Starling, W. v. Lake Meade Prop., Aplt.

• Court: Supreme Court of Pennsylvania
• Decided: May 25, 2017
• Docket: Starling, W. v. Lake Meade Prop., Aplt. - No. 30 MAP 2016
• Status: Published

Opinion

[J-91-2016] [M.O. - Wecht, J.] IN THE SUPREME COURT OF PENNSYLVANIA MIDDLE DISTRICT

W. LOWELL STARLING AND NANCY : No. 30 MAP 2016 STARLING, : : Appeal from the Order of the Superior Appellees : Court at No. 1779 MDA 2014 dated : August 11, 2015, Reconsideration : Denied October 14, 2015, Reversing v. : and Remanding the Order of the Adams : County Court of Common Please, Civil : Division, at No. 2010-S-498 dated LAKE MEADE PROPERTY OWNERS : September 26, 2014. ASSOCIATION, INC., : : Appellant : ARGUED: September 14, 2016

CONCURRING OPINION

CHIEF JUSTICE SAYLOR DECIDED: May 25, 2017

I join the majority opinion in full and write only to note that I am not

unsympathetic to the Starlings. Candidly, I find any effort by the Association to

encourage common use of the Disputed Property -- particularly large-scale use -- to be

distasteful, especially if the history of disorderly conduct on and around such property is

as alleged. In this respect, I regard the Association’s assertion of legal title to this land

to be doubtful in its own right; moreover, it seems to me that the land was originally

intended to be left simply as a part of a thin undeveloped shoreline appurtenant to a

wider road. Nevertheless, per the Uniform Planned Community Act, it would appear

that the Association has the legal right to provide for common use, see 68 Pa.C.S.

§5302(a)(6) (recognizing that an association may “[r]egulate the use, maintenance, repair, replacement and modification of common elements” of a planned community), 1

subject, of course, to its own rules and regulations, prevailing covenants, and the law of

nuisance.

1 Notably, for purposes of the statute, “common elements” is defined to subsume not only “common facilities,” i.e., real estate owned or leased by the association, but also “controlled facilities,” which includes any real estate within the community – owned or non-owned – over which the association asserts control. 68 Pa.C.S. §5103.

[J-91-2016] [M.O. - Wecht, J.] - 2