State v. Pierce

2022 UT 22, 511 P.3d 1164
Utah Supreme Court·Decided June 9, 2022·No. Case No. 20200864·Published·Cited by 2 cases

Opinion

ÿ ÿ 2322ÿ45ÿ22ÿ

ÿ

ÿ

67ÿ89 ÿ

4 ÿ4 5ÿÿ5ÿ55ÿÿ45ÿ ÿ

88 ÿÿ89ÿ

!"ÿ

$%ÿ

&7ÿ'(ÿ)6&* ÿ

+",",-.ÿ

ÿ

7/.ÿ01011234ÿ

95678ÿ967:;ÿ<3ÿ0100ÿ

=>58ÿ'?@5ÿAÿ0100ÿ

ÿ

@ÿ*57B=/767=ÿB/ÿB;5ÿB6;ÿ*/?7Bÿ/CÿDD56>Eÿ ÿ

8;=78ÿF=EB7=:Bÿ6>BÿG6H5ÿ 8;5ÿ9/@/76I>5ÿJ57@=:5ÿ.ÿ8756E5ÿ 7/.ÿ<3<A1311Kÿ

ÿ

BB/7@5LEMÿ

56@ÿF.ÿ&5L5EÿNOOPQÿSTUVWÿXTYY75Lÿ.ÿZ76LÿEEB.ÿ/>=:.ÿZ5@.ÿ6>BÿG6H5ÿ *=BLÿC/7ÿ75ED/@85@Bÿ

76B;6>=5ÿH=I=@5ÿ6>BÿG6H5ÿ*=BLÿC/7ÿD5B=B=/@57ÿ ÿ

*96ÿ'86* ÿF&&78ÿ6?B;/758ÿB;5ÿ/D=@=/@ÿ/CÿB;5ÿ*/?7Bÿ=@ÿ[;=:;ÿ '86* ÿ) &* ÿ'FZ ÿ\G87ÿ7Fÿ'FZ ÿ*96&ÿ]/=@58.ÿ '86* ÿ) 8 & 7ÿC=>58ÿ6ÿ:/@:?77=@^ÿ/D=@=/@.ÿ 96_=@^ÿ75:?E58ÿ;=`E5>Cÿ*68 ÿ*96ÿ'86* ÿG ÿ8/5Eÿ@/Bÿ D67B=:=D6B5ÿ;575=@aÿF68&6*8ÿ'FZ ÿ'97ÿ'.ÿ\G87ÿE6B.ÿ F?5ÿB/ÿ;=Eÿ75B=75`5@Bÿ'86* ÿ9697ÿ8=8ÿ@/BÿD67B=:=D6B5ÿ ;575=@aÿF68&6*8ÿ'FZ ÿ9 Gÿ).ÿ*96&ÿE6B.ÿ ÿ

ÿ ÿ

01213ÿ56ÿ893 3ÿ ÿÿÿÿ

ÿ 93ÿ0193ÿ 21ÿ ÿÿÿÿ !"#$%&'"($!ÿ

*+ÿÿ-./01ÿ3/4/56ÿ78ÿ7ÿ978815613ÿ/5ÿ./8ÿ:3;<.13=8ÿ<3>?@AÿB73;5ÿC7Dÿ 8EÿFGFHÿÿGÿGHÿGFIÿJÿGÿIGÿHFÿÿGÿ KFLGHÿMGKKGKÿ1GKGNÿ1ÿGFIÿOEGKGHÿGHÿMNÿ 8EÿPGKKQÿRHÿÿESÿFÿÿGHÿGHÿOÿMNÿ1GKGNÿ MNÿ1GKGÿHHÿÿFOÿJHOÿGHÿÿ0GÿEGFHÿMNÿ8Eÿ JÿIHNÿÿ *ÿ0KQÿGÿÿOFÿGHÿGÿEPFÿTUVWXYWÿ JGFOÿMNÿ8EÿOSÿJÿKGJÿEIÿGHÿEKGIHÿ FGKKQÿGÿÿSKKHÿMNÿ1GKGÿÿOKZHONÿ1ÿHOEÿEÿ PGKKQÿO OOHÿMNÿ8E=8ÿ8<7<1[15<8ÿ<;ÿ9;0/?1ÿ78ÿ:1/56ÿ LGHÿÿPKGÿÿOÿEOGKÿFONÿ *\ÿ]EGOÿMNÿ8EÿOÿMNÿ1GKGÿGÿGÿEJHHÿOEÿ ÿ0GÿEGKKHÿIÿGÿGÿH^ÿJOOOÿÿPHÿOIQÿÿ ÿPOÿOHFÿÿOFNÿ1FÿOÿJOOOÿ FGKKQÿGFHÿGÿMNÿ8EÿGHÿMNÿ1GKGÿFGFHÿÿGÿGHÿ GFIÿGHÿGÿMNÿ8EÿOÿMNÿ1GKGÿÿOIOÿ HHÿÿOPGKÿI GÿJGQO_ GEKGKQÿGOÿÿJÿMNÿ 1GKGÿJGOÿGFFOOPÿÿGFÿJGHÿMNÿ8ENÿMNÿ8Eÿ [;`14ÿa;3ÿ7ÿ4/31?<14ÿ`134/?<ÿ7a<13ÿ<.1ÿb<7<1=8ÿ?781ÿ/5ÿ?./1aAÿ736>/56ÿ GÿÿPHEÿJGOÿOEÿÿPÿGÿMNÿ8EÿJGOÿÿ GEFÿÿOKZHONÿ1ÿHOEÿEÿHHÿÿINÿ *cÿMNÿ8EÿSÿÿOGHÿGÿGKNÿÿOHÿGÿMNÿ1GKGÿ d78ÿ:1/56ÿ7663188/̀1Aÿ.74ÿ8.;><14ÿ81`1370ÿ</[18ÿef=[ÿ6;/56ÿ<;ÿagggÿ D;>ÿ>9ÿ[;<.13aggg13Ahÿ.74ÿ<.317<1514ÿMNÿ8E=8ÿ:3;<.13Aÿ754ÿd78ÿ ÿÿGEÿÿOJFFÿOÿKFLGHÿGÿMNÿ8EÿJÿMNÿ8Eÿ ONÿ1ÿ0GÿI GEHÿMNÿ8E=8ÿ<18</[;5Dÿ:Dÿ9;/5</56ÿ;><ÿ GÿÿEGHÿOFEGKQÿIÿREKGQÿHGKÿGÿÿOQÿ ÿ PHHÿÿÿ KENÿ1ÿiQÿEPEHÿMNÿ8Eÿÿ IGOKGFÿLGOHÿÿI EÿOKZHONÿ *jÿMNÿ8EÿG GKHÿÿÿEÿÿG GKOÿGFFÿGÿÿ HOEÿEÿHÿÿHQFÿOÿIÿÿHEHÿPHEÿGHÿ Gÿÿ0G=8ÿ/[917?.[15<ÿI  KQÿEIIHÿÿOÿFÿÿ IGÿOKNÿ1ÿEÿÿG GKOÿGIHÿÿGÿ LKOHÿ HNÿ *kÿMNÿ8EÿJÿGOSOÿOÿÿPOÿÿEÿÿG GKOÿ GFFÿÿHÿÿGIFÿÿHGKÿÿOÿIÿÿHEHÿ PHEÿGHÿLQÿ.;04/56ÿ<.7<ÿ<.1ÿb<7<1=8ÿ/[917?.[15<ÿ4/4ÿ5;<ÿ`/;07<1ÿ OÿEOGKÿFONÿlÿGINÿ]EGOÿMNÿ8EÿHHÿÿLiEÿ ÿ

0123ÿ567ÿ8988ÿ ÿ88ÿ

11ÿÿ23ÿ02ÿ

ÿ ÿÿÿ !"#ÿ$ÿ%&$ÿÿ!"'"(ÿ!(ÿ)%ÿ *51ÿ3+ÿ,1-ÿ3.136ÿ2652ÿ5/ÿ5**3031ÿ3ÿ262ÿ533ÿ433ÿ 4316ÿ2ÿ23ÿ11621-2ÿ-25ÿ733ÿ566210ÿ12ÿ,56ÿ3ÿÿ23ÿ 8%!ÿ!'%ÿÿ(($ÿÿÿ12 35-232+ÿ43-563ÿ23ÿ*5,ÿÿ 23ÿ1663ÿ16ÿ6322*31+ÿ5/ÿ5**3031ÿ3ÿ,*1ÿ2ÿ533ÿ433ÿ4316ÿ 2ÿ23ÿ11621-2ÿ-25ÿ93ÿ5*6ÿ512ÿ23ÿ8%!ÿ!'%ÿ1315*ÿÿ:5ÿ ;13-3ÿ"ÿ)%ÿ8%!8ÿ&%8!ÿ<!'ÿ'))!"ÿ&8"!ÿ=ÿ 2ÿ6 %ÿÿ>'%?ÿ&%8!ÿ)ÿ"('@%ÿ<?ÿ %)!ÿ()A 133635ÿÿ CDEFGHIJKLÿ

