,
~_._~1~ <'--li1l'-J-~ ~ 2fL ~1"i__jg._':l_(!(l·_~JI-~}J~~~~hf2K&_._~~--
4, E.\ t ~ \ i I\~ '6-&S B.uJ ~d t51 cr~x:. lS~~J ._ . . . ~-·, . .{.
5. GJ \tjc..ULi d . .. Jl.J] S.t . . d1: .gcJ .Ar . '. . ltlloi!J; ... . . .·. _.,,_: ..., ..., ,. ,;:,:..... . ... ~- ~-=. < "<- • ~ ' ' "' "' • ,~,.~ , , .... -· --~---- • • :-: •••
~~ lu IP..E-. C.tlr~-~-~- ..... :t. - . _. ./- . -~--:..:-·;~<··::.:r~:. -· ..... ~.--"·-·-···---- .. .
~, ll.iSSA&Y.·545.s.u.>2d 2-J;;\i.; f ··;J~{"'5·~··; . ..::l''' 7'', .,_ .. "
. "!. ""~l~.,.',fHAI G~5,ul.&.l J9~ r~ . ~M!:~·At.1•j.3~ 'f
·..,c:-. ···nj, SAJ: E:Ttl C,l}S &td .2cJ 1/o~. ~ .fd=ah: . ~J,4 ~hf.f,:::~.51~J.,_ / , .. '~ u, 6Uun4 L• IQ.l)H.~tt L' t&M _.135 12·LL13k;I~I41S-lli·~Ur1J.... f1rl-J'l\. Onoc. LL WAIILD 1A %11 6•1 d• 1d ~\3 Tblt 1~'1.~.:ctl;!lJq!"~1C, ·1.3. 4tJw.u~ .2.31.. s,u.r od .ao• n:-x. Cxh4t.4alL:1Cl~-~. ·-'· ; ::,.;
IJ~uuo r~. . ~· ... :·:· ... ' . · ··· · ·· · ~········ • -· ··: · · --- --·.· ,.~·=.·- ·.•.·.. -·H=?··~-~.-:::.~.'~;~~9.::~-f::::•,:.-:·:_~_;;·.=:::... - ~ · ~- • .. ·• ·~·::" ···· ..,.,. • •.··x·..;···;.; :.· · • ~-
l. T&. Om/r, tl1di-. ~gg,2.21 (A-)(_t-b)(Ai~l!.JQI!-L~:tO·. -- It ,,, ''• •....,., 1_,... ;., .• · .
S.IIlU:.iUJuJL(ll:;_tLJ~ C11&.__::_~_ __,.......-,- .... ~~~.~~~ch;:~~rhcJtbmir ···rnt:. ·g,J
·ril\g l ~ ldMt< 1K u~ A k.Auri:IJ. ~JJ1;l.K-.. L.j_J)C)t~ JAlQ J\Jf .· IJG .ll ei1, J j n 14 L 1! lr11lll~: .uJ.i J.l. • [MJJTitljl \ fll w. L'Jknt\i"l A ;Jl1(¥)i~ 11JYJII:l0tti&;i&!·~~uKLJ~~-. ' •' ~. ,:
. dK.d t1. vi ru ;)J(l,OJR-M~}ll ·~t&: .kl~ t;.f: 11.A r1ri t11l'
. 11Ji04., lr Jdr~i!. ~ifl.JJI\AIIt1U~Y;~~-ll.~l!·li4Lt. d...u.ILJE. . ~e,[u5,rJ ILl ,A, J\ t~ dKJ 1.\rt .GilecJ .~kAt;]·ciukJ6 . .. . . ., . . . . ..... . . '. .. • . . . . .. '' .,~ ' . • • •... · . • . .•.•·• ·.-· ......... ,. <;·<"":'">.' .· ·"·"'"·','"'"'"(8 ·'' ·..".>''"<:"'%'»·\~··< ' .. ,, ... ' ., ,
f,
11rud ()I oAc.J i 0116. T!dut. l1 CC~J.<:::·;n-J~• ,:)(SliJiUk.IU< File.rJ l!al:L .J)K i alAI - I AJ It j [ J l F..lk!4p d t1 MUd 4i l J i flA.· T!;ij, . ;ifll CilqnJ C!F jj~I~JJ '!J;Jl!! .1-l.lailLll ruf_ l· l t5 .. 1\ u JL:J .rtJC. , ~ .J.1 Llldl ,,f·:;:;:-:,·,·~::
~ -~-·~ .... " ·'"" . .
. l1 ltti·y i ul.k I~ t<21t{r l ~ i • Jr ~ , fJk.J ... ,":: .. J::::• :.,,;,L ;o .. 11J irl4 Lluf ~~W u0\Sr i u_y_wc. J ud4f. u~qJltb1-tf~llld JU Il+t L11Li~- f'JI1~tm:I'iu~-~-· Ji.J.d~.L--L'Atvi .i>~!.Li6 cJ1u.ttLUL.1:tLLUiiLlhA_~~~~ . ., , R~v. 01.14/14 FUK _--......,..--_ - -l ~ Al: .. ,. ~~-------------~-,~~.-------- _ _ _lf>5u_o...__~JL
;l· .
i111 kAd~I CJ vd A ayJ C&.t,14AiJ JA l tl) ttt'l~- E?Rcl i" u16 TI-ll- Iu; A I Cl'ltJifl "'4116[ ;#.rilQ.. i k 1 du.cltU< rtJ11r ndf. {)£Jiri i:ltt.JU MJ\11 ~irl4u Ac.c.a ()I ~ullul duJ1JJ4C..kLir~' & 1Ji6 C.~tt ~~ ru.:;, /1cJ Ur q1 vr kJt~l.-CtJ~~idQM!l r IrJAJ 1!.1 131! d etll i a rt1 IJ~rllt I!:h'lye,. >J,j D't1a.J~ i 6 A l'\AiK\i6HMiA\t:\~l., t\~t:TIJt~.d;:.tiLiJ1~JeJ1- ) . . . . .
