Stephens v. Bacon Park Commissioners

Supreme Court of Georgia

Stephens v. Bacon Park Commissioners

93 S.E.2d 351, 212 Ga. 426, 1956 Ga. LEXIS 397

CourtSupreme Court of Georgia

DecidedJune 13, 1956

Docket19340

StatusPublished

This text of 93 S.E.2d 351 (Stephens v. Bacon Park Commissioners) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Supreme Court of Georgia primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook

Stephens v. Bacon Park Commissioners, 93 S.E.2d 351, 212 Ga. 426, 1956 Ga. LEXIS 397 (Ga. 1956).

Pincite

Opinion

Wyatt, Presiding Justice.

The plaintiff in error filed suit against the Bacon Park Commissioners, the Mayor and Aldermen of the City of Savannah, Thomas M. Ryle, and D. B. Calder, seeking to enjoin as a nuisance the construction of a “Half-Way House” on the Municipal Golf Course. He alleged in substance that, if the “Half-Way House” was constructed, his property, including his home, would be irreparably injured in various ways. A general demurrer and certain special demurrers to the petition were duly sustained. The exception here is only to the sustaining of the general demurrer. Held:

1. This court has held in a number of cases that the mere apprehension of injury, based upon the assumption that a lawful business, not in operation, will be operated in an improper manner so as to become a nuisance, is not sufficient to authorize the granting of an injunction. See Collins v. Lanier. 201 Ga. 527 (40 S. E. 2d 424). A court of equity will only exercise the power to restrain the erection of a building and the maintenance therein after construction of a lawful business on the ground that the operation of such business will constitute a nuisance where it is made to appear with reasonable certainty that such operation necessarily constitutes a nuisance, the consequences of which will be irreparable in damages. Elder v. City of Winder, 201 Ga. 511 (1) (40 S. E. 2d 659). Allegations of mere speculative or contingent injury, with nothing to show in fact that it will occur, are insufficient to support a prayer for injunctive relief. Rounsaville v. Kohlheim, 68 Ga. 668 (45 Am. R. 505); Barton v. Rogers, 166 Ga. 802 (144 S. E. 248); Powell v. Garmany, 208 Ga. 550 (67 S. E. 2d 781). The fact that the erection of a building will impair the view from the petitioner’s home is insufficient to support a prayer for injunctive relief. Standard Oil Company v. Kahn, 165 Ga. 575 (141 S. E. 643).

2. The cases cited and relied upon by the plaintiff in error are all distinguishable on their facts from the instant case, and all deal with the exceptions stated in the rales above set out.

3. Under the rulings above made, it was not error to sustain the general demurrer to the petition.

Judgment affirmed.

All the Justices concur.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Wyatt, Presiding Justice.

The plaintiff in error filed suit against the Bacon Park Commissioners, the Mayor and Aldermen of the City of Savannah, Thomas M. Ryle, and D. B. Calder, seeking to enjoin as a nuisance the construction of a “Half-Way House” on the Municipal Golf Course. He alleged in substance that, if the “Half-Way House” was constructed, his property, including his home, would be irreparably injured in various ways. A general demurrer and certain special demurrers to the petition were duly sustained. The exception here is only to the sustaining of the general demurrer. Held:

1. This court has held in a number of cases that the mere apprehension of injury, based upon the assumption that a lawful business, not in operation, will be operated in an improper manner so as to become a nuisance, is not sufficient to authorize the granting of an injunction. See Collins v. Lanier. 201 Ga. 527 (40 S. E. 2d 424). A court of equity will only exercise the power to restrain the erection of a building and the maintenance therein after construction of a lawful business on the ground that the operation of such business will constitute a nuisance where it is made to appear with reasonable certainty that such operation necessarily constitutes a nuisance, the consequences of which will be irreparable in damages. Elder v. City of Winder, 201 Ga. 511 (1) (40 S. E. 2d 659). Allegations of mere speculative or contingent injury, with nothing to show in fact that it will occur, are insufficient to support a prayer for injunctive relief. Rounsaville v. Kohlheim, 68 Ga. 668 (45 Am. R. 505); Barton v. Rogers, 166 Ga. 802 (144 S. E. 248); Powell v. Garmany, 208 Ga. 550 (67 S. E. 2d 781). The fact that the erection of a building will impair the view from the petitioner’s home is insufficient to support a prayer for injunctive relief. Standard Oil Company v. Kahn, 165 Ga. 575 (141 S. E. 643).

2. The cases cited and relied upon by the plaintiff in error are all distinguishable on their facts from the instant case, and all deal with the exceptions stated in the rales above set out.

3. Under the rulings above made, it was not error to sustain the general demurrer to the petition.

Judgment affirmed.

All the Justices concur.

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)

93 S.E.2d 351, 212 Ga. 426, 1956 Ga. LEXIS 397, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/stephens-v-bacon-park-commissioners-ga-1956.

Opinion

Related

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack