State v. Coenan

48 Iowa 567
Supreme Court of Iowa·Decided June 8, 1878·Published·Cited by 5 cases

Opinion

Adams, J.

1. ciominal intoiifatinl liquors to minors. Section 1539 of the Code provides that “it shall be unlawful ■ for any person to sell or give away, by agent, or otherwise, any spirituous or intoxicating liquor, including wine and beer, to any minor, for any ° , , . , purpose whatsoever, unless upon the written order of his parent, guardian or family physician.” It is contended by the defendant that if it be shown that the parent’s consent was obtained it is immaterial whether it was obtained in writing or not. To this it is sufficient to say that it is not for us to override an express provision of the statute, because, in our judgment, the provision is unnecessary. Besides, the provision in question seems to us to be a wise one. It is calculated to insure deliberation on the part of the parent, guardian or physician, and, in addition, it is calculated to secure such evidence of the fact of consent as will prevent litigation upon the question as to whether the consent was given. We think that the demurrer was rightly sustained.

Affirmed.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

State v. Coenan, 48 Iowa 567 (iowa 1878).

48 Iowa 567 (State v. Coenan) — published by Counsel Stack Legal Research, free access to 12M+ legal documents.

Related

State v. Gary
101 S.W. 614 (Missouri Court of Appeals, 1907)
State v. Sasse
60 N.W. 853 (South Dakota Supreme Court, 1894)
Yakel v. State
17 S.W. 943 (Court of Appeals of Texas, 1891)
State v. Johnson
40 Kan. 266 (Supreme Court of Kansas, 1888)