State v. City of Des Moines

266 N.W. 41, 221 Iowa 642
CourtSupreme Court of Iowa
DecidedMarch 17, 1936
DocketNo. 43016.
StatusPublished
Cited by23 cases

This text of 266 N.W. 41 (State v. City of Des Moines) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Supreme Court of Iowa primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
State v. City of Des Moines, 266 N.W. 41, 221 Iowa 642 (iowa 1936).

Opinion

Hamilton, J.

In this case the state of Iowa and state treasurer seek to enjoin the city of Des Moines and certain officials of said city from receiving in this state from outside the state “motor vehicle fuel” for use or resale within the state, without having first obtained a distributor’s license as required by chapter 56, Acts of the Forty-fifth General Assembly, Extra Session, and ask for an accounting as to the quantity of motor vehicle fuel so received and to determine the amount of license fees or excise tax owing to the state of Iowa on such receipts, and to compel payment thereof to the state treasurer as pro *644 vicled by said act. The cause was submitted to the trial court on a motion to dismiss plaintiff’s petition, which motion was overruled, and, defendants not desiring to plead further, a decree was granted as prayed. All material fact allegations properly pleaded in said petition are admitted by the filing of the motion to dismiss. The only contention of appellants that can be, under the weight of authority, seriously urged, is that by the definitive sections of the act municipalities are not included within the purview of the act, and hence the city of Des Moines is not subject to its provisions.

In defining terms as applied to any given act, the legislature is its own lexicographer.

At the outset we are met with the well-established rule of construction that statutes should be construed so as to give force and effect to the manifest legislative intent as embodied therein. Seavert v. Cooper, 187 Iowa 1109, 1113, 175 N. W. 19. This legislative intent should and will be determined from a consideration of the entire statute relating to the same subject-matter. Howard v. Emmet County, 140 Iowa 527, 532, 118 N. W. 882.

In the title of the act in question (chapter 56, Acts 45th G. A., Extra Session) it is declared to be “an act to amend, revise and codify chapter two hundred fifty-one-A one (251-Al), Code, 1931, and chapters seventy-five (75) and eighty-six (86) of the acts of the Forty-fifth General Assembly relating to the collection of license fees on all motor vehicle fuel used or otherwise disposed of in the state of Iowa; to define motor vehicle fuel; to impose a license fee of three cents per gallon or fraction of a gallon on all motor vehicle fuel sold or used in the State of Iowa,” etc.

By section 1 the legislature attempts to define the purpose of the act, and it reads:

“It is the intent md purpose of this act * * * to continue the policy of collecting for highway purposes am, excise tax or license fee on all motor vehicle fuel used to propel motor vehicles on the highways of this state, and to provide such regulations as will prevent the evasion * * * thereof a/nd to that end to collect the license fee on all motor vehicle fuel in the state and from the first person receiving the same in this state for sale or use in this state and to require such person, and all subsequent *645 sellers to collect such license fee from purchasers to whom the same is sold for use or resale in this state so that said license fees shall be ultimately paid by the person using said motor vehicle fuel in this state and to refund to such user such license fees so paid by him on all motor vehicle fuel not used in connection with the operation of motor vehicles on the public highway.
“Sec. 2. Definition of terms. The following words, terms and phrases, for the purpose of this act, are defined as follows:
“a. The term ‘distributor’ shall mean any person who receives from outside the state * * * any motor vehicle fuel to be used within the state or sold or otherwise disposed of within the state for use in the state. * * *
“b. The term ‘person’ shall mean any individual, firm, partnership, joint stock company, association, trust, estate, joint adventure, and/or corporation. * * *
“i. The term ‘highway’ shall mean any way or place of whatever nature open to the use of the public as a matter of right for the purpose of vehicular travel. * * *
“See. 3. Tax imposed. A license fee of three (3) cents per gallon or a fraction of a gallon is hereby imposed on the sale or use of all motor vehicle fuel sold or used in this state for any purpose whatsoever, except [here follow the only exceptions from the tax contained in the act and they are (1) exports of such motor vehicle fuel from the state, and (2) motor vehicle fuel sold to the United States or any of its instrumentalities or agencies]; provided, however, that no license fee shall be imposed on the motor vehicle fuel brought into this state in the ordinary fuel tanks attached to and forming a part of a motor vehicle operating upon the highways where such amount does not exceed twenty gallons in the ordinary automobile and fifty gallons in busses and trucks. * * *
‘ ‘ Sec. 4. [Provides for the passing on of the tax to the ultimate consumer.]
“See. 5. Licensing of distributors. It shall be unlawful for any person to engage in business as a distributor in this state without first having procured a distributor’s license as provided in this act. * * * A fee of one dollar shall be collected by the treasurer from each person to whom a distributor’s license is issued.
“Sec. 6. Application for distributor’s license. Every per *646 son desiring to engage in business as a distributor shall file a duly verified application with the treasurer * * * . If such applicant is a firm or co-partnership, the application shall also contain the names and addresses of the several persons constituting the same and if a corporation or municipal subdivision, the correct name under which it is authorized to transact business, the name of its principal officers, resident agent or managing agent and attorney in fact. * * ®
“Sec. 7. Security required of distributor before license issued. Bach applicant for a distributor’s license, except agencies of the state amd municipal corporations in the state or other governmental subdivisions of the state shall, before the license is issued to him, file with the treasurer of state a bond” etc.

Section 29 provides for a refund of the tax on any motor vehicle fuel used for any specified purpose other than propelling vehicles on the highway, and the term used in section 29 is “any person who shall use any motor vehicle fuel” etc. (The above italics are supplied by us.)

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

United States v. Tyler
220 F. Supp. 386 (N.D. Iowa, 1963)
United States v. Merchants Mutual Bonding Company
220 F. Supp. 163 (N.D. Iowa, 1963)
United States v. West View Grain Company
189 F. Supp. 482 (N.D. Iowa, 1960)
Ferguson v. Brick
82 N.W.2d 849 (Supreme Court of Iowa, 1957)
Morrison-Knudsen Co. v. State Tax Commission
44 N.W.2d 449 (Supreme Court of Iowa, 1950)
Plank v. Grimes
28 N.W.2d 34 (Supreme Court of Iowa, 1947)
Union Pacific Railroad v. Riggs
166 P.2d 926 (Idaho Supreme Court, 1946)
Umthun v. Day & Zimmermann, Inc.
16 N.W.2d 258 (Supreme Court of Iowa, 1944)
Haas v. Independent School District No. 1
9 N.W.2d 707 (South Dakota Supreme Court, 1943)
City of Muscatine v. Swickard
6 N.W.2d 23 (Supreme Court of Iowa, 1942)
State v. McVey
123 P.2d 181 (Oregon Supreme Court, 1941)
W. J. Sandberg Co. v. Iowa State Board of Assessment & Review
278 N.W. 643 (Supreme Court of Iowa, 1938)
Keokuk Waterworks Co. v. Keokuk
277 N.W. 291 (Supreme Court of Iowa, 1938)
Hale v. State Bd. of Assessment and Review
302 U.S. 95 (Supreme Court, 1937)
State Ex Rel. Mitchell v. National Life Insurance
275 N.W. 26 (Supreme Court of Iowa, 1937)
State Ex Rel. Pfost v. Boise City
66 P.2d 1016 (Idaho Supreme Court, 1937)
Hale v. Iowa State Board of Assessment & Review
271 N.W. 168 (Supreme Court of Iowa, 1937)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
266 N.W. 41, 221 Iowa 642, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/state-v-city-of-des-moines-iowa-1936.