State v. Allen

800 So. 2d 378, 2001 La. App. LEXIS 2487, 2001 WL 1346075
Louisiana Court of Appeal·Decided October 17, 2001·No. No. 2000-KA-0346·Published·Cited by 7 cases

Opinions

hPER CURIAM.

We reverse and remand this second degree murder verdict because of the legal errors committed during the jury selection process and the failure to grant a mistrial based on the continued display of a photograph of the victim at the prosecutor’s table and a witness wearing a T-shirt depicting the deceased victim. Two judges, concur, with separate reasons that inadmissible hearsay was improperly admitted at trial.

[380]*380 PROCEDURAL HISTORY

Defendant Lonnie Allen was charged by grand jury indictment with first degree murder, a 'violation of La. R.S. 14:3o.1 Defendant pleaded not guilty. Defendant withdrew motions to suppress the evidence and confession, and the trial court denied defendant’s motion to suppress the identification. Trial commenced on November 15, 1999. On November 16, 1999, this court denied defendant’s writ application pertaining to the trial court’s grant of the State’s motion in limine pertaining to defense evidence.2 The Louisiana Supreme Court granted defendant’s writ application, reversing the judgment of the trial court, and ruling | ¡¿hat the relevancy of evidence is determined at the time it is offered.3 The jury reached a verdict of guilty of second degree murder and defendant was sentenced to life imprisonment at hard labor, without benefit of parole, probation or suspension of sentence.

STATEMENT OF FACTS

On April 27, 1998, at approximately 9:30 p.m., Norman Royal, the decedent, was sitting on the front porch at 1802-1804 Music Street, New Orleans, Louisiana. He was with his friends, Robert Spriggens, Tremane Andrews, Reginald Davis, and Lawrence Clark, drinking beer. Suddenly, three men approached the group, one without a mask carrying a pistol, the other two armed and wearing partial or complete bandanas. The gunman threatened Norman Royal, fired two shots in the air, and robbed Robert Spriggens of $230. They attempted to herd the victims into the residence, when one of the robbers shot and killed Norman Royal, also wounding Robert Spriggens and Tremane Andrews. The felons fled in a red Pontiac automobile, which was eventually linked to Lonnie Allen, through statements made by his wife, Traleya Smith, and her mother, Linda Reeves.

New Orleans Police Homicide Detective Greg Hamilton investigated the homicide. When he arrived on the scene that night he observed the victim lying on the ground with blood all over him, trying to breathe. He noticed two other wounded persons. Reginald Davis was standing over the victim urging him to breathe. The detective later took a statement from Mr. Davis. The detective could not recall what information Mr. Davis gave him. Mr. Davis later was taken to view a red car, which he stated was not the one used by the perpetrators.

| sDetective Carlton Lawless also investigated the robbery/murder, and learned from his interviews that Norman Royal, Reginald Davis, Tremane Andrews, Robert Spriggens and Lawrence Clark had been sitting on the front porch of 1802-1804 Music Street drinking beer when three individuals robbed them. One grabbed Norman Royal by the neck, fired two shots into the air, and struck him twice in the head. Mr. Davis gave one of the robbers $230, and the robbers attempted to herd all of the people into one side of the double residence. Mr. Clark fled inside 1804 Music Street, at which time the robbers opened fire, fatally shooting Norman Royal in the neck, and wounding Mr. Sprig-gens in the forearm and Mr. Andrews in the chest.

[381]*381Det. Lawless identified photographs of the scene, as well as bullet fragments and a .38 shell casing recovered from the scene. Det. Lawless interviewed a neighbor, Mr. Sampson, who said he was asleep when awakened by the sound of gunshots. He looked out of his window across the street, where he observed three black males standing on the sidewalk in front of 1802-1804 Music Street, pointing guns at men on the porch of that dwelling. One gunman was aimed with one gun, the other two each had two guns, one in each hand. He could not identify anyone, because all he saw was silhouettes.

Reginald Davis informed Det. Lawless on the night of the shooting that the perpetrators fled in a red two-door Pontiac Sunbird, with a malfunctioning rear taillight and a commercial license plate containing the letter “A.” The next day Det. Lawless received a telephone call from Barbara Davis, the victim’s aunt, who raised the decedent. She gave the license plate number of what might be the vehicle used by the perpetrators. Det. Lawless contacted the Hertz Corporation, and learned that the car had been rented on April 27, 1998, at 5:29 p.m. to a female |4from Washington, D.C. Det. Lawless contacted Mrs. Davis, advised her that he had spoken to the two white females using the car. Det. Lawless concluded that this car was not involved, and continued to search for the suspect car. He subsequently received a telephone call from Reginald Davis that a red Sunbird was the vehicle leaving the scene. Det. Lawless put out a radio alert to be on the lookout for the vehicle in the area of N. Claiborne Avenue and Flood Street. A vehicle fitting the description was subsequently located in the 2100 block of Desire Street, parked in front of the home of defendant’s mother-in-law, Linda Reeves. Traleya Smith entered the vehicle, and she was subsequently stopped. The vehicle had a malfunctioning rear taillight. Reginald Davis identified the red vehicle. Det. Lawless interviewed Ms. Smith, who informed him that defendant used to be her boyfriend. She said that her mother, Linda Reeves, had rented the Pontiac Sunfire for Ms. Smith’s use. Det. Lawless identified a copy of an Enterprise Rental lease agreement, reflecting Ms. Reeves’ lease of a 1998, two-door, red Pontiac Sunfire, license plate number A507640. Det. Lawless identified a photograph of the rear of the vehicle, showing that the right rear taillight was not illuminated, due to what he discovered was a faulty electrical connection. Det. Lawless said that while speaking to Ms. Reeves he learned that Ms. Smith was married to defendant, and that they lived together at 6122 Music Street. The detective also learned that defendant used the Pontiac Sunfire most of the time. Ms. Smith subsequently admitted to Det. Lawless that she was married to defendant, that defendant used the vehicle most of time, and that on the night in question defendant used the car after he dropped her off at her mother’s residence. Det. Lawless said it was also brought out that defendant did not use the vehicle after that date, and that Ms. 1 KSmith had tried to get her mother to trade in the vehicle, claiming that it had some type of mechanical difficulty.

Det. Lawless subsequently prepared a photographic lineup containing defendant’s photo, and displayed it to Reginald Davis. Mr. Davis selected defendant’s photo. Robert Spriggens also identified defendant’s photo in a lineup. Mr. Spriggens told him that Thompson’s photo in the second lineup looked like one of the robbers, but that he did not want to accuse an innocent person. Lawrence Clark made a tentative identification of defendant; he said it looked like him but he did not want to accuse an innocent person. Tremane [382]*382Andrews and former New Orleans police officer Frank Oliver could not identify anyone in defendant’s photo lineup. Frank Oliver had been on N. Roman Street, where the perpetrators parked before walking around the corner to Music Street. Mr. Oliver identified a photo lineup of defendant’s co-defendant, Antoine Thompson.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

State v. Allen, 800 So. 2d 378, 2001 La. App. LEXIS 2487, 2001 WL 1346075 (La. Ct. App. 2001).

800 So. 2d 378 (State v. Allen) — published by Counsel Stack Legal Research, free access to 12M+ legal documents.

Related

State Of Louisiana v. Shanelll Thompson
Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2023
S.L.B. v. C.E.B.
252 So. 3d 950 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2018)
State v. Doucette
243 So. 3d 704 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2018)
State v. Hathorn
63 So. 3d 1142 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2011)
State v. Allen
876 So. 2d 122 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2004)
State v. Lee
826 So. 2d 616 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2002)
Ford v. Nationwide Mutual Fire Insurance
214 F. Supp. 2d 11 (D. Maine, 2002)