State v. Mason

782 So. 2d 1093, 2001 WL 79760
CourtLouisiana Court of Appeal
DecidedJanuary 30, 2001
Docket00-KA-1223
StatusPublished
Cited by2 cases

This text of 782 So. 2d 1093 (State v. Mason) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Louisiana Court of Appeal primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
State v. Mason, 782 So. 2d 1093, 2001 WL 79760 (La. Ct. App. 2001).

Opinion

782 So.2d 1093 (2001)

STATE of Louisiana
v.
Rodney A. MASON, Jr.

No. 00-KA-1223.

Court of Appeal of Louisiana, Fifth Circuit.

January 30, 2001.

*1094 Bruce G. Whittaker, Louisiana Appellate Project, New Orleans, LA, Attorney for Appellant Rodney A. Mason, Jr.

Paul D. Connick, Jr., District Attorney, 24th Judicial District, Parish of Jefferson, State of Louisiana; Churita H. Hansell, Terry M. Boudreaux, Appellate Attorneys, Assistant District Attorneys; David P. Wolff, Felony Assistant District Attorney, Research and Appeals, Courthouse Annex, Gretna, LA, Attorneys for Appellee State of Louisiana.

Panel composed of Judges GOTHARD, CANNELLA and GAUDIN, Pro Tempore.

JAMES L. CANNELLA, Judge.

Defendant, Ronald A. Mason, Jr., appeals his conviction for second degree murder, a violation of La. R.S. 14:30.1 and sentence of life imprisonment. We affirm and remand.[1]

On January 26, 1998, the Defendant shot and killed Melissa DiGiovanni (DiGiovanni) while they were sitting in a car in the parking lot of the Elmwood Plantation Apartments on Veterans Blvd. The Defendant, age 43, and DiGiovanni, age 17, were engaged at the time of the homicide. Testimony at trial revealed they had a very tumultuous relationship.

The Defendant and DiGiovanni met through a mutual friend, Lawrence "Butch" Heller. They started dating and living together in 1996. Several friends of both the Defendant and DiGiovanni testified that they often argued. Tanna Heidelberg (Heidelberg), a friend of DiGiovanni, testified that on December 17, 1997 DiGiovanni called her crying. Heidelberg heard the Defendant screaming and yelling and she heard slapping and hitting noises. DiGiovanni ultimately called the police and the Defendant was arrested for aggravated assault and simple battery. During the 911 call, the Defendant can be heard saying, "If the cops come, you're dead. You're dead." The responding officer testified that he observed minor swelling and redness on DiGiovanni's thighs and forearms and that DiGiovanni stated that Defendant used a knife during the assault. Heidelberg further testified that although she had never seen the Defendant hit DiGiovanni, she had seen bruises on her and knew that on one occasion the Defendant kicked DiGiovanni.

During his testimony, the Defendant claimed that the incident on December 17, 1997 occurred when DiGiovanni returned home at 1:00 a.m. and he learned that she had been out looking at Christmas lights with a man named Carl. He stated that *1095 DiGiovanni slapped him and he slapped her back. He denied using a knife.

Heller, the Defendant's friend for 12 or 13 years, testified that he never saw the Defendant hit DiGiovanni but he had heard him threaten to kill her. Heller also testified that the Defendant was very jealous and did not let DiGiovanni have any friends. Heller explained that the Defendant accused DiGiovanni of having relations with every man to whom she talked. He believed that most of the Defendant's accusations were unfounded. However, he admitted that DiGiovanni may have kissed a guy named Carl.

Defendant testified that, on the night of the murder, he went to pick DiGiovanni up from Heidelberg's house at approximately 9:00 p.m. DiGiovanni drove since Defendant had been drinking and was feeling sick. On the way home, they started arguing about where she had been earlier that night. According to the Defendant, DiGiovanni told him that "she was with Carl and she f* * * *d him and `Tomorrow I'm going to f* * * David'." (R., p. 460). The Defendant told DiGiovanni to stop the car and to get out but she refused. He claims that he blacked out. He only remembers grabbing the gun from under the driver's seat.

The Defendant testified that he lost control upon hearing DiGiovanni comment on her sexual relations with other men. However, he also testified that he lost control thinking of all the bills which he owed and could not pay. He stated that he was mentally exhausted from working long hours and that his life had gone downhill since he had met DiGiovanni. He blamed her for his poor financial state and his depression. There was evidence that the Defendant had a long standing drinking problem. He also had players' cards for numerous casinos in the area.

Prior to picking up DiGiovanni that night, the Defendant noticed a phone number for David on DiGiovanni's calendar which reminded him of an incident that occurred three days earlier where he came home from work and found her on the phone with David. He and David exchanged heated words and the conversation ended with David threatening the Defendant by stating, "watch your back." The Defendant testified that, after getting off the phone, he asked DiGiovanni who David was and she responded he was just a friend. However, he noticed her calendar had David's birthday on it. Three days before the homicide, Defendant learned that DiGiovanni had some type of relationship with David. He found a note in her handwriting stating, "Melissa is leaving Allan on December 17, 1997, because I am going to live with David."

The engagement ring that the Defendant gave to DiGiovanni was found behind the passenger's side rear tire. Heidelberg testified that DiGiovanni was wearing the ring on the day of the homicide. She explained that every time the Defendant and DiGiovanni fought, he demanded his engagement ring back. She stated that DiGiovanni always gave the ring back. This was supported by Deputy Brandon Dutreix who testified that after the December 17, 1997 incident, DiGiovanni took off her engagement ring and left it in the apartment before moving out. There was also an incident on January 1, 1998 when the Defendant reported that DiGiovanni had stolen the engagement ring after she left the apartment with another man.

After he shot DiGiovanni, the Defendant went back to his apartment and called Heller, his mother, and "Mr. Rocky," another friend. According to Heller, the Defendant telephoned at 11:00 p.m. on the night of the homicide to see if he could *1096 arrange for some time off from work.[2] Defendant then told Heller that he shot DiGiovanni. Heller tried to convince the Defendant to call 911 but the Defendant refused and Heller called 911, after ending his call with the Defendant. At that time, Heller did not know if DiGiovanni was alive or dead.

Kerry Suhre (Suhre), a resident of the Elmwood Plantation Apartments, testified that between 10:00 and 11:00 p.m. on January 26, 1998, he heard arguing outside his apartment. He looked out of his sliding glass door and saw a man standing outside the passenger's side of a car arguing and yelling into the car.[3] He could not hear or understand what the man was yelling and did not see anything in the Defendant's hands. Suhre testified that he watched for about two to three minutes and then returned to his computer. Approximately ten minutes later, Suhre heard a "pop" noise and looked outside again. He saw the man look into the car and then walk away into the apartment breezeway. He did not know what caused the "pop" noise, but did not think it sounded like a gunshot. Suhre testified that the argument only stopped after he heard the "pop" sound. Thirty-five to 40 minutes later an ambulance arrived, after which Suhre went outside where he saw a girl slumped at the driver's side window of the car.

Another resident of the complex, Omar Gonzales (Gonzales), arrived home at approximately 11:15 p.m. He saw DiGiovanni's car parked with its lights on and a lady in the car who appeared to have passed out. He knocked on the window of the car and asked if she was okay. There was no response.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

State v. Favorite
862 So. 2d 208 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2003)
State v. Johnson
820 So. 2d 604 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2002)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
782 So. 2d 1093, 2001 WL 79760, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/state-v-mason-lactapp-2001.