State v. Bowens

871 So. 2d 1178, 2004 WL 727889
CourtLouisiana Court of Appeal
DecidedMarch 31, 2004
Docket2003-KA-1408
StatusPublished
Cited by1 cases

This text of 871 So. 2d 1178 (State v. Bowens) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Louisiana Court of Appeal primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
State v. Bowens, 871 So. 2d 1178, 2004 WL 727889 (La. Ct. App. 2004).

Opinion

871 So.2d 1178 (2004)

STATE of Louisiana
v.
Michael BOWENS.

No. 2003-KA-1408.

Court of Appeal of Louisiana, Fourth Circuit.

March 31, 2004.

*1179 Eddie J. Jordan, Jr., District Attorney, Claire Adriana White, Assistant District Attorney, New Orleans, LA, for Plaintiff/Appellee.

Bruce W. Harris, New Orleans, LA, for Defendant/Appellant.

(Court composed of Judge PATRICIA RIVET MURRAY, Judge TERRI F. LOVE, Judge EDWIN A. LOMBARD).

TERRI F. LOVE, Judge.

Defendant was convicted of indecent behavior with a juvenile, and sentenced to three years at hard labor. The sentence was suspended and the trial court placed the defendant on five years active probation with the special condition that he serve fifty consecutive weekends in the Orleans Parish Prison. The defendant was also ordered to register himself as a sex offender in accordance with La. R.S. 15:542. On appeal the appellant alleges *1180 the trial court erred by sustaining the State's objection after defense counsel asked the victim whether she had retained a civil attorney. For reasons assigned below, we reverse the defendant's conviction and sentence.

STATEMENT OF CASE

On September 9, 1998, the State filed a bill of information charging Michael Bowens with molestation of a juvenile. The defendant pled not guilty at his arraignment on September 23, 1998. A preliminary hearing was held on November 13, 1998, and the trial court found probable cause. The case was set for trial on November 30, 1998, and on that date the State entered a nolle prosequi.

On January 6, 1999, the State re-instituted the charge and the defendant pled not guilty at his arraignment on February 5, 1999. The case proceeded to trial on March 11, 1999, and the jury found the defendant guilty of indecent behavior with a juvenile. On June 24, the trial court denied defendant's motion for new trial and motion of post verdict judgment of acquittal. Mr. Bowens waived all delays. The court sentenced the defendant to three years at hard labor and suspended the sentence. The court placed the defendant on five years active probation with the special condition that he serve fifty consecutive weekends in the Orleans Parish Prison. The defendant was also ordered to register himself as a sex offender in accordance with La. R.S. 15:542. Subsequently, the defendant lodged this appeal.

STATEMENT OF FACT

The victim, U.M., testified that on December 13, 1997, she was employed at Wendy's restaurant located at 1515 Poydras St. as a crew worker.[1] She was sixteen years old at the time. On the day in question she arrived at work at approximately 12:30 p.m. and prior to her clocking in, the manager, Michael Bowens, made a crude gesture towards her by licking his lips. Later during the day while U.M. was on a break she was talking about a book she was reading for school entitled "Make You Want to Holler," by Nathaniel McCauly, and Mr. Bowens stated to her that "He would make her want to holler." When U.M. heard the remark she stated to Mr. Bowens, "What did you say," and Mr. Bowens did not respond.

Later in the day, while the restaurant was closing, U.M. was washing trays, and Mr. Bowens came up behind her and caressed her stomach. U.M. told him to "get the F off of me" and told him to get back in his office. She also made a derogatory comment about the defendant's penis, and Mr. Bowens responded in kind. Mr. Bowens also told U.M. that rather than taking her to her home after work, he would be taking her to his place. U.M. did not respond to these comments.

Later, U.M. related what Mr. Bowens had said about not taking her home to another co-worker named Kenneth, who told her that Mr. Bowens was just acting silly and that he did not mean anything by it.

After the restaurant had closed, Mr. Bowens left to take another coworker, Nicole, home. U.M. remained in the restaurant alone. She telephoned a pair of friends and related what had happened that day and how uneasy she felt about getting a ride home from Mr. Bowens. One friend, Casey, told U.M. that if she wasn't home by 9:00 or 9:30 he would call the police and her father.

When Mr. Bowens returned, U.M. was still on the telephone, and Mr. Bowens went into the office and then turned off all *1181 the lights in the restaurant. Approximately ten to fifteen minutes later he came out and asked U.M. if she was ready. She ended her conversation shortly thereafter and then went into the office to replace the phone on the charger. When U.M.'s back was turned, Mr. Bowens came from behind the desk and began to caress her stomach. U.M. pushed him off of her, and the two began to struggle until the telephone rang. U.M. stated she was able to get away from Mr. Bowens and went to get her coat and things.

After Mr. Bowens hung up the telephone, he got behind U.M. and pushed her into the wall. Mr. Bowens pulled U.M.'s shirt out of her pants, reached his hand under her shirt and caressed her breast. U.M. pushed Mr. Bowens off of her, but he tried to kiss her, and she pushed him off her again. Then Mr. Bowens picked her up and took her into the office. Once inside, he put her on top of the desk. U.M.'s legs were open, and Mr. Bowens had himself between them. He tried to kiss her on the lips and the neck and then pressed his penis into her vaginal area. She pushed him off of her again, and they struggled. She asked him if she could leave, and finally he stepped aside from the doorway and allowed her to go.

Mr. Bowens told U.M. that he was just playing, that he had heard she was easy, and that she had proved him wrong. He also said that he was teaching her a lesson. The two rode the elevator up to his car. While he was driving her home, he asked her if she was going to quit and whether she was going to tell her parents what had happened. When he dropped her off at her house, her father was waiting.

U.M. explained that she did not inform her father what had happened for fear that he would go after Mr. Bowens and do something irrational. She likewise explained that she did not tell her mother for fear that she would try to kill Mr. Bowens. On the following Monday, U.M. told her teacher what had happened. The principal then informed Officer Olivia Fontenot, the school resource officer, who performed the investigation.

The State called Armand Chauvin, who was employed as a security officer at 1515 Poydras Street. Shortly after the incident, he was asked to complete a review of the surveillance video tape for the day of the incident. He testified that Mr. Bowens can be seen leaving the Wendy's at 8:04 p.m. with a woman and locking the door. The tape reflects that another woman was still located inside the store at that time. The tape showed that he returned to the restaurant at 8:41 p.m. and that upon returning the lights inside the restaurant went out. The tape showed that he left the restaurant at 8:57 p.m. with another woman.

Officer Olivia Fontenot testified that she was employed as a School Resource Officer with the New Orleans Police Department in December of 1997. She conducted the investigation of U.M.'s molestation and was responsible for obtaining a warrant for Michael Bowens' arrest.

The defense called Corey Lewis, a comanager for Wendy's. He stated that he knew Michael Bowens from working with him. He stated Mr. Bowens had a reputation for being truthful. Pamela Hall testified that she has worked as a crew member for Wendy's for sixteen years.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Ladner v. Government Employees' Insurance Co.
992 So. 2d 1098 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2008)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
871 So. 2d 1178, 2004 WL 727889, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/state-v-bowens-lactapp-2004.