State v. Hutchinson

190 So. 3d 1264, 15 La.App. 5 Cir. 611, 2016 WL 1719923, 2016 La. App. LEXIS 805
CourtLouisiana Court of Appeal
DecidedApril 27, 2016
DocketNo. 15-KA-611
StatusPublished
Cited by1 cases

This text of 190 So. 3d 1264 (State v. Hutchinson) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Louisiana Court of Appeal primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
State v. Hutchinson, 190 So. 3d 1264, 15 La.App. 5 Cir. 611, 2016 WL 1719923, 2016 La. App. LEXIS 805 (La. Ct. App. 2016).

Opinion

SUSAN M. CHEHARDY, Chief Judge.

|aOn appeal, James Hutchinson challenges his convictions for second degree murder and unauthorized use of a motor vehicle. For the following reasons, we affirm those convictions.

Procedural history

On January 24, 2013, a Jefferson Parish Grand Jury indicted defendant,. James Hutchinson, on one count of . second degree murder, in violation of La. R.S. 14:30.1, and one count of unauthorized use of a motor vehicle, in violation of La. R.S. 14:68.4. On March 10, 2015, trial commenced. After two days of testimony, the twelve-person jury found defendant guilty as charged on both counts. On April 8, 2015, the trial judge sentenced defendant, for second degree murder, to life imprisonment without" benéfit of parole, probation, or suspension of sentence and, for unauthorized use of a motor vehicle, to five years at hard labor, to run concurrently. Defendant’s motion for appeal was granted that day.

Facts

On September 28, 2012, King Honoré was found dead in Room 124 of the La-Quinta Inn on the South'1-10 Service Rd in Metairie. According to Dr. | ..¡Marianna Eserman, the expert forensic pathologist, Mr. Honore’s death was' a homicide caused by manual and ligature strangulation. Moreover, the force exerted during the strangulation was substantial enough to fracture the victim’s hyoid bone,1 which is a nare finding seen in only about 20% of the cases of manual strangulation. Finally, the pathologist determined that he had been dead for about two days.

Détective Rhonda Goff of the Jefferson Parish Sheriffs Office Homicide Division was the lead investigator on this case. Initially, Detective Goff observed that Mr. Honoré was found unclothed, lying prone on the floor of the room. Mr. Honoré had bruises and scratches on his face and neck. He also had skin under his fingernails, Which were not clipped short. Further, there was blood bn the floor and bedding near Mr. Honoré that was indicative of a struggle before his death.

. During her investigation, Detective Goff learned that the last keyed entry by a guest into Mr. Honore’s room was at 10;Q9 p.m. on Wednesday, September 26, 2012. Further, the housekeeper reported to the manager, on Thursday, September 27, 2012,' that there was a man “sleeping naked” on the floor in Room 124 but the manager thought the man was probably drunk so took no action. On Friday, September 28, 2012, when a second housekeeper reported the man on the floor, the manager reported the incident. Detective Goff also learned that Mr. Honore’s rental car was not in the motel’s parking lot so she reported the car as stolen.

On October 2, 2015, DNA analysis of swabs from the victim showed a. match to ■James Hutchinson. At trial, David Cox, an expert in forensic DNA analysis for the Jefferson Parish Sheriffs Office stated that a large amount of tissue, which was about 10 times larger than a typical sam-[1268]*1268pie, was found under the |4fingernails of the victim’s right hand. The DNA in that tissue matched, James Hutchinson with a probability greater than 1 in 100 billion. DNA was also, found under the fingernails of the victim’s left hand, which, with the same probability, was consistent with both the victim and James Hutchinson’s DNA. Further, the swab of the bite wound on the victim’s cheek contained James Hutchinson’s DNA with a probability of greater than 1 in 100 billion. Finally, the swab of the lacerations on the .victim’s neck contained James Hutchinson’s DNA with a probability of greater than 1 in 100 billion.

On October 2, 2015, Detective Goff learned that Mr. Hutchinson had been arrested on Friday, September 28, 2012 in St. John the Baptist Parish on unrelated charges and remained in custody there. An' official from the St. John Parish Sheriffs Office provided Detective Goff with a copy of the booking photograph taken of Mr. Hutchinson on September '28, 2012, which reflected bruises and partially-healed cuts on his face. Further, the arresting deputy testified that the cuts were not consistent with injuries that had just been inflicted.

On October 3,2015, Detective Goff interviewed James Hutchinson at the St. John the Baptist Parish Sheriffs Office. Mr. Hutchinson gave' two conflicting statements. In his first statement, Mr. Hutchinson admitted that he had known the victim for rnáhy years as they were both from LaPlace. Mr. Hutchinson also admitted going to meet the victim at LaQuin-ta “last Wednesday” to get some Vodka but could not recall the name of the person that drove him to the motel or how he returned to LaPlace from the motel in Metairie.

After the first statement, Detective Goff, pursuant to a search warrant, obtained a buccal swab from Mr. Hutchinson to compare to the DNA evidence obtained from the victim. Once Mr. Hutchinson was informed his DNA was found on the victim, he made a second statement to explain his skin,under the victim’s |snails. In the second statement, Mr. Hutchinson said the victim may have “gotten blood from me under his fingernail” because Mr. Hutchinson cut himself “one day” and the victim had “rubbed it and messed witfsic ] it.” Hutchinson denied being involved in any physical altercation with the victim but rather attributed his current bruises and scratches to two separate altercations: one between himself and his girlfriend and another between" himself and “a couple of dudes” at the LaPlace projects. He also denied that he had gone to meet Mr. Hon-oré at a motel at any time. At that point, Detective Goff arrested-James Hutchinson for the homicide of King Honoré.

On October 5, 2012, the victim’s rental car was found at the rear of the parking lot of the Winn Dixie Supermarket at 179 Belle Terre in LaPlace. Video surveillance of that area reflects that the vehicle was driven by a shirtless African-American man, who parked the car at 12:26 a.m. on Thursday, September 27, 2012. The video was grainy and the driver was wearing a hat so there was no clear picture of the driver’s face. Detective Goff pointed out, however, that the car was parked only three-tenths of a mile from the home address that James Hutchinson gave in his statements and where he was arrested on Friday, September 28,2012.

After hearing testimony and evidence, the twelve-member jury found defendant guilty as charged on.one count of second degree murder and one count of unauthorized use of a motor vehicle. This appeal follows.

Law and Argument

On appeal, defendant raises three assignments of error: first, the evidence was insufficient to support this conviction; sec[1269]*1269ond, a mistrial should have been declared when Erica Lewis was dismissed from the jury over counsel’s objection; and, third, reversible error occurred when juror Amber Bonura was not dismissed for cause.

|fiIn his first assignment of error, defendant contends that the evidence was insufficient to support both his second degree murder conviction and unauthorized use of a motor vehicle conviction. He argues that not every reasonable hypothesis of innocent activity had been- eliminated. While he concedes that ■his DNA was found on the victim, he points out that someone else could have committed.- the murder. He argues-that the- State was required to negate the possibility that someone else murdered the victim and took his car. Additionally, he submits that the victim’s car was never checked for fingerprints, and while there was-the surveillance video, it did not show the identity of the driver.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

State v. Brown
219 So. 3d 518 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2017)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
190 So. 3d 1264, 15 La.App. 5 Cir. 611, 2016 WL 1719923, 2016 La. App. LEXIS 805, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/state-v-hutchinson-lactapp-2016.