St. Dunstan Society v. Mendelson

120 N.Y.S. 49

• Court: Appellate Terms of the Supreme Court of New York
• Decided: December 22, 1909
• Status: Published

Opinion

PER CURIAM.

Defendant signed a contract, by which he agreed to buy from M. Walter Dunne—

“one set of the Autograph Edition de Luxe registered and numbered copies of Universal Classics Library and Classics Manuscripts, to be completed in 31 volumes printed on deckle-edge water-marked paper, illustrated with aquarelles, etchings, mezzotints, and photogravures. Not less than 12 hand-painted Japan plate reproductions, signed by the artists. Autograph page, in colors, on Japan,” etc.

The contract indicated that defendant’s set was No. 22. For these books defendant agreed to pay $97.50, at the rate of $5 monthly. This contract was subsequently assigned to plaintiff. The books were delivered, and defendant paid $15 of the price, after which he refused to pay further, alleging that he had been induced to sign the contract upon fraudulent statements, and that the books were' not as represented.

Although these contentions may be as alleged, yet the only evidence upon which the trial court gave judgment was that defendant had opened one book, and that he had seen a similar set for sale at a department store for $35. This last statement was only brought out on cross-examination of defendant by plaintiff’s counsel. The rest of the testimony consisted chiefly of narrating the conversation had between defendant and the book agent at the time of signing the contract. These facts are far from sufficient to support an allegation of fraud, or that the books are not as represented. The defendant should be given an opportunity to prove his contentions, which he utterly failed to do upon this trial.

Judgment reversed, and new trial ordered, with costs to appellant to abide the event.