State v. Thornburn

Supreme Court of Vermont

State v. Thornburn

52 A. 1039, 75 Vt. 18, 1902 Vt. LEXIS 85

DecidedAugust 27, 1902

StatusPublished

This text of 52 A. 1039 (State v. Thornburn) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Supreme Court of Vermont primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook

State v. Thornburn, 52 A. 1039, 75 Vt. 18, 1902 Vt. LEXIS 85 (Vt. 1902).

Pincite

Opinion

Tyler, J.

Information for selling cider without authority. The State offered to prove, and the respondent admitted ten sales of fermented cider, and the court thereupon adjudged the respondent guilty of ten offenses, but allowed exceptions and suspended sentence. In this court the respondent concedes that the judgment below was in accordance with State v. Waite, 72 Vt. 108, 47 Atl. 397, but contends that the decision should be overruled.

In State v. Waite it was held that, as V. S. 446,0 classified fermented cider with intoxicating liquors, the permission given in section 4463 to sell cider, related to unfermented cider. This is the only reasonable construction of the two sections considered together, — the only way to give effect to both sections. The doctrine of stare decisis must be applied.

[19]*19 Judgment that the respondent take nothing by his exceptions; let there be sentence and execution thereof.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Tyler, J.

Information for selling cider without authority. The State offered to prove, and the respondent admitted ten sales of fermented cider, and the court thereupon adjudged the respondent guilty of ten offenses, but allowed exceptions and suspended sentence. In this court the respondent concedes that the judgment below was in accordance with State v. Waite, 72 Vt. 108, 47 Atl. 397, but contends that the decision should be overruled.

In State v. Waite it was held that, as V. S. 446,0 classified fermented cider with intoxicating liquors, the permission given in section 4463 to sell cider, related to unfermented cider. This is the only reasonable construction of the two sections considered together, — the only way to give effect to both sections. The doctrine of stare decisis must be applied.

[19]*19 Judgment that the respondent take nothing by his exceptions; let there be sentence and execution thereof.

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)

52 A. 1039, 75 Vt. 18, 1902 Vt. LEXIS 85, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/state-v-thornburn-vt-1902.

Opinion

Related

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack