State v. Griffin

568 So. 2d 198, 1990 WL 140250
Louisiana Court of Appeal·Decided September 26, 1990·No. 21688-KA·Published·Cited by 8 cases

Opinion

568 So.2d 198 (1990)

STATE of Louisiana, Appellee,
v.
Leonard GRIFFIN, Appellant.

No. 21688-KA.

Court of Appeal of Louisiana, Second Circuit.

September 26, 1990.

*200 Samuel Thomas, Tallulah, for appellant.

William J. Guste, Jr., Atty. Gen.; James D. Caldwell, Dist. Atty., Tallulah; and John D. Crigler, Asst. Dist. Atty., St. Joseph, for appellee.

Before MARVIN and FRED W. JONES, Jr., JJ., and JASPER JONES, J. Ad Hoc.

JASPER JONES, Judge Ad Hoc.

The defendant, Leonard Griffin, age 59, was convicted of second degree murder pursuant to LSA-R.S. 14:30.1, for the shooting death of Roy Lee Ray. He was sentenced to life imprisonment without benefit of parole, probation or suspension of sentence. He now appeals his conviction arguing that the trial court erred in admitting into evidence oral statements and confessions made by the defendant after he allegedly had asserted his right to counsel. He further contends the trial court erred in admitting the testimony of certain police officers of a co-defendant's statements which implicated the defendant. We affirm. The defendant makes the following three assignments of error:

ASSIGNMENT OF ERROR NO. 1

The defendant, LEONARD GRIFFIN, urges on appeal that the Trial Court committed error, when it allowed the confession of June 22, given without counsel, to be introduced into evidence where the defendant stated to the Honorable Judge Brackin on June 20th that he wanted legal representation.

ASSIGNMENT OF ERROR NO. 2

The defendant urges on appeal that the Trial Judge committed error when he allowed hearsay evidence of Paul Tolbert, Jr., in a statement to Sheriff Scott.

ASSIGNMENT OF ERROR NO. 3

The defendant urges on appeal that the Judge committed error when he allowed hearsay testimony of Paul Tolbert, Jr., to be introduced into evidence by State Trooper Jim Morris.

FACTS

On the morning of June 14, 1985, Roy Lee Ray was found lying face down in an agricultural field in an isolated area south of Waterproof, Louisiana, dead of multiple shotgun blasts to the face and head.

The police while investigating the crime scene discovered a spent shotgun shell identified as a ".12 gauge shotgun shell Super X 00 buck". The crime scene investigation revealed tire tracks leading from the victim's body. The tire impressions in the dirt revealed they were made by a vehicle with street tires on the front and back of the right side and mud grip tires on the front and back left side of the truck. Because of the unusual nature of these tread marks, the investigating officers determined they should attempt to locate a vehicle with similar tires.

A wallet was found in the victim's pocket indicating the victim's name was Roy Lee Ray. The investigating officers went to the victim's residence reflected on his driver's license and spoke with the victim's wife, Margaret Ray. She provided the officers with some information about who Roy Ray associated with and Paul Tolbert was included among Ray's associates.

Pursuant to information received by the officers regarding the suspect truck, several police officers went to the residence of Paul Tolbert. A truck with tires similar to the tires which made the tracks found at the crime scene was found at the Tolbert residence. Because the tires on Paul Tolbert's truck could have made the tracks found at the scene, the officers took Tolbert to the Concordia Parish Sheriff's department. After a short period of interrogation, Tolbert "got very emotional and said, I didn't kill him (Roy Ray) but I can tell you who did". Tolbert related to the *201 officers that the defendant, Leonard Griffin, had shot and killed Roy Ray. Based upon the subsequent statements made by Tolbert concerning the specifics of the murder, Trooper Jim Morris prepared a search warrant affidavit and secured a search warrant for the residence of Leonard Griffin. Sheriff Fred Scott prepared affidavits and obtained arrest warrants for Paul Tolbert and Leonard Griffin. Tolbert later pled guilty to Second Degree Murder. He was in the Tensas Parish Jail at the time of the trial but did not testify.

On June 15, 1985, the defendant, Leonard Griffin was arrested in Concordia Parish and charged with second degree murder. He was advised of his constitutional rights and of the fact that a search warrant for his residence had been obtained. Griffin also signed a consent to search form for his residence.

The officers entered the defendant's residence and discovered an Ithica .12 gauge shotgun, one of the items named in the search warrant based upon the information received from Paul Tolbert. The gun was not dusted for fingerprints as it had been recently oiled and rubbed down. Griffin was again advised of his rights and transported to Concordia Parish Sheriff's Department. There, he was questioned by Jim McKinsey and Fred Scott. The defendant admitted ownership of the .12 gauge Ithica shotgun but denied any knowledge of the murder of Roy Ray. An expert who testified at trial established that the spent shell found at the crime scene was fired by this gun.

On June 19 the defendant was interrogated by Roger Jaubert and Edward Thompson. He was fully informed of his constitutional rights including his right to counsel. In this interrogation the defendant admitted he was present when Roy Ray was murdered but stated that Tolbert was the murderer. The defendant related to the officers that Tolbert had come by his residence on June 14 and told him to get his shotgun and buck shot stating that "we are going to go get one." Griffin said that he thought that what Tolbert meant by that statement was that they were going to go deer hunting. He stated they picked up Ray, drove around and drank beer. He stated they drove out to the area where the murder occurred, walked around looking for deer, went into the woods and hunted for a while, and returned to the truck when they did not see any deer. Griffin said that Tolbert asked Ray if he had stopped in Baskin and seen "that woman tonight" and that Ray stated that he had not. Griffin stated that Tolbert then said "you've lied to me your last time, I told you that if you lied to me again I was going to lob your ass" and that Tolbert then shot Ray in the face with the shotgun. Griffin stated that Tolbert then told Griffin to go home and wash the gun and keep his mouth shut.

On June 22, 1985, Deputy Ed Thompson transported the defendant to Alexandria for the purpose of obtaining a polygraph examination on the defendant. Buddy Cavanaugh, a state licensed polygraph examiner was to perform the test. The defendant was informed of his rights and that he did not have to take the test. He agreed to take it, and during Cavanaugh's explanation of the procedures, Griffin suddenly stopped him and stated that his conscience had been bothering him and he wished to confess. This interview was recorded on both audio and video tape. The tapes revealed the defendant had been advised of his constitutional rights and waived them. The tapes were introduced into evidence and viewed by the jury. Essentially, defendant said he and Tolbert knew they were going to kill Ray when they went to pick him up because a week before, at the home of Tolbert's mother, he and Tolbert planned how to murder Ray. In explaining the shooting of the victim, the defendant stated that he fired three shots at the victim. The first shot caused Ray to fall straight back, and the final two were fired straight down into Ray's face. He further stated that before leaving the scene he and Tolbert picked up two of the spent shells and later threw them away.

After returning to St

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

State v. Griffin, 568 So. 2d 198, 1990 WL 140250 (La. Ct. App. 1990).

568 So. 2d 198 (State v. Griffin) — published by Counsel Stack Legal Research, free access to 12M+ legal documents.

Related

State v. Green
164 So. 3d 331 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2015)
State v. Martin
679 So. 2d 557 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1996)
State v. Jackson
672 So. 2d 215 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1996)
State v. Rossiter
623 N.E.2d 645 (Ohio Court of Appeals, 1993)
State v. Hicks
607 So. 2d 937 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1992)
State v. Plater
606 So. 2d 824 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1992)
State v. McNair
597 So. 2d 1096 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1992)
State v. Griffin
592 So. 2d 1330 (Supreme Court of Louisiana, 1992)