State v. McCarthy

468 P.2d 652, 2 Or. App. 346, 1970 Ore. App. LEXIS 647

• Court: Court of Appeals of Oregon
• Decided: April 23, 1970
• Status: Published

Opinion

PER CURIAM.

Defendant was convicted of the crime of contributing to the delinquency of a minor under the third category (the “manifestly tends” portion) of ORS 167.210, and he appeals. ORS 167.210 reads, in part, as follows:

“When a child is a delinquent child as defined by any statute of this state, [1] any person responsible for, or by any act encouraging, causing or contributing to the delinquency of such child, [2] or any person who by threats, command or persuasion, endeavors to induce any child to perform any act or follow any course of conduct which would cause it to become a delinquent child, [3] or any person who does any act which manifestly tends to cause any child to become a delinquent child, shall be punished upon conviction * *

The “manifestly tends” portion of ORS 167.210 has been declared unconstitutional by State v. Hodges, 254 Or 21, 457 P2d 491 (1969), and an indictment thereunder fails to state a crime. The state concedes that this conviction cannot stand under the “manifestly tends” portion of the statute, but argues that the indictment also charges defendant with a violation of the first category. The first category is also unconstitutional and an indictment thereunder also fails to state a crime. Coon v. Cupp, 2 Or App 114, 467 P2d 140 (1970).

This cause is remanded to the trial court for referral to the grand jury in the event the prosecution deems it proper to proceed under another statute or that he be discharged.

Reversed with directions.