State v. Allen

478 So. 2d 589
Louisiana Court of Appeal·Decided October 30, 1985·No. 17286-KA·Published·Cited by 9 cases

Opinion

478 So.2d 589 (1985)

STATE of Louisiana, Appellee,
v.
Clyde ALLEN, Appellant.

No. 17286-KA.

Court of Appeal of Louisiana, Second Circuit.

October 30, 1985.
Rehearing Denied November 27, 1985.

*591 Office of Indigent Defender Richard C. Goorley, Shreveport, for appellant.

William J. Guste, Jr., Atty. Gen., Baton Rouge, Paul J. Carmouche, Dist. Atty., Scott J. Crichton, A.M. Stroud and John Broadwell, Asst. Dist. Attys., Shreveport, for appellee.

Before MARVIN, FRED W. JONES and LINDSAY, JJ.

LINDSAY, Judge.

The defendant, Clyde Allen, was charged by bill of information with attempted first degree murder in violation of LSA-R.S. 14:27 and 14:30. After a jury trial, the defendant was convicted of this offense and sentenced to serve 50 years at hard labor. Finding that a firearm was used in the commission of this felony offense, the trial court applied the provisions of LSA-C. Cr.P. Art. 893.1 and imposed the sentence without benefit of probation, parole or suspension. The defendant now appeals his conviction and sentence urging four assignments of error. However, as assignment of error number two was not argued or briefed, it is considered abandoned. State v. Domingue, 298 So.2d 723 (La.1974).

The record reflects that on the afternoon of December 7, 1983 in downtown Shreveport, the defendant became involved in an argument with another individual, identified as Paul Simmons. A witness to this argument testified that she saw Mr. Simmons grab a shiney silver object from his pocket as he advanced toward the defendant. Backing away, the defendant pulled out a gun and shot Mr. Simmons in the stomach. The defense later argued that this action was in self-defense as a knife was subsequently retrieved from Mr. Simmons.

After the shooting, the defendant left the downtown area and boarded a Shreveport City Bus headed for Linwood Avenue. Police officers arriving at the scene of the shooting, obtained a detailed description of the defendant and learned that he was armed with a large caliber handgun. Witnesses also indicated that the defendant might be on the Linwood bus. This information was then broadcast by radio to police headquarters.

Officer Pat McGaha, patrolling Linwood Avenue in the Cedar Grove area of Shreveport, heard the broadcast of the shooting suspect's description. He also spoke directly with one of the police officers at the scene of the shooting who asked Officer McGaha to try and intercept the bus which could be carrying the suspect. Officer McGaha subsequently located a bus traveling on Linwood Avenue which contained two men who appeared to match the suspect's description. Following the bus on Linwood for some time, Officer McGaha noted that these two men never left the rear of the bus. Officer Johnnie Alvin Coffey, who was also in the area in a separate patrol unit, joined Officer McGaha as he followed the bus. At the corner of Hollywood and Linwood, Officer McGaha turned on his red lights and pulled in front of the bus forcing it to stop. As the bus stopped, Officer Malcolm Butler also arrived, placing his vehicle behind the bus and Officer Coffey's unit.

The officers then left their patrol units and attempted to enter the bus. Officer McGaha proceeded through the front door and into the bus, while the other officers tried to pry open the side door. Officer McGaha testified that as he entered the bus he unsnapped his holster, pulled his gun somewhat loose, and put his hand on the grip. He did not, however, completely withdraw the gun from its holster. Officer McGaha then proceeded down the aisle of the bus, approaching the two men who matched the suspect's description. Officer McGaha did not say anything, as he did not know which of the two men was the proper suspect. While he was looking at the man on his left, the defendant rose from his *592 seat, pointed his gun at Officer McGaha and yelled "You are not going to take me to jail." He then shot Officer McGaha in the left leg. At this time, the bus driver opened the doors and exited the bus. This freed the side door to open which enabled Officers Coffey and Butler to see the defendant as he shot Officer McGaha. Both officers then fired their guns at the defendant. Officer McGaha also managed to fire a shot at the defendant subsequent to his own leg injury. In the gunfire exchange, the defendant was struck and injured.

The defendant was then immediately apprehended and transported to the LSU Medical Center for treatment of his gunshot wounds. Officer McGaha was also transported to a hospital for medical treatment. The following day, December 8, 1983, the defendant was formally placed under arrest for the attempted first degree murder of Officer McGaha and was then advised of his Miranda rights. There was no attempt to interview the defendant at that time due to his medical condition. Later, on December 12, 1983, the defendant was released from the LSU Medical Center and incarcerated in the Shreveport City Jail.

The defendant was then interviewed by police officers at the jail in connection with the shooting of Officer McGaha. The defendant was again informed of his Miranda rights. The defendant stated that he understood those rights and that he wished to waive them. The defendant signed a Miranda rights card and then gave a recorded statement in which he confessed to the shooting of Paul Simmons and Officer McGaha. The police officers interviewing the defendant, became concerned when the defendant referred to both shooting incidents in his statement. In an attempt to clarify and distinguish the two incidents, the police officers obtained a second statement from the defendant after speaking with an assistant district attorney who notified the officers that an attorney had been appointed for the defendant. Prior to the taking of the second statement, the defendant was again advised of his Miranda rights. The officers also informed the defendant that an attorney had been appointed to represent him. The defendant again acknowledged his rights and advised the officers that he was willing to give a second statement without his attorney being present. The defendant later moved to suppress these statements, but after a hearing, the trial court overruled the defendant's motion.

ASSIGNMENT OF ERROR NO. 1

The defendant first contends that the trial court erred in refusing to grant his motion to suppress the statements given to the Shreveport Police Officers on December 12, 1983. He asserts that his constitutional rights were violated as he was not sufficiently informed of the fact that counsel had been appointed to represent him, therefore he could not make a knowing and intelligent waiver of his right to counsel. Defendant's counsel asserts that once the police knew that the defendant was represented by the Indigent Defender's Office, some attempt to contact that office should have been made before the second interview took place. Furthermore, counsel contends that due to the defendant's past history of mental illness and his physical condition at the time of these interviews, the defendant could not make a knowing and intelligent waiver of his right to counsel. Therefore, his statements, admitting the shooting of Officer McGaha, should have been suppressed.

The Louisiana Supreme Court in State v. Leatherwood, 411 So.2d 29, 33 (La.1982) stated:

In addition to proving the voluntariness of a confession, the state must show that a confession obtained during a custodial interrogation was preceded by Miranda warnings and valid waiver of the defendant's constitutional rights. See State v.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

State v. Allen, 478 So. 2d 589 (La. Ct. App. 1985).

478 So. 2d 589 (State v. Allen) — published by Counsel Stack Legal Research, free access to 12M+ legal documents.

Related

State v. Devillier
258 So. 3d 230 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2018)
State v. Fontenot
38 So. 3d 1122 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2010)
State of Louisiana v. Darrell James Fontenot
Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2010
State v. Falkins
9 So. 3d 190 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2009)
State v. Taylor
956 So. 2d 25 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2007)
State v. Williams
688 So. 2d 1277 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1997)
State v. Rubin
588 So. 2d 1289 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1991)
State v. Allen
491 So. 2d 12 (Supreme Court of Louisiana, 1986)