State v. Jones

165 So. 3d 74, 2013 WL 2249168
Louisiana Court of Appeal·Decided May 23, 2013·No. No. 12-KA-788·Published·Cited by 7 cases

Opinion

MARC E. JOHNSON, Judge.

|PDefendant, Willie Jones, appeals his conviction and sentence for second degree murder from the 24th Judicial District Court, Division “M”. For the following reasons, we affirm the conviction and vacate the sentence in part, and remand the matter for further proceedings.

FACTS AND PROCEDURAL HISTORY

On August 26, 2010, Defendant, Willie Jones, was indicted by a Jefferson Parish Grand Jury for the second degree murder of Perry Noel, a violation of La. R.S. 14:30.1. Defendant pleaded not guilty at arraignment. Defendant filed various pretrial motions, including motions to suppress evidence and identification, which were heard and denied by the trial court on March 24, 2011.

The matter was tried before a 12-person jury on March 14-15, 2012. On the second day of trial, the State filed a Motion in Limine, seeking to prohibit the defense from introducing improper character evidence and/or evidence of other crimes, wrongs, or acts of the victim. The trial court granted the State’s motion that same day. The following facts were taken from the trial.

|oOn April 29, 2010, Deputy Pamela Mel-ford, of the Jefferson Parish Sheriffs Office, was driving southbound on Ames Boulevard when she was flagged down by a woman who advised her that someone had just been shot at the corner of Ames Boulevard and Mount Kennedy Drive. Upon arriving at the scene, Deputy Melford observed the victim, 40-year-old Perry Noel, lying face down on the sidewalk. Deputy Melford notified headquarters and requested that EMS be dispatched to her location. She approached the bystanders that had gathered and asked them whether anyone had seen or heard anything. No one came forward with any information at that time.

Soon thereafter, Deputy Abraham Andi-no arrived on the scene to investigate the homicide. When he arrived, several people had gathered in the area in front of a nearby convenience store. No casings were recovered at the scene. The only other physical evidence present at the scene was a bicycle and a rag. No other objects, weapons, or bottles were found on or near the victim’s body. There were also no weapons found in the victim’s pockets.

Upon learning that a potential witness, Paul Babineaux, had been transported to the Detective’s Bureau, Deputy Andino turned the scene over to Captain Dennis Thornton, so he could interview the witness. Information provided by Babineaux indicated that the suspect was a black male, 17 to 19 years of age, with dread-lock-styled hair. Deputy Andino compiled a photographic lineup based on Babi-neaux’s description; however, Babineaux was unable to identify any of the men as [79]*79the person he had observed running from the scene. That particular photographic lineup did not contain a picture of Defendant.

While Deputy Andino was searching in the database for additional photographs, Veronica and Braxton Clement arrived at the Bureau stating that they had information about the homicide. Based upon the information they separately 1¿provided, Defendant was developed as a suspect. Another photographic lineup with Defendant’s picture was compiled and presented to Babineaux and Braxton Clement by Detective Burke and Sergeant Kevin Decker. Thereafter, an arrest warrant for Defendant was prepared.

Deputy Andino also prepared a search warrant for Defendant’s residence located at 5325 Tulip, which was near the scene of the homicide. After knocking on the door and receiving no response, deputies forced entry into the home. Defendant was located in one of the upstairs bedrooms. Deputy Andino transported Defendant to the Detective Bureau, while the other deputies completed the search of the home. Pursuant to the search, deputies seized live ammunition, gun grips, warranty cards, and a couple of speedloaders.1

A few days later, on May 4, 2010, a parish employee was cutting grass on the canal bank on Tulip Court when he discovered three guns and called the Jefferson Parish Sheriffs Office. Two of the recovered guns, a .45 Ruger and a .357 Rossi, had been reported stolen on April 7, 2010.

On the evening of the homicide, Babi-neaux was living at the Ridgefield Apartments located off of Mount Kennedy Drive. Babineaux testified that he was standing next to a fire hydrant near his apartment complex when a man rode by on a bicycle and appeared to be “kind of tipsy.” Upon hearing a noise, Babineaux looked in the direction of Jake’s Seafood Restaurant where the man appeared to have fallen off of his bicycle and was sitting on the curb rubbing his arms.2 | RBabineaux began walking away when he heard three gunshots.3 Babineaux ran back to his previous location by the fire hydrant to see what was happening when three young black men ran by him. While running by him, one of the men stated “[s]omebody’s shooting back there.” Babi-neaux testified that the young man’s hand was inside his pants or holding up his pants. The young man who spoke to Babi-neaux was slim, had long braided hair, was wearing a black shirt and shorts, appeared to be between 17 and 19 years old, and was approximately 5'5" to 5'6" tall. Babineaux testified that he identified the young man who spoke to him that day from a photographic lineup shown to him by the police after the incident.

Eighteen year-old Braxton Clement testified that he has known Defendant for approximately five years and was best [80]*80Mends with Defendant at the time of the shooting.4 Braxton testified that on the day of the shooting, he was at a girl’s house on Ames Boulevard with Defendant, Kris Ellis, Richard, and the victim. Brax-ton and Defendant arrived separately, and the victim arrived ten to fifteen minutes later on a bicycle. Braxton testified that Defendant and the victim engaged in an argument, which he described as “just a few words passed back and forth. It wasn’t my business, so I didn’t really pay any mind to it.”5 Braxton testified that Defendant was “backing up, telling him leave me alone, basically.”6 Braxton also testified that the victim never brandished a weapon, and Defendant and the victim were “just fussing.”

The victim eventually left the house. Ten to fifteen minutes later Braxton, Defendant, and Richard left the house to meet up with Ellis at the Ames Express Store. According to Braxton, Ellis entered the convenience store while he, [ (¡Richard, and Defendant kept walking. When they heard a noise behind them, they turned around to find the victim standing there with a broken bottle in his hand. Braxton testified that the victim was holding the top half of the bottle and had discarded the bottom half.7 Braxton testified that after that he “really didn’t pay attention. Once I walked past him[,] I didn’t look back. I just knew he threw the bottom half away.” However, Braxton heard the victim tell defendant that “he’s still got love for him,” to which Defendant responded, “this ain’t (sic) no Tupac song.” Braxton testified that he kept on walking and heard the victim and Defendant engage in a shouting match.8 Braxton did not see anything that was going on between the victim and Defendant because they were behind him.9 A minute or two later, Braxton heard three gunshots. At trial, Braxton testified that he did not see Defendant fire the gun but admitted telling the police that he did. However, Brax-ton also testified that Defendant was the only person shooting a gun that night.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

State v. Jones, 165 So. 3d 74, 2013 WL 2249168 (La. Ct. App. 2013).

165 So. 3d 74 (State v. Jones) — published by Counsel Stack Legal Research, free access to 12M+ legal documents.

Related

State of Louisiana v. Karl Davis
Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2020
People v. Jones
2018 COA 112 (Colorado Court of Appeals, 2018)
State v. Comeaux
239 So. 3d 920 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2018)
State of Louisiana v. Adam Comeaux
Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2018
State v. Williams
186 So. 3d 242 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2016)
State v. Jones
176 So. 3d 713 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2015)
State v. Graham
171 So. 3d 272 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2015)
State v. Jones
134 So. 3d 1164 (Supreme Court of Louisiana, 2014)