Steinert v. Ruppenthal

1970 OK CIV APP 2, 465 P.2d 797, 36 Oil & Gas Rep. 114, 1970 Okla. Civ. App. LEXIS 53
CourtCourt of Civil Appeals of Oklahoma
DecidedJanuary 13, 1970
DocketNo. 42172
StatusPublished

This text of 1970 OK CIV APP 2 (Steinert v. Ruppenthal) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Court of Civil Appeals of Oklahoma primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Steinert v. Ruppenthal, 1970 OK CIV APP 2, 465 P.2d 797, 36 Oil & Gas Rep. 114, 1970 Okla. Civ. App. LEXIS 53 (Okla. Ct. App. 1970).

Opinion

LAVENDER, Presiding Justice.

This appeal involves the judgment of the District Court of Garfield County, Oklahoma, in an action in which the plain[799]*799tiff in error herein, W. G. Steinert, asked the court to establish, and quiet his title to all of the Northeast Quarter of Section 19, Township 20 North, Range 3 West of the Indian Meridian, in that county, including all oil, gas and other minerals therein and thereunder.

The land was originally granted by the United States of America to one Christ Kretzinger, by patent dated April 15, 1913. Christ Kretzinger died on July 29, 1921, while a resident of Logan County, Oklahoma, survived by his wife, Anna Kret-zinger, and all six of their children. The widow, Anna Kretzinger, and one of the six children, Anna Allen, died prior to 1941. The other five children, fourteen children of various children of Christ Kretzinger, six persons who were claiming interests in the oil, gas and other minerals in and under this land under the fourteen grandchildren of Christ Kretzinger, and the surviving husband of Anna Allen, deceased, were named as defendants in the action, along with the unknown heirs (etc.) of Christ Kretzinger, deceased, Anna Kret-zinger, deceased, and Anna Allen, deceased. However, since the trial court sustained the plaintiff’s claim against all of defendants except the fourteen grandchildren of Christ Kretzinger and their six grantees and sustained their claim to all of the oil, gas and other minerals in and under the land, it appears that the fourteen grandchildren of Christ Kretzinger, and their six grantees, are the only real defendants in error herein. And, since those grandchildren support the claims of their six grantees, along with their own, we shall, for convenience, treat the situation as though the grandchildren had made no conveyances.

The plaintiff claimed his title through Charles Kretzinger (sometimes referred to as Charley Kretzinger or Charlie Kret-zinger) and Herman Kretzinger, sons of Christ Kretzinger, as devisees under the last well and testament of Christ Kret-zinger, deceased, and the order of distribution of his estate as made by the County Court of Logan County, Oklahoma, under date of March 21, 1925.

With respect to this particular tract of land (which, apparently, was the only real property in Garfield County which was owned by Christ Kretzinger at the time of his death), the order of distribution of the County Court of Logan County, Oklahoma, as evidenced by its final decree of March 21, 1925, is as follows:

“It is therefore considered, ordered, adjudged and decreed by the court, that the real estate in the County of Garfield, State of Oklahoma, described as follows:
The Northeast Quarter (14) of Section Nineteen (19) in Township Twenty (20) North, Range Three (3) West of the Indian Meridian.
vest in the said Herman Kretzinger and Charles Kretzinger, to be divided equally between them. (Provided, however, that in the event oil is discovered, the oil interest is to vest in the grand-children, born or unborn, as provided by said last will and testament.)”

For reasons which will appear later on in this opinion, we set forth all of the provisions of the last will and testament of Christ Kretzinger, which was a holographic will:

“Guthrie, May 18, 1920. Under today’s date it is my duty that I make this testament, and more plainer and careful, know that I and my wife later when we will not be on this earth, my children between each other in strife may not enter.
“1st. I have one son, George, at present in Ponca City, living. This one has already had $600.00.
“2nd. I have on my farm in Garfield County one daughter, Anna, residing. She, too, has already $600.00.
“3rd. Have I another two sons, Herman and Charley. They become each one 80 acres from the farm.
[800]*800“4th. Have I another son in Portland, Oregon, by the name of Willie. This one has not got anything.
“At present I have a house and three lots in Guthrie that belongs to me and my wife, and, should I die first, then it belongs to my wife, and should it be sold, then she still has a home on the farm until her death.
“Next shall they divide according to their best judgment, then if once oil is found on my farm, then shall the children divide it. George has three, Anna two and Willie one.
“Herman and Charley are single. Should they get married, then their children should have a share. Then have I another daughter in Kansas. She is married to John Herd. She has three children and they too have a share in the oil, and if there is some case money, they shall divide it among each other, and my daughter has a part. Her married name was Carrie Kretzinger, and her present address is John Herd, Russell County, Kansas.
“For executors I name Herman and Charley.
Christ Kretzinger.”

In its final decree, the county court— without declaring who, by name, were all of the heirs at law of the decedent — found that the decedent was survived by his wife, Anna Kretzinger, and all six of his children (naming them), and by twelve grandchildren (naming them) but that the court could not, at that time, say how many more grandchildren might yet be born (and did not declare who, by name, vjere the persons included in the class of “grandchildren” of the decedent). However, with respect to the tract of land involved herein, the court did find, and decree, that all of the decedent’s grandchildren, “born, and unborn, shall equally share in all oil found under and on said land.”

Subsequent to such final decree, two more children were born to children of Christ Kretzinger, and, apparently because of this last-mentioned finding and decree in that final decree, they, as well as the twelve grandchildren who were living at the time of the death of Christ Kretzinger, were made parties defendant in the instant action and in the mortgage foreclosure action hereinafter mentioned.

By answers and cross-petitions in the instant action, the fourteen grandchildren of Christ Kretzinger alleged that, by the above-mentioned last will and testament of Christ Kretzinger, deceased, and final decree of the County Court of Logan County, Oklahoma, all of the oil, gas and other minerals in and under the described land was vested in them, in equal shares, and, except for the interests therein conveyed by them to six of the other defendants, was still owned by them. They also pleaded that this plaintiff, as the successor to whatever interest may have been possessed by Thomas Wolf, the mortgagor-defendant in a mortgage foreclosure action numbered 18,879 in the District Court of Garfield County, Oklahoma, in which J. W. Hoyt was the mortgagee-plaintiff, was estopped, by the judgment rendered in that case on January 20, 1942, in favor of the fourteen grandchildren and against all of the parties to that action, from asserting any right, title or interest in or to the oil, gas and other minerals.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Oberlander v. Eddington
1964 OK 98 (Supreme Court of Oklahoma, 1964)
Long v. Drumright
375 P.2d 953 (Supreme Court of Oklahoma, 1962)
Hayhurst v. Hayhurst
1966 OK 238 (Supreme Court of Oklahoma, 1966)
Matthewson v. Hilton
1958 OK 6 (Supreme Court of Oklahoma, 1958)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
1970 OK CIV APP 2, 465 P.2d 797, 36 Oil & Gas Rep. 114, 1970 Okla. Civ. App. LEXIS 53, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/steinert-v-ruppenthal-oklacivapp-1970.