State v. . Dejournette

199 S.E. 920, 214 N.C. 575, 1938 N.C. LEXIS 410

• Court: Supreme Court of North Carolina
• Decided: December 14, 1938
• Status: Published

Opinion

Criminal prosecution, tried upon indictment charging Bat DeJournette, his wife, Kate DeJournette, and Elmer Williams with the murder of one Garland Mangum.

Upon the call of the case for trial, Elmer Williams tendered a plea of "guilty of accessory before the fact to murder in the first degree," which plea was accepted by the State. The defendants Bat DeJournette and Kate DeJournette pleaded not guilty, and were tried by a jury.

Verdict: Bat DeJournette, "guilty to murder in the first degree as charged in the bill of indictment"; Kate DeJournette, "guilty accessory after the fact of murder in the first degree."

Judgment as to Bat DeJournette: Death by asphyxiation.

The defendant Bat DeJournette appeals, assigning errors. The transcript consists of the record proper, the charge of the court, and a number of exceptions to the charge. This is agreed to as the case on appeal. S. v. Dee, ante, Nothing else appears on the record. S. v. Ross,193 N.C. 25, 136 S.E. 193.

With no knowledge of how the homicide occurred or what the evidence was — and this is a matter we can know judicially only from the record — we cannot say the instructions complained of are prejudicial or hurtful, even if theoretically they appears to be slightly erroneous in some particulars.

No reversible error having been shown, the verdict and judgment will be upheld.

No error.