State v. Collins

998 So. 2d 765, 2008 WL 4724292
Louisiana Court of Appeal·Decided October 29, 2008·No. 43,645-KA, 43,646-KA·Published·Cited by 2 cases

Opinion

998 So.2d 765 (2008)

STATE of Louisiana, Appellee
v.
Akintunde Charmez COLLINS, Appellant.

Nos. 43,645-KA, 43,646-KA.

Court of Appeal of Louisiana, Second Circuit.

October 29, 2008.

*768 Louisiana Appellate Project, by Carey J. Elllis, III, for Defendant/Appellant, Akintunde Charmez Collins.

Akintunde Charmez Collins, pro se.

J. Schuyler Marvin, District Attorney, John M. Lawrence, Assistant District Attorney, for Appellee.

Before BROWN, CARAWAY & PEATROSS, JJ.

PEATROSS, J.

Defendant, Akintunde Charmez Collins, was convicted of Possession of a Schedule II Controlled Dangerous Substance, namely Methamphetamine; Possession of a Schedule I Controlled Dangerous Substance, namely Methylenedioxymethamphetamine (MDMA); and Possession of a Schedule II Controlled Dangerous Substance, namely Cocaine. He was sentenced to 3 years at hard *769 labor for the Possession of Methamphetamine conviction; 5 years at hard labor for the Possession of MDMA conviction; and, for the Possession of Cocaine conviction, 15 years at hard labor; however, all but the first 10 years are suspended and to be served without benefit of parole, probation or suspension of sentence, with 5 years' probation and a $100,000 fine. All sentences are to be served concurrently. Defendant appeals. For the reasons stated below, we affirm the convictions and sentences of Defendant.

FACTS

On the morning of October 15, 2005, Louisiana State Trooper Shane Sears stopped a car driven by Khalfani Mustafaa Kamau,[1] in which Defendant was a passenger, on the side of Interstate 20. Trooper Sears had been assisting another state trooper, James Nash, at a separate traffic stop when he witnessed a burgundy Ford Taurus pass them without changing lanes to travel in the lane farthest from the stopped emergency vehicles. The failure to move into the inside lane away from a stopped emergency vehicle, if possible, is a traffic violation of R.S. 32:125(B).

Trooper Sears testified that, since the prior stop was coming to an end, he chose to pursue the burgundy car with the intent of pulling the car over for failure to yield for an emergency vehicle. Trooper Sears followed the vehicle and clocked it with his radar as traveling at 78 miles an hour in a 70-mile an hour speed zone. After stopping the vehicle, Trooper Sears asked the driver, Kamau, to step out of the vehicle.[2] Trooper Sears explained that the proper procedure during a traffic stop is to speak with drivers behind the stopped car and off the shoulder of the road as a safety precaution from the interstate traffic.

Trooper Sears observed Kamau's behavior to be aggressive: "... [H]e, in a confrontational-type manner, asked me what he was stepping out of the car for." Trooper Sears further described Kamau's behavior as "confrontational. He seemed agitated. He was what we call noncompliant because I asked him to step in—over into the grass several times and he wouldn't do it."

Trooper Sears discovered that the vehicle was a rental car rented to a third party who had named Kamau as a driver of the vehicle. As a result of a driver's license check on both Kamau and Defendant, Trooper Sears discovered several names and social security numbers connected to both Kamau and Defendant.

When asked by Trooper Sears what their travel plans were, Kamau told him that they had been headed to Atlanta, Georgia. By that time, Deputy James McLamb, a Caddo Parish Sheriff's deputy, had arrived on the scene and had begun interviewing Defendant. Deputy McLamb had been participating in the prior stop along with Trooper Sears. Deputy McLamb further described Kamau's demeanor as:

I could see the guy was just anxious, a little—kind of flexing his fists, just— there was—there was something there. I didn't hear the conversation between them. I could just tell by eyesight that *770 something wasn't quite right, so I—that's the reason I stayed instead of going back and getting in my car.
* * *
He just—he wasn't quite listening. He would—he would walk back towards the car. He was moving around. He was flexing his fists. Further into the conversation when I was talking to him, he would glance down at my weapon. He just—just—It's not exactly one thing. It's a lot of combinations of things that he was doing.

Trooper Sears discovered, during his driver's license search, that Defendant had an outstanding warrant in Texas and, at that time, took him into custody and placed Defendant in the back of his patrol car. Trooper Sears returned Kamau's driver's license and vehicle documents to him without issuing him a citation, but continued the traffic stop while waiting on confirmation from Texas that the outstanding warrant for Defendant was valid.

While waiting for information on the outstanding warrant, Trooper Sears asked Kamau for consent to search the vehicle. Kamau initially agreed. Deputy McLamb conducted the search of the vehicle and found a screwdriver in the glove box which he thought looked out of place in a rental vehicle. He then retrieved his K-9 from his vehicle and conducted an open-air sniff around the vehicle. At that point, Kamau protested the search, but Deputy McLamb continued to circle the vehicle with the dog. Deputy McLamb subsequently informed Trooper Sears that the K-9 had alerted to the presence of narcotics in the vehicle and a more in-depth search was necessary. The K-9 appeared to alert on the trunk and, later on, on the driver's side at the front of the vehicle. Deputy McLamb looked more closely at an area near where the windshield met the vehicle body where the dog had seemed most focused. At that point, he identified an area that looked like a portion of the plastic had been removed and replaced. When he pried the plastic back off, he was able to locate the hiding place of the narcotics.

Trooper Sears described the location where the narcotics were located as:

[T]he narcotics were located in the lower left—what we call the firewall, which is below the windshield, that plastic—piece of plastic that touches the windshield to the motor department [sic] where your windshield wipers are, it was—the plastic had been pried open and the narcotics were bundled up in duct tape and dryer sheets stuffed down in a natural void below the windshield wipers in the firewall.

The officers also found a receipt in the car for a box of Claritin sinus medication and another receipt for a box of Bounce dryer sheets purchased on the same night within five minutes of one another from the same CVS Pharmacy in Humble, Texas. The officers located cocaine and Ecstasy tablets in the firewall of the vehicle.

After the search was conducted and the narcotics were located, Defendant and Kamau were transported back to Troop G. Trooper Jason Parker testified that he had taken possession of the narcotics once the vehicle and its occupants were transported to Troop G and he maintained custody of them until they were transferred to the Shreveport Field Office. The narcotics were delivered by Trooper Parker to the Crime Lab on October 17, 2005, and picked up from the evidence custodian the day before his testimony on October 25, 2007. Trooper Parker could not testify from personal knowledge who had transferred them from the Crime Lab to the evidence custodian or when that transfer had occurred.

*771 Defendant and Kamau were tried together and, after waiving any conflict problems, were represented by the

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

State v. Collins, 998 So. 2d 765, 2008 WL 4724292 (La. Ct. App. 2008).

998 So. 2d 765 (State v. Collins) — published by Counsel Stack Legal Research, free access to 12M+ legal documents.

Related

State v. Fogleman
98 So. 3d 964 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2012)
State of Louisiana v. Byran Louis Fogleman
Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2012
State of Louisiana v. Clyde A. Bowens
Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2010
State v. Wilson
26 So. 3d 210 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2009)