State of Iowa v. Jason Levant Ferguson

CourtCourt of Appeals of Iowa
DecidedMarch 5, 2025
Docket24-0348
StatusPublished

This text of State of Iowa v. Jason Levant Ferguson (State of Iowa v. Jason Levant Ferguson) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Court of Appeals of Iowa primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
State of Iowa v. Jason Levant Ferguson, (iowactapp 2025).

Opinion

IN THE COURT OF APPEALS OF IOWA

No. 24-0348 Filed March 5, 2025

STATE OF IOWA, Plaintiff-Appellee,

vs.

JASON LEVANT FERGUSON, Defendant-Appellant. ________________________________________________________________

Appeal from the Iowa District Court for Pocahontas County, Derek Johnson,

Judge.

The defendant appeals his convictions, alleging insufficient evidence

supports the jury’s verdicts. AFFIRMED.

Martha J. Lucey, State Appellate Defender, and Ella M. Newell, Assistant

Appellate Defender, for appellant.

Brenna Bird, Attorney General, and Zachary Miller, Assistant Attorney

General, for appellee.

Heard by Greer, P.J., and Langholz and Sandy, JJ. 2

GREER, Presiding Judge.

A jury found Jason Ferguson guilty of theft in the second degree and fifty

timber violations involving his harvesting of trees on the Stoddard Wildlife

Management Area in Pocahontas County (Stoddard Property). Ferguson appeals

his convictions, arguing that insufficient evidence underlies the jury’s verdict as to

all fifty-one counts. He points to the State’s alleged failure to prove when the trees

were cut, that he cut or caused to be cut and appropriated fifty trees from the

Stoddard Property, and that he was not acting under a mistake of fact as to who

owned the trees at the time. After review, we find sufficient evidence on the record

to support the jury’s verdicts and affirm Ferguson’s convictions.

I. Background Facts and Proceedings.

The Stoddard family once owned a sliver of land abutting an old river bottom

area next to the Des Moines River. On July 24, 2020, the Stoddard family sold the

land to the National Heritage Foundation (NHF), which held and maintained

properties until identified properties could be transferred to government entities for

use as conservation land. The Stoddard Property was formally transferred on

August 3, 2020. On August 20, 2021, the Stoddard Property was officially

transferred to the State of Iowa.

On or about October 23, 2022, a bow hunter called in a tip to authorities,

alerting them to out-of-the-ordinary activity on the Stoddard Property. Officer

Spece, a conservation officer for the Iowa Department of Natural Resources

(DNR), responded to the tip. Upon arrival to the Stoddard Property, Spece

observed evidence of logging, including tree stumps. After realizing the magnitude

of ecological disturbance, Spece recorded photos and waypoints of tree stumps, 3

equipment, and man-made trails on a phone application called “OnX.” Once

Spece finished walking the Stoddard Property, he returned to his vehicle and called

another conservation officer, Officer Yarkosky.

Yarkosky joined Spece and transversed the property to the bank of the old

Des Moines River bottom, where the officers spotted an individual, later identified

as Jason Ferguson, among the undergrowth. When officers approached,

Ferguson was compliant, answered questions, and voluntarily pulled out his phone

to compare digital resources showing property lines. Drawing on a previous

observation from a public road, Spece took a sincere special interest in a large bur

oak tree in Ferguson’s driveway. Spece asked Ferguson whether he would be

willing to show him the tree, as Spece was a self-described “tree nerd.” Ferguson

agreed.

Before leaving to see the bur oak tree, the officers followed Ferguson to his

car parked in the forest, asking him to open the trunk of his SUV. In the trunk were

several chainsaws, industrial chains, and other miscellaneous equipment. As a

storm rolled in, the men split and entered their respective vehicles; the three made

their way to Ferguson’s property.

On Ferguson’s property, Spece and Yarkosky examined the massive bur

oak tree on a trailer in Ferguson’s driveway. The men conversed about that tree,

other trees on Ferguson’s property, and more generally about building and

woodworking. The officers left Ferguson’s property without incident.

The next day, Officer Nathan Haupert surveyed the Stoddard Property.

Haupert, a sixteen-year veteran of the DNR, found dozens of tree stumps on the

Stoddard Property. He also took note of signage marking the boundary of the 4

State-owned property from a neighboring privately-owned property. As more and

more damage came to light, Haupert called in a reinforcement—Officer Steve

Griebel, also a conservation officer for the DNR. Griebel started numbering

stumps with spray paint. By the end of the day, Haupert decided to invite Kevin

Oetken, an expert in forestry, onto the Stoddard Property to investigate the scope

of timbering activities.

On July 12, 2023, after a thorough investigation, Oetken found more than

fifty tree stumps1 on the Stoddard Property. Oetken identified the boundaries of

the Stoddard Property prior to his arrival using maps obtained from the Beacon

GIS website for the county. Then, using forestry techniques, including estimating

diameter at breast height for each stump and the Scribner log rule,2 Oetken was

able to approximate the monetary value of each of the fifty trees that once stood

on the Stoddard Property. Special care was taken to evaluate the monetary value

of the large bur oak tree, thought to be 175 years old at the time it was felled on

the property. In Oetken’s professional opinion, because of the tree’s size and

value to wildlife, the large bur oak tree had a special estimated value of $25,549.

The value of the logs for the other fifty trees, including the value of logs from the

bur oak tree, was $5327.92. Oetken also compared an overhead GIS photograph

1 Oetken observed cut tree stumps for one bur oak, twenty-four silver maple, twenty-eight green ash, and two elm trees, but at sentencing corrected his report to reflect twenty-two silver maple trees and twenty-five green ash to match the verdicts returned by the jury. 2 Oetken described this as a “log rule stick . . . that allows [him] to measure the

diameter of the stump . . . [and] calculate the volume of the wood in the tree.” He called it “Iowa’s official log rule,” as well as the Department of Forestry’s official rule. 5

of the area from April 2021 to a March 2023 GIS photograph of the same area and

opined that the bur oak was no longer observable in the more recent image.

Because of the scope of damage, the DNR pursued charges against

Ferguson. In January 2023, the State of Iowa charged Ferguson with theft in the

second degree, a class “D” felony, in violation of Iowa Code sections 714.1(1) and

714.2(2) (2022),3 and a series of timber violations, each of which was a serious

misdemeanor in violation of sections 456A.36(3)(b) and 456A.36(5)(c).4 Ferguson

gave noticed he intended to assert a justification defense.

The matter proceeded to trial. Ferguson maintained that he was acting

under a mistake of fact about who owned the property and, accordingly, the trees

at the time he harvested them. After a four-day trial, the jury found Ferguson guilty

on all counts. At sentencing, the district court imposed a five-year suspended

prison sentence; a suspended fine for Count I, second-degree theft; and a fine on

each of Ferguson’s fifty timber violations, for a total of $21,500, plus a 15%

3 It was alleged Ferguson committed the acts between April 2021 and October

2022.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

State v. Biddle
652 N.W.2d 191 (Supreme Court of Iowa, 2002)
State v. Brown
400 N.W.2d 74 (Court of Appeals of Iowa, 1986)
State v. Potter
786 N.W.2d 268 (Court of Appeals of Iowa, 2010)
State v. Dalton
674 N.W.2d 111 (Supreme Court of Iowa, 2004)
State v. Freeman
450 N.W.2d 826 (Supreme Court of Iowa, 1990)
State of Iowa v. Scott Robert Robinson
859 N.W.2d 464 (Supreme Court of Iowa, 2015)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
State of Iowa v. Jason Levant Ferguson, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/state-of-iowa-v-jason-levant-ferguson-iowactapp-2025.