H1u rUt. Cil1 !td dF ll~GA
rtb: Tui&l CltJuf Ft1iltd fll ~tltQ ...· ... · · • • · · ·· · · · • --, " · . '}j:', h.-~' <. ~=-=··~"' ~~-r~, ·. ~-;·v:::.:··· ~- ·, ...,....,,.~..;.~-'- '
5TAICMQ ff r1r "•ltJMJ~:5-t:JfQiiC1uJ.· l1 - - - -_ --- -=r·· .·:- - - -- . u.
._XlAio C111 J!iA .UF C.ki\c~M•~ltt&i . .• ~Ul1-Jdtt6 d 1..< 1·.11 i. k lA l JtJt{I6CJl r:riiJf\J,,,.i,J;:~,Qtj·J({lX)AtlC ~ Tu TEX. 14. App. ~nLic .. #.. 52._. -(·~c~r~& .
ll ~=-------------~----~-------~
~ . ... , . 5..11Y-t.lv.tllllLJ-L.1f~-J:tJt:.~t1~
. 0Aii6 l~t!~IUWJ t-~ lk1Mi65,·a~ J.j:·;·CM~ •i
" ·1 ·r\A- '/\ . 1-tl\ (!tl~ J{,}l 1 ' 11- V1 '1 ~ ~ ·; ~ JU( -Lt L I<~. w+1tdl}-~.! ~~~ T I'- < .n- r . .·..:..:.~·. ·M · _-p::_·- f=:'·t.. -H~f'LU-AJ ,• . -~
·f:.J AI!Jd . l(.j;j: c.C.IJLJH l- Clr ll:~fl·-:;A~':~.l! J4~.Jt lr!Ave_Td i\WQ.SS. IHj;.~J.Likt ~Oc td~- t&4\~ . \':IK.-~5dJLJ6 i:jj u.. iT~ r: A; \u ~ttL Td ~u 1Q.,. f, · . . .,,.! _:.
Re,v. OT/14/14 -------~· _____..................... .. '•''' ..,._._,,_ 'G.R:o~··· ••• • n •••••• •••• , . . _... • u • • '"'' •• •••umH on mp••••· ••• m • • .,. n ••
. · · "· · ·.............. _:·-·'"·<-tllt>t lOL-.. .Cll: .. -. fDi6.CAt-J';i:l·d·il:t''~''''·"·. .,f<···· •• ' . '•' ' ,._,••... ;o-;•->·, ..•... ' ·-:·· •••. ' ~·-· :· .•..
fACTS SUPPORTING GROLTN'D: . . - -----.----- - - · ..... -- -- - ---IUF t Jifi'A\ Ci1LlwJ J.?IJts -[-.4f\·ld--- _, ___ _ • • ••• '. y•• ·········"'""''; ••••••••••••••• ·-···· • •••• ....
W AuiQ. 1111 TJ-\t: (lFiiii ~~- ~~Y.Jil~l Mi'1Til)a>6 As d . p]Q 1:\c.l i u4 .ltl i Q4i • 1. A. ~etl~,"~A.hle ..AN!fu.JT :
t\E 1 i b Ao _i •l- t• HJ; eJJ .111 cl,j._ Ll1d _____:~...... . • : ·, •' • •• • •• '' '- -.. •-, .•··~ •• • , · , ' -~•.••-; ,. ' • •-~-• >'-''<"'••,•:.,..,.·-~-~ .. _iL ·•·•:..·~"">;~;"}<''>'•'';·<·~c••f'"•·~---v. "''' • . _. _ - .. ·: .... - ,•••'""· ·--•~~ '
, STAtt\ClAKLl t1P ·t6&<~.i~.t) ..... L......... · ·-·--··. " rvtt\l>ClA"A'Jo ~oJ iL}: ' . ' i6. AliJ . . fi.:rliAt~t
At'tA I· ~t.Mu:ltl· $, J:.r I t&:. fiAJJ141!J.~IIJIJ.l~ &1 ' ;2&5 u.u.\ &l lal9 ·- b2.3 ·I~. ~'tlt411,,{1~J1r,tli• .-. pi1:dt.e.e d'"
iot\ . A"\ 1:2St JfJS _I1ult \ It] ll Wse... 0allLM.tt:l, A ·. Qla.Ji-J,( dJ cl i 5eJu r i t1lLI r\K iiJr. \li dl ~Ji.t'J~t Jl£. 1,\ . dtJlil i u ~ pct.se cl ·b..l .l A«. L Jd 1-Iuu 11Ju<.t. "i6::;~;,~,)'~;-J!)nt~ 1-k.lF ~u . Aif. £nvttd !Ia ~ \tl.W· :tr. L•lt!IK~ N ~lH'JL~ 'b-?1 ~ s.tLhad ~ T£X, 15~.1 Ll~i~. ~~~rMcH~ rJ~~dJiv~ Jyl~~5dnJ \J ruuKTU MuuJ tlfv 4(J(JU\l6 1 od 5':.w. ~cl Gtt.,-'1 11 Tfi. 111 'i(.5 Ll~i~L{. ·(JntlUtd i!Ll~. T6 51.\-L\W ... <;,.
·f_'~1i l \ t M a..uT ru tvt !l HJLJ).\ u tJ5 A.(\ i·ti ~(
.A ~f.TiTilJLIUt IUL16T (\) s\11L1 nl1T d~ I~A) uU . Ado~d11IG.~uAq£1qllclaul m.~~lfRUSJU.: A~l- .,;
.f,~t£1 IJ l\ 14A . ll u1 (~ ) tldf . Ac.l. ~Ut!J4~T fit. ~. tli- u (lo II ocl _is _M i' & 'if>TlJ< i Al .Aa tl-dJaf,?~~.~ ~uji h r~1dl- 1: . . ' -~· .
\If. A Cl i'6C HJ.Ii \11 lAm~ ·11w -ltlcJ \c. ,AjlJ":~flo.boi 0, l. ' ~ . :; .·, . .
s:, d ctJ ~J17 .:p-;x, k::!M.M r:llfl+l,·· ~t1/17; ooo~ Lli.Ju Ll~ 6 ola Pni~.lJrUAI. CJ
~~ CJt llA A(¥1, ~t1115,. r _ .. . "··. ,_., . ·· . {'··:
JU,:' l l Jl Ttlli Q I lJk TJJ,~ '(\l1'}A,.Ql.~:i·« tl..A!hiJ)!;L.,EJ:liltA A~ff. C.lluuJ ,;l:l5T r 1111\/ ic.TitJuJ .•-~.(j~U.JO;ti•lillu ll liJi c.J-1 A .5TM): Oi SJwicr cIJtl!M i<>l!Klli'-;· Jd ~ JAi Id Ttl ~~ ,t •... 11~' mr. .Pf.ri rit:ll\ IM6 E,iJ,R.(~~·~M!Jfi 11 ~. t:.> ' ' . ' ' ' •, -. ; . ' ' ~ ' . ~i
A,~~ plucl i a. ~~ • A1d. Ill£. J::l~ ,lqvi:IJ~+Ji::l ,C.11, JpJ ·51 1t.u .l\ .. !l< ,J1oN 4 wJ1111ld ~ag.~:J:::n ::v.J~lll.EM6\~~J- . ; ;,::_~
ClAll AU5 Tl.lMt'1t )~lJ JUi5 .Pfl,J.wl:J.~:G ··4·~~~5.,:ltltt"' -· '" . ~
, i0d f~f i Uu aM1uLIILj TJ.!C j{)Eiiri~IIJu cJAJIJ • i5 dtll WquiLilbliU ~ WKi{ ur~ I~A~~ W· , K..ptJ0 putt5u A~tJl Tt1 J1 11..r t, ~ 1o_ ll, a1 ·~ cu;~y.:()l/1.46!4 · -. · '
~ TI~G:. Tt:i, ·.~clo.., dF (!Jt_it\iL \Cln L!L ,\o01AJ6t. 6TwuL
~ . \-\A~ kJQJUlJ p.\A~td uud.u .W~til. ~liJusL AJUd r Aa' 1\JJjl~ llJ Qp;} IJJF \5TI1a IG1 1!14 cJo.]JG ·.J:!rt!• J Lrtl . ~ 4 Utlu on t.Qu 11, llle t~lq di.PW~U H u;l I)KUill" I
· AvA\ i Abll'" F\JJ.t:loJJf£a llo A·JlJ 4v.e.~tJtJL .fu&<- ~u i& 5fu~ E~-ptittl~ ·vrth\t.. }\ u~ b. iu-·Ja.,:J.• JSS-,.0.5:lJEJt, ' . ·.
:CJLiJ\A, t\(¥1.: G:.b 13. :lt\t:tl, 2 . . . . . . ~- .
- · . · · . ·. ·· · ... ·.;· -~-,. .:"~ · ... · :·· ·:· ...:· ···· ..,!.· ..~~-,\,t<.c-:"'~:~,:;.:.r~.·:·:.:··... y,,,.... ·~=~f'e·' ·.:... .., _:-~
· u IIJw A ,llri!'1Iil'h.LI6 iO!il~tGUfkj ()ttJi~ lot fu .Ill } 6l14.c.i AL ct'1t 114( Jili:. Ac.J;~tK.• 4JJLI~i rJ RJ.ti u ~ Aul iAu l,i tiLl tJ f)d11 1 I$ Mid (.( ll~;_;.i~ 4 ;Mi Ui-,51- . :1
E:.Kilk \·- /\~1 •5f& F: l i J;· U +l\a )ft:•::.Cl:-f,,,\f~t\Jl:\11 \) ~J ej\ \ I ~- . ~ .
>a~1 ;s ....J ~d J6.1(TE~j
.E.Vb.Ji. idA:J /1~ .i&At'>ltldAhJg.1.'t:iMl-- (a;;~iTIJijlt ..wJ4iW ·.TCJ ' . . ··-':{"' ):.: .. . .