MNÿ ÿ:5/ÿ8P+ÿ896Q+ÿ:5ÿ;13-3ÿ,56ÿ1110ÿ56ÿ5ÿ566303ÿ1ÿ5ÿ 1-R ÿ2-Rÿ1133ÿ4/ÿ16ÿ423ÿST23U5ÿ3ÿ2-Rÿ,56ÿ**10ÿ5ÿ 251*3ÿ43-563ÿ:5ÿ;13-3ÿ,56ÿ3*10ÿT23ÿ2335ÿ:5ÿ 5*5ÿ ,5*R31ÿ 562ÿ23ÿ2-Rÿ-5/10ÿ5ÿ*0451+ÿ51ÿT23ÿ2513ÿ5ÿ *1ÿ/3*10ÿ163ÿ252ÿ6252*31ÿ:5ÿ5*55ÿ:5ÿ5*5ÿ**,31ÿ23ÿ 2-Rÿ21*ÿ12ÿ62 31ÿ52ÿ5ÿ46/ÿ12363-21+ÿ523ÿ,1-ÿ5ÿ3345*ÿ 50232ÿ3631ÿ252ÿ33325**/ÿ--*131ÿ,12ÿ:5ÿ;13-3ÿ3V1210ÿ 23ÿ331-*3+ÿ0ÿ1ÿ51+ÿ51ÿ6210ÿ:5ÿ5*55ÿ:5ÿ5*5ÿ1131ÿ 2ÿ062ÿ,165ÿ MPÿ;*1-3ÿ51331ÿ52ÿ23ÿ6-33ÿ62*/ÿ523ÿ23ÿ62105ÿ:5ÿ ;13-3ÿ,56ÿ11321131ÿ56ÿ5ÿ663-2+ÿ51ÿ3ÿ2*1ÿ23ÿ*1-3ÿ3ÿ,5231ÿ5ÿ *5,/35ÿ:5ÿ;13-3ÿ,56ÿ256231ÿ2ÿ23ÿ *1-3ÿ62521+ÿ,56ÿ 1231ÿÿ16ÿWXYZ[\Zÿ1026+ÿ51ÿ50331ÿ2ÿ635R5ÿ:5ÿ;13-3ÿ0533ÿ 16ÿ5--2ÿÿ,52ÿ5 331ÿ2ÿ23ÿ*1-3ÿ51ÿ-*51231ÿ3ÿ62ÿ:5ÿ 5*5ÿ1ÿ63*A133635ÿT2ÿ23ÿ625232326ÿ,33ÿ*523ÿ6 36631ÿ523ÿ 23ÿ11621-2ÿ-2ÿ1ÿ23ÿ *1-3ÿ12 3216614*/ÿ.362131ÿ:5ÿ ;13-3ÿ523ÿ3ÿ3.36231ÿ5ÿ5223/5ÿ M^ÿ3ÿ_2523ÿ-5031ÿ:5ÿ;13-3ÿ,12ÿ2135ÿ`2ÿ215*+ÿ23ÿ_2523ÿ -5**31ÿ21233ÿ,1236636ÿS-616210ÿÿ221626ÿ51ÿ23ÿ 1113115*6ÿ52ÿ23ÿ6-33Uÿ2ÿ23621/ÿ542ÿ23ÿ62105ÿ31ÿ5--26ÿ 351315ÿ 0ÿ35*/ÿ5**ÿ23621131ÿ252ÿ:5ÿ;13-3ÿ51ÿ:5ÿ 5*5ÿ ,33ÿ/3**10ÿ52ÿ35-ÿ23+ÿ3ÿ-*1ÿ25R3ÿ2ÿ3V5-2*/ÿ,52ÿ,56ÿ 65115ÿ_23ÿ23621131ÿ252ÿ:5ÿ5*5ÿ,56ÿ4310ÿ500366133ÿ51ÿ51ÿ 2352331ÿ:5ÿ;13-3ÿ,12ÿ16ÿ*0451+ÿ,1*3ÿ236ÿ23621131ÿ252ÿ :5ÿ5*5ÿ,56ÿ2ÿ4310ÿ500366133ÿ51ÿ51ÿ333ÿ2352331ÿ:5ÿ aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaÿ 6ÿÿ3351 *ÿÿ*51ÿ3ÿ3313,+ÿ5ÿ133152ÿ262ÿ36254*16ÿ252ÿ ÿ

bcdÿef"ÿ%%%ÿ=gÿcdÿÿ%%%ÿ'(8ÿ&ÿ<"ÿ<&'ÿÿÿ %(ÿ!'%gÿ"8ÿcdÿÿ%%%ÿÿ%)'(hiÿjkZklÿmnÿoZ[ÿpqXrl[+ÿ896^ÿ ÿ6+ÿMÿ9+ÿstÿ;51ÿ898ÿS5*23521ÿ1ÿ1015*UÿS-12521ÿ212231U5ÿÿ ÿ 01213ÿ56ÿ893 3ÿ ÿÿÿÿ

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

State v. Pierce, 2022 UT 22, 511 P.3d 1164 (Utah 2022).

2022 UT 22 (State v. Pierce) — published by Counsel Stack Legal Research, free access to 12M+ legal documents.

Related

State v. Black
Court of Appeals of Utah, 2026
State v. Talbert
Court of Appeals of Utah, 2026
State v. Cesspooch
2024 UT App 15 (Court of Appeals of Utah, 2024)
In re A.B.
2022 UT 39 (Utah Supreme Court, 2022)