[; .. ·.. . ...
pt.lt~&?·~"A .. a·r~ tMi,IB"{it~ •·AL9Yibf·•;;~~:.S4P9q. v. qJ:\K.{!jA I • • -~· ' '
~45 s. i J 2tJ14st· L.JEX. J\\l)r;···t:,~._\_t,8~trJl~~,il!~·J~1.1~.nu,.j~. p;oJC... '
A• r uu l ~Yr. ~ t~1. Jq'i.2 L11Li L\. f)w uc.., :· . ·i . R¢y.•Ol/J4(l.4 :. ·.--..·
<}I} ;•
, i..ltL.Kt. 'ttl ClALf6 )J/.\6 Pil061lL;\ ~ TUut.t- hlllL A ~ IUI1a.td ilkAI.Jj 16 J\Pf.l~•1fl u lAl £. Tit ~ ~lll:, iML TI-l~ Tu..itd C.l1tH1111 kl!Jid 11 tJtAA.i&l~ A,d ~fl(~4~ocj~ .di6t~tll- +.
WJjkL 5Fi CJ!i\Ds \J 5ciAul1)e 1~~ S.il)a91d.~!~ds Ct'Ti&.l~ ~IA~ ....• ;
UJ;Jj )J l\All\q_ ]14 5.idw&d 2Gfl. ·ta.·.A~flL,O\Jl., ..~~~G iL~,·~~ (\K•j~JI \5~- A(lpt-.A !di'( ..· _, I ,JO: ··L ~·fi ,(\15(1 lLi~.SAM
\J. ...1J )itlt'llu 64.5 . s,,_,J ....ad. ..2to6 ":;'"'· f rnli:."eautif It>~ . .... ILj664[t.A .
· up ct rut. pt.Tiii o,._l_t...f.·P' .tt J~ift. . k'o.O.,-~J\1~:.-·K~J l' " r¥ t<:>l .j'u ~ . /) ; "' . dilhJL\ TIJ~. CJ1ulif 6fAted TUtif. :,fltb;. . A!~~.,~)QQtd_A4JJ .Klt..l5f · '
#.i llq, il~d4,K .nlM lUi=. {)l;Jil.i!h·;U.:.~M•I··fill-14<. At.t.- I' I E.(.lr ui6 ~1.1li u~ llt:< An lll'.u. IJ;:,''c~~:.t.lJ ~lr02 Jd~~·r ~ . .i
~ ~J. :!.:? I (A) l ~}\\lui\ mJ IG~X.lJ;,(l, ..fu-~F~ .CD~tilAJA Oi1 ' ;~
·•. . .... . '.. . . ,. . . ' . ' ... , .. ···, . . .. ,. . ...... , . . . . .... .~
··~· ,' ····-. .... :·.,·.·:·, ~""'"'""'·:''o:.'i'·'~>:<,<
~!
. ;
., . /.;., ........ ..,.;..·.. ,·,....-.-.... "·: .·,::-~·: .... :~~.:':'.~"=··'·'"·:·-Y.. , .:.~·.;-.:;:·~·.•.('<, ~,.. .;;x:'.'.:,:,~~:.:~:.... .
7 GRQUNllTWO:
_,........,.;..-.,.---,..,----L..::.A:!..12.·lL>~Iu...J5=!.Ji' e.,""'". . J.. lt1u..:. F. .:. . . .-..e...lL)..u.l6lo.,;.t. _~t.,I;L;K"""L.L,;L[i.__.O~l~L. ;. . .··;.;..;....· ;,.· . ~-.,. ;~; )',
~~: t.~. ' - ....•.... -~- .. • ,- '• • • <';u,>·:<·o•O';•• •• ·'·~· ~;····" :•! :• •" ·~··<' •: .. ,-<;:('~''"'- ~., ., • • +•'·<~' ''"'~ "•w.• ·.'""'" • ' ._._,
l'A(:TS ~Ui'POR'I'ING GROUNDTWO: -:-u G: . h F-rJA .•• c,.J. 11! •t1J-= 4 ~pi!A!b J
.. go..\11\lt.d U1 q•tt:1&11 Dli;:_ ~I ITi!t,J,LJ.t.~ ..bJth..JJA--IL.ALi:S ·. . ,. . ,. .
. ~cliLI: bcilv;>e,J1i6 A~tM.i...•~!i<:!ltLtudr Wu· IAiat· ~u~"'nt= It4M;.~:.J!4}M~··:X4~t~ . ~gP&LvU?.l .n4t. I\J.L1)1t! Lis A1 rd ()Ia Ad tA 1~6 · ,l . K,l.~fttf~d 4ffi . . r
C~J:Lo..[. 6\Joaf~.tt.~ .. c.9.J.ii\_GC-A. Tf~:l.ll.k:;.:~~)~b::' .... ::.:~-· · . 51 4 k !GIA11 cl dE .14Q..V:t¢.~ .. · · · ·· ' ·"' ·· · ... ··· . ··· · · ···: ··· ·· · ·· ... · "';" ····> ::;;~·.=·;>,co..~'"\~?--{('·~· J · ,.· ·; ·· : ··f.,_,_ _., ,, ;•,.
(6 n:l!: 61\ILAO. !-\:» it L. ~qru~L!Il.lc.{t. diU€.} •.E." )ri·rtcL M u 'l.:Tt1 . . MAr~.t14~.Al_.!Q . A~ti~..t; ~ . j . ., , . , . , . • . j.. : .
. <... i·o. rhh:. ~AnAL: As i.i-~., Cl:.tf.Llun.:Jq;,:~-:"0·&:~).:·· .... l\(1Q~l.t4TF tw.g,q4··~A;~}J}iJ .. . .It.!~ i\ tA 1 u n..f. ur: ·o4i5 cJA; lkl -~ /\11-.i 5( FttuJtA • • ~ .• :. ·. ·• • • · · :< ,: ·~--:;:,-~ ,<-·"'•.1-."' ·~;:~·-·-::;;:;;::~~-~·;x,----~~-··"""" ··_;·:·;>' >.'I'T• -···-.)~-:.~ ~--- '···· • d """'-•"'· · ' " · ' .~ ••
Hh\ r- i i>o4 C.Du M t1t:' t\ pflM1:; .ttl~:.!FXtfc~ lf'[ Oi~1 t.ls. ~ef...IJ.u&. rHt A~CL.t IArt.. Cilud dt}OOTiTuJu:.l iT~ .. .,,,.,:. . {
tlp i'u i uKJ Fu K rl-lAT r1 f rl4~ r HA·Nt l+Uu·HI /lud clll.I ~ UillJ~ rUnf iT Wduld ~uLt~ A. ·ai'f+QJL.o.JT WuULl- . · · Rev. OT/14114 ~ 6i tlkJ. uwc'4uLd5 Tf·~E T1~ J.d ~uKI6 fA(\ LiQ riJ · ulc.. .. 5tf tj\tl~"Z..tiU llod ~.w ~d AT····fL,tc(o, f\w ·rUt_ tJrJ ly lJ 'J.h~ 'fu e.Jau~CL} ff}t_ b.Julll t'lf: JlAQ~ Til ltXiAL A WILif uf: MA.UdAUL.b !llJAiu~J TIA~ ·ru_iM CJ.1u4 . . \6.Tl~~wyU ·n-~ e.LJ,J;tf 11r: C..wi~JitJJl:l .A~lUU.s ulZ T£i.M . ... .. ~ ~ .
- ~6L Tl~~ T4.~~ Ll~ ~Jfiu i·s IUdT Ull\1Ui LAkJ1L b..f W!~ !J or. t~Jlbe.AO C.Uiif)U" AJ~uAttJf''·n1 Au;cJL U1 nt: u. m: ·rt:x.. c.ud~ Or: CJ{j'k/1 •. ()nd~· bafA.JSL drutJL .lA As ldaw pLI-1&... uude.K W~t~l- ~lt.Jut>L ~ud tAu· tUdf Mu.J TJ4i.- 6ri11LJGI!.\nili dl~ Attr. tl.~1 ~ 4 b~ p1!L51Wllu~ IUWiy di3etlvuo_c1 t1K LJttJAvA \. i !l Ia IL- E..vilJUJ ~ ·J'Jc Au AvLxJIJL fL1K ~dJ I tf,.. ~ t:x.-·pAJ(Tl:: 0fuAJL ,.tUt1o i.JK- 22-1t35- o6 (rGd.. &J'ki_, 11~{1 ~b to. 1dtl~). tLti Ni:.ST u i Jl \ --l\ tJ TU-t:. Ci1J i(f U1: fl()(}o.A\.5 l41b. J Ll Mi.6 cJ i~ i UKJ -nj . cJi·KCU!J Tu:t. TMA'A-l CiluKJ rd MAUt.. /J. d~t..i0jtJkJ tUnilu4l4 i-SS Uluuu. 'l1~ MAuclA MLJ6 :·As A iv\ ~~ut:.sr~iM --Aer~ ~u· .3/.\I~Ty ,. · 945 :s.w, ~d ~~ ~ ·(JE:ii AflJ. ~Au• 1\)l.frtJ ru1 n 1qq 1 OKJ tL)Kii~ y. ~ll -l j ll '-t
.,. .. ,0KAL\
TlJA1 T~l16 c_utJKA Alliuu1 1Ji7 u~ 1lk 6 T14 tDuifi 1\~\s Tlj ~Q;)(JuucJ Td r!4L LJ~1 ur. M"'udA~tlu5. Aa:J ~ · b1uo.61 d r. Tl4e T11.-iM Ci1u tJ ft hJ,uJAot .d lhJ U~<.iq i l.l4L Ul~i t l1T- rMJiA1-T~~tA·Jstt_,(i·td·r ~ drJi/flMWT ur- ~~~To 1=-vtdk.if CJl,_j~ lulL 9 \ --4 2 '-! 5~ T AW 1\16 ~ ~Lhlu ~·r a~ ·n4J. 5n1 C!nu u.A u,: 1\pPEJl;\6 Ttl hJ!
· AII:Kw lu_. vrtJuL ()EJiTiuvu · f....·ll.. ) A ·ri-\E- 5 ·n~ r__ou~~tT ur: /1t1()DJ1;~ IUWllUJ.kJdu u(Ji ~ 1uu ·~ y'; i _... ./·
DENY; and Opinion Filed June 4, 2015.
In The Qtourt of Appeals lJiiftq ilintrirt of Wexan at ilaUan No. 05-15-00661-CV
IN RE ALFRED LEE STONE, Relator ....;:. :, ..
Original Proceeding from the 283rd Judicial District Court Dallas County; Texas Trial Court Cause No. F-9i-42452-T
MEMORANDUM OPINI'ON ...---s::Before Justices Lang, Fillmore, and Evans / Opinion by Justice Fillmore Relator filed this petition for writ of mandamus requesting that the Court order the trial
court to rule on various post-conviction motions filed February 2, 2015. To establish a right to
mandamus relief in a criminal case, the relator must show that the trial court violated a
ministerial duty and there is no adequate remedy at law. In reState ex rei. Weeks, 391 S.W.3d
117, 122 (Tex. Crim. App. 20 13) (orig. proceeding). Further, as .the party seeking relief, the
relator h~s the burden of providing the Court with a sufficient mandamus record to establish his
right to mandamus relief. Lizcano v. Chatham, 416 S.W.3d 862, 863 (Tex. Crim. App. 2011)
(orig. proceeding) (Alcala, J. concurring); Walker v. Packer, 827 S.W.2d 833, 837 (Tex. 1992)
(orig. proceeding).
The mandamus record before us does not include a certified or sworn copy of the trial ' court's docket sheet or other proof that establishes the trial court has failed to rule on relator's
motions. TEX. R. APP. P. 52.3(k)(l)(a) (appendix must contain certified or sworn copy of order --~
complained of, or any other document showingthe matter complained of); 52.7(a) (relator must
file with petition certified or sworncopy of every document material to relator's claim for relief).
Absent such a record, we cannot conduct a meaningful review of relator's claims. Lizcano, 416
S.W.3d at 863 (Alcala; J. concurring).
We deny the petition.
ROBERT M. FILLMORE JUSTICE
150661F.P05
-2- .,,
Order entered June 4, 2015
In The Ql:ourt of ~peal~ jfiftb Jli~trict of 'lEexa~ at JlaUa~ No. 05-15-00661-CV
IN RE ALFRED LEE STONE, Relator
Original Proceeding from 'the 283rd Judicial District Court Dallas County, Texas Trial Court Cause No. F-91-42452-T
ORDER Before Justices Lang, Fillmore and Evans
Based on the Court's opinion of this date, we DENY the petition for writ of mandamus.
We GRANT relator's request for return of the exhibits attached to his petition and DIRECT the
Clerk to return relator's original exhibits. We ORDER relator to bear the costs of this original
proceeding.
Is/ ROBERT M. FILLMORE JUSTICE Order entered June 22, 2015
In The QI:ourt of ~pealg .:Jf iftb JHgtrict of mexag at 11BaU~g No. 05-15-00661-CV
Original Proceeding from the 283rd Judicial District Court ·Dallas County, Texas Trial Court Cause No. F-91-42452-T
Before the Court is relator's motion for reconsideration. We DENY the motion.
/s/ ROBERT M. FILLMORE JUSTICE
~ .. ~ ,J'" ' I •• . . i : . • ' '· .. ~ .f ' ..
. .! 1.~ f ~ • •; • • • r:.· .-·-.,· : ..: ''.':.:t •.. \ .... ) 8· ll·-\t. .r,t i ,4;I ~ MJ f>r~·r £ Mo.AJT d r r.:AA~..J~ ; r1-te r Kikl ('jj~Ju.A r JtA'Nl u Tu..Aus~ ipr s .. ·
. ,. . ;~.-
~ · TUE. W ILi T ttr. M~udllAA Ll5. .
..·. . . \. . \~ .. I .1
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF TEXAS /ld6t hJ DIVISION
1\.IFK ed }.oL oroi'JL 5Gl1~b6 Plaintiff's name and ID Number
Place of Confinement
CASE NO. _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __ (Clerk will assign the number) v. TUc f-\ (=n! ~u~t;\ d\: Af>pe.Alo APPLICATION TO PROCEED
~i l!k M~uiS IN FORMA PAUPERIS
Defendant's name and address
1,41. F111U\ l.t.L 6\0ttJ, ~clare, depose, and say I am the Plaintiff in the above entitled case. In support of my motion to proceed without being required to prepay fees, costs, or give security therefor, I state because of my poverty, I am unable to pay in advance the filing fee for said proceedings or to give security for the filing fee. I believe I am entitled to relief.
I, further declare the responses which I have made to the questions and instructions below are true.
l- Have you received, within the last 12 months, any money from any of the following sources?
a. Business, profession or from self-employment? Yes 0 No@ b. Rent payments; interest or dividends? Yes 0 No~ c. Pensions, annuities or life insurance payments? Yes 0 No~ d. Gifts or inheritances? Yes 0 No~ e. Family or friends? Yes 0 No [a/ f. Any other sources? · Yes 0 Nog/
If you answered YES to any of the questions above, describe each source of money and state the amount received from each during the past 12 months.
2. Do you own cash, or do you have money in a checking or savings account, including any funds in prison accounts? Yes 0 No rz(' If you answered YES to any of the questions above, state the total value of the items owned.
·AATCIFP (REV. 9/02) 3. Do you own real estate, stocks, bonds, note, automobiles, or other valuable property, excluding ordinary household furnishings and clothing?
Yes 0 No~ If you answered YES, describe the property and state its approximate value.
I understand a false statement in answer to any question in this affidavit will subject me to penalties for perjury. I declare (certify, verify, or state) under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and correct (28 u.s.c. §1746).
Signed this the _ ....,,.3,___ _d.ay of __,;2=· ,j U \ ~ , 20 ~6.
YOU MUST ATTACH A CURRENT SIX (6) MONTH HISTORY OF YOUR INMATE TRUST ACCOUNT. YOU CAN ACQUIRE THE APPROPRIATE INMATE ACCOUNT CERTIFICATE FROM THE LAW LffiRARY AT YOUR PRISON UNIT.
2 ~ATCIFP (REV. 9/02) "i CSINIB08/CINIBel2 TEXAS DEPARTIYIENT OF CRIMINAL JUSTICE 07/23/15 E223/DPH2185 IN-FORMA-PAUPERIS DATA 11 : 1ZI3: L•6 TDCJ#~ 00599665 SID#: 03028672.LOCATION: ESTELLE INDIGENT DTE: 04/18/13 NAME: STONE,ALFRED LEE BEGINNING PERIOD: PREVIOUS TDCJ NUMBERS: 00562542 CURRENT BAL: 20.20 TOT HOLD AMT: 100.00 3MTH TOT DEP: 6MTH DEP: 6MTH AVG BAL: 6MTH AVG DEP: MONTH HIGHEST BALANCE TOTAL DEPOSITS MONTH HIGHEST BAL~NCE TOTAL DEPOSITS
PROCESS DATF.::: HOLD AMOUNT HOLD DESCRIPTION
NO BANKING ACTIVITY WITHIN THE PAST 6 MONTH PERIOD.
STATE OF TEXAS COUNTY OF~ ON THIS THE DAY OF :S: J(!; /0__, I CERTIFY THAT THIS DOCUMENT IS A TRUE? COMPLETE,AND UNALTERED COP MADE BY ME OF INFORMATION CONTAINED IN THE COMPUTER DATABASE REGARDING THE OFFENDER'S ACCOUNT. NP SIG: PF1-HELP PF3-END ENTER NEXT TDCJ NUMBER~ OR SID NUMBER:
,·············~········· :a~* • Demetrfc Phipps ·: .Dtary Plabllc, · · - - , - . . . • I ;;..rA IIIJ C-Jaalon Ea:pl... •
Itt............... ; 01'~ . 09/23.12015
Motarv W•thout a~.:J . • • • •• : liJ n.:tf CJ1 ulll l.1f. c._.u Jvl i Ukl l\p (}l.M6 A\ jZ 11td 1tL 6TlltJL 1\ .. - L.AuSl.I )Uu, . ·"'
fOETi Tj tJ fl_\Qj(_, I \1 l~ Fr ~T14 tnun.A ar: !la:JtA 16 Ait.JL MA-4 vJi6.. . ~!!.Spl1u::.IJWY. 1 ~ll.h'iuQJSr h:k A ~Q_,jpLJ.U3L rtt rue.. WK.il f!1: MAAJLl11JvitJ6 . . iiJ ~Lht~/WU. Ill TE:X. -1.. A~ .sa,_ j011Llt.. :P..,, me. tJffititJIUIU ~UJuur A ~(h1M.J6t.. m "Ilk. ILAAAJd111viU5 ~rtlitvl ntc. At5pjuciJWb. A11:1t££J 1O_L s·m1JL p&.liTiuKJUL t~JtJ i'l=-\ !!_.11 Tf.. t11: ~ u_v i CJL I fl11: n_td LD..L 5 ruu L (.)Er i ri uKJW. d.u 1.~ Q.Jil.L by ru f i f-t..\ Hi-M A r~tU .t. W(Ji-t- 0 f. ·114.:. ~lliu tul hJIL 1.\ ~~ ~. lJUStL Td T~ LJYI.AT ·dt: Mll~~lVftJS UAs kltt.MJ u.~i MA;Iu:\ Td: ·rnt_ ~dJJL LUultA 1.§ ~iMiuM tl,1~fN10 f1~ TB!AS rJ.d. 6dY 11. 3d~ ~p~·-ru' 0r111 1\.1tt.J Au~Tiu ·rt.i/16 1
~t: Tl~ r-i· ~ n1 Wuif u(: A?Jp~L~ 2JUd t::L ·~Eilwi1~ 1. 1.\U
(l) l aJ fl-l- t- G_ilu. £111 d ~ C_M. . i hA i 11 J/.lt I 11 pp~ lo A1r: 111 .q cJ \ O_L uT ,j kJ-L · ~Al.J~·L tt)L~. t/) ;:_T i T \ d ILJeJ,i_. lf \1 r~t.t_ F' [: ·rt4 (!_u tJ u1 L1 ~ A~ .po_A!L~ IAL5{) 1Jx I d AAJT • 1 ttJ uTi' ~ __[)__. lJ \: M t\ ~1 Jd 11 M LJ 5 ·IAJ i)LHf51JihJ£lL TU -rft, VL. Ar('· i)~ue .. 11.. ~;!Pt. ()~riritJtUVt Att:lfW lu...dn'1~tl•'- YtvL !Ub riLL TlJ rl>h: A lallvL Fi r-- nf O_jjuu r ,Jr A~ f]c>- Al.s fi-!AL A uJI!lir tJ~ ~Au JclA 11AU6 HA6 loUJJ t:,·l w A~A;u51 ·nt~ uJ ln4 iaJ n~ tl~U\IL CliiL\1 W Wu K--t n4~ M A n 1{1 11 '"J\ t.J6 i\ e_r , tJ u 15 1o As iL~'J u 9 u6LJ Abu~t- 0\Z {)i6CJAil1iiJJLJ h:lu qUuu_ f11i\tJJI[L ITl W h:htLL d11 Wfi\AraJ T1kf. rniM f' Uu0 m ~tJk_ LlKJ IUL\ fh1A.J (lud 4 F: l ~cl (Jt16f {l_ d11J Vi Lf ~(Jil} IAAU tt ~ LhJ6 All..ILl l()lwtJ iAJY6 TtJM n.IULL.l ()Q.l 1dl,uy kJ Q_..@ VLL lA I tJ . . /1.\ f' rt g_cl tM_ 6Tt:htJ~ .rp~::.Tl'f ItJ llJ w_ iJArE: £ 1-~ l ~ L kJ r 1~ ~ c...u u w:t 1:-J t= ·l'__ w·i 11\A ~~ n '~I 4p>()o-M, <) A\ t: VLUJ l 6 IOWAA.Jd FdVI ~ h'1M~Co .. ; g \ {)dK StJ 11-KJ u flj fiZjl, ~. A(l(1· {JL-t.l1L: A -
Tl-tE () j::_ r iT i LJ 1\j u AI ruP£1 l OL 5TUn ~IL tf)o JtJ A-11Ld (<) R:1K TWl~ lo~l Lhd PEK FzJ Ill 1-ViJhJU htClM.: Tl4t /J. fJP Vl!l.<. · rJ f.: Tt~II/') ~At 1uQJ IZ 11:: fiA t"_ i::l rJ "'X r) P f/A~ I~Ad J1. ta_yAl dt.J1Lj TI~AT 16 111= A llll1XI-di6 0t(l_XIJ1 KJAI A~r duJecJ r,j · n+~ !p[TiTiL'1~~~tl.K W- Ar L~,~ lJJk~ 1\llurJ.Jo_cJ Jtl1A_i6 a~~t_·r1 u 1tJ m UK.tt- vuT llllJT F141 \ .uJ rl1 cJ t1 ~u ~ . {)wAilYJ ·- /{~Glt JOJST L TW AT rWc. Fi r: m CD u uJ Ll r:: 11(Y)QJ.1/I "~ i :55 l- E. J1 rll_M iT t'lr: MA~tJdAM Jt<) A~AikJ~')r Judq~ A;('/1 bV!AL}~tllo"'\ n:t C.ihA(-laJ n1 ~111fL iJk I ~' rwup~ EK.1y ri!W jL)UtJl Pi1KJ\JrLTilhJ MttTit1d\') AJ q p cl rJ l o,/1 rJ i ,J 6 T14~T b\J llt d tl_al::l i n J lnllf7-w o.t:.fi Ll- A\ r- vtJLrJ ta_~_.J 6Tr1 n ~ e ,·. tDAI~ b1 l~ I~ (_\) lu ·r~ tuuJ df:· ~tliu1tJAl · 1\p().uJ/Ls A1FHJ~.d 1ttL 6TuuL CfiuuL uiJ, ()(liTiu u~ ., \J ·rt-te.. Fi ~ TJa Q_Uu K1 u1: 11 (J(JEMs i 1 A; I!JL MAi4ui6 .. ~~t()uruclMJT.,
MLlri· uij I:JK_ 1QJ1 vL Ttl h l tL A wu.,~r lJi~ vv1 A A1J t\1111 tJ6 r tLJ (_)uusuAMl!_L Tu fEi, ~. t\{-l(-1; f)Mile..; ~. lG ~ t()E11Tiu t\Ju. IA~u~-~ r tOJ1v~ ru R It.. 11 uJK--Il urv MA,rJd.t1Jt.A uu · . i u Ttl Tl4~·6 CiJt) wi. []: ~bLi hA iuLVI Ap(Ju~b . . J1n:vtuJ lLL ord.uL . p&-Ti'T i LlouLu.. llir\ ~ 1~1f. or.: 6Q_Jt v; u.. I Alf MiLl la.L oftlitJt pE.ltTiiJuu tJ(j l-~~JLL ~ ~JJ.JL~ ri ~=y ni-M A r w_ut. tuf}iL ar .114t! M1jr;uu HJu. luvL Ttl hIt- A W~tiT d{= MAillAMu5 1--ltts bLUJ u.61 'MA·.1ttJ rd: r~ CJW e.n Ud df. & i ~J i IIJM lif>flu.MS d!Z T8M ~ML ~I'N - 11 Od
-~ AD \ is1W lo~J dLJ :_ {)t'j(~_.i_HvlWTS ~~~~ c.A);r11if.. CiJkA.p\Q__fQ_~ f~ttiA\ ~dullif 5fJVf£.Ma_xJf ~65 ut: l~). ri4L£. trl~u (11o-r~ fH_iA\ ~Jj,_JM.I fukt15llli. (Jr6 .. (fJ li~E t0U1itL ~efJLliLL 11 i li:n tcl Iu_, 0rlluL ;rET if i u!JtK- u t_u..l U .~, MAi Ied fi:t ~ li~E cJ 11M ll. ei:luuJ l1 r: {_l_K;IU; JLl At t.lf1(18.llo di- TE.tA-s ().!1. ~ijll -1Jot1<2 tApin1l-5TATiiliJ AJOnlll fEXM t'6-zll LJnJ ··n-\i:S ~ 3 _ dA J df:_ Ju ~~_ __..b{u_§_ .. ·
/11 Fn_e.cJ I~JL 8TilJU·L f()Eri ft"utJ